sunny.png
Thursday October 17th, 2019 11:49AM

SC House gives near final backing to heartbeat abortion bill

By The Associated Press

COLUMBIA, S.C. (AP) — The South Carolina House gave near final approval to a bill Wednesday that would ban almost all abortions once a fetal heartbeat can be detected, but the measure may have little chance of clearing the Senate.

The House voted 70-31 to give the bill second reading after more than five hours of debate. One last routine vote could take place as early as Thursday before the bill heads over to the Senate.

Other legislatures in Kentucky, Ohio and Georgia have passed fetal heartbeat abortion bills this year. But in South Carolina, even if the bill passes the House, it would need a two-thirds vote from the less conservative Senate because it had missed a legislative deadline. And time was running short, with only seven working days remaining in the legislative session after Wednesday.

Supporters called for final House and Senate passage, saying all life should be considered sacred once a heartbeat can be detected.

But much of Wednesday's debate arose from opposition by Democratic lawmakers, who questioned the motives of debating a bill that would likely face an immediate legal challenge and be ruled unconstitutional by the courts.

Democratic Rep. David Mack said lawmakers take up proposed abortion restrictions year after year and need to refrain from passing laws concerning women's bodies.

"This waste of time is just very sickening to me," the North Charleston lawmaker said.

The bill, drafted by Republican Rep. John McCravy, would require medical professionals to test for a detectable heartbeat before any abortion is performed.

McCravy said that if a heartbeat is detected, the bill would require the medical professional to ask the mother if she would like to hear the heartbeat and then advise the woman of the chances of her successfully carrying the pregnancy to full term.

A heartbeat typically can be detected around the sixth week of pregnancy, so early that many women are sometimes unaware they are pregnant.

"We're forcing women from across the state of South Carolina to fight the issue of time," Democratic Rep. Justin Bamberg said.

Bamberg proposed a number of amendments to filibuster the legislation, a similar strategy he took during a contentious debate during a House committee meeting earlier this month. They all have failed. The Bamberg Democrat's proposals included allowing registered nurses, physician assistance and telemedicine providers to perform abortions. Other provisions would have created a fund to pay for women to travel outside of South Carolina to get an abortion, as well as a fund for physicians to be trained on using the ultrasound to detect the heartbeat.

"We can be so comfortable here in Columbia dictating what women can and cannot do with their bodies and there's never a discussion of how this can impact their pocketbook or checkbook," Bamberg said.

Bamberg ultimately withdrew all his proposed amendments, saying he did so out of respect to the leadership and their colleagues after what they deemed inevitable House approval of the measure.

"It's frustrating to come to Columbia every year and every single year we have to take up something regarding abortion," Bamberg said. "Let's make sure we're doing every single thing possible to invest in, fight for the children that are already here, that are suffering or sick and dying, and that's all I ask for the body."

The only amendment to pass after several hours of debate allowed for exemptions to the ban in cases of rape or incest, proposed by Republican Rep. Nancy Mace of Charleston. McCravy opposed that amendment to his bill.

While Democratic lawmakers supported expanding the exemptions, they criticized language in the proposal that would require physicians to use their judgment to determine whether it was their "belief" that the pregnancy was the result of rape or incest. They said they wondered why a doctor would not trust a woman about that kind of trauma.

"I apologize to all the women in South Carolina who have been raped, who have been subjected to incest," Democrat John King of Rock Hill said. He protested what he called the actions of "the men who sit in these chambers here and across the hall who feel it is in our interest to make decisions for the women of South Carolina and especially for women who have been raped or subject to incest."

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Health, AP Health - Women's health
© Copyright 2019 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Tesla posts surprisingly large 1Q loss as sales slump 31%
Even though Tesla CEO Elon Musk had prepped Wall Street for a first-quarter loss, analysts weren't ready for the size: $702.1 million, among the worst quarters for the company in the past two years
8:23PM ( 10 minutes ago )
Texas executes avowed racist in black man's dragging death
An avowed racist who orchestrated one of the most gruesome hate crimes in US history has been executed in Texas for the dragging death of a black man
8:23PM ( 11 minutes ago )
The Latest: Texas executes man for 1998 dragging death
An avowed racist who orchestrated one of the most gruesome hate crimes in US history has been executed in Texas for the dragging death of a black man
8:20PM ( 14 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Authorities keep distance, yet work with armed border group
Authorities have distanced themselves from an armed civilian group that detains asylum-seeking families at the U.S.-Mexico border
7:39PM ( 54 minutes ago )
NYC mayor takes aim at glass towers as energy hogs
New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio is taking aim at glass and steel skyscrapers as energy hogs but experts say such buildings can also be energy efficient
7:18PM ( 1 hour ago )
Motorist who hit people held on 8 counts attempted murder
A California man who authorities said drove his car through a crosswalk in a quiet Silicon Valley suburb, injuring eight, is being held in jail on eight counts of attempted murder
7:16PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
Trump to keep fighting opioids 'until our job is done'
President Donald Trump is pledging to continue battling the deadly epidemic of opioid drug abuse "until our job is done."
7:34PM ( 1 hour ago )
Booker tax returns show income drop, high charitable giving
Democratic presidential candidate Cory Booker has released 10 years of tax returns, showing his income dipped significantly last year but he remained generous toward charity
6:27PM ( 2 hours ago )
Opponents spar over California vaccine exemption bill
Hundreds of opponents of mandatory vaccines are opposing a California proposal to give state public health officials instead of local doctors the power to decide which children can skip their shots before attending school.
6:14PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Rep. King compares criticism of him to persecution of Christ
Iowa Republican Steve King says the criticism he has faced from fellow members of Congress over his offensive remarks gives him "better insight" into what Jesus Christ experienced when he was persecuted for his beliefs
3:48PM ( 4 hours ago )
US eases effects of sanctions on Iran's elite guard force
The Trump administration has carved out major exemptions to new sanctions on Iran's Revolutionary Guard amid fears they may hurt U.S. diplomatic and military cooperation with other countries
2:51PM ( 5 hours ago )
US gives exemptions to sanctions on Iran Revolutionary Guard
The Trump administration has carved out major exemptions to new sanctions on Iran's Revolutionary Guard amid fears they may hurt U.S. diplomatic and military cooperation with other countries
2:21PM ( 6 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
The Latest: Trump says he won't stop fighting opioid crisis
President Donald Trump says his administration is using every resource it has to fight the nation's opioid crisis
2:19PM ( 6 hours ago )
Trump claims credit for progress in battling opioid epidemic
President Donald Trump is claiming credit for progress in battling the opioid epidemic
1:26PM ( 7 hours ago )
Planned Parenthood: States should oppose Trump 'gag rule'
The president of Planned Parenthood says it's time for states with leaders who support abortion rights to go on the offensive against Trump administration attempts to restrict abortion that she says would reduce access to health care
12:56AM ( 19 hours ago )
AP Health
The Latest: LA Times cited for work on abuse case at USC
Three Los Angeles Times reporters have won the Pulitzer Prize for investigative reporting for their coverage of a gynecologist accused of abusing hundreds of students at the University of Southern California
4:16PM ( 1 week ago )
Ohio governor signs ban on abortion after 1st heartbeat
Ohio's governor has signed a bill imposing one of the nation's toughest abortion restrictions
5:49PM ( 1 week ago )
South Korean court orders easing of decades-old abortion ban
In a major reversal, South Korea's Constitutional Court has ordered the easing of a decades-long ban on abortions, one of the strictest in the developed world
10:34AM ( 1 week ago )
AP Health - Women's health
Tesla posts surprisingly large 1Q loss as sales slump 31%
Even though Tesla CEO Elon Musk had prepped Wall Street for a first-quarter loss, analysts weren't ready for the size: $702.1 million, among the worst quarters for the company in the past two years
8:23PM ( 11 minutes ago )
Texas executes avowed racist in black man's dragging death
An avowed racist who orchestrated one of the most gruesome hate crimes in US history has been executed in Texas for the dragging death of a black man
8:23PM ( 11 minutes ago )
The Latest: Texas executes man for 1998 dragging death
An avowed racist who orchestrated one of the most gruesome hate crimes in US history has been executed in Texas for the dragging death of a black man
8:20PM ( 14 minutes ago )
The Latest: Police: Driver who hurt 8 didn't express remorse
Police say a driver who veered into a crosswalk and injured eight pedestrians in California did not say why he did it but indicated the act was intentional
7:59PM ( 34 minutes ago )
California court is latest to weigh Manson follower's parole
A yearslong saga over whether Charles Manson follower Leslie Van Houten deserves to be freed from prison has taken another sharp turn as an appeals court questions its jurisdiction in the case
7:59PM ( 35 minutes ago )