rain.png
Wednesday July 17th, 2019 4:40PM

Scrap 'Obamacare'? Maybe not all, Trump administration says

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — Scrap "Obamacare"? Well, maybe not all of it.

The Trump administration is arguing in court that the entire Affordable Care Act should be struck down as unconstitutional. But at the same time, Justice Department lawyers recently suggested that federal judges could salvage its anti-fraud provisions, raising questions about keeping other parts as well.

Serving up more mixed messages, President Donald Trump last week floated to a Democratic lawmaker that he'd like to revive her legislation shoring up the health law's insurance markets. "I was kind of stunned, but I said, look, I am willing to work with anyone," recalled the lawmaker, Sen. Patty Murray of Washington.

Following questions from The Associated Press, the White House released a statement: "Obamacare remains unconstitutional but people deserve relief from all of its empty promises, so the Trump Administration is working within current law to reduce fraud and lower cost for all Americans."

But analyst Timothy Jost says the administration may be undercutting its own legal argument that the 9-year-old statute, President Barack Obama's health care law, is so flawed it must be overturned entirely.

"Somehow they want their cake and to eat it, too," said Jost, a retired law professor who supports the health law's goal of expanding coverage.

Jost called the Justice Department's latest filing with the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals a "mashed together combination" seemingly written by different administration factions, one seeking a total rollback and the other anxious to preserve useful provisions.

Case in point: Drawing on language used by conservative Supreme Court justices, administration lawyers likened various health law provisions to "ornaments" that must come down if a Christmas tree falls. But they also suggested the courts might want to keep the ACA's anti-fraud provisions, which have made it easier for prosecutors to win Medicare cases involving kickbacks, increased screening of providers who bill public programs, and made other significant changes.

The New Orleans-based appeals court is hearing the lawsuit after a lower court judge sided with the plaintiffs — Texas and other Republican-led states. The district judge ruled the entire law unconstitutional because Congress repealed its unpopular fines for being uninsured. Democratic states appealed, saying that's a stretch. The appeals court has indicated it will hear oral arguments the second week of July.

Originally, the Trump administration had argued that only certain provisions — like protections with people with preexisting medical conditions — should be invalidated. Then, following a White House directive, the Justice Department said the whole law must go. Now the administration seems to be further hedging its position.

"The relief awarded should be limited only to those provisions that actually injure the individual plaintiffs," the Justice Department wrote last week in its brief. "For example, the ACA amended several criminal statutes used to prosecute individuals who defraud our health care system." A judge can "determine the precise scope of the judgment" later, added the administration.

There's no conceivable reason to do away with the health law's anti-fraud provisions, said Joan Krause, a health care fraud expert who teaches at the University of North Carolina law school in Chapel Hill.

"It would get more complicated, and more effort would be required for the government to put together a case," she said. "And it opens a huge door for defendants."

Similar arguments can be made for other parts of the health law, said Jost. That includes a Medicare innovation center the Trump administration is using to drive changes in drug prices, Medicaid expansion that's helping AIDS patients and people caught up in the opioid epidemic, and a regulatory framework for lower-priced versions of advanced biologic drugs.

"These provisions are essential for Trump administration initiatives," said Jost. But the Justice Department "seems to argue that these provisions, along with the rest of the ACA, should somehow be invalidated, but not prevented from operating."

For a brief time last week, even Trump himself seemed to be having second thoughts about "Obamacare." During a White House meeting with Democratic leaders on a potential infrastructure deal , he pitched the idea of reviving bipartisan legislation that would help stabilize the ACA's insurance markets. HealthCare.gov could be wiped away if the administration prevails in the court case.

Trump "just threw out there that he didn't understand why our bill got sidetracked," said Murray, a Democratic senator from Washington state and co-author of a proposal that went nowhere last year after the White House balked.

"His intent was, 'Why can't we get this done?'" Murray added.

For a few hours, health care staffers on Capitol Hill wondered if a new opening was in the works. Then a prominent Republican senator released a statement that essentially shut down the speculation.

Reflecting on her experience, Murray said, "it was very incoherent."

___

Associated Press writer Catherine Lucey contributed to this report.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Health, AP Business
© Copyright 2019 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Scrap 'Obamacare'? Maybe not all, Trump administration says
Trump administration sends mixed messages on fate of 'Obamacare': Should federal judges salvage parts of the law?
12:08PM ( 4 minutes ago )
Prosecutors get more time to file Colorado shooting charges
Judge gives prosecutors more time to file charges in a suburban Denver school shooting that killed 1 student and wounded 8 more
12:02PM ( 9 minutes ago )
The Latest: Diplomat warns European signatories of nuke deal
Semi-official Mehr news agency is reporting that Iran's Deputy Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi has sent a warning to European signatories of the 2015 nuclear deal
12:00PM ( 11 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Trump's foreign policy challenges mounting around the world
Trump's foreign policy entanglements around the world are mounting, with missile tests by North Korea, a trade standoff with China and fresh nuclear tensions with Iran among them
11:30AM ( 41 minutes ago )
Russian agent saw political analysis as 'valuable' to Russia
A Russian gun rights activist who admitted being a secret agent for the Kremlin says she believed Russian officials would consider her notes and analysis to be 'valuable' as she tried to infiltrate conservative U.S. political groups
11:25AM ( 47 minutes ago )
Schools close in Houston area after storms drench area
The Houston area braced for more flooding as heavy rain and hail pelted the nation's fourth largest city for the second time this week, threatening to send some streams over their banks
11:12AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
After Trump invite, Iran commander says: No talks with US
Iranian commander says there will be no talks with US, day after Trump sent message: 'Call me'
8:49AM ( 3 hours ago )
Butina saw US political analysis as 'valuable' to Russia
A Russian gun rights activist who admitted being a secret agent for the Kremlin says she believed Russian officials would consider her notes and analysis to be 'valuable' as she tried to infiltrate conservative U.S. political groups
8:40AM ( 3 hours ago )
Suspects in Colorado school shooting due back in court
Both suspects in a suburban Denver school shooting are due back in court as prosecutors file charges in the violent attack that killed 1 student and wounded 8 more
8:08AM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Online National News
Pompeo going to Russia amid disputes over Venezuela, Arctic
Secretary of State Mike Pompeo will head to Russia to hold talks next week with President Vladimir Putin amid disputes over Venezuela's political turmoil, the Arctic and other issues
10:32AM ( 1 hour ago )
Poland's president to meet Trump at White House in June
An aide to Polish President Andrzej Duda says the leader and the first lady have been invited to the White House in June to meet with President Donald Trump
8:21AM ( 3 hours ago )
Buttigieg sells out fundraiser at iconic Hollywood gay bar
Pete Buttigieg drew a sold-out crowd to a fundraiser at an iconic West Hollywood gay bar, providing an intimate moment with the first Democratic White House contender who is a member of the LGBT community
3:16AM ( 8 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Texas House OKs death penalty ban for severely mentally ill
Republican-controlled Texas House backs a ban on executing inmates who are severely mentally ill
6:03PM ( 18 hours ago )
Carolina Panthers offered $120M to move practice field to SC
The South Carolina Senate has agreed to provide $120 million in tax breaks to the Carolina Panthers to move their practice fields and team headquarters out of North Carolina
6:02PM ( 18 hours ago )
A growing number of states call porn a public health crisis
More than a dozen states have moved to declare pornography a public health crisis, encouraging supporters but raising concerns among some experts who say the label goes too far and carries its own risks
6:00PM ( 18 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Indian company buys famous UK toy retailer Hamleys
An Indian company says it has agreed to take over the famous toy retailer Hamleys
11:24AM ( 48 minutes ago )
The Latest: Trump tweets that more China tariffs on the way
The Latest: Trump tweets that more China tariffs are in the works
10:48AM ( 1 hour ago )
European steel merger derailed by antitrust regulators
German steelmaking giant Thyssenkrupp says it will cut some 6,000 jobs as it expects European regulators to block its plan to combine some operations with India's Tata Steel
8:41AM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Business
Prosecutors get more time to file Colorado shooting charges
Judge gives prosecutors more time to file charges in a suburban Denver school shooting that killed 1 student and wounded 8 more
12:02PM ( 10 minutes ago )
The Latest: Diplomat warns European signatories of nuke deal
Semi-official Mehr news agency is reporting that Iran's Deputy Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi has sent a warning to European signatories of the 2015 nuclear deal
12:00PM ( 11 minutes ago )
US hikes tariffs on Chinese goods, Beijing vows retaliation
Trump's tariff hike on Chinese imports takes effect, Beijing says it will retaliate
12:00PM ( 11 minutes ago )
As Zuckerberg visits, France threatens new rules on Facebook
France welcomed Facebook's Mark Zuckerberg on Friday with a threat of sweeping new regulation
11:56AM ( 15 minutes ago )
Spanish official who helped end militant ETA campaign dies
Alfredo PĂ©rez Rubalcaba, a former deputy prime minister of Spain who played a key role in ending militant group ETA's violent six-decade campaign for Basque independence, has died
11:56AM ( 16 minutes ago )