Monday December 9th, 2019 1:57PM

Ethiopian pilot pleaded for training weeks before Max crash

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

NEW YORK (AP) — Just days after a Lion Air Boeing 737 Max nosedived in Indonesia and killed all 189 people aboard, an Ethiopian Airlines pilot began pleading with his bosses for more training on the Max, warning that crews could easily be overwhelmed in a crisis and that one of their planes could be the next to go down.

"We are asking for trouble," veteran pilot Bernd Kai von Hoesslin wrote in a December email obtained by The Associated Press, adding that if several alarms go off in the cockpit at once, "it will be a crash for sure."

That prediction proved all too accurate.

What Ethiopian Airlines did in response to his warnings is unclear, and whether it made any difference is a matter of dispute. But within weeks, an Ethiopian Max indeed went down, killing all 157 people on board. It slammed into the ground amid a flurry of alarms as the pilots struggled to control a malfunction in the automatic anti-stall system.

While the anti-stall system has gotten most of the scrutiny in the two Max crashes five months apart that have led to a worldwide grounding of the planes, the concerns raised by von Hoesslin have added to a debate on the role pilot error played, and whether Ethiopian's pilots were as prepared as they could have been to avert disaster.

Von Hoesslin, a Canadian citizen who resigned from Ethiopian last month, argued in three emails to senior managers after the anti-stall system came under scrutiny in the Lion Air crash that crews flying Ethiopian's five Max jets should have been given more information and training on how the system worked. He also said pilots should be drilled on the steps to override it if it faltered. Von Hoesslin's emails were first reported by Bloomberg.

The Max's system, called MCAS, for Maneuvering Characteristics Augmentation System, automatically pushes the plane's nose down when it is at risk of stalling. It misfired in both fatal crashes, with pilots losing control of the plane as they fought against it.

According to the email chain obtained by the AP, Ethiopian responded to the Oct. 29 Lion Air crash with a few emails to pilots detailing bulletins from the U.S. Federal Aviation Administration and Boeing on what do if the anti-stall system malfunctioned. Other Ethiopian pilots who spoke to the AP say those emails required no signoffs that pilots actually read and understood the directives, and no mandated additional training.

"Ethiopian Airlines is a rapidly expanding airline and they have extremely inexperienced crews," von Hoesslin said in documents obtained by the AP. "You need to spoon-feed them the information and make sure they understand."

To underscore his point, von Hoesslin made a video shortly after the Ethiopian crash in which he quizzed a Max pilot on a Boeing list of warning signs on the stall system that crew members were required to commit to memory. That video, obtained by AP, shows him going blank on most of it.

"You have to have confirmation that they opened it, that they read it and that they understood it," von Hoesslin said in a document obtained by the AP. "They should have done a little online test with 10 questions. You don't pass until you get the 10 questions."

Ethiopian Airlines tweeted Wednesday that "the source of these false allegations is a disgruntled former employee ... who has left the airline after many administrative problems."

Von Hoesslin's lawyer, Darryl Levitt, issued a statement saying the pilot was not fired but "resigned due to legitimate concerns he had raised that he felt were not adequately addressed." He added that von Hoesslin will be cooperating with regulators and authorities "with his sole objective of contributing to make air travel safe."

Ethiopian has said that the requirements for warning and training Max pilots after the Lion Air crash were set by the FAA and Boeing and that their directives were used to "brief all our pilots" and incorporated into flight manuals.

CEO Tewolde Gebremariam said in an interview shortly after the Ethiopian crash, "Today we believe that might not have been enough."

Gebremariam declined to say whether the pilots on the doomed flight took additional training after the Lion Air crash on Ethiopian's Max simulator, a multimillion-dollar piece of equipment most airlines don't have, but said "it wouldn't have made any difference" because the simulator wasn't designed to imitate problems in the new jet's flight-control system.

Ethiopian has said both the captain and co-pilot followed all the steps Boeing laid out in its bulletin on how to respond to a malfunction in the anti-stall system.

But the preliminary report on the March 10 crash of Ethiopian Airlines Flight 302 from Addis Ababa to Nairobi showed that the pilots deviated from the directives and made other mistakes, notably flying the plane at an unusually high speed and inexplicably reactivating the anti-stall system shortly after manually overriding it.

Six minutes into its flight, the plane with passengers from nearly a dozen countries cratered into the ground about 40 miles from the airport.

Former FAA Administrator Randy Babbitt said the Ethiopian pilots clearly bear some of the blame.

"So Boeing was at fault because a light came on or this thing tripped mistakenly, but it shouldn't have brought the airplane down," Babbitt said of the anti-stall system. "That was very fixable and a pretty simple solution. And they didn't come to grips with it. ... They let the plane get away from them."

Peter Lemme, a former Boeing engineer who worked on flight control systems, said apportioning blame between Boeing and the crew is difficult.

"Some pilots in their easy chairs are saying they would have known how to react, but it's not so easy," he said. "Did the pilots cause the accident? No. Could they have prevented it? Yes."

Von Hoesslin, a 56-year-old pilot with three decades of flying experience, initially wrote to his bosses Nov. 11 in response to the airline's five-sentence email to dozens of pilots alerting them to the Boeing bulletin and reminding them about the checklist of steps to perform should something similar go wrong.

He urged Ethiopian to give more information because pilots are not "fully or even aware of how" the MCAS works. That prompted a second email from the airline with more detail.

A month later, on Dec. 12, von Hoesslin sent another email, urging a close reading of a preliminary report from Indonesian regulators on the crash there. He pointed out several potential problems with the Max and recommended steps be taken to make sure pilots know the checklist.

The next day, he sent a third email recommending new simulator training designed to roughly re-create what went wrong in the Indonesian flight, adding that he had already practiced in a simulator rigged in such a way and his experience with all the alarms going off was frightening.

"Throw in a GPWS PULL UP" — a warning to pilots that the plane is in danger of crashing into the ground — "and it would be a crash for sure."

Boeing has said that its fix to software on the Max's anti-stall system will be accompanied by additional training for pilots. The acting chief of the FAA, Daniel Elwell, said last week that his agency hasn't decided whether that training should be conducted on computers or in flight simulators.


AP writer David Koenig in Dallas and researchers Jennifer Farrar, Randy Herschaft and Rhonda Shafner in New York contributed to this report.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, AP Business
© Copyright 2019
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Missouri governor doubles down on abortion license threat
Missouri Gov. Mike Parson has doubled down on the state's threat not to renew the license of the only abortion clinic in the state
3:48PM ( 10 minutes ago )
Ethiopian pilot pleaded for training weeks before Max crash
An Ethiopian pilot pleaded with his bosses for more training on the Boeing Max, just weeks before one of the airline's jets crashed, killing everyone on board
3:47PM ( 10 minutes ago )
The Latest: Pelosi says 'nothing off the table' on Trump
House Speaker Nancy Pelosi says "nothing is off the table," including potential impeachment proceedings against President Donald Trump
3:44PM ( 13 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
1 dead, 3 including deputy wounded in East Texas shootings
Police are searching for a man they say killed a woman and wounded three people, including a sheriff's deputy, during shootings in East Texas
3:04PM ( 53 minutes ago )
Trial against border activist who helped migrants begins
Jury selection has begun in a federal trial against a border activist charged with harboring migrants in a case that advocates say is a politically-motivated
2:57PM ( 1 hour ago )
Gucci makes abortion rights statement with 2020 Cruise line
Gucci creative director Alessandro Michele has made a clear abortion rights message in his latest Cruise collection, as the issue heats up again in the United States
2:45PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
In UAE, Trump's adviser warns Iran of 'very strong response'
Trump's security adviser warns Iran of 'very strong response' if Tehran launches attacks on US, allies in Persian Gulf
1:50PM ( 2 hours ago )
Navy SEAL seeks to toss slaying case over withheld evidence
Lawyers for a Navy SEAL accused of killing an Islamic State prisoner in Iraq in 2017 are seeking to have the charges dismissed for alleged prosecutorial misconduct
1:16PM ( 2 hours ago )
Israel's political crisis could trigger a new election
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu faces a midnight deadline to form a new governing coalition as he sought to stave off a crisis that could trigger an unprecedented second election this year or even force him to step down
1:04PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Online National News
Jordan stands by 2-state Israel-Palestinian solution
Jordan stands by a two-state solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, exposing a rift with the United States as the Trump administration tries to rally Arab support for a peace conference next month in Bahrain
2:29PM ( 1 hour ago )
US stocks slide toward first monthly loss of 2019
Stocks fell broadly and investors fled to safer holdings as anxiety over global trade tensions continued to spread.
12:34PM ( 3 hours ago )
European Central Bank sends Italy a warning over debt
The European Central Bank says challenges to financial stability in the eurozone have risen amid trade tensions, and warns that indebted governments such as Italy could run into trouble if they don't heed debt rules
12:14PM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Business
Missouri governor doubles down on abortion license threat
Missouri Gov. Mike Parson has doubled down on the state's threat not to renew the license of the only abortion clinic in the state
3:48PM ( 10 minutes ago )
The Latest: Pelosi says 'nothing off the table' on Trump
House Speaker Nancy Pelosi says "nothing is off the table," including potential impeachment proceedings against President Donald Trump
3:44PM ( 13 minutes ago )
Spain decries UN working group's opinion on jailed Catalans
The Spanish government lashed out Friday at what it called impartiality of experts working under the United Nations umbrella that had called for releasing from custody three Catalan separatists who are on trial in Spain
3:29PM ( 28 minutes ago )
'Super old' Federer to face ex-contemporary's son at French
Roger Federer's next opponent at the French Open is the son of someone who was in the field the first time Federer entered the tournament back in 1999
3:25PM ( 32 minutes ago )
Barr in Alaska to talk Native violence, not Mueller remarks
U.S. Attorney General William Barr is visiting Alaska to meet with tribal leaders and other officials about disproportionately high rates of violence and sexual assault in Native communities
3:20PM ( 37 minutes ago )