sunny.png
Monday November 23rd, 2020 3:04PM

Supreme Court says 1 state can't be sued in another's courts

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Supreme Court decided Monday that one state cannot unwillingly be sued in the courts of another, overruling a 40-year precedent and perhaps, foreshadowing an argument over the viability of other high court decisions.

The outcome left one dissenting justice wondering "which cases the court will overrule next."

The justices divided 5-4 to end a long-running dispute between California officials and Nevada inventor Gilbert Hyatt.

Hyatt is a former California resident who sued California's tax agency for being too zealous in seeking back taxes from him. Hyatt won a judgment in Nevada courts.

But Justice Clarence Thomas wrote for the court's conservative justices that the Constitution forbids states from opening the doors of their courts to a private citizen's lawsuit against another state. In 1979, the high court concluded otherwise.

The four liberal justices dissented, saying they would have left alone the court's decision in Nevada v. Hall. Justice Stephen Breyer said there are good reasons to overrule an earlier case, including that it is no longer workable or a vestige of an otherwise abandoned legal doctrine.

But Breyer said that justices should otherwise adhere to the principle of stare decisis, Latin for to stand by things decided.

"It is far more dangerous to overrule a decision only because five members of a later court come to agree with earlier dissenters on a difficult legal question," Breyer wrote. He included a reference to the court's 1992 ruling in Planned Parenthood of Southeastern Pennsylvania v. Casey that reaffirmed the right to abortion the court declared in Roe v. Wade in 1973.

The future of abortion rights at the court is a matter of intense interest as several states have enacted increasingly restrictive abortion laws in the hope that a more conservative Supreme Court majority will uphold them.

In his majority opinion, Thomas cited other Supreme Court precedent that held "stare decisis is not an inexorable command."

The Hyatt case had been to the Supreme Court twice before. In 2016, the justices split 4-4 over the same question that was finally answered on Monday.

The case is Franchise Tax Board of California v. Hyatt, 17-1299.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Supreme Court News, AP Business
© Copyright 2020 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
'Empire' to get 1 more season on Fox amid schedule shake-up
The Fox network says 'Empire' will be back for one last season in the fall for its finale
10:31AM ( 22 minutes ago )
Poland shaken by documentary about pedophile priests
A new documentary about pedophile priests is shaking mostly Catholic Poland, eliciting an apology by the church hierarchy and prompting one priest to leave the clergy
10:28AM ( 25 minutes ago )
Amazon offers to help employees start delivery business
Amazon to employees: Quit your job and we'll help you start delivery business
10:24AM ( 29 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Britain warns US-Iran conflict could break out 'by accident'
Britain is warning that conflict might break out "by accident" between the United States and Iran, as U.S. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo held talks with EU powers backing the nuclear deal with the Islamic Republic
9:20AM ( 1 hour ago )
Trade row deepens as China ups tariffs on $60B in US goods
Companies brace for Chinese retaliation against Trump tariff hikes as economists warn growth likely to suffer
9:19AM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: Assange case reopening hailed by Swedish accuser
The lawyer for a Swedish woman who reported being raped by WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange in 2010 says "today we got great news."
8:59AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Hundreds gather at ceremony to bid farewell to Rosenstein
Hundreds of Justice Department employees have gathered to send off Deputy Attorney General Rod Rosenstein
6:09PM ( 3 days ago )
Pence slams district court rulings against Trump policies
Vice President Mike Pence has announced that the Trump administration intends to challenge the right of federal district courts to issue rulings blocking nationwide policies
10:11PM ( 4 days ago )
A push grows for Oregon to drop nonunanimous jury verdicts
Oregon is the only state in America that allows nonunanimous jury verdicts, but momentum is building to scrap that system
9:08PM ( 4 days ago )
AP Online Supreme Court News
Uber shares continue sliding in first full day of trading
Uber shares are skidding again, falling 8% in morning trading
10:03AM ( 51 minutes ago )
Markets Right Now: Stocks sink as trade war escalates
Stocks are plunging at the open on Wall Street after China announced retaliatory tariffs against goods from the United States
9:44AM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: US markets hit as China retaliates with tariffs
US markets hammered as China retaliates against tariff hikes
9:22AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
Legendary actress and singer Doris Day dead at 97
Doris Day, whose wholesome screen presence stood for a time of innocence in '60s films, has died
10:43AM ( 10 minutes ago )
'Empire' to get 1 more season on Fox amid schedule shake-up
The Fox network says 'Empire' will be back for one last season in the fall for its finale
10:31AM ( 22 minutes ago )
Poland shaken by documentary about pedophile priests
A new documentary about pedophile priests is shaking mostly Catholic Poland, eliciting an apology by the church hierarchy and prompting one priest to leave the clergy
10:28AM ( 25 minutes ago )
Amazon offers to help employees start delivery business
Amazon to employees: Quit your job and we'll help you start delivery business
10:24AM ( 29 minutes ago )
UK halts export of 'Lady Chatterley' copy from famous trial
The British government has used its powers to preserve the nation's cultural treasures to halt the export of a tattered paperback copy of "Lady Chatterley's Lover."
10:21AM ( 32 minutes ago )