Thursday October 1st, 2020 12:34AM

To impeach or not? Pelosi balances competing calls

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — House Speaker Nancy Pelosi still isn't ready to impeach President Donald Trump.

Even after special counsel Robert Mueller essentially called on Congress to pick up where his investigation left off, Pelosi isn't budging. Scores of her Democratic lawmakers do want to start impeachment proceedings. Outside groups say it's time. But Pelosi is carrying on as she has since taking the speaker's gavel in January, promising the House will methodically pursue its investigations of Trump -- wherever they lead.

This is Pelosi's balancing act: toggling between mounting pressure from other Democrats and her own political instincts. She's sticking with her plans for a more measured, "ironclad" investigation that makes it clear to Americans the choices ahead. It's uncharted territory for the speaker, and this Congress, with both high risks and possible rewards ahead of the 2020 election.

Trump declared his own challenge on Thursday . He called impeachment a "dirty, filthy, disgusting word" and said courts would never allow it.

"Many constituents want to impeach the president," Pelosi acknowledged shortly after Mueller's remarks Wednesday. "But we want to do what is right and what gets results."

Her calculus is political as well as practical, knowing that even if Democrats in the House have the votes to approve articles of impeachment, the Republican majority in the Senate is hardly likely to vote to convict him. Opinion polling does not favor impeachment, and a full-blown but failed effort might well help the president win re-election. Rather than go it alone, she is urging Democrats to build the case so the public is with them, whatever they decide.

"Nothing is off the table," Pelosi said, "but we do want to make such a compelling case, such an ironclad case."

It has been this way for weeks. As more and more Democratic lawmakers -- and presidential candidates -- call for impeachment proceedings, Pelosi is urging restraint. Those around her say she's feeling no pressure.

On Wednesday, many Democrats took Mueller's words as an invitation to impeach.

Mueller told the country, as he said in his 448-page report last month, that while charging the president with obstructing justice was "not an option" under Department of Justice guidelines, he also did not exonerate Trump.

Instead, Mueller said, "the Constitution requires a process other than the criminal justice system to formally accuse a sitting President of wrongdoing." Without saying the word, Mueller was pointing to impeachment.

More presidential hopefuls -- Cory Booker, Kirsten Gillibrand and John Hickenlooper -- quickly called for impeachment proceedings. Half the Democrats on the House Judiciary Committee want an inquiry. And dozens of other House Democrats, not just the liberal left flank, are on board.

At a town hall meeting that night, Rep. Pramila Jayapal told voters in Seattle, said the road ahead "weighs on me." She is among those who want formal impeachment proceedings.

"Not everybody in the caucus is there yet, that is why Speaker Pelosi has a difficult role and she has been trying to figure out exactly how we will move forward," she told the audience. "The more the president obstructed justice ... the more certain we are going to be headed in a direction that I think many of us have already come out for -- and that is an impeachment inquiry."

More joined Thursday, including Rep. Greg Stanton, a freshman congressman from Arizona who said, "This conclusion will be unpopular with some, but it is the right thing to do."

At a town hall in Henderson, Nevada, presidential hopeful Bernie Sanders, who favors impeachment, said, "Nancy Pelosi does not have an easy job."

But this isn't entirely new for her.

She witnessed the efforts to impeach Richard Nixon and Bill Clinton and, as speaker a decade ago, tamped down cries to impeach George W. Bush over the Iraq War.

Also, the voices for impeachment make up just a slim fraction of the broader Democratic majority in the House. Many of the others represent more conservative districts and face re-election where Trump has significant support.

Back home during a visit to a supermarket in Peoria, Illinois, Rep. Cheri Bustos fielded questions on health care and other issues, an aide said — but impeachment didn't come up.

Most of Pelosi's top lieutenants are following her lead.

Rep. Adam Schiff, chairman of the House intelligence committee, said Thursday in California he's not urging impeachment yet, "though the president seems to be doing everything in his power to get me there."

Schiff warned that impeachment is not a "cure all." He said, "Impeachment doesn't remove this president. There is only one way to remove this president, and that's by voting him out of office."

Six committees in the House are pushing ahead with investigations of Trump's actions -- his business dealings, his actions during the Russia probe, his running of the government -- and many of their inquiries are moving into legal battles where, so far, courts are siding with Congress against blocking efforts.

At the same time, the House is trying on other fronts to hold Attorney General William Barr and others in contempt of Congress for failing to comply with subpoena requests for documents and testimony. The actions will test the Supreme Court's decision, some 100 years ago that Congress has an oversight role as part of the nation's system of checks and balances, in ways that could set precedent for years to come.

One Democrat on the Judiciary panel, Val Demings of Florida, a former police chief who favors opening an impeachment proceeding, explained in an earlier interview, that she and others are "just trying to figure it out."

"During the civil rights movement I'm sure the time probably wasn't right politically, but we did in our hearts what we knew was right," she said.

With Mueller now unlikely to testify before Congress, Democrats are being denied a star witness who could focus Americans' attention in a high-profile way.

Billionaire Tom Steyer, a leading impeachment advocate, says time is narrowing for Pelosi to launch impeachment hearings before the 2020 political campaign.

For so long, Democrats were waiting for Mueller's report. Now, Steyer said Mueller has spoken and provided them the way forward. Rather than being risky, Steyer said in an interview Thursday, the politics are on the side for impeachment.

"Justin Amash got a standing ovation," he said, referring to the Michigan Republican who broke ranks with the GOP and joined calls for impeachment. "Americans like truth tellers. Americans like people who stand up for their values."


Associated Press writers Mary Clare Jalonick in Washington and Michelle Price in Henderson, Nev., contributed to this report.

Follow Lisa Mascaro on Twitter at

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Elections, General Election News, General Presidential Election News
© Copyright 2020
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
To impeach or not? Pelosi balances competing calls
Speaker Nancy Pelosi still isn't ready to impeach President Donald Trump
6:15PM ( 13 minutes ago )
Louisiana's Democratic governor signs abortion ban into law
Louisiana's Democratic governor has signed a ban on abortion as early as six weeks of pregnancy, a move that has provoked anger from members of his own party
6:12PM ( 15 minutes ago )
Trump says not involved with keeping McCain ship out of view
President Donald Trump and his acting defense secretary are distancing themselves from an order to keep a warship named for the late Sen. John McCain out of sight during the commander in chief's recent visit to Japan
6:12PM ( 15 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Major Hollywood studios start to weigh in on heartbeat bill
Sony, WarnerMedia, Disney among the major Hollywood studies weighing in on Georgia's new abortion law, with some saying they'll reconsider production in the state if the law goes into effect in 2020
5:18PM ( 1 hour ago )
Bernie Sanders defends his support for Clinton in 2016
Democratic presidential candidate Bernie Sanders is defending his efforts to back his party's presidential nominee in 2016 and says he'll do the same in 2020 if he doesn't win the nomination himself
5:17PM ( 1 hour ago )
Pence says US-Canada relationship has 'never been stronger'
Vice President Mike Pence says the U.S.-Canada relationship has "never been stronger," less than a year after a trade tiff had chilled the allies' historically warm ties
4:55PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Former US Sen. Thad Cochran of Mississippi dies at 81
Former U.S. Sen. Thad Cochran, who steered billions of dollars to his home state of Mississippi, has died
3:26PM ( 3 hours ago )
The Latest: Barr: Mueller could have decided on obstruction
Attorney General William Barr says special counsel Robert Mueller could have reached a decision on whether President Donald Trump obstructed justice
3:20PM ( 3 hours ago )
7 dead, 21 missing after SKorean tour boat sinks in Hungary
Rescue crews in Hungary's capital were preparing to raise a sightseeing boat from the bottom of the Danube River Thursday as search teams scoured the waters for 21 people missing
2:33PM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Honduras president, others targets of DEA investigation
U.S. federal court documents show that Honduras President Juan Orlando Hernández and some of his closest advisers were among the targets of a Drug Enforcement Administration investigation
5:21PM ( 1 hour ago )
Trump erupts after special counsel says he's not exonerated
President Donald Trump is branding special counsel Robert Mueller a "never Trumper," a day after Mueller rejected Trump's insistence that the Russia probe exonerated him.
3:01PM ( 3 hours ago )
The Latest: Trump muddles waters over Russia election help
President Donald Trump is assailing special counsel Robert Mueller as a "never Trumper" and as a rejected, conflicted job-seeker
1:18PM ( 5 hours ago )
AP Elections
Mueller's public statement fuels calls for Trump impeachment
Special counsel Robert Mueller's first public statement on the Russia investigation is fueling fresh calls on Capitol Hill to begin impeachment proceedings against President Donald Trump, a step that Democratic leaders have so far resisted
11:06PM ( 19 hours ago )
More 2020 Dems call for impeachment after Mueller speaks out
More Democratic White House hopefuls are backing impeachment proceedings after a rare public statement from special counsel Robert Mueller that made clear his Russia report didn't exonerate President Donald Trump
8:43PM ( 21 hours ago )
McConnell: 'We'd fill' any Supreme Court vacancy in 2020
The Senate majority leader says if there's a vacancy on the Supreme Court during next year's election cycle, the Republican-controlled Senate would likely confirm a nominee selected by President Donald Trump
5:23PM ( 1 day ago )
General Election News
Robert Mueller's brief remarks get wall-to-wall coverage
Robert Mueller spoke for only 10 minutes, and his statements yielded no new information on the Russia probe
7:32PM ( 22 hours ago )
Mueller: Special counsel probe did not exonerate Trump
Special counsel Robert Mueller resigns, returning to private life.
1:56PM ( 1 day ago )
Amash at town hall: 'My job is to protect the Constitution'
The only Republican in Congress to accuse President Donald Trump of impeachable conduct was largely applauded during a town hall in his Michigan district
10:40PM ( 1 day ago )
General Presidential Election News
Louisiana's Democratic governor signs abortion ban into law
Louisiana's Democratic governor has signed a ban on abortion as early as six weeks of pregnancy, a move that has provoked anger from members of his own party
6:12PM ( 15 minutes ago )
Trump says not involved with keeping McCain ship out of view
President Donald Trump and his acting defense secretary are distancing themselves from an order to keep a warship named for the late Sen. John McCain out of sight during the commander in chief's recent visit to Japan
6:12PM ( 16 minutes ago )
Mixed verdict reached in Penn State frat-fall death case
The former manager of a Penn State fraternity where a pledge fell during a night of hazing and drinking and later died has been convicted of hindering apprehension but acquitted of evidence tampering and obstruction
6:07PM ( 21 minutes ago )
Oregon, awash in marijuana, takes steps to curb production
Oregon is awash in pot, glutted with so much legal weed that if growing were to stop today, it could take more than six years to smoke or eat it all
5:59PM ( 29 minutes ago )
Judge considering Missouri abortion clinic license case
A St. Louis judge is deciding whether to grant an order that would allow Missouri's only abortion clinic to keep its abortion license past Friday
5:54PM ( 34 minutes ago )