Saturday July 4th, 2020 9:03PM

Court denies new trial in 'Serial' podcast murder case

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

ANNAPOLIS, Md. (AP) — Maryland's highest court denied a new trial Friday for a man whose murder conviction was chronicled in the hit podcast "Serial."

In a 4-3 opinion, the Court of Appeals agreed with a lower court that Adnan Syed's legal counsel was deficient in failing to investigate an alibi witness, but it disagreed that the deficiency prejudiced the case. The court said Syed waived his ineffective counsel claim.

The court reversed a Court of Special Appeals' judgment, sending the case back to that court with directions to reverse a Baltimore Circuit Court judgment granting a new trial.

Syed is serving a life sentence after he was convicted in 2000 of strangling 17-year-old Hae Min Lee and burying her body in a Baltimore park. More than a decade later, the popular "Serial" podcast brought Syed's case to millions of listeners with its debut 2014 season. The show revealed little-known evidence and attracted millions of listeners, shattering podcast-streaming and downloading records.

In 2016, a lower court ordered a retrial for Syed on grounds that his attorney, Cristina Gutierrez, who died in 2004, didn't contact an alibi witness and provided ineffective counsel. The state appealed. The special appeals court upheld the lower court's ruling last year and the state appealed that decision, too.

In the majority opinion, Court of Appeals Judge Clayton Greene concluded "there is not a significant or substantial possibility that the verdict would have been different," if Syed's lawyer had presented the alibi witness, Asia McClain, who said she saw Syed at a public library in Woodlawn, Maryland, around the time the state contended Syed killed Lee on Jan. 13, 1999.

"Ms. McClain would have been an alibi witness who contradicted the defendant's own statements, which were themselves already internally inconsistent; thus Ms. McClain's proffered testimony could have further undermined Mr. Syed's credibility," the court wrote.

The appeals court found that McClain's account focused on "a narrow window of time in the afternoon" of the day Lee disappeared. It said her testimony wouldn't have rebutted the state's evidence about Syed's actions that evening, and at best "would have highlighted Mr. Syed's failure to account precisely for his whereabouts after school" that day.

Judge Michele Hotten wrote separately with Chief Judge Mary Ellen Barbera and Judge Sally Adkins that she would have ordered a new trial. Hotten agreed with the majority's conclusion that Syed's trial counsel's failure to investigate McClain as a potential alibi witness constituted deficient performance, but she wrote that she believed the deficiency "was prejudicial against Mr. Syed."

Syed's attorney Justin Brown said in a statement that they are "devastated" by the decision "but we will not give up on Adnan Syed."

"Our criminal justice system is desperately in need of reform. The obstacles to getting a new trial are simply too great," Brown said. "There was a credible alibi witness who was with Adnan at the precise time of the murder and now the Court of Appeals has said that witness would not have affected the outcome of the proceeding. We think just the opposite is true. From the perspective of the defendant, there is no stronger evidence than an alibi witness."

Attorney General Brian Frosh said in a statement that "we are pleased with the Court's decision."

"Justice was done for Hae Min Lee and her family," Frosh said.

Thiru Vignarajah , a special assistant attorney general who worked on the case, said the state always said the conviction was "just and supported by overwhelming evidence."

"This has been an arduous process for Hae Min Lee's family, and we are hopeful the decision finally brings them a measure of comfort and closure," Vignarajah said.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, AP Entertainment
© Copyright 2020 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Sanders' 'Medicare for All' expands long-term care benefits
Sanders and House allies expanding long-term care under 'Medicare-for-all' bills; no word on how they'll pay
3:11PM ( 4 minutes ago )
CDC: Unvaccinated Oregon boy almost dies of tetanus
An unvaccinated 6-year-old boy in Oregon was hospitalized for eight weeks and almost died of tetanus after getting cut while playing on a farm
3:02PM ( 13 minutes ago )
International Women's Day: Strikes, protests and holidays
International Women's Day is being marked across the globe Friday under the slogan #BalanceforBetter, with calls for a more gender-balanced world
3:01PM ( 14 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Trump sees massive damage in Alabama from deadly tornado
President Donald Trump is surveying the damage that was left behind in a rural Alabama town after a powerful tornado roared through, killing nearly two dozen people
2:22PM ( 53 minutes ago )
US wages rise by most in decade even as hiring tumbles
US wages rise by most in decade in February even as hiring tumbles
2:07PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Exclusive: California spent $1.8M on harassment inquiries
AP Exclusive: California Legislature spent $1.8 million in 13 months on legal fees related to sexual harassment investigations
2:00PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
Trump says Michael Cohen lied about not seeking pardon
President Donald Trump says his former lawyer Michael Cohen told a "stone cold lie" in claiming that he did not seek a pardon
1:06PM ( 2 hours ago )
Manafort gets 47 months, judge cites mostly 'blameless' life
Manafort sentenced to nearly four years in prison, much less than what was called for under sentencing guidelines; Trump says he feels 'very badly' for him
12:58PM ( 2 hours ago )
UK leader warns Brexit may never happen unless deal approved
Prime Minister Theresa May is trying to pressure U.K. lawmakers to support her Brexit deal, warning that if they vote down the agreement next week, Britain may never leave the European Union at all
12:29PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Online National News
Sanders' 'Medicare for All' expands long-term care benefits
Sanders and House allies expanding long-term care under 'Medicare-for-all' bills; no word on how they'll pay
3:11PM ( 4 minutes ago )
CDC: Unvaccinated Oregon boy almost dies of tetanus
An unvaccinated 6-year-old boy in Oregon was hospitalized for eight weeks and almost died of tetanus after getting cut while playing on a farm
3:02PM ( 13 minutes ago )
International Women's Day: Strikes, protests and holidays
International Women's Day is being marked across the globe Friday under the slogan #BalanceforBetter, with calls for a more gender-balanced world
3:01PM ( 14 minutes ago )
Emoji gods approve skin-tone options for couples of color
The emoji gods, otherwise known as the Unicode Consortium, approve skin-tone options for couples of color
2:54PM ( 22 minutes ago )
LSU suspends head men's basketball coach Will Wade
LSU suspends coach Will Wade indefinitely amid reports about his conversations with a person convicted last year of funneling money to the families of basketball recruits
2:46PM ( 29 minutes ago )