clearn.png
Thursday December 5th, 2019 10:25PM

Fashion brand 'FUCT' seeks trademark help from Supreme Court

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — Erik Brunetti's four-letter fashion brand starts with an "F'' and rhymes with "duct." The federal government calls it "scandalous" and "immoral" and has refused to register the trademark. Brunetti has a different word for his brand and designs: "thought-provoking."

"We wanted the viewer to question it: Like, is that pronounced the way I think it's pronounced?" he said of his streetwear brand "FUCT," which began selling clothing in 1991.

On Monday, the Supreme Court will hear Brunetti's challenge to a part of federal law that says officials should refuse to register trademarks that are "scandalous" or "immoral." Brunetti says it should be struck down as an unconstitutional restriction on speech.

The government is defending the century-old provision. The Trump administration says in court papers that the law encourages trademarks that are appropriate for all audiences. It argues it isn't restricting speech but rather declining to promote it.

Brunetti and others like him who are denied trademark registration under the "scandalous" provision can still use the words they wanted to register for their business, nonprofit or brand. They just don't get the benefits that come with registering a trademark. For Brunetti, that would largely mean a better ability to go after counterfeiters who knock off his designs.

Brunetti would seem to have a strong argument. Two years ago, the justices unanimously invalidated a related provision of federal law that told officials not to register disparaging trademarks. In that case, an Asian-American rock band sued after the government refused to register its band name, "The Slants," because it was seen as offensive to Asians.

In court, the justices had no trouble saying the band's name, but Brunetti's brand may be different. His lawyer, John R. Sommer, says he plans to say the individual letters of the name, "F-U-C-T," which Brunetti sometimes does too. Another possible workaround: explaining the brand is something of an acronym for "Friends U Can't Trust."

Part of Sommer's argument is what he sees as the arbitrary nature of the United States Patent and Trademark Office's decisions about what gets tagged as scandalous or immoral. A lawyer working for the office who is from the South might find something "not nice" that wouldn't faze a lawyer from the Bronx, Sommer said. That means "you can register profanity if you're lucky" and you get assigned a lawyer who allows it, Sommer said.

Two New York University professors gave that argument substantial support in a brief they filed in the case. They showed that the office routinely refuses to register trademarks both by saying something is scandalous and, ironically, too confusingly similar to something that is already registered. For example, the office refused to register "FUK!T" for being scandalous and immoral but also confusingly similar to the already-registered "PHUKIT." ''MIDDLEFINGER" was denied after "JONNY MIDDLEFINGER" was registered, and "Ko Kane" was rejected after "Kokanee" was registered. And those are just some printable examples.

Brunetti said the trademark office has registered trademarks "far more offensive than my mark."

The trademark office declined to comment on the case.

If Brunetti wins, the public is unlikely to notice a whole lot of change, his lawyer said. Retailers will decide what products are appropriate for their customers, and Target and Walmart aren't going to carry Brunetti's brand, Sommer said.

Brunetti hopes a victory at the high court will help him pursue counterfeiters. In the nearly 30 years since he began his company from his bedroom in Venice, California, he's produced thousands of clothing designs. Some of the best known are parodies involving the Ford logo and "Planet of the Apes."

These days, he directs a staff of four from a downtown Los Angeles office. They release new clothing on their website about once a month. Some items have sold out in less than a minute, and new collections are always sold out in under three days, Brunetti said. Because of the items' scarcity, some are resold on eBay for a profit, with a T-shirt that cost $40 sometimes fetching more than $100.

Brunetti said he's never met anyone truly offended by his brand.

"Most people find it clever," he said.

___

Follow Jessica Gresko on Twitter at http://twitter.com/jessicagresko

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Entertainment, AP Business
© Copyright 2019 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Fashion brand 'FUCT' seeks trademark help from Supreme Court
The Supreme Court is getting ready to hear a clothing brand's challenge to federal trademark law
8:52AM ( 7 minutes ago )
Sudan activists: 'Regime' kills 16 after al-Bashir's ouster
Sudanese activists say 16 people, including a soldier, have been killed since the military forced President Omar al-Bashir from power on Thursday following months of protests
8:31AM ( 28 minutes ago )
Pelosi says Trump using 9/11 images for 'political attack'
House Speaker Nancy Pelosi says President Donald Trump "shouldn't use the painful images of 9/11 for a political attack.''
8:26AM ( 33 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
The Latest: DHs denies Trump urged 'anything illegal'
The Department of Homeland Security denies that President Donald Trump "indicated, asked, directed or pressured" Kevin McAleenan to do anything illegal
6:09AM ( 2 hours ago )
UK lawmakers: Julian Assange should face justice in Sweden
More than 70 British legislators are urging the government to make sure WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange faces Swedish justice if prosecutors there revive rape allegation against him
6:03AM ( 2 hours ago )
Booker to launch campaign tour from city where he was mayor
Cory Booker will launch a national tour on Saturday at a rally that he hopes will play to his skill at connecting with crowds as he looks to gain momentum in the packed Democratic presidential primary
6:01AM ( 2 hours ago )
AP National News
Sudan army removes leader, rejects al-Bashir extradition
Sudanese army says it won't extradite deposed President al-Bashir, wanted for genocide, but will try him at home
11:42PM ( 9 hours ago )
Venezuela's ex-spy chief arrested in Madrid on US warrant
Venezuela's longtime spy chief has been arrested in Madrid by Spanish police acting on a United States warrant for allegedly trafficking tons of cocaine
11:38PM ( 9 hours ago )
Kim Jong Un says he's open to another summit with Trump
North Korean leader Kim Jong Un says he's open to a third summit with President Donald Trump if the United States could offer mutually acceptable terms for an agreement by the end of the year
9:35PM ( 11 hours ago )
AP Online National News
Growing number of states move to shield lottery winners
Arizona could be the next of a growing number of states moving to allow winners of big lottery jackpots to stay anonymous
9:11PM ( 11 hours ago )
Luke Walton out as Lakers coach after 3 losing seasons
The Los Angeles Lakers say they have mutually agreed to part ways with coach Luke Walton after three losing seasons
8:47PM ( 12 hours ago )
AP sources: Pelicans hiring former Cavs GM Griffin
Three people familiar with the situation say the Pelicans have reached an agreement in principle to make former Cleveland Cavaliers general manager David Griffin New Orleans' new executive vice president of basketball operations
7:21PM ( 13 hours ago )
AP Business
Sudan activists: 'Regime' kills 16 after al-Bashir's ouster
Sudanese activists say 16 people, including a soldier, have been killed since the military forced President Omar al-Bashir from power on Thursday following months of protests
8:31AM ( 28 minutes ago )
Pelosi says Trump using 9/11 images for 'political attack'
House Speaker Nancy Pelosi says President Donald Trump "shouldn't use the painful images of 9/11 for a political attack.''
8:26AM ( 33 minutes ago )
Kim open to another summit with Trump, with conditions
North Korean leader Kim Jong Un says he's open to a third summit with President Donald Trump if the United States could offer mutually acceptable terms for an agreement by the end of the year
8:18AM ( 41 minutes ago )
AP Explains: Why 2nd-worst Ebola outbreak is growing concern
AP Explains: Why the 2nd-deadliest Ebola outbreak in history is a growing concern
7:33AM ( 1 hour ago )
Taliban launch multi-pronged attack on northern Afghan city
The Taliban have launched a new assault on the northern city of Kunduz, which briefly fell to the insurgents in 2015 and has come under attack several times since then
7:28AM ( 1 hour ago )