Friday July 10th, 2020 4:49AM

California vaccine rules advance over emotional opposition

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

SACRAMENTO, Calif. (AP) — California lawmakers advanced tougher rules for vaccinations late Wednesday after hearing hours of testimony from hundreds of opponents while the nation grapples with the highest number of measles cases in decades.

The Senate Health Committee approved the proposal to give state public health officials instead of local doctors the power to decide which children can skip their shots before attending school. The push coincides with this year's national measles tally reaching the highest it's been since 1994, according to an Associated Press count .

Lawmakers decided stronger oversight is needed to stem bogus exemptions granted in many cases by doctors who are paid to excuse students from vaccinations.

They acted despite more than three hours of often emotional opposition from parents and some children, and after spending another hour debating where to draw the line between individual rights and public safety.

"Our job here in Sacramento is to try to thread the needle," concluded Democratic Sen. Bill Monning of Carmel. "Your right to your choice should not interfere with the health and safety of my child or grandchild."

The measure passed to a fiscal committee on a party-line vote, with the panel's two Republicans opposed.

Democratic Sen. Richard Pan of Sacramento said his legislation would give state health officials the tools they need to prevent outbreaks of vaccine-preventable diseases like measles, which in the first four months of the year have reached 28 confirmed cases in California.

"If we continue to let these fake medical exemptions increase, we're going to have another larger outbreak, and we need to stop that now," Pan said.

Pan's bill is one of a number of efforts by state legislatures to address measles outbreaks. Washington state lawmakers voted Tuesday to remove parents' ability to claim a personal or philosophical exemption from vaccinating their children for measles, although medical and religious exemptions will remain. Oregon is considering removing all non-medical exemptions, drawing the ire of hundreds of parents who came to the state capitol Tuesday to protest.

Opponents of Pan's bill, including members of parental rights and religious groups, doctors and alternative healthcare practitioners, said the measure strips away parents' rights and isn't necessary to prevent outbreaks.

"Now they're going after us parents whose children have been injured by vaccines, and doctors as well," said Christina Mecklenburg, who flew in from her Orange County home. "We can't remain silent any more. Too many of our children are being injured."

She said a vaccine last year left her now 2-year-old daughter, Hayden, cross-eyed with an ocular palsy that wouldn't qualify for a medical exemption if Pan's bill becomes law.

Opponents who jammed the hearing room and nearby hallways criticized the bill and Pan in unusually personal and emotional terms, with several accusing him of "committing crimes against humanity." ''Shame on you," said another, while a third called the bill "evil" and urged him to "please, save your soul."

Dr. Sergio Flores, testifying in support of the bill on behalf of the California Medical Association, countered that "vaccines save lives." Dozens of other medical professionals and students, many wearing white medical jackets, also lined up to support the bill.

Sacramento mother Alyssa Hernandez supported the bill, saying a high vaccination rate is necessary to protect her son, Noah, 2. He received a liver transplant and so cannot be vaccinated himself against many common but vaccination-preventable diseases. "Each of them could be life-threatening for him," she said.

Supporters said pockets of unvaccinated students are helping to spread measles outbreaks in California and elsewhere. Pan said a few unethical doctors are helping parents avoid vaccinating their children by selling medical exemptions through word of mouth or online advertising.

California ended non-medical immunization exemptions in 2016, but Pan's bill would follow West Virginia's lead in having public health officials rather than doctors decide who qualifies for medical exemptions. Doctors would certify that they examined the patient and then send the state health department the reason they are recommending the exemption.

State and county health officials could also revoke exemptions if they are found to be fraudulent or contradict federal immunization standards. Federal guidelines say less than 1%of children should avoid vaccinations if they have a severe allergic reaction or impaired immunity such as from a liver problem, the HIV virus or chemotherapy.

Dr. Nicole Sharrock, a pediatrician, testified that she generally supports vaccinations but said the exemptions would be too narrow and exclude legitimate conditions. She called Pan's legislation "too extreme" because it would let state health officials overrule doctors' decisions.

Those officials have "never laid eyes on my child," said Catharine Layton, who flew in from her Southern California home. "It totally comes between the patient and doctor relationship, which is sacred."

Layton said her now 5-year-old son, Brennan, suffered a permanent brain injury after he was vaccinated at age 2. "He's pretty much unable to speak, he's in diapers, he functions at the level of an 18-month-old. And prior to the vaccine he was healthy," she said.

Statewide immunization rates increased to more than 95% after California abolished the personal belief exemption in 2016, enough to keep most outbreaks from spreading.

But health officials say the rate of medical exemptions has also tripled. It is still less than 1% of school children statewide, but advocates said more than half of students aren't vaccinated in at least three California schools and 50 schools have exemption rates of at least 15%.

Dr. Edmond Sarraf, a pediatrician opposing the bill, said medical exemptions are up only because personal exemptions are no longer permitted.

The bill is backed by the California Medical Association and American Academy of Pediatrics. But more than 100 doctors sent a letter opposing what they called "an ill-advised bill" with a "one-size-fits-all" solution.

Pan's office said some of the doctors are believed to be providing questionable exemptions, while the group noted that Pan has accepted tens of thousands of dollars in campaign contributions from the pharmaceutical industry.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Health, AP Health - Children's Health, AP Business, AP Business - Industries, AP Business - Health Care
© Copyright 2020
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Texas executes avowed racist in black man's dragging death
An avowed racist who orchestrated one of the most gruesome hate crimes in US history has been executed in Texas for the dragging death of a black man
11:43PM ( 5 minutes ago )
California vaccine rules advance over emotional opposition
California lawmakers are advancing tougher rules for vaccinations despite hearing hours of testimony from hundreds of opponents
11:27PM ( 20 minutes ago )
Russia's Putin arrives for summit with North Korea's Kim
Russian President Vladimir Putin has arrived in Vladivostok for a summit with North Korean leader Kim Jong Un
11:26PM ( 22 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Some women of color frustrated by Biden's expected 2020 bid
Some women of color frustrated by Biden's expected 2020 bid
9:41PM ( 2 hours ago )
Facebook anticipates an FTC privacy fine of up to $5 billion
Facebook anticipates an FTC privacy fine of up to $5 billion
9:34PM ( 2 hours ago )
The Latest: Trump says White House to fight House subpoenas
President Donald Trump says he and his administration will battle House Democrats on all legal fronts after the special counsel's Russia report
8:39PM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
California lawmakers advance plan for denser housing
California lawmakers have advanced a proposal to spur more housing near transportation
5:24PM ( 6 hours ago )
Boy Scouts: Handful of sex-abuse cases emerged in 2018
Under pressure over past allegations of child sex abuse, the Boy Scouts of America is defending its current prevention policies
5:08PM ( 6 hours ago )
White presidential hopefuls face 'woke litmus test' on race
Race in America is being addressed directly by white candidates running for the Democratic nomination for president
5:00PM ( 6 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
US measles cases hit highest mark in 25 years
U.S. measles cases have climbed to their highest level in 25 years, largely because misinformation is turning parents against vaccines
7:24PM ( 4 hours ago )
The Latest: Trump says he won't stop fighting opioid crisis
President Donald Trump says his administration is using every resource it has to fight the nation's opioid crisis
2:19PM ( 9 hours ago )
Trump claims credit for progress in battling opioid epidemic
President Donald Trump is claiming credit for progress in battling the opioid epidemic
1:26PM ( 10 hours ago )
AP Health
UN: Malawi is 1st nation to use malaria vaccine to help kids
UN says Malawi becomes 1st nation to begin immunizing children against malaria
10:41AM ( 1 day ago )
Lawyer: Challenge to NYC's vaccination order in the works
New York City's effort to halt a measles outbreak by ordering mandatory vaccinations in one Brooklyn neighborhood is facing opposition
6:59PM ( 2 weeks ago )
How NYC plans to enforce unusual measles vaccination order
In a rare order, New York City is requiring residents of a heavily Orthodox Jewish neighborhood to be vaccinated for measles; now the question is enforcing the demand.
1:12AM ( 2 weeks ago )
AP Health - Children's Health
AP joins global initiative to expand reporting on religion
AP, Religion News Service and The Conversation form initiative to expand reporting on religion
10:17PM ( 1 hour ago )
Asian shares mixed after US stocks retreat from record high
Asian shares are mixed after U.S. stocks closed lower, giving back some of its gains a day after the S&P 500 and Nasdaq hit record highs
9:59PM ( 1 hour ago )
Nora Roberts sues Brazilian author, cites 'multi-plagiarism'
Best-selling novelist Nora Roberts is suing a Brazilian writer for copyright infringement
9:21PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Business
Occidental tries to outbid Chevron for Anadarko Petroleum
A bidding war is breaking out over Anadarko Petroleum, with Occidental making an offer that it says is about a 20% premium to Chevron's deal announced earlier this month
6:17PM ( 5 hours ago )
Iran minister: Trump's aim is talks, Bolton wants conflict
Iran's foreign minister says President Donald Trump's aim "is to bring us to our knees to talk" _ but that national security adviser John Bolton and U.S. allies in the Mideast want "regime change" and the "disintegration of Iran."
6:11PM ( 5 hours ago )
Tesla's $700M Q1 net loss much larger than expected
Tesla posted a surprisingly large $702.1 million net loss in the first quarter as sales of its electric cars slumped and demand appeared to be waning
5:48PM ( 6 hours ago )
AP Business - Industries
UnitedHealth beats expectations all around, stock still lags
UnitedHealth Group reported strong first-quarter numbers driven by its main insurance business
12:27PM ( 1 week ago )
Johnson & Johnson posts strong revenue in 1Q
Johnson & Johnson reports rising sales of Stelara, tops profit and revenue projections in 1Q
11:30AM ( 1 week ago )
The Dalai Lama recovering fast from chest infection
The Dalai Lama has almost recovered from a chest infection and likely to leave a New Delhi hospital in a day
12:08AM ( 1 week ago )
AP Business - Health Care
Texas executes avowed racist in black man's dragging death
An avowed racist who orchestrated one of the most gruesome hate crimes in US history has been executed in Texas for the dragging death of a black man
11:43PM ( 5 minutes ago )
Russia's Putin arrives for summit with North Korea's Kim
Russian President Vladimir Putin has arrived in Vladivostok for a summit with North Korean leader Kim Jong Un
11:26PM ( 22 minutes ago )
LEADING OFF: Guerrero to majors; Gonzalez back to Brewers
LEADING OFF: Vladimir Guerrero Jr. gets promotion; Gio Gonzalez returns to Brewers; Cleveland to visit Houston in playoff rematch
11:02PM ( 45 minutes ago )
Verlander dominates Twins in Astros' 7-1 win
Justin Verlander pitched eight dominant innings, and Carlos Correa, Michael Brantley and Josh Reddick all homered to lead the Houston Astros to a 7-1 win over the Minnesota Twins
10:55PM ( 53 minutes ago )
Hoskins taunts Rhame after near-beanings, Phils top Mets 6-0
Rhys Hoskins homered off reliever Jacob Rhame and taunted him with a slow jog around the bases a night after Rhame buzzed him with two fastballs, and the struggling Philadelphia Phillies beat the New York Mets 6-0
10:47PM ( 1 hour ago )