cloudy.png
Monday May 25th, 2020 1:35PM

Justices seem ready to OK asking citizenship on census

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — Despite evidence that millions of Hispanics and immigrants could go uncounted, the Supreme Court's conservative majority seemed ready Tuesday to uphold the Trump administration's plan to inquire about U.S. citizenship on the 2020 census in a case that could affect American elections for the next decade.

There appeared to be a clear divide between the court's liberal and conservative justices in arguments in a case that could affect how many seats states have in the House of Representatives and their share of federal dollars over the next 10 years. States with a large number of immigrants tend to vote Democratic.

Three lower courts have so far blocked the plan to ask every U.S. resident about citizenship in the census, finding that the question would discourage many immigrants from being counted . Two of the three judges also ruled that asking if people are citizens would violate the provision of the Constitution that calls for a count of the population, regardless of citizenship status, every 10 years. The last time the question was included on the census form sent to every American household was 1950.

Three conservative justices, Samuel Alito, Neil Gorsuch and Clarence Thomas, had expressed skepticism about the challenge to the question in earlier stages of the case, but Chief Justice John Roberts and Brett Kavanaugh had been silent, possibly suggesting a willingness to disrupt the administration's plan.

However, over 80 minutes in a packed courtroom, neither Roberts nor Kavanaugh appeared to share the concern of the lower court judges who ruled against the administration.

Kavanaugh, the court's newest member and an appointee of President Donald Trump, suggested Congress could change the law if it so concerned that the accuracy of the once-a-decade population count will suffer. "Why doesn't Congress prohibit the asking of the citizenship question?" Kavanaugh asked near the end of the morning session.

Kavanaugh and the other conservatives were mostly silent when Solicitor General Noel Francisco, the administration's top Supreme Court lawyer, defended Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross' decision to add the citizenship question. Ross has said the Justice Department wanted the citizenship data, the detailed information it would produce on where eligible voters live, to improve enforcement of the Voting Rights Act.

Lower courts found that Ross' explanation was a pretext for adding the question, noting that he had consulted early in his tenure with Stephen Bannon, Trump's former top political adviser and immigration hardliner Kris Kobach, the former Kansas secretary of state.

The liberal justices peppered Francisco with questions about the administration plan, but they would lack the votes to stop it without support from at least one conservative justice.

"This is a solution in search of a problem," Justice Sonia Sotomayor, the court's lone Hispanic member, said of Ross' decision.

Justice Elena Kagan chimed in that "you can't read this record without sensing that this need was a contrived one."

Roberts appeared to have a different view of the information the citizenship question would produce.

"You think it wouldn't help voting rights enforcement?" Roberts asked New York Solicitor General Barbara Underwood, who was representing states and cities that sued over Ross' decision.

Underwood and American Civil Liberties Union lawyer Dale Ho said the evidence showed the data would be less accurate. Including a citizenship question would "harm the secretary's stated purpose of Voting Rights Act enforcement," Ho said.

Census Bureau experts have concluded that the census would produce a more accurate picture of the U.S. population without a citizenship question because people might be reluctant to say if they or others in their households are not citizens. Federal law requires people to complete the census accurately and fully.

The Supreme Court is hearing the case on a tight timeframe, even though no federal appeals court has yet to weigh in. A decision is expected by late June, in time to print census forms for the April 2020 population count.

The administration argues that the commerce secretary has wide discretion in designing the census questionnaire and that courts should not be second-guessing his action. States, cities and rights groups that sued over the issue don't even have the right to go into federal court, the administration says. It also says the citizenship question is plainly constitutional because it has been asked on many past censuses and continues to be used on smaller, annual population surveys.

Gorsuch, also a Trump appointee, also noted that many other countries include citizenship questions on their censuses.

Douglas Letter, a lawyer representing the House of Representatives, said the census is critically important to the House, which apportions its seats among the states based on the results. "Anything that undermines the accuracy of the actual enumeration is immediately a problem," Letter said, quoting from the provision of the Constitution that mandates a decennial census.

Letter also thanked the court on behalf of Speaker Nancy Pelosi for allowing the House to participate in the arguments.

"Tell her she's welcome," Roberts replied.

___

Associated Press writers Jessica Gresko and Darlene Superville contributed to this report.

___

Follow Mark Sherman on Twitter: https://www.twitter.com/shermancourt

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Online Supreme Court News
© Copyright 2020 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Justices seem ready to OK asking citizenship on census
The Supreme Court's conservative majority seems ready to uphold the Trump administration's plan to ask about citizenship on the 2020 census, despite evidence that millions of Hispanics and immigrants could go uncounted
12:56PM ( 8 minutes ago )
Court hears arguments over citizenship question on census
The Supreme Court's conservative majority seems ready to uphold the Trump administration's plan to ask about citizenship on the 2020 census, despite evidence that millions of Hispanics and immigrants could go uncounted
12:49PM ( 14 minutes ago )
Conservative Washington lawmaker strikes back at critics
A Republican state lawmaker from Washington is striking back at critics who say he should resign for appearing to support spying on political opponents
12:49PM ( 14 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Militants blamed in Sri Lanka attacks had incendiary leader
Leader of militant group blamed for Sri Lanka suicide attacks on Easter called for non-Muslims to be 'eliminated' in incendiary speeches, faith leaders say
11:54AM ( 1 hour ago )
Prosecutor: Greed fueled college basketball coaches' bribes
A prosecutor says greed led a fledgling manager of basketball players to bribe college coaches but defense lawyers say it was all an FBI setup
11:53AM ( 1 hour ago )
Sri Lanka, like world, again sees scourge of suicide attacks
The Easter attacks on churches and hotels were a bloody echo of decades past in Sri Lanka, when militants inspired by attacks in the Lebanese civil war helped develop the suicide bomb vest
11:51AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
Sri Lanka minister: Easter bombings a response to NZ attacks
Sri Lanka's state minister of defense says Easter Sunday bombings of churches and hotels were "carried out in retaliation" for attacks on mosques in Christchurch, New Zealand, last month
10:27AM ( 2 hours ago )
Migrants anxious after Mexican authorities raid caravan
Central American migrants hoping to reach the U.S. are finding a much tougher trek than those in previous caravans, meeting unwelcoming townsfolk and a surprise raid by Mexican police and immigration agents who detained hundreds in Mexico's south
9:07AM ( 3 hours ago )
Impeachment, felons voting divides Democrats at CNN forums
Democratic presidential candidate Kamala Harris has joined those calling for President Donald Trump's impeachment
7:04AM ( 6 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
Kushner: Middle East peace plan to be unveiled after Ramadan
The White House is planning to release its long-awaited Middle East peace plan in the next few months.
12:03PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Interview: Weber launches EU campaign, backs UK staying
The leading conservative candidate in next month's European Parliament election tells The Associated Press he would like to see Britain stay in the European Union
12:02PM ( 1 hour ago )
UK's May under fire as Parliament returns from Brexit break
British Prime Minister Theresa May is facing new pressure from her restive Conservative Party to resign as lawmakers return to Parliament _ and to Brexit wrangling _ after an 11-day Easter break
11:59AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
House chairman issues subpoena to former White House lawyer
President Donald Trump says he's 'not even a little bit' worried about impeachment
3:43AM ( 9 hours ago )
Investigation ongoing, House subpoenas ex-White House lawyer
As Pelosi urges focus on investigations instead of impeachment, House chairman subpoenas ex-White House counsel
12:42AM ( 12 hours ago )
Harris joins impeachment call during Democratic town hall
Kamala Harris joins call for impeachment during 2020 Democratic town halls
11:56PM ( 13 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Appeals court rejects Chelsea Manning's effort to leave jail
A federal appeals court has rejected a bid by former Army intelligence analyst Chelsea Manning to be released from jail for refusing to testify to a grand jury
3:44PM ( 21 hours ago )
Darfur justice could prove elusive despite al-Bashir's fall
Justice for Darfur victims could prove elusive, even with Sudan's al-Bashir behind bars
11:28AM ( 1 day ago )
Justice Department set to release redacted Mueller report
After nearly two years of waiting, America will get some answers straight from Robert Mueller
6:49PM ( 5 days ago )
AP Online Supreme Court News
Court hears arguments over citizenship question on census
The Supreme Court's conservative majority seems ready to uphold the Trump administration's plan to ask about citizenship on the 2020 census, despite evidence that millions of Hispanics and immigrants could go uncounted
12:49PM ( 14 minutes ago )
Conservative Washington lawmaker strikes back at critics
A Republican state lawmaker from Washington is striking back at critics who say he should resign for appearing to support spying on political opponents
12:49PM ( 14 minutes ago )
Teen activist says future has been stolen by climate change
Teenage climate-change activist Greta Thunberg has accused adults of stealing young people's future as she met senior British politicians at Parliament
12:45PM ( 18 minutes ago )
Kushner downplays Russia election interference
Jared Kushner, senior adviser and son-in-law to President Donald Trump, is downplaying Russia's interference in the 2016 presidential election
12:39PM ( 25 minutes ago )
Hearing set over possible leak of Robert Kraft massage video
Attorneys for two Florida massage parlor employees plan to ask a judge to hold police and prosecutors responsible for the possible unauthorized release of video that they say shows New England Patriots owner Robert Kraft paying for sex
12:31PM ( 33 minutes ago )