Thursday August 13th, 2020 7:52AM

Huawei asks court to rule US security law unconstitutional

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

SHENZHEN, China (AP) — Fighting to maintain its access to major markets for next-generation communications, Chinese tech giant Huawei is challenging the constitutionality of a 2018 U.S. law that bars it from selling telecoms equipment to U.S. government agencies and contractors.

In a motion filed late Tuesday in eastern Texas federal court, Huawei argues for summary judgment in the case in filed in March against the U.S. government. It says the law violates a constitutional prohibition against "trial by legislature" of individual entities.

Congress thus acted unconstitutionally when it "adjudicated Huawei's guilt and blacklisted it," the motion argues.

The motion comes as the U.S. and China are embroiled in a broader trade war in which both sides have imposed billions of dollars of punitive tariffs against each other's products. Chinese state media suggested Wednesday that the country's rich supply of rare earths — key elements for high-tech manufacturing — could be used as leverage against the U.S. in the dispute.

Huawei is the biggest global maker of network equipment and enjoys a lead in 5G, or fifth-generation, technology. It also is the No. 2 maker of smartphones. The Trump administration says the company can be legally compelled to spy on behalf of the Chinese government and is thus a threat to international cybersecurity.

"This decision threatens to harm our customers in over 170 countries, including more than 3 billion customers who use Huawei products and services around the world," Huawei's chief legal officer, Song Liuping, said at a news briefing Wednesday.

Huawei, whose U.S. headquarters is in Plano, Texas, said in Tuesday's motion that the U.S. national defense law that punishes it as an alleged agent of Beijing's ruling Communist Party also violates its rights by presuming its guilt without a fair trial.

The summary judgment motion seeks to accelerate the legal process to give U.S. customers access to Huawei equipment sooner, Huawei said in a statement.

Song said the "state-sanctioned campaign" against the company will not improve cybersecurity.

"Politicians in the U.S. are using the strength of an entire nation to come after a private company," he said. "This is not normal."

But just because something might strike us as not quite fair or outright wrong doesn't necessarily make it unconstitutional, said Steven Schwinn, a professor at John Marshall Law School in Chicago.

He said Huawei's arguments, while strong on U.S. lawmakers' punitive intent, fall short constitutionally.

Schwinn and other legal scholars aren't sanguine about Huawei's chances.

"Given that this relates to national security we can expect the courts to be fairly deferential to the government and we ought to think of that as the thumb on the scale in favor of the government in all of these claims," he said.

The presiding judge has scheduled motions through Sept. 10 so Schwinn said it was unlikely the case would be dismissed before then.

Separately, the U.S. Commerce Department this month placed Huawei on its "Entity List," effectively barring U.S. companies from selling their technology to it and other Chinese firms without government approval. Huawei relies heavily on U.S. components, including computer chips, and about one-third of its suppliers are American.

The backdrop is China's longstanding huge trade surplus with the U.S. and complaints that Beijing and Chinese companies use unfair tactics to acquire advanced foreign technologies.

The most recent round of negotiations between Beijing and Washington ended earlier this month without an agreement after President Donald Trump more than doubled duties on $200 billion in Chinese products. China responded by raising tariffs of 5% to 25% on $60 billion worth of American goods.

At least three Chinese state media outlets on Wednesday suggested the country's supply of rare earths could be used as a weapon.

People's Daily, the official newspaper of the ruling Communist Party, said in an editorial that the U.S. is a major buyer of China's rare earth materials and "highly dependent" on such resources. The editorial was titled "The U.S. should not underestimate China's ability to enact countermeasures."

Chinese President Xi Jinping visited rare earth-related businesses in southeastern Jiangxi province earlier this month. He called rare earths "an important strategic resource" while stressing the importance of owning independent core technologies, the state-run China Daily reported.

As a weapon, the nationalistic Global Times said, rare earths "convey that China will not succumb to U.S. pressure." If the U.S. does not exercise restraint, it will see that "China is far from running out of cards, and we have the will and determination to fight the U.S. to the end," the editorial said.

An official of China's top economic planning agency did not rule out using rare earths as a countermeasure against "the U.S.'s unwarranted suppression."

The actions against Huawei have already affected the company's U.S. partnerships. Google said it would continue to support existing Huawei smartphones, but future devices won't include its flagship apps and services, including maps, Gmail and search — a change that will likely make Huawei phones less appealing.

Song said the U.S. has not provided any evidence to show that Huawei is a security threat.

"There is no gun, no smoke, only speculation," he said, accusing the U.S. of setting a "dangerous precedent."

"Today it's telecoms and Huawei," he said. "Tomorrow it could be your industry, your company, your consumers."


Associated Press video producer Olivia Zhang in Shenzhen and writer Chris Bodeen in Beijing and Frank Bajak in Boston contributed to this report.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Health, AP World News, AP Business, AP Business - Corporate News, AP World News - International incidents, AP Business - Economy, AP Technology News
© Copyright 2020
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Huawei asks court to rule US security law unconstitutional
Huawei challenges constitutionality of U.S. law limiting sales of telecom equipment
8:59AM ( 3 minutes ago )
Russia, Serbia blame NATO for Kosovo police raid
Russia and Serbia have blamed pro-NATO and Western influences for an armed raid by Kosovo police in the Serb-dominated north of Kosovo that raised tensions in the region.
8:58AM ( 4 minutes ago )
McConnell: 'We'd fill' any Supreme Court vacancy in 2020
Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell says if a Supreme Court vacancy occurs during next year's election cycle the Senate would confirm a GOP nominee selected by President Donald Trump
8:51AM ( 11 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Huawei asks court to deem US security law unconstitutional
Chinese tech giant Huawei has filed a motion in U.S. court challenging the constitutionality of a law that limits its sales of telecom equipment
1:14AM ( 7 hours ago )
Illinois to expand abortion rights as other states restrict
The Illinois House adopted protections for abortion on Tuesday as Democrats fire back at steep curbs in other states which conservatives hope will land the issue in a U.S. Supreme Court leaning toward a wholesale review of legalized abortion
9:11PM ( 11 hours ago )
6 months later, gene-edited babies stir new interest, debate
Six months after a Chinese scientist was widely scorned for helping to make the world's first gene-edited babies, new information suggests that others may be interested in pursuing the same kind of work
8:10PM ( 12 hours ago )
AP Health
Boris Johnson to face court questions about Brexit claims
A British judge has ruled that former Foreign Secretary Boris Johnson will be summoned to court to answer questions about his possible misconduct in public office during the Brexit referendum campaign in 2016
8:01AM ( 1 hour ago )
European Central Bank sends Italy a warning over debt
The European Central Bank says challenges to financial stability in the eurozone have risen amid trade tensions, and warns that indebted governments such as Italy could run into trouble if they don't heed debt rules
7:48AM ( 1 hour ago )
Deadly knife attack on schoolgirls startles Japan
A deadly knife attack on a group of mostly schoolgirls near Tokyo this week has raised concerns over the safety of schoolchildren in Japan, known for its low crime rate and where children usually walk to school on their own or in groups
7:46AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP World News
World stocks tumble as China-US jitters set in
World markets retreat again as fears that China-US dispute could weigh on growth
7:36AM ( 1 hour ago )
World stocks retreat as China-US jitters set in
World markets retreat on fears that China-US dispute would simmer and weigh on growth
5:23AM ( 3 hours ago )
Veteran China dissident urges linking of human rights, trade
Veteran Chinese dissident Wang Dan is urging Western nations to restore the link between human rights and trade with China
5:20AM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Business
Sports Illustrated magazine sold for $110 million
Publisher Meredith Corp. is selling the Sports Illustrated brand to Authentic Brands Group for $110 million
5:33PM ( 15 hours ago )
US stocks, bond yield slump, signaling market jitters
U.S. stocks fell broadly Tuesday as anxious investors shifted money into bonds, sending yields to their lowest level in nearly two years
4:59PM ( 16 hours ago )
Raiders agree to 1-year deal with troubled guard Incognito
Oakland Raiders agree to 1-year deal with troubled guard Richie Incognito
4:51PM ( 16 hours ago )
AP Business - Corporate News
Trump team faces tough audiences as it sells Mideast plan
President Donald Trump's top Mideast advisers face skeptical audiences as they start a tour of the region to rally support for their 'economy-first' plan for Israeli-Palestinian peace
5:35PM ( 15 hours ago )
Serbian troops on full alert after Kosovo police arrests
Serbia put its troops on full alert after heavily armed Kosovo police entered Serb-dominated northern Kosovo, firing tear gas and arresting about two dozen people.
1:21PM ( 19 hours ago )
Trump says he backs Japan's efforts to talk with Iran
President Donald Trump says he would back the Japanese prime minister's efforts to open communications with Iran
1:51AM ( 2 days ago )
AP World News - International incidents
US does not brand China as currency manipulator
Trump administration does not brand China as currency manipulator but puts 9 nations on watch list
6:53PM ( 14 hours ago )
Kushner in Morocco to build support for Mideast peace plan
President Donald Trump's son-in-law and senior adviser Jared Kushner is in the Mideast to drum up support for his as-yet unveiled Israeli-Palestinian peace plan
1:17PM ( 19 hours ago )
Contenders to be next UK leader divided over no-deal Brexit
The race to succeed Prime Minister Theresa May is becoming a battle over whether Britain should leave the European Union without a divorce agreement _ or whether that would cause economic and political mayhem
11:57AM ( 21 hours ago )
AP Business - Economy
McConnell: 'We'd fill' any Supreme Court vacancy in 2020
Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell says if a Supreme Court vacancy occurs during next year's election cycle the Senate would confirm a GOP nominee selected by President Donald Trump
8:51AM ( 11 minutes ago )
New Israeli government or election: Netanyahu faces deadline
Israel faces midnight deadline for new government to be formed or it goes to unprecedented second election this year
8:33AM ( 29 minutes ago )
The Latest: 20-year-old Moutet downs Pella at French Open
Corentin Moutet produced the biggest win of his burgeoning career in front of his home crowd to reach the third round at a Grand Slam tournament for the first time
8:23AM ( 38 minutes ago )
As craft beer market grows, so do wild flavors
As craft breweries have boomed, competition for attention has intensified and that has a lot of brewers looking for ways to differentiate themselves by introducing strange new flavors
8:08AM ( 54 minutes ago )
Trump urges Roy Moore not to run for US Senate in Alabama
President Donald Trump is warning the "consequences will be devastating" if Republican Roy Moore again runs for the U.S. Senate from Alabama
8:02AM ( 1 hour ago )