Monday October 21st, 2019 1:14AM

In some Democrat-led states, lawmakers differ on abortion

By The Associated Press

PROVIDENCE, R.I. (AP) — A bill seeking to preserve abortion protections in state law fails to pass a key committee. Lawmakers cite God, church and faith in proclaiming their opposition to it. Abortion-rights groups protest outside a gathering of lawmakers.

What sounds like a legislative fight in a state controlled by anti-abortion Republicans is actually quite different.

The bill seeking to protect abortion rights is in Rhode Island, a state controlled by Democrats at all levels of political power, and it's stalled.

"This is an issue, I think, where it's very difficult to draw a line down party lines," said Democratic state Sen. Erin Lynch Prata, a committee chairwoman who voted in favor of the bill. "It's a very personal issue to a lot of people."

Rhode Island is not the only state led politically by Democrats where abortion-rights legislation has either died or stalled this year. A bill to remove a dormant criminal ban on abortion in New Mexico was voted down in March by the Democrat-led state Senate, despite a push to shore up abortion rights by Democratic Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham. In Hawaii, where all but six of the 76 lawmakers are Democrats, a bill allowing advanced-practice registered nurses to perform some abortions passed the Senate but died in a House committee.

To be sure, some Democratic-led states are taking steps to enshrine the right to an abortion should the U.S. Supreme Court ever overturn the 1973 Roe v. Wade decision. Among them are Nevada, New York and Vermont.

But the enthusiasm and recent success of anti-abortion activists to pass near total bans on the procedure in about a half-dozen Republican-dominated states provides a stark contrast to the more muted response in states controlled by Democrats.

In those states, the legislative records and personal views of Democratic lawmakers are mixed, much to the disappointment of abortion-rights supporters.

Jocelyn Foye, co-director of The Womxn Project in Rhode Island, said she thinks that while many politicians run as Democrats in the state to win, they don't always vote like Democrats, particularly on abortion rights. She said she is frustrated that the abortion-protection bill has not progressed.

"At the same time, it has empowered me, as well as the community we have working with us, to really just not let up," Foye said. "We're going to keep fighting."

Members of The Womxn Project staged a protest last week outside a fundraiser for the Rhode Island Senate Democrats political action committee, intended to pressure the legislative leaders to bring the bill to a floor vote. Foye said it also was a way to hold the senators accountable for taking care of the women of Rhode Island.

"The only thing standing in the way of this bill is Democrats, and they need to know that," said Liz Gledhill, a member of the Rhode Island Democratic Party Women's Caucus who was among roughly 150 people attending the protest. "You can't call yourself a Democrat and vote against a bill like this."

The Rhode Island bill says the state will not restrict the right to an abortion prior to fetal viability or afterward if an abortion is necessary for the health or life of the mother. It also would repeal older state abortion laws deemed unconstitutional by the courts.

Passage is far from assured in a heavily Catholic state where many lawmakers cite their faith as a guide to their political decisions.

Democratic Sen. Harold Metts, a Baptist deacon whose statehouse office is decorated with crosses, said he would never vote for an abortion-rights bill because "abortion robs God of his glory by substituting man and government in God's place to determine life and death."

Similar sentiments doomed the abortion-rights legislation in New Mexico earlier this year.

Eight Senate Democrats joined with Republicans to defeat the bill, which would have overturned a 1969 statute making it a felony for an abortion provider to terminate a pregnancy. Opponents, including the local Roman Catholic Church, highlighted provisions that would allow late-term abortions to continue.

The outcome caught many of the bill's supporters by surprise and makes it likely that the state's dormant abortion ban will stand at least through the 2020 election, in a state where Democrats control the Legislature and every elected statewide office.

During the floor debate on the bill in March, Democratic state Sen. Gabriel Ramos held aloft letters of opposition from three Catholic dioceses and urged colleagues to follow their advice.

"To me, I was just doing what's right in my mind and for my district," said Ramos, who voted against the bill and rejects the notion that abortion is a partisan topic. "This is a life issue; this is a moral issue."

State Sen. Gerald Ortiz y Pino, a practicing Catholic who supports abortion rights, said the Senate vote should be a wake-up call to abortion-rights advocacy groups in New Mexico. He noted that there are just eight women in the 42-member Senate.

"We lost; there is no way of getting around that," he said. "If activists want to get a different result, they're going to have to get more women in the Senate or they're going to have to explain to more men in the Senate that they want a women's right to choose to be honored."

In Hawaii, state Rep. John Mizuno, a Democrat, said lawmakers on the health committee he chairs believed a Senate bill expanding the ranks of those who can perform abortions needed further discussion.

The committee amended the bill to create a task force and two other House committees deferred it, effectively killing it for the session. Mizuno said the bill could be taken up next year.

Abortion-rights activists have taken heart in the actions of other states controlled by Democrats.

New York adopted an abortion-rights measure in January that, among other things, codifies many court-granted rights. Vermont's Democratic-led Legislature this month passed both a bill and constitutional amendment that would guarantee the right to abortion. Republican Gov. Phil Scott has said the bill will become law, but the amendment must be approved again by the Legislature elected in 2020 for it to appear on the 2022 ballot.

The Democratic-led Nevada Legislature, which has the nation's first overall female majority, voted this past week to relax abortion laws. The measure would repeal criminal penalties for people who perform or supply medications to induce abortion without the advice of a physician. It also would repeal requirements to document the woman's marital status and inform her about the "emotional implications" of abortion.

Andrea Miller, president of the National Institute for Reproductive Health, a New York-based nonprofit advocacy group, said abortion opponents sensed an opportunity to challenge Roe v. Wade before a more conservative Supreme Court and used that to make a major legislative push in Republican-dominated states this spring.

"At the same time, though, we really are seeing momentum in these other states that are seeking to do anything and everything they need to protect abortion rights and advance access to abortion care," Miller said. "We have a lot of confidence that those are going to continue to move forward in the coming weeks."

The fight will not necessarily play out along neat partisan lines, however. The fate of bills this year seeking to expand or codify abortion rights is uncertain in a number of states where Democrats are in control, including Illinois and Maine.

In Rhode Island, abortion-rights supporters are working on compromise language for the stalled bill in hopes they can persuade enough Senate Democrats to eventually approve it; the House passed its version of the legislation in March. Democratic state Sen. Dawn Euer said tensions are high around the issue and that lawmakers' conversations are "under a microscope."

Barth Bracy, executive director of Rhode Island Right to Life, said he thinks some Democrats are pushing back against being stereotyped on the issue.

"There are a lot of John F. Kennedy Democrats in Rhode Island who feel betrayed by the suggestion that in order to be a good Democrat, they must be pro-abortion," he said.


Lieb reported from Jefferson City, Missouri. Associated Press writers Morgan Lee in Santa Fe, New Mexico, and Audrey McAvoy in Honolulu contributed to this report.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Online Supreme Court News, AP Health, AP Health - Women's health
© Copyright 2019
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
California congressman says he's taken photo with dead enemy
U.S. Rep. Duncan Hunter of California has acknowledged taking a photo with a dead combatant during his time as a Marine as he defended a Navy SEAL charged with multiple war crimes
4:09PM ( 3 minutes ago )
Champion, queen, goddess, mother: Serena wins at French Open
Disappointing to dominant: Serena Williams comes back to beat Vitalia Diatchenko at French Open
3:39PM ( 33 minutes ago )
Texas lawmakers approve safe gun storage program despite NRA
A $1 million safe gun storage campaign could be new pressure point for NRA, gun control advocates and Republican Gov. Greg Abbott
3:36PM ( 35 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Serena Williams turns match around to win at French Open
Disappointing to dominant: Serena Williams recovers to beat Vitalia Diatchenko at French Open
2:29PM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: Merkel wants quick deal on head of EU Commission
German Chancellor Angela Merkel says she'd like to see a quick agreement on who should run the European Union's executive branch, a matter on which her own governing coalition so far is divided
2:15PM ( 1 hour ago )
Israel faces possible second election amid coalition crisis
Israel's newly elected parliament is promoting a bill to dissolve itself as a deadline to form a coalition government nears with no progress in sight
2:13PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
Macron vs. Salvini: Two leaders face off over EU's future
France's pro-EU president and the leader of Italy's euroskeptic, far-right movement are jockeying for the role of chief powerbroker on the continent after elections to the European Parliament hollowed out the traditional political middle
1:07PM ( 3 hours ago )
Trump and Japan's Abe at odds over North Korea missile tests
President Donald Trump says he's not "personally" bothered by recent short-range missile tests that North Korea conducted this month, breaking with Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe, who has been hosting the president on a four-day state visit
12:37PM ( 3 hours ago )
Baghdad court sentences fourth French IS member to death
Iraqi court sentences fourth French former IS member to death, postpones verdict for fifth man
11:28AM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Online National News
Spotlight on Oklahoma for start of trial for opioid makers
Oklahoma is poised to become the first state to go to trial in a lawsuit against the makers of pharmaceuticals blamed for contributing to the nation's opioid crisis
10:25AM ( 5 hours ago )
The Latest: 2nd apparent tornado hits Oklahoma near Tulsa
An apparent tornado has downed trees and power lines and heavily damaged some businesses in a suburb of Tulsa, Oklahoma
6:24AM ( 9 hours ago )
Tornadoes rake 2 Oklahoma cities, killing 2 and injuring 29
Authorities say a tornado leveled a motel and tore through a mobile home park near Oklahoma City overnight, killing two people and injuring at least 29 others before a second twister raked a Tulsa suburb more than 100 miles away
8:15PM ( 19 hours ago )
Top U.S. News short headlines
Pence honors fallen service members at Arlington cemetery
Vice President Mike Pence has paid tribute to fallen members of the armed forces in a Memorial Day ceremony at Arlington National Cemetery
3:14PM ( 58 minutes ago )
French far-right makes big demands on Macron after small win
If French far-right leader Marine Le Pen gets her wish, her National Rally party, victorious in European Parliament elections, will force a dissolution of France's own parliament but French President Emmanuel Macron is standing in her way
1:25PM ( 2 hours ago )
EU elections: Gutted center, high turnout, rising right
The European Union prides itself on being a brilliant mosaic of nations, but on Sunday it produced a hodgepodge of sometimes contradictory results that complicates the future
12:47PM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
UK Brexit Party scores big as Conservatives, Labour bashed
Veteran euroskeptic Nigel Farage says Britain should get set to leave the European Union without a divorce deal, after a European election that saw his Brexit Party and pro-EU forces carve up the votes at the expense of the long-dominant larger parties
8:28AM ( 7 hours ago )
The Latest: May says drubbing shows need for Brexit deal
British Prime Minister Theresa May says her Conservative Party's drubbing in EU elections shows the need for Parliament to pass a Brexit deal and take the U.K. out of the European Union
8:09AM ( 8 hours ago )
The Latest: Scottish National Party does well in EU vote
Scottish National Party wins 3 of 6 Scottish seats in the European Parliament while Labour Party comes up empty
7:46AM ( 8 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Judge blocks Trump from building sections of border wall
A federal judge blocked President Donald Trump from building key sections of his border wall with money secured under his declaration of a national emergency, delivering what may prove a temporary setback on one of his highest priorities
4:20PM ( 1 day ago )
Federal lawsuit filed to block Alabama's new abortion ban
Abortion providers are asking a federal judge to block an Alabama law that would ban most abortions in the state
5:42PM ( 2 days ago )
Anita Hill, Bob Woodward honored at annual PEN American gala
Anita Hill, Bob Woodward and three Saudi Arabian dissidents among those honored at annual gala hosted by PEN America
10:56AM ( 5 days ago )
AP Online Supreme Court News
State abortion bans may hand Democrats a political weapon
Members of both parties say a flood of laws banning abortions in Republican-run states has handed Democrats a political weapon heading into next year's elections
3:53PM ( 2 days ago )
Both parties say abortion bans give Dems a political weapon
Members of both parties say a flood of laws banning abortions in Republican-run states has handed Democrats a political weapon heading into next year's elections
9:59AM ( 2 days ago )
Pope: Abortion is never OK, equates it to "hiring a hitman"
Pope Francis says abortion can never be condoned, even when the fetus is gravely sick or malformed, and is urging doctors and priests to support families to carry such pregnancies to term
9:18AM ( 2 days ago )
AP Health
Administration moves to revoke transgender health protection
A new Trump administration rule would roll back sex discrimination protection for transgender people in health services
5:04PM ( 2 days ago )
Family of incapacitated woman who was raped blames Arizona
The parents of an incapacitated woman who was raped and later gave birth at a Phoenix long-term care center says the facility and state broke their promise to have only female caregivers tend to their daughter
9:06PM ( 3 days ago )
Pregnant woman seeks deportation asylum in Chicago church
A pregnant woman is seeking asylum in a Chicago church after she says she received a deportation order and must leave the U.S. WBEZ radio reported Tuesday that Adilene Marquina has a high-risk pregnancy and is afraid to travel back to Mexico
3:49PM ( 5 days ago )
AP Health - Women's health
Champion, queen, goddess, mother: Serena wins at French Open
Disappointing to dominant: Serena Williams comes back to beat Vitalia Diatchenko at French Open
3:39PM ( 33 minutes ago )
Texas lawmakers approve safe gun storage program despite NRA
A $1 million safe gun storage campaign could be new pressure point for NRA, gun control advocates and Republican Gov. Greg Abbott
3:36PM ( 36 minutes ago )
New Ukrainian President Zelenskiy visits eastern war zone
Ukraine's new president has visited military positions in the country's east, where the army has been fighting Russia-backed separatists for five years
3:32PM ( 40 minutes ago )
Pedroia taking leave; injured Red Sox 2B may not play again
Red Sox second baseman Dustin Pedroia will take an "indefinite leave" in his long struggle to recover from knee trouble, putting in doubt whether he'll ever play again in the majors
3:26PM ( 46 minutes ago )
Texas approves safe gun storage campaign over NRA objection
A $1 million safe gun storage campaign could be new pressure point for NRA, gun control advocates and Republican Gov. Greg Abbott
3:24PM ( 48 minutes ago )