sunny.png
Monday April 22nd, 2019 2:51PM

In 'FUCT' fashion brand case, justices avoid saying word

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — None of the Supreme Court's justices wanted to say the four-letter word.

The high court was discussing a trademark case Monday involving a Los Angeles-based fashion brand "FUCT." But the justices did some verbal gymnastics to get through about an hour of arguments without saying the brand's name.

Chief Justice John Roberts described it as the "vulgar word at the heart of the case." Justice Samuel Alito called it "the word your client wants to use." And Justice Stephen Breyer called it "the word at issue."

The case has to do with a portion of federal law that says officials should not register trademarks that are "scandalous" or "immoral." Officials have refused to register the brand's name as a result.

But the artist behind the brand, Erik Brunetti, argues that portion of law should be struck down as an unconstitutional restriction on speech.

The government is defending the century-old provision, arguing it encourages trademarks that are appropriate for all audiences. Lawyer Malcolm Stewart, who was arguing for the Trump administration, said the law is not a restriction on speech but rather the government declining to promote certain speech.

Stewart, for his part, also went to great lengths not to say the name of the brand, calling it "the equivalent of the profane past participle form of a well-known word of profanity and perhaps the paradigmatic word of profanity in our language."

Brunetti and others like him who are denied trademark registration under the "scandalous" provision can still use the words they wanted to register for their business, nonprofit or brand, a point some justices underscored. They just don't get the benefits that come with registering a trademark. For Brunetti, that would largely mean a better ability to go after counterfeiters who knock off his designs.

Brunetti's lawyer, John R. Sommer, got the closest to saying the brand's name, using the phrase "the F word" and noting his client's brand "isn't exactly" a "dirty" word.

"Oh, come on. You know, come on," responded Alito, adding: "Be serious. We know...what he's trying to say."

It wasn't clear from arguments how the case might ultimately come out, but Brunetti would seem to have a strong case. Two years ago, the justices unanimously invalidated a related provision of federal law that told officials not to register disparaging trademarks. In that case, an Asian-American rock band sued after the government refused to register its band name, "The Slants," because it was seen as offensive to Asians.

During Monday's argument, some of the justices seemed troubled by what they suggested are inconsistent decisions by the United States Patent and Trademark Office about what gets tagged as scandalous or immoral.

Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg noted that the office has refused to register some trademarks both by saying they are scandalous and, ironically, too confusingly similar to something that is already registered. For example, the office refused to register "FUK!T" for being scandalous and immoral but also confusingly similar to the already registered "PHUKIT."

Justice Neil Gorsuch said, "There are shocking numbers of ones granted and ones refused" that "do look remarkably similar." Gorsuch suggested that the outcomes in such cases were as arbitrary as the "flip of a coin."

"I don't want to go through the examples," he said to laughter. "I really don't want to do that."

The case is 18-302, Iancu v. Brunetti.

___

Follow Jessica Gresko on Twitter at http://twitter.com/jessicagresko

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Business
© Copyright 2019 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
In 'FUCT' fashion brand case, justices avoid saying word
In 'FUCT' fashion brand case, justices avoid saying the word
11:33AM ( 10 minutes ago )
Memorial at Nixon Library for Ed Nixon, president's brother
About 200 people gathered at a Southern California memorial service for Ed Nixon, the younger brother of President Richard Nixon, who died in February at age 88
11:19AM ( 24 minutes ago )
Charges dropped against woman accused of assaulting Conway
Prosecutors have dropped a criminal case against a Maryland woman who was charged with assaulting White House counselor Kellyanne Conway during a confrontation last year at a restaurant in a Washington suburb
11:13AM ( 31 minutes ago )
U.S. News
20 years on, Solskjaer hopes for another Camp Nou comeback
Manchester United manager Ole Gunnar Solskjaer is looking to overturn another Champions League deficit at the Camp Nou
11:30AM ( 13 minutes ago )
S&P 500 dips, on pace for just its third loss in 3 weeks
U.S. stock indexes pulled back in Monday morning trading, and the S&P 500 was on track for just its third loss in the last three weeks, as falling bank stocks weighed on the market
11:09AM ( 35 minutes ago )
Sudan's military attempts to break up sit-in, activists say
The Sudanese military attempted to break up an anti-government sit-in, African Union gave Sudan's transitional military council 15 days to hand over power to a "civilian-led political authority"
10:56AM ( 48 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
France's Macron to respond to yellow vest economic crisis
French President Emmanuel Macron will be laying out his responses to the yellow vest crisis after three months of a national debate that aimed to encourage ordinary people to propose changes to France's economy and democracy
10:25AM ( 1 hour ago )
US stock indexes waver as banks fall
U.S. stock indexes wavered in Monday morning trading, weighed down by losses for banks
10:24AM ( 1 hour ago )
Elizabeth Warren is out with a new public lands plan
Elizabeth Warren is vowing to prohibit new fossil fuel leasing on public lands if she's elected president, one of several new energy proposals she's rolling out
10:08AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
Memorial at Nixon Library for Ed Nixon, president's brother
About 200 people gathered at a Southern California memorial service for Ed Nixon, the younger brother of President Richard Nixon, who died in February at age 88
11:19AM ( 24 minutes ago )
Charges dropped against woman accused of assaulting Conway
Prosecutors have dropped a criminal case against a Maryland woman who was charged with assaulting White House counselor Kellyanne Conway during a confrontation last year at a restaurant in a Washington suburb
11:13AM ( 31 minutes ago )
Weather service confirms tornadoes in southern storms
The National Weather Service says more than a dozen tornadoes have been confirmed in the South after a weekend of violent weather that left at least eight people dead
10:42AM ( 1 hour ago )
Storms flatten buildings, leave thousands without power
Much of the eastern Great Lakes and mid-Atlantic have woken up to damaged buildings, closed schools, and dark homes and businesses after powerful storms that spawned at least one confirmed tornado
9:54AM ( 1 hour ago )
Runners gear up for another wet Boston Marathon
Runners are trying to stay dry as they await the start of the 2019 Boston Marathon
9:29AM ( 2 hours ago )