Friday October 23rd, 2020 11:09PM

Court rules gun maker can be sued over Newtown shooting

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

HARTFORD, Conn. (AP) — Gun-maker Remington can be sued over how it marketed the rifle used to kill 20 children and six educators at Sandy Hook Elementary School in 2012, a divided Connecticut Supreme Court ruled Thursday.

Gun control advocates touted the ruling as providing a possible roadmap for victims of other mass shootings to circumvent a long-criticized federal law that shields gun manufacturers from liability in most cases when their products are used in crimes. Gun rights supporters bashed the decision as judicial activism and overreach.

In a 4-3 decision, justices reinstated a wrongful death lawsuit against Remington and overturned the ruling of a lower court judge, who said the entire lawsuit was prohibited by the 2005 federal law. The majority said that while most of the lawsuit's claims were barred by the federal law, Remington could still be sued for alleged wrongful marketing under Connecticut law.

"The regulation of advertising that threatens the public's health, safety, and morals has long been considered a core exercise of the states' police powers," Justice Richard Palmer wrote for the majority, adding he didn't believe Congress envisioned complete immunity for gun-makers.

Several lawsuits over mass shootings in other states have been rejected because of the federal law.

The plaintiffs in Connecticut include a survivor and relatives of nine people killed in the massacre. They argue the Bushmaster AR-15-style rifle used by Newtown shooter Adam Lanza is too dangerous for the public and Remington glorified the weapon in marketing it to young people, including those with mental illness.

Remington, based in Madison, North Carolina, has denied wrongdoing and previously insisted it can't be sued because of the 2005 law, called the Protection of Lawful Commerce in Arms Act. A Remington spokesman said Thursday the company had no comment on the court ruling.

"We have no timeline for any comments to be made on the subject," spokesman Eric Suarez wrote in an email to The Associated Press.

James Vogts, a lawyer for Remington, has cited the 2005 federal law and previously said the Bushmaster rifle is a legal firearm used by millions of people for hunting, self-defense and target shooting.

Lanza, 20, shot his way into the locked school in Newtown on Dec. 14, 2012, and killed 20 first-graders and six educators with a Bushmaster XM15-E2S rifle, similar to an AR-15. He shot his mother to death in their Newtown home beforehand, and killed himself as police arrived at the school.

Connecticut's child advocate said Lanza's severe and deteriorating mental health problems, his preoccupation with violence and access to his mother's legal weapons "proved a recipe for mass murder."

Nicole Hockley, whose 6-year-old son Dylan died in the shooting, said Thursday that a main goal of the lawsuit is to stop Remington and other gun makers from gearing their advertising toward troubled young men.

"We have always said our case is about reckless sales and marketing to disturbed youth," Hockley said. "We wanted our day in court. This is a step forward to ensure that manufacturers like Remington are not allowed to keep targeting people who are at risk."

A gun industry group, the National Shooting Sports Foundation, which happens to be based in Newtown, said the state Supreme Court ruling was an "overly broad interpretation" of an exception to the 2005 federal law.

"The majority's decision today is at odds with all other state and federal appellate courts that have interpreted the scope of the exception," the group said in a statement, adding it "respectfully disagrees with and is disappointed by the court's majority decision."

Connecticut Chief Justice Richard Robinson focused much of the dissenting opinion on the intent of Congress to limit gun-makers' liability.

"Because the distastefulness of a federal law does not diminish its preemptive effect, I would affirm the judgment of the trial court striking the plaintiff's complaint in its entirety," Robinson wrote.

U.S. Sen. Richard Blumenthal, a Connecticut Democrat, called the ruling a victory for gun violence victims that gives moment to an effort by him and other federal legislators to repeal the 2005 law.

"It's a wow moment in American legal history," he said. "It will change the legal landscape for this industry, potentially all across the country."

Blumenthal said the ruling reminded him of early court victories against tobacco companies that led them to disclose damaging internal documents and later agree to billions of dollars in legal settlements over sickened smokers.

Joshua Koskoff, a lawyer for the plaintiffs, has said the Bushmaster rifle and other AR-15-style rifles were designed as military killing machines and should never have been sold to the public. He accuses Remington of targeting younger, at-risk males through "militaristic marketing and astute product placement in violent first-person shooter games."

"The families' goal has always been to shed light on Remington's calculated and profit-driven strategy to expand the AR-15 market and court high-risk users, all at the expense of Americans' safety," Koskoff said Thursday. "Today's decision is a critical step toward achieving that goal."

The lawsuit seeks undisclosed damages.

Military-style rifles have been used in many other mass shootings, including in Las Vegas in October 2017 when 58 people were killed and hundreds more injured.

The case was watched by gun rights supporters and gun control advocates across the country as one that could affect other cases accusing gun-makers of being responsible for mass shootings. Several groups, ranging from the NRA to emergency room doctors, submitted briefs to the court.

The 2005 federal law has been cited by other courts that rejected lawsuits against gun makers and dealers in other high-profile shooting attacks, including the 2012 Colorado movie theater shooting and the Washington, D.C., sniper shootings in 2002.

Robert J. Spitzer, chairman of political science at the State University of New York at Cortland and an expert on guns and the Second Amendment, said the Connecticut ruling runs counter to the 2005 federal law. Even though the court allowed the case to proceed, he said, there still be a very high bar for successfully suing Remington.

"The likelihood they'll succeed is small," he said.

Still, allowing the lawsuit to move forward means that there will be an opportunity for discovery that would unearth company documents that could be embarrassing for Remington. Since gunmakers have in recent history been shielded from litigation, company officials may have felt emboldened to openly discuss tactics, marketing strategies and other revealing details about business dealings.

Remington filed for bankruptcy reorganization last year amid years of slumping sales and legal and financial pressure over the Sandy Hook school massacre.


Associated Press writer Lisa Marie Pane in Boise, Idaho, contributed to this report.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Business, AP Business - Corporate News
© Copyright 2020
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Nuclear industry pushing for fewer inspections at plants
The Nuclear Regulatory Commission is considering requests from the nuclear power industry for fewer inspections at its plants
3:32PM ( 8 minutes ago )
US stock indexes veer lower as 3-day winning streak stalls
U.S. stock indexes are edging mostly lower in late-afternoon trading as the market's three-day winning streak stalls
3:28PM ( 12 minutes ago )
The Latest: Golfer Mickelson used admissions consultant
Golfer Phil Mickelson says he is among "thousands" who used a college consulting company accused of orchestrating a massive bribery scheme
3:27PM ( 13 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Reputed Gambino crime boss shot to death in New York City
The reputed boss of New York's Gambino crime family has been gunned down outside his home, dying a virtual unknown compared with his swaggering 1980s-era predecessor, the custom-tailored tabloid sensation John Gotti
2:57PM ( 43 minutes ago )
Senate rejects Trump border emergency as Republicans defect
The Republican-run Senate has rejected President Donald Trump's declaration of a national emergency at the southwest border
2:54PM ( 46 minutes ago )
The Latest: Senate votes to terminate Trump's border order
The Republican-controlled Senate has voted to terminate President Donald Trump's declaration of a national emergency at the U.S.-Mexico border
2:53PM ( 47 minutes ago )
AP National News
UK lawmakers gear up for vote on delaying Brexit
British lawmakers are on whether to scuttle the already dwindling chance the U.K. will leave the European Union this month as planned
1:51PM ( 1 hour ago )
US immigration agents find ways around 'sanctuary' policies
Despite scores of "sanctuary" laws around the country to shield immigrants from deportation, federal authorities are still getting under-the-table cooperation from some local law enforcement agencies
1:40PM ( 2 hours ago )
Anguished families of crash victims find nothing to bury
Anguished families of crash victims fear there is nothing to bury; 'they will stay missing'
1:34PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Online National News
Huawei pleads not guilty in US court in Iran sanctions case
Lawyers for the Chinese electronics giant Huawei have entered a not-guilty plea in a U.S. case charging the company with violating Iran trade sanctions
1:47PM ( 1 hour ago )
Bribed coaches were far from the top, but had keys to campus
Coaches accused of taking bribes were far from the top of their sport, but they did hold the keys to an elite campus
1:30PM ( 2 hours ago )
Feds: Charity funneled millions in college bribery scam
A charity helped the man accused of masterminding a wide-ranging college admissions scandal funnel millions of dollars in bribes
1:16PM ( 2 hours ago )
Top U.S. News short headlines
UK lawmakers gear up for vote on Brexit delay request
British lawmakers face another tumultuous day Thursday ahead of a vote on whether to request a delay to the country's scheduled departure from the European Union
9:18AM ( 6 hours ago )
Brazil wonders why after school shooters kill 8, themselves
A Sao Paulo suburb prepares to bury its dead and look for reasons why two masked former students armed with a hand gun, knives, axes and crossbows killed five teenagers and two adults at a school before killing themselves as police closed in
9:13AM ( 6 hours ago )
Charity masked web of fraudulent college donations, feds say
Prosecutors and tax documents say the mastermind of a wide-ranging college admissions scandal set up a charity that funneled money from wealthy parents to bribe coaches and others to get their children into elite universities
8:51AM ( 6 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
Democratic lawmakers grill Ross on citizenship question
Democratic lawmakers on a House oversight panel accused Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross on Thursday of orchestrating the efforts to add a citizenship question to the 2020 census
2:57PM ( 44 minutes ago )
Guthrie dropped from nominees for contributions to NASCAR
Janet Guthrie was dropped from the list of nominees eligible to win the Landmark Award the honors contributions to NASCAR
2:42PM ( 58 minutes ago )
Why France is analyzing Ethiopian jet's black boxes
France doesn't see an unusually large number of aviation disasters, but its plane crash investigators are world famous
2:07PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
Putin courts Russian business, keeps mum on jailed US exec
Russian President Vladimir Putin has promised that the government will do more to encourage investments and reduce business risks
12:33PM ( 3 hours ago )
Dubai-based port firm DP World reports $1.29B profit in 2018
Global port operator DP World says its profit rose 10 percent in 2018 despite worldwide tensions over trade, Brexit fears
6:46AM ( 8 hours ago )
Etihad Airways loses $1.28B in 2018 in third year of losses
Abu Dhabi-based long-haul carrier Etihad Airways says it lost $1.28 billion in 2018, third consecutive year of losses
6:18AM ( 9 hours ago )
AP Business - Corporate News
Nuclear industry pushing for fewer inspections at plants
The Nuclear Regulatory Commission is considering requests from the nuclear power industry for fewer inspections at its plants
3:32PM ( 8 minutes ago )
The Latest: Golfer Mickelson used admissions consultant
Golfer Phil Mickelson says he is among "thousands" who used a college consulting company accused of orchestrating a massive bribery scheme
3:27PM ( 13 minutes ago )
Late-winter storm hits Midwest after paralyzing Colorado
A blizzard that paralyzed parts of Colorado and Wyoming has barreled into the Midwest
3:27PM ( 13 minutes ago )
The Latest: Trump's reaction to Senate vote? 'VETO!'
President Donald Trump has one thing to say after the Republican-led Senate voted to block his national emergency declaration for border wall funding: "VETO!"
3:25PM ( 15 minutes ago )
US-Russian crew blasts off to International Space Station
A Russian-American crew of three has blasted off to the International Space Station, their second attempt to reach the outpost following an aborted launch in October
3:22PM ( 18 minutes ago )