sunny.png
Tuesday January 21st, 2020 3:29PM

Lawsuit: Trump family-planning rule 'politicizes' medicine

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

A new Trump administration rule for family-planning grants could trigger a national public health crisis, the American Medical Association and Planned Parenthood said in a lawsuit Tuesday challenging the rule.

The new rule, announced last week by the Department of Health and Human Services, would prohibit family planning clinics funded by the federal Title X program from making abortion referrals — a provision that critics denounce as a "gag rule."

Clinics that receive Title X grants also would be barred from sharing office space with abortion providers — a requirement that would in many cases boost costs for providers like Planned Parenthood that offer abortions and other services, including family planning.

The result of the rule, if implemented, "will be a national public health crisis in short order," the lawsuit said.

"Pregnancies that are unintended, and thus riskier, will increase. The number of abortions will also increase. And there will be fewer tests for sexually transmitted infections and cancer screens — putting patients and their partners at great health risk," the lawsuit said.

Planned Parenthood, which operates a nationwide network of health centers, says it will leave the Title X program if the rule is implemented, forgoing an estimated $60 million in annual funding rather than abide by the new restrictions.

Such an exit could have enormous impact: Planned Parenthood serves 1.6 million of the 4 million women who get care through Title X. The program, enacted in 1970, makes family-planning services available to low-income individuals for free or at low cost.

In the lawsuit filed in U.S. District Court in Eugene, Oregon, the AMA and Planned Parenthood contended that the new rule violates a congressional mandate that patients receiving information about their pregnancies through Title X must receive complete, unbiased information about their options. They argued that the ban on abortion referrals violates this mandate and unconstitutionally infringes on health care providers' responsibilities to their patients.

"Because of the administration's overreach and interference ... physicians will be prohibited from having open, frank conversations with their patients about all their health care options," said the AMA's president, Dr. Barbara McAneny. "This blatant violation of patients' rights under the Code of Medical Ethics is untenable."

Leana Wen, a physician who is Planned Parenthood's president, said a majority of the Title X patients served by her organization are low-income black and Hispanic women.

"Families that are struggling to make ends meet and people who live in rural areas must have the same access to full, unbiased information from their doctor as everyone else," said Wen.

Wen stressed that Planned Parenthood, even if it left Title X, would continue to offer its full array of services, including birth control and screenings for sexually transmitted diseases and cancer. But it would not be able to maintain the level of free or low-cost contraception that was available via Title X.

The new Trump administration rule is scheduled to take effect in 60 days, but implementation is likely to be delayed by litigation. In addition to the AMA/Planned Parenthood lawsuit, the rule is being challenged in a lawsuit filed Monday by California officials and another filed Tuesday by officials in 20 other mostly Democratic controlled states. A lawsuit also is planned by the National Family Planning and Reproductive Health Association, which represents publicly funded family planning providers.

The Department of Justice and the Department of Health and Human Services have declined comment on the lawsuits. HHS contends that the new rule "makes notable improvements designed to increase the number of patients served and improve the quality of their care."

The AMA cited two primary motives for challenging the rule: to prevent infringement on the physician/patient relationship and to protect the integrity of Title X, which the AMA considers one of the most cost-effective federal health programs. Its grants totaled $286 million in the 2017 fiscal year.

The AMA has engaged previously in cases involving physician/patient communications. For example, it joined other medical organizations in successfully opposing a Florida law that barred doctors from discussing firearm risks and safety with their patients.

One of the concerns of the AMA and Planned Parenthood is that the new Title X rule may result in a shift of some money to ideologically conservative entities which favor abstinence education and natural family planning and which would be unwilling or unable to provide women with the most effective forms of contraception.

The new rule "blesses biased and incomplete pregnancy counseling where the interests of the patient are no longer paramount," the lawsuit said. The rule "will politicize the practice of medicine and the delivery of health care."

Abortion is a legal medical procedure, but federal laws prohibit the use of taxpayer funds to pay for the procedure except in cases of rape, incest, or to save the life of the woman.

Religious conservatives and abortion opponents contend that Title X has been used to indirectly subsidize Planned Parenthood — the leading abortion provider in the U.S.

Groups such as the National Right to Life Committee have hailed the new rule, saying it does not cut funding, but "merely ensures that health facilities receiving Title X funds do not perform or promote abortion as a method of family planning."

  • Associated Categories: Homepage, Local/State News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP Health, AP Business, AP Health - Women's health
  • Associated Tags: planned parenthood, trump
© Copyright 2020 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Lawsuit: Trump family-planning rule 'politicizes' medicine
American Medical Association and Planned Parenthood claim in a lawsuit that new Trump administration rule for family-planning grants could trigger a national public health crisis
6:49PM ( 7 minutes ago )
Sanders vs. Clinton: 2016 rivalry proves hard to overcome
The 2020 Democratic primary may be in full swing, but the bruising 2016 contest between Bernie Sanders and Hillary Clinton never ended for some
6:48PM ( 8 minutes ago )
Sacramento police who killed Stephon Clark won't be charged
California's attorney general has joined a local prosecutor in declining to charge two Sacramento police officers who fatally shot an unarmed black man last year
6:38PM ( 19 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Omar the flashpoint as Democrats confront divide over Israel
Omar the flashpoint: Democrats deal with divide over Israel
6:15PM ( 42 minutes ago )
Ex-NYC Mayor Bloomberg won't run for president in 2020
Former New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg is not running for president
6:11PM ( 45 minutes ago )
3 get prison in college basketball recruiting scandal
3 sentenced in college basketball recruiting scandal that's tainted 2 dozen schools
6:01PM ( 56 minutes ago )
AP National News
Counterterror police examine 3 explosive devices in London
Britain's counterterrorism police are investigating after three padded mailing bags containing small explosive devices were found near major transport hubs in London
4:55PM ( 2 hours ago )
As investigations swirl, Trump team prepares to fight
Trump's response plan to the ever-expanding congressional probes into his campaign, White House and personal affairs is coming into focus
4:45PM ( 2 hours ago )
Despite the cold, New Orleans celebrates Mardi Gras
The streets of New Orleans were filled Tuesday with excited kids hoping to catch beads from atop ladders, revelers in fancy costumes walking through the French Quarter and Mardi Gras Indians wearing finely beaded costumes
4:44PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Online National News
First lady prods media to cover opioids as much as 'gossip'
Melania Trump is prodding the press to devote as much coverage to the opioid epidemic as it does to "idle gossip or trivial stories"
6:15PM ( 41 minutes ago )
First lady asks public to see opioid crisis as 'human story'
Melania Trump is asking the public to look beyond the numbers and to see the opioid crisis as a 'human story'
4:20PM ( 2 hours ago )
AMA: Trump family-planning abortion rule risks health crisis
The American Medical Association and Planned Parenthood in a lawsuit are claiming that a new Trump administration rule for family-planning grants could trigger a national public health crisis
4:16PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Health
Industrial, tech companies pull US stocks slightly lower
A mostly listless day on Wall Street ended Tuesday with stocks closing slightly lower as losses in industrial, technology and financial stocks outweighed gains elsewhere in the market.
5:05PM ( 1 hour ago )
Hello Kitty to make her big screen debut
Hello Kitty might not have a mouth but she's got a movie deal: Warner Bros.'s New Line Cinema announced Tuesday that it has acquired film rights to Hello Kitty from the Japanese corporation Sanrio.
4:24PM ( 2 hours ago )
Holiday season defines winners and losers in retail
The holiday season turned out to be a mixed bag for retailers, with Walmart, Target and Best Buy enjoying strong sales while mall-based clothing stores and department stores continue to muddle along
4:22PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Business
New sensors monitor sick babies without wires blocking hugs
Wireless sensors promise to monitor critically ill newborns without hurting their skin or blocking parents' cuddles
2:52PM ( 5 days ago )
Officials see no link between miscarriage risk and flu shots
Health officials say new research has not found a miscarriage risk for women who get annual flu shots
2:29PM ( 5 days ago )
Missouri House passes wide-ranging abortion restrictions
Missouri's Republican-led House has passed a bill to ban almost all abortions if the U.S. Supreme Court overturns Roe v. Wade
5:57PM ( 6 days ago )
AP Health - Women's health
Sanders vs. Clinton: 2016 rivalry proves hard to overcome
The 2020 Democratic primary may be in full swing, but the bruising 2016 contest between Bernie Sanders and Hillary Clinton never ended for some
6:48PM ( 8 minutes ago )
Sacramento police who killed Stephon Clark won't be charged
California's attorney general has joined a local prosecutor in declining to charge two Sacramento police officers who fatally shot an unarmed black man last year
6:38PM ( 19 minutes ago )
Board votes to retain Stoneman Douglas superintendent
Florida officials have decided to retain the school superintendent in charge of the district where a shooting massacre happened
6:34PM ( 23 minutes ago )
Prosecutors: Manafort 'blames everyone' but himself
Federal prosecutors say former Trump campaign chairman Paul Manafort "blames everyone" but himself for his crimes
6:29PM ( 27 minutes ago )
Feds: Forgery operation produced over 10,000 fake documents
A man from a primarily Hispanic town in Oregon has pleaded guilty to conspiracy to produce false documents after agents found a document-forging lab in his
6:29PM ( 28 minutes ago )