Thursday February 27th, 2020 3:45PM

NCAA can claim victory after losing federal antitrust case

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

The NCAA was able to claim victory Friday night after a judge ruled against the governing body for college sports in a federal antitrust lawsuit.

U.S. District Judge Claudia Wilken in Oakland, California, said college football and men's and women's basketball players competing at the NCAA's highest level should be permitted to receive compensation from schools beyond the current athletic scholarship, but only if the benefits are tied to education.

The NCAA cannot "limit compensation or benefits related to education," Wilken wrote. That opens the door to athletes receiving more scholarship money to pursue postgraduate degrees, finish undergraduate degrees or study abroad. The NCAA could not, under the court's injunction, limit schools if they choose to provide athletes items that could be considered school supplies such as computers, science equipment or musical instruments.

"Technically the plaintiffs won the case and the NCAA will not be happy that they were found to be in violation of antitrust law, but ultimately this allows the NCAA to keep the bulk of their amateurism rules in place," said Gabe Feldman director of the Tulane University sports law program.

The plaintiffs in the so-called Alston cases were seeking much more.

Plaintiffs had asked the judge to lift all NCAA caps on compensation and strike down all rules prohibiting schools from giving athletes in revenue-generating sports more financial incentives for competing. The goal was to create a free market, where conferences set rules for compensating athletes, but this ruling still allows the NCAA to prohibit cash compensation untethered to education-related expenses.

The claim against the NCAA and the 11 conferences that have participated in the Football Bowl Subdivision was originally brought by former West Virginia football player Shawne Alston. It was later merged with similar lawsuits, including a notable case brought by former Clemson football player Martin Jenkins.

Plaintiffs argued the NCAA illegally restricts schools from compensating football and men's and women's basketball players beyond what is traditionally covered by a scholarship. That includes tuition, room and board and books, plus a cost-of-attendance stipend to cover incidentals such as travel.

Plaintiffs touted the ruling as "monumental."

"We have proven to the court that the NCAA's weak justifications for this unfair system are based on a self-serving mythology that does not match the facts," said Steve Berman, the Seattle-based lead attorney for the plaintiffs. "Today's ruling will change college sports as we know it, forever."

Feldman, though, said: "The remedy is relatively narrow and this is certainly not the sea change that the plaintiffs were looking for in college sports,"

The NCAA argued altering amateurism rules would lead to pay-for-play, fundamentally damaging college sports and harming academic integration of athletes.

"The court's decision recognizes that college sports should be played by student-athletes, not by paid professionals," NCAA chief legal counsel Donald Remy said in a statement. "The decision acknowledges that the popularity of college sports stems in part from the fact that these athletes are indeed students, who must not be paid unlimited cash sums unrelated to education. NCAA rules actively provide a pathway for tens of thousands of student-athletes each year to receive a college education debt-free.

The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has already said it expects to take the case. It is possible the injunction will be stayed until the Ninth Circuit rules. Feldman said both sides could have incentive to appeal the ruling.

"We believe the ruling is inconsistent with the decision by the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals in O'Bannon," Remy said. "That decision held that the rules governing college athletics would be better developed outside the courtroom, including rules around the education-related support that schools provide."

Wilken is the same judge who ruled on the so-called O'Bannon case, which challenged the NCAA's right to use athletes' names, images and likenesses without compensation. The case also produced a mixed ruling that eventually went to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals.

In O'Bannon, Wilken ruled schools should be permitted, but not required, to compensate athletes for use of their name, image and likeness, with payments capped at $5,000 per year. The appeals court overturned that and said payments "untethered" to education were not required by schools."

Wilken also ruled the NCAA was required to allow schools to factor in their federally determined cost of attendance into the value of an athletic scholarship. That is now common practice in major college sports, though schools were already moving toward NCAA legislation allowing for cost of attendance when Wilken made her ruling.

The plaintiffs argued in the Alston case that implementation of cost-of-attendance stipends prove paying athletes even more would not hurt college sports.


Follow Ralph D. Russo at and listen at


More AP college football: and

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP Sports, AP Online Football, AP Online Basketball, AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, College Sports, AP Business, AP Business - Corporate News, AP Sports - College Football, AP Sports - Women's College Basketball
© Copyright 2020
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
NCAA can claim victory after losing federal antitrust case
The NCAA was able to claim victory Friday night after a judge ruled against the governing body for college sports in a federal antitrust lawsuit
11:40PM ( 6 minutes ago )
Fleetwood, Bradley tied for lead at Bay Hill
Tommy Fleetwood, Keegan Bradley share lead at Bay Hill with a little separation
11:01PM ( 45 minutes ago )
Homeless man pleads guilty to state charge in GoFundMe plot
A homeless man has pleaded guilty to a state charge in a GoFundMe scheme that prosecutors say netted $400,000 with a made-up story about him aiding a stranded driver
11:00PM ( 46 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
LSU suspends head men's basketball coach Will Wade
LSU suspends coach Will Wade indefinitely amid reports about his conversations with a person convicted last year of funneling money to the families of basketball recruits
8:57PM ( 2 hours ago )
Computer to call balls and strikes in minor league
Computers will be used for ball/strike calls starting April 25 in the independent Atlantic League, where the distance between the mound and home plate will be increased by 2 feet to 62 feet, 6 inches for the second half of the season beginning July 12
7:59PM ( 3 hours ago )
Molina plays for 1st time this spring, Ohtani plays catch
St. Louis Cardinals catcher Yadier Molina played in his first spring training game this year after having knee surgery last December
7:54PM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Sports
Jags clear $30M in space by cutting Jackson, Gipson, others
The Jacksonville Jaguars cleared $30 million in salary cap space by cutting five veterans, including former Pro Bowl defenders Malik Jackson and safety Tashaun Gipson
2:31PM ( 9 hours ago )
Jags clear $30M in space by cutting Jackson, Gipson, 3 more
The Jacksonville Jaguars have released defensive tackle Malik Jackson, safety Tashaun Gipson, offensive lineman Jermey Parnell, running back Carlos Hyde and long-snapper Carson Tinker to create $30 million in salary cap space for 2019.
1:11PM ( 10 hours ago )
Dan Jenkins, sports writing great and author, dies at 89
Dan Jenkins, sports writing great and best-selling author known for his humor, dies at 89
9:32AM ( 14 hours ago )
AP Online Football
AP source: Yankees buy back YES control with Amazon help
The New York Yankees are buying back the YES Network, partnering with Amazon in a deal that will give the company the right to stream games in the team's broadcast territory
3:19PM ( 8 hours ago )
Krzyzewski: Williamson 'doubtful' for Duke's game at UNC
Duke coach Mike Krzyzewski says freshman star Zion Williamson is doubtful to play in Saturday's game against third-ranked North Carolina as he continues his recovery from a knee sprain
3:04PM ( 8 hours ago )
Thunder get wild 129-121 OT victory over the Trail Blazers
Russell Westbrook had 37 points while Paul George added 30 points and 13 rebounds for the Oklahoma City Thunder in a chippy 129-121 overtime win over the Portland Trail Blazers
3:16AM ( 20 hours ago )
AP Online Basketball
US regulators clear path for genetically modified salmon
Genetically modified salmon have cleared another hurdle to be sold in the U.S., but could still face legal challenges
10:06PM ( 1 hour ago )
National Women's Hall of Fame announces Class of 2019
Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor, actress Jane Fonda and attorney Gloria Allred are being inducted into the National Women's Hall of Fame
9:36PM ( 2 hours ago )
Warren says tech giants have 'too much power,' need breakup
Democratic presidential candidate Elizabeth Warren says the technology industry is too heavily concentrated among the biggest companies and she has a plan to address that
9:31PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP National News
Trump surveys devastation, pays respects to tornado victims
President Donald Trump has paid his respects to the 23 people who died after a powerful tornado roared through a rural Alabama town
7:24PM ( 4 hours ago )
California man learns he's dying from doctor on robot video
A Northern California family is devastated that their 78-year-old patriarch was told he didn't have long to live by a doctor appearing on a robot's video screen
7:23PM ( 4 hours ago )
Manafort case sparks conversation about sentence disparities
A judge's decision to sentence former Trump campaign chairman Paul Manafort to less than four years in prison sparked widespread anger and opened up a conversation about whether the justice system treats different crimes and criminals fairly
7:22PM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Online National News
Boeheim deemed 'not reckless' in fatal crash, case is closed
Syracuse coach Jim Boeheim deemed 'not reckless' in fatal highway accident and case is closed
4:31PM ( 1 day ago )
Lady Vols edge LSU 69-66 in SEC to keep NCAA hopes alive
Evina Westbrook and Rennia Davis combined for 39 points, 27 in the second half, and Tennessee edged LSU 69-66 in a critical second-round game of the Southeastern Conference tournament
4:18PM ( 1 day ago )
No. 10 LSU stays hot, beats Florida 79-78 in OT in rematch
Tremont Waters dribbled the length of the court for the tying basket with 3 seconds remaining in regulation and then hit a 3-pointer early in overtime, helping No. 10 LSU escape with a 79-78 victory at Florida
10:29PM ( 2 days ago )
College Sports
FDA approves 1st immunotherapy drug to treat breast cancer
FDA approves 1st immunotherapy drug for treating breast cancer
6:26PM ( 5 hours ago )
The Latest: IDB will have until March 15 to decide on Guaido
An international arbitration tribunal is ruling that Venezuela must pay ConocoPhillips more than $8 billion as compensation for the government's expropriation of the U.S. oil giant's investments in Venezuela in 2007
6:18PM ( 5 hours ago )
Manafort gets 47 months; Trump says he feels 'very badly'
Manafort sentenced to nearly four years in prison, much less than what was called for under sentencing guidelines; Trump says he feels 'very badly' for him
5:40PM ( 6 hours ago )
AP Business
Feds probe alleged prison cellphone use by 'Pharma Bro'
Federal authorities are investigating claims that Martin Shkreli has been running his pharmaceutical company from behind bars
4:29PM ( 7 hours ago )
China promises 'all necessary measures' to defend companies
China's foreign minister is promising "all necessary measures" to defend Chinese companies and citizens abroad amid legal clashes between tech giant Huawei and Washington
6:47AM ( 16 hours ago )
Asian shares tumble on poor Chinese trade data
Asian shares tumble after China says its exports fell by more than 20 percent in February
2:13AM ( 21 hours ago )
AP Business - Corporate News
Big Ten Commissioner Jim Delany will step down in June 2020
Big Ten's Jim Delany will step down as commissioner when his contract expires in June 2020
4:38PM ( 4 days ago )
Fast food at White House for North Dakota football champs
It's fast food at the White House again, this time for North Dakota State football champs
3:25PM ( 4 days ago )
Sweat, Metcalf among big winners at NFL scouting combine
Receiver D.K. Metcalf showed off his muscle-man physique _ and his speed _ in Indianapolis
3:15PM ( 4 days ago )
AP Sports - College Football
Fleetwood, Bradley tied for lead at Bay Hill
Tommy Fleetwood, Keegan Bradley share lead at Bay Hill with a little separation
11:01PM ( 45 minutes ago )
Homeless man pleads guilty to state charge in GoFundMe plot
A homeless man has pleaded guilty to a state charge in a GoFundMe scheme that prosecutors say netted $400,000 with a made-up story about him aiding a stranded driver
11:00PM ( 46 minutes ago )
Judge rules against NCAA in federal antitrust lawsuit
A judge has ruled against the NCAA in a federal antitrust lawsuit, saying football and basketball players should be permitted to receive more compensation from schools but only if the benefits are tied to education
10:56PM ( 51 minutes ago )
Trump budget will seek funds for border wall, Space Force
President Donald Trump will be making a significant request for border wall funds and seeking money to stand up Space Force as a new branch of the military in the White House budget being released next week
10:55PM ( 51 minutes ago )
The Latest: Smollett attorney: Indictment is 'vindictive'
An attorney for Jussie Smollett says a 16-count indictment against the "Empire" actor is "vindictive" and Smollett "maintains his innocence."
10:42PM ( 1 hour ago )