mcloudy.png
Wednesday September 18th, 2019 9:58AM

Judge skeptical of Trump effort to keep records from House

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — A federal judge suggested Tuesday he is skeptical of President Donald Trump's efforts to block Congress from obtaining some of his financial records.

Judge Amit Mehta spent about an hour and a half holding a hearing on Trump's effort to keep financial records from Congress. Mehta did not rule during the hearing whether the House's subpoena of Trump financial records is a valid exercise of legislative power, but he said he would do so "promptly."

The lawsuit before Mehta comes amid a widespread effort by the White House and the president's attorneys to refuse to cooperate with congressional requests for information and records. In asking Mehta to block the subpoena, Trump is in essence asking the judicial branch to stop the legislative branch from investigating his past.

Trump and his business organization sued the House oversight committee in April in an attempt to block a subpoena issued to Mazars USA, an accountant for the president and Trump Organization. Trump's lawyers argued the subpoena "has no legitimate legislative purpose" and accused Democrats of harassing Trump and wielding their new majority in Congress to try to stain the president's standing.

But House lawyers told the judge that the Constitution gives Congress broad powers to investigate and that it doesn't need to tie an investigation it is undertaking to a specific piece of legislation it is considering.

Mehta, who was nominated to his position by President Barack Obama, suggested during the hearing that Congress has wide latitude to investigate. He told Trump lawyer William Consovoy that there isn't a case since 1880 where the Supreme Court or an appeals court found that Congress overstepped its boundaries in issuing a subpoena.

Douglas Letter, an attorney for the House, told the judge that "President Trump has no chance of success here." And he said Trump has taken the position that Congress is "just getting in his way" of running the country.

Mehta did suggest to Letter that the subpoena does seem to be an effort to get into Trump's private affairs. And he asked Letter whether there are any limits on what Congress can obtain. Letter acknowledged that there are some outer limits, suggesting a request for the president's blood or his diary from when he was a child might be too extreme. But he said the subpoena for financial records is clearly permissible.

The judge seemed to be looking to resolve the case quickly, though he said he would accept additional materials until Friday.

"We're not going to drag this out," he said at one point.

Consovoy, Trump's lawyer, indicated near the end of the hearing that his client would appeal if the judge ruled against him.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Business
© Copyright 2019 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Judge skeptical of Trump effort to keep records from House
A federal judge in Washington is set to hold a hearing Tuesday on President Donald Trump's attempt to block a House subpoena that seeks years of his financial records
1:14PM ( 10 minutes ago )
AP source: Barr working with intel chiefs on Russia review
Attorney General William Barr is working with CIA Director Gina Haspel and Director of National Intelligence Dan Coats to examine intelligence methods used during the Russia investigation
1:05PM ( 18 minutes ago )
Military officer says no rise in Iran threat in Iraq, Syria
A senior officer in the U.S.-led military coalition combating the Islamic State says there is no increased threat from Iranian-backed forces in Iraq or Syria
12:56PM ( 28 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
AP sources: Trump officials discussed deporting families
AP sources: Homeland Security officials considered rounding up migrant families around the country who had final deportation orders, and detain and remove them from the U.S. in a flashy show of force
12:43PM ( 41 minutes ago )
Trump looks to highlight energy exports in Louisiana
President Donald Trump will highlight his administration's efforts to ramp up liquefied natural gas exports as he visits a new plant in southwest Louisiana
11:59AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP sources: Trump Jr. subpoena sent when interviews declined
AP sources: Senate intelligence committee subpoenaed Donald Trump Jr. after he backed out of two scheduled interviews as part of the panel's Russia investigation
11:51AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Candidates face off in GOP primary for NC congressional race
Republicans are deciding who should carry their banner into a high-profile congressional race in a North Carolina district lacking a delegate in Washington because last year's election was tainted by fraud
8:59AM ( 4 hours ago )
Ex-Congressman Weiner leaves halfway house
Former U.S. Rep. Anthony Weiner has left a New York City halfway house after completing his prison sentence for illicit online contact with a 15-year-old girl
8:31AM ( 4 hours ago )
Unofficial tally shows Duterte allies winning big in polls
President Rodrigo Duterte's allies appear to have overwhelming leads in elections for the Philippine Senate, one of the opposition's last bulwarks against a brash populist leader accused of massive human rights violations
8:19AM ( 5 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Stocks rebound a day after nosedive induced by trade worries
Stocks clawed higher and regained some lost ground following a rout over trade war anxiety
12:44PM ( 40 minutes ago )
Revolution hire 5-time MLS Cup champ Bruce Arena as coach
Revolution hire 5-time MLS Cup winner and former US coach Bruce Arena as coach, director
12:30PM ( 54 minutes ago )
Disney takes over Hulu from Comcast as stream wars heat up
Disney takes full control of Hulu, elevating the fight for dominance of the stream
11:58AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
AP source: Barr working with intel chiefs on Russia review
Attorney General William Barr is working with CIA Director Gina Haspel and Director of National Intelligence Dan Coats to examine intelligence methods used during the Russia investigation
1:05PM ( 19 minutes ago )
Military officer says no rise in Iran threat in Iraq, Syria
A senior officer in the U.S.-led military coalition combating the Islamic State says there is no increased threat from Iranian-backed forces in Iraq or Syria
12:56PM ( 28 minutes ago )
US targets $300B of Chinese goods for new tariff hikes
The United States has issued a $300 billion target list of additional Chinese goods for tariff hikes in a possible new escalation of a trade fight that is shaking financial markets and fueling concern about global economic growth
12:46PM ( 38 minutes ago )
Stocks rebound a day after nosedive induced by trade worries
Stocks clawed higher and regained some lost ground following a rout over trade war anxiety
12:44PM ( 40 minutes ago )
AP sources: Trump officials discussed deporting families
AP sources: Homeland Security officials considered rounding up migrant families around the country who had final deportation orders, and detain and remove them from the U.S. in a flashy show of force
12:43PM ( 41 minutes ago )