clearn.png
Thursday February 27th, 2020 9:54PM

Budget office: Caveats to government-run health system

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — Congressional budget experts said Wednesday that moving to a government-run health care system like "Medicare for All" could be complicated and potentially disruptive for Americans.

The report from the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office was a high-level look at the pros and cons of changing the current mix of public and private health care financing to a system paid for entirely by the government. It did not include cost estimates of Sen. Bernie Sanders' Medicare for All legislation or its House counterpart, but raised dozens of issues lawmakers would confront.

"The transition toward a single-payer system could be complicated, challenging and potentially disruptive," the report said. "Policymakers would need to consider how quickly people with private insurance would switch their coverage to a new public plan, what would happen to workers in the health insurance industry if private insurance was banned or its role was limited, and how quickly provider payment rates under the single-payer system would be phased in from current levels."

One unintended consequence could be increased wait times and reduced access to care if there are not enough medical providers to meet an expected increased demand for services as some 29 million currently uninsured people get coverage and as deductibles and copayments are reduced or eliminated for everyone else.

"An expansion of insurance coverage under a single-payer system would increase the demand for care and put pressure on the available supply of care," the report said.

Sanders, I-Vt., pushed back, telling reporters that what's really disruptive is that millions of Americans remain uninsured while others can't afford high co-pays and drug prices. "That is disruptive," said Sanders. "What is not disruptive is expanding Medicare, which is a very popular and cost-effective program to guarantee health care for every man, woman and child."

The Democratic presidential candidate's single-payer proposal is coloring the nomination fight and is likely to be a significant theme in the 2020 elections. President Donald Trump derides it as "socialism."

Employers now cover more than 160 million people, roughly half the U.S. population. Medicare covers seniors and disabled people. Medicaid covers low-income people and many nursing home residents. Other government programs serve children or military veterans.

Proponents of Medicare for All say the complexity of the U.S. system wastes billions in administrative costs and enables hospitals and drugmakers to charge much higher prices than providers get in other economically advanced countries. Critics acknowledge the U.S. has a serious cost problem, but they point out that patients don't usually have to wait for treatment and that new drugs are generally available much more rapidly than in other countries.

While a government-run system could improve the overall health profile of the U.S., pressure on providers to curb costs could reduce the quality of care by "by causing providers to supply less care to patients covered by the public plan."

Other potentially difficult choices flagged in the report included:

— Coverage for people living in the country without legal permission, which CBO called "a key design issue." Sanders' bill and its House counterpart would cover all U.S. residents, leaving it to a future administration to define that term.

— Payment for long-term care services, which CBO said could substantially increase government costs. Sanders and House counterparts would cover long-term care.

— Use of a government-set "global budget" to control cost, a strategy CBO said is "barely used" in the U.S. Programs like Medicare and Medicaid rely on other approaches.

Private payments from employers and individuals currently cover close to half of the nation's annual $3.5 trillion health care bill. A government-run system would entail new taxes, including income taxes, payroll taxes, or consumption taxes, said CBO. Or lawmakers could borrow, adding to the overhang of national debt.

Several independent studies of Sanders' plan have estimated it would dramatically increase government spending, from $25 trillion to $35 trillion or more over 10 years. But supporters say the expense could be much lower if expected savings are factored in.

Single-payer health care doesn't have a path to advance in Congress for now.

It has zero chances in the Republican-led Senate. In the Democratic-controlled House, key committees that would put such legislation together have not scheduled hearings. They're instead crafting bills to lower prescription drug costs and stabilize and expand coverage under the Affordable Care Act.

The CBO report was prepared for the House Budget Committee, which is expected to hold hearings but does not write health care legislation.

Within the health care industry, groups including hospitals, insurers, drugmakers and doctors have formed a coalition to battle a government-run system. Major employers are likely allies.

Polls show that Americans are open to single-payer, but it's far from a clamor. Support is concentrated mostly among Democrats.

.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Health, AP Elections, General Election News, General Presidential Election News, AP Business, AP Business - Industries, AP Business - Financial Services, AP Business - Health Care, AP Business - Personal Finance
© Copyright 2020 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Budget office: Caveats to government-run health system
Congressional budget experts say moving to a government-run health care system like "Medicare for All" could be complicated and potentially disruptive for Americans
4:12PM ( 4 minutes ago )
'It is over:' Republicans close ranks at Barr hearing
Sen. Lindsey Graham, the Republican chairman of the Judiciary Committee, set the tone for his party as he opened an extraordinary hearing with Attorney General William Barr
4:05PM ( 11 minutes ago )
Maine becomes 1st state to ban single-use foam containers
Maine has banned single-use food and drink containers made from polystyrene foam, commonly known as Styrofoam, becoming the first state to do so
3:57PM ( 18 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
NYC makes calls from jail free, 1st major US city to do so
Mayor Bill de Blasio says New York is now providing free phone calls from jails, making it the first major U.S. city to eliminate fees for inmate calls
3:35PM ( 40 minutes ago )
Fed foresees no rate hikes amid unusually low inflation
Fed foresees no rate hikes ahead amid signs of solid growth but unusually low inflation
3:05PM ( 1 hour ago )
Budget office finds caveats to government-run health system
Budget office: Government-run health care system entails complicated and potentially disruptive transition
2:53PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Olympic runner Semenya loses appeal on testosterone rules
Olympic champion Caster Semenya has lost her appeal against rules governing unusually high testosterone in female runners, meaning she and other women like her will have to take medication to suppress their levels of the male sex hormone
1:26PM ( 2 hours ago )
Barr, Mueller trade barbs as Russia probe rift goes public
Attorney General Barr faces lawmakers' questions for the first time since releasing special counsel Mueller's Russia report
1:05PM ( 3 hours ago )
The Latest: House committee votes to allow Barr questioning
The House Judiciary Committee has voted to allow its staff to question Attorney General William Barr, throwing his scheduled testimony into question
12:26PM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
New York City to pay $3.5M settlement in Rikers inmate death
New York City has reached a $3.5 million settlement in a lawsuit filed over the 2014 death of a Rikers Island inmate who records show was deprived of seizure medication
3:30PM ( 45 minutes ago )
Alabama House approves near total abortion ban
Alabama House lawmakers has overwhelmingly approved a bill that would ban almost all abortions in the state, sending legislation to Senate for consideration
8:56PM ( 19 hours ago )
EPA reaffirms glyphosate safe for users as court cases grow
The Environmental Protection Agency is reaffirming that a popular weed killer is safe for users, even as legal claims mount
5:28PM ( 22 hours ago )
AP Health
The Latest: Powell says politics not part of policy decision
The Latest: Powell says politics not part of monetary policy decisions
3:43PM ( 33 minutes ago )
The Latest: Thousands mourn for Puerto Rico at May Day rally
Thousands of Puerto Ricans marched to the rhythm of traditional music and tambourines while opposing austerity measures, with many demanding the ouster of a federal control board overseeing the U.S. territory's finances
3:42PM ( 34 minutes ago )
Florida massacre defendant's attorneys to remain for now
A judge ordered the public defenders representing the former student charged with the Florida high school massacre to stay on his case while she determines if he remains indigent
3:18PM ( 58 minutes ago )
AP Business
CVS beats all around and ups expectations for the year
CVS Health 1Q results beat estimates and the company hikes expectations for the year
12:38PM ( 3 hours ago )
The Latest: US markets edge higher ahead of Fed decision
Major U.S. stock market indexes are edging higher ahead of a Federal Reserve policy meeting
12:23PM ( 3 hours ago )
Big moves by Apple, CVS help drive US stock indexes higher
US stocks move higher as large companies including Apple, CVS report solid profits
12:08PM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Business - Industries
Trump: Better Fed policies would give economy 'rocket' boost
Trump says economy could 'go up like a rocket" with better Fed policies while his candidate for Fed board faces questions
5:01PM ( 23 hours ago )
US stock indexes waver on mixed earnings; Alphabet down
Major U.S. stock indexes are edging mostly lower after a day of mostly sideways trading as investors size up a mix of company earnings reports
3:49PM ( 1 day ago )
The Latest: Trumps file suit to block bank subpoenas
President Donald Trump, his family and the Trump Organization have filed a lawsuit against Deutsche Bank and Capital One in an attempt to block congressional subpoenas seeking their banking and financial records
3:48PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Business - Financial Services
Pfizer 1Q profit jumps 9% on higher drug sales, lower costs
Higher prescription drugs sales and restrained spending gave drugmaker Pfizer a 9% jump in first quarter profit as it easily topped analysts' profit expectations.
3:27PM ( 1 day ago )
Biopharmaceuticals power Pfizer in the first quarter
Pfizer reports 9% jump in first quarter profit on strong biopharmaceutical showing
12:04PM ( 1 day ago )
Revenue slowdown at Alphabet helps drag US stocks lower
U.S. stocks are moving lower in morning trading, dragged down by big communications companies after Google's parent company, Alphabet, reported a slowdown in revenue growth. Investors
11:32AM ( 1 day ago )
AP Business - Health Care
Dem 2020 hopeful Buttigieg releases 10 years of tax returns
Democratic presidential candidate Pete Buttigieg has released 10 years of tax returns
3:53PM ( 1 day ago )
Millennial Money: 'Tidy up' so each dollar sparks joy
Here are simple ways to minimize financial clutter in your life and get more joy from each dollar
12:04PM ( 1 day ago )
Lawmakers debate future of loan relief for public workers
Political battle is reheating over a federal program that was designed to cancel student loans for certain public workers but has largely failed to deliver that promise
5:57AM ( 2 days ago )
AP Business - Personal Finance
'It is over:' Republicans close ranks at Barr hearing
Sen. Lindsey Graham, the Republican chairman of the Judiciary Committee, set the tone for his party as he opened an extraordinary hearing with Attorney General William Barr
4:05PM ( 11 minutes ago )
Maine becomes 1st state to ban single-use foam containers
Maine has banned single-use food and drink containers made from polystyrene foam, commonly known as Styrofoam, becoming the first state to do so
3:57PM ( 18 minutes ago )
The Latest: Barr says Mueller letter was 'a bit snitty'
"Snitty." That's the way Attorney General William Barr described a letter from special counsel Robert Mueller expressing concerns about his portrayal of the Russia probe
3:53PM ( 23 minutes ago )
Arizona licenses center where incapacitated woman was raped
A Phoenix long-term care facility where an incapacitated woman was raped and later gave birth has received an Arizona license to operate
3:51PM ( 25 minutes ago )
Fed signals neither a rate hike nor a cut is likely soon
Fed foresees no rate hikes or cuts ahead amid signs of solid growth but unusually low inflation
3:50PM ( 26 minutes ago )