sunny.png
Monday September 23rd, 2019 4:45PM

NFL/union helmet test covers potential inconsistency

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

NEW YORK (AP) — Did some helmet manufacturers design models with the purpose of testing well rather than performing properly on the field?

Possibly, but the lab testing by the biomechanical engineers appointed by the league and its players' union accounted for such a practice in the rankings for the annual helmets poster that is displayed at every team facility.

In the study, rotational velocity and acceleration are measured to evaluate helmets to determine which best reduced head impact severity. The poster was released last month and showed six of 11 helmets tested this year moved into the top-10 rated models.

An important question was whether some helmets were constructed simply to get high marks in the extensive testing that took place for nearly four months.

"I think that happens," says Thad Ide, Riddell's senior vice president of research and product development. "The NFL addressed it in its poster by graying out some areas. A lot of models no players are wearing and some of those may have been developed for the test, sort of a placeholder on the poster."

Grant Goulet, vice president of product innovation at Xenith LLC, says he is encouraged by the work put into this test.

"It is scientifically rigorous," he said. "However, it could also be something of a cautionary tale that more helmets got into that green group (at the top of the rankings). I think there could be a propensity to be engineering helmets for these tests and metrics and that could be what is bumping them up into this green group.

"What is important to emphasize is more of a holistic approach to designing the best gear for the athlete on the field."

The NFL and players' union believe the top manufacturers not only are doing so, but are rapidly making improvements and innovations for safety, comfort and appearance. And, yes, the theory that some new models are being designed simply to get high test ratings has been addressed.

"We have heard that discussed that there may be an effort by some to build to the test," says Jeff Miller, the league's executive vice president of health and safety initiatives. "We think that better performing helmets certainly are a positive. We are seeing due to the testing and engineering road map that there are better and more protective helmets being produced, and the players are wearing them on the field. We're trying to educate the players, equipment managers, athletic trainers, everyone, with the poster and the supportive material for it."

Jeffrey Crandall, the league's consultant to the independent testing, explains that the poster shading was done to ensure players could make informed choices on helmet safety, comfort and appearance.

"Many things go into the helmet, with safety the primary factor," Crandall says. "If a player is going to switch models during camp, for example, or try a different helmet during the season, if they look at what others are using, maybe they can learn from it."

He adds that in the past year more than 50 percent of the players upgraded their helmets.

" If we get to players, equipment managers and athletic trainers, they all look at the poster and we go through all the aspects: Changes in helmets, how some models are similar to ones players were wearing that were prohibited or in the yellow (ranking)," he said.

"We go through every helmet players will use in a year and might be able to tell them, 'Here is a helmet that tested better and has the attributes you might be looking for.' There is not a helmet that has not been looked at (thoroughly)."

___

More AP NFL: https://apnews.com/tag/NFL and https://twitter.com/AP_NFL

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Sports, AP Online Football, AP Business, AP Business - Corporate News, AP Sports - NFL
© Copyright 2019 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Warren's opioids message applauded in hard-hit West Virginia
Democratic presidential candidate Elizabeth Warren's plan to battle the nation's drug addiction problem drew an enthusiastic response in a small West Virginia community waging its own fight against the cost of dealing with opioid abuse.
4:21PM ( 8 minutes ago )
House passes $19B disaster aid bill over Trump opposition
The House has passed a $19 billion disaster aid bill that would deliver long-sought relief to farmers, victims of hurricanes and floods, and rebuild southern military bases
4:16PM ( 14 minutes ago )
UN: Plastic waste pact approved with US among few holdouts
United Nations officials say nearly all of the world's countries have agreed on a deal to better manage plastic waste, with the United States a notable exception
4:11PM ( 19 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Kang 10-under 61 for the Nelson lead, matches course record
Sung Kang matches Trinity Forest course record with 10-under 61 in second round at the Byron Nelson
3:49PM ( 41 minutes ago )
Ceferin stresses big clubs with closed Champions League idea
UEFA President Aleksander Ceferin told leaders from European leagues not to forget the importance of big clubs in generating cash during a private meeting in which plans were detailed for a closed-off Champions League favoring the elite
3:27PM ( 1 hour ago )
Cubs INF Russell says he understands fans' booing
Cubs INF Addison Russell says he understands booing from fans
2:54PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Sports
McCarthy shoots 63 for 1st-round lead at Byron Nelson
Denny McCarthy shot a career-low 8-under 63 to take lead after first round at Byron Nelson
8:15PM ( 20 hours ago )
Against backdrop of controversy, Red Sox honored by Trump
President Donald Trump honors the World Series champion Boston Red Sox _ well, some of them _ at the White House
7:51PM ( 20 hours ago )
Carolina Panthers offered $120M to move practice field to SC
The South Carolina Senate has agreed to provide $120 million in tax breaks to the Carolina Panthers to move their practice fields and team headquarters out of North Carolina
6:02PM ( 22 hours ago )
AP Online Football
Pentagon shifting $1.5 billion to border wall construction
The Pentagon says it is reallocating $1.5 billion to help pay for construction of 80 miles of wall at the U.S.-Mexican border
3:55PM ( 34 minutes ago )
Trump says China tariffs help, not hurt the US
US-China trade talks break off, but Trump says they will continue 'into the future'
3:51PM ( 38 minutes ago )
The Latest: Trump says US, China held 'constructive' talks
The Latest: Trump says US, China held 'candid and constructive' talks
3:51PM ( 38 minutes ago )
AP Business
Uber begins trading nearly 7% below its IPO price
Uber began trading as a public company at $42 per share Friday, nearly 7% below its initial public offering price
1:10PM ( 3 hours ago )
Rihanna to launch groundbreaking new fashion label with LVMH
Rihanna is partnering with LVMH Mo√ęt Hennessy Louis Vuitton to launch a new fashion label
12:59PM ( 3 hours ago )
Your Uber has arrived, on Wall Street
Uber becomes a public company as trading opens on New York Stock Exchange
10:41AM ( 5 hours ago )
AP Business - Corporate News
Prosecutors accuse Kraft's lawyers of lying in court
Two of Patriots owner Robert Kraft's defense attorneys are being accused of lying by prosecutors in his solicitation of prostitution case
7:49PM ( 2 days ago )
NFL concussion fund pays out $485M, but legal fights resume
A claims administrator for the NFL concussion fund says the fund has paid out $485M, but some retired players' lawyers say there aren't enough approved doctors in the program
4:01PM ( 3 days ago )
Texas bartender charged with overserving man prior to attack
A suburban Dallas bartender is accused of continuing to serve drinks to a drunken man who later went to his estranged wife's home and killed her and seven other people while they were watching a Dallas Cowboys game on TV two years ago
3:16PM ( 3 days ago )
AP Sports - NFL
Warren's opioids message applauded in hard-hit West Virginia
Democratic presidential candidate Elizabeth Warren's plan to battle the nation's drug addiction problem drew an enthusiastic response in a small West Virginia community waging its own fight against the cost of dealing with opioid abuse.
4:21PM ( 8 minutes ago )
House passes $19B disaster aid bill over Trump opposition
The House has passed a $19 billion disaster aid bill that would deliver long-sought relief to farmers, victims of hurricanes and floods, and rebuild southern military bases
4:16PM ( 14 minutes ago )
UN: Plastic waste pact approved with US among few holdouts
United Nations officials say nearly all of the world's countries have agreed on a deal to better manage plastic waste, with the United States a notable exception
4:11PM ( 19 minutes ago )
US-China talks break up after US raises tariffs
US-China talks break up with no deal after Trump hikes tariffs on $200 billion in Chinese imports
4:07PM ( 23 minutes ago )
NCAA committee proposes moving 3s to international line
The NCAA men's basketball rules committee is proposing moving the 3-point line to the international distance and shortening shot-clock resets to 20 seconds following offensive rebounds
4:05PM ( 25 minutes ago )