sunny.png
Sunday October 20th, 2019 6:11PM

Legal hurdles would look familiar in any new R. Kelly case

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

CHICAGO (AP) — Prosecutors will have to clear a series of high legal hurdles if they intend to charge R. Kelly and convict him, even if there's video evidence.

One case illustrates the difficulties: The R&B star's own 2008 trial at which he was acquitted. At the heart of that child pornography trial was a VHS recording that prosecutors said showed Kelly, in his 30s at the time, having sex with a girl as young as 13 sometime between 1998 and 2000.

Speculation that Kelly, now 52, could face new charges arose after attorney Michael Avenatti said he recently gave prosecutors a VHS tape of Kelly having sex with an underage girl, although it's not clear when it allegedly was recorded.

The office of Cook County State's Attorney Kim Foxx hasn't commented about whether a grand jury has convened to consider charges against Kelly. But Foxx may feel emboldened to bring new charges in the #MeToo era, said one legal scholar.

"Because they couldn't get the conviction in 2008, the state's attorney's office may feel justice wasn't done and they may want to take another stab at it," said DePaul University College of Law professor Monu Bedi, who teaches criminal law and procedure and has followed the Kelly case closely.

Kelly's attorney, Steve Greenberg, has said his client "never knowingly had sex with an underage woman."

"If R. Kelly is charged with anything, we will address it in court. I am confident he will leave through the front door," Greenberg told The Associated Press.

Prosecutors in 2008 played the 27-minute VHS tape — entered as "People's Exhibit No. 1" — nearly every day for jurors during the monthlong trial. In it, a man has sex with a young female, who is not wearing any clothes for most of the recording. He speaks to her in a hushed voice, and she calls him "Daddy."

But in the end, jurors took just seven hours to deliberate before acquitting Kelly on all 14 child pornography counts. As the verdict was read aloud, tears streamed down Kelly's face.

"Thank you, Jesus," the singer said over and over in a soft voice.

Afterward, lead trial prosecutor Shauna Boliker told reporters the acquittal "shows the world how difficult this crime is to prosecute."

Prosecutors didn't explain in 2008 why they chose not to charge and try Kelly for sexual assault, though legal experts said it almost certainly had to do with the alleged victim's unwillingness to testify. Child pornography is, or should have been, easier to prove without a cooperating victim.

Statute of limitations is also an issue.

If prosecutors now hope to charge Kelly anew, determining the time of any alleged crime will be crucial to seeing if too much time has passed for him to be charged under Illinois law.

The tape handed over to prosecutors recently was recorded in VHS format, which suggests the incident also dates to around or before 2000. So any crime could be 20 or more years old.

Illinois legislators in 2017 did erase all time limits for charging sexual assault of children and it unambiguously applies to such crimes that happened anytime since 2017. But it can't apply retroactively to older crimes.

Bedi said older sexual assault crimes against children are governed by the statute of limitations as it existed before 2017, when prosecutors had 20 years to charge an assault against children. So, if Kelly sexually assaulted a minor as far back as the late 1990s, prosecutors could still charge him under the 20-year charging window.

Other factors, including when an abused child turned 18, can extend that charging window.

Kelly's across-the-board acquittal in 2008 stunned many legal observers, and a future Kelly trial team may try to use similar defense strategies.

Defense lawyers in 2008 focused on Kelly's insistence that the man in the video was not him. They showed jurors that Kelly has a large mole on his back, but played excerpts of the video in which a mole was not visible on the man appearing on the screen. Prosecutors used different excerpts to show a dark spot was visible.

One of Kelly's attorneys, Sam Adam Jr., told jurors during closings there was no mole on Kelly's back and that meant one thing: "It ain't him. And if it ain't him, you can't convict."

Defense attorneys even suggested the video footage could have all been computer-generated to make the man look like Kelly.

One reason child pornography and child sexual abuse cases are difficult is that the accusers find it traumatizing to recount what happened to them. The situation can be more intense if the setting is a high-profile trial involving a celebrity defendant.

In the 2008 trial, Kelly's alleged victim, who by then was around 23 years old, did not testify. She denied before trial that she was on the video. Instead, prosecutors relied on friends of hers and four relatives to identify her as the girl in the video.

Prosecutors also called on Kelly acquaintances who said the man in the video was clearly Kelly.

Jurors who spoke to reporters after the trial ended said they had difficulty convicting someone when the alleged victim didn't testify. One said he wasn't convinced the girl was a minor when the tape was made. Another said jurors had reasonable doubts about the identity of the people in the video.

"You want to be 100 percent sure it's Kelly and (the alleged victim)," one juror said. "What we had wasn't enough."

___

Follow Michael Tarm on Twitter at http://twitter.com/mtarm

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Entertainment, AP Online Recordings News, APOnline Celebrity News
© Copyright 2019 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Legal hurdles would look familiar in any new R. Kelly case
Prosecutors will have to clear a series of legal hurdles if they intend to charge R. Kelly and convict him, even if video evidence is available
7:23PM ( 6 minutes ago )
Police dismiss tip Smollett, 2 brothers together in elevator
Chicago police have investigated but dismissed a tip that on the night "Empire" actor Jussie Smollett reported being attacked by two masked men he was in an elevator of his apartment building with two brothers questioned in the probe
7:17PM ( 11 minutes ago )
Lawmakers seek probe of ICE force-feeding of immigrants
Nearly 50 Democratic lawmakers are calling for a watchdog investigation of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement after reporting revealed that the agency was force-feeding immigrant detainees on a hunger strike
7:05PM ( 24 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Sen. Bernie Sanders says he's running for president in 2020
Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders says he's running for president in 2020: 'Our campaign is about transforming our country'
6:20PM ( 1 hour ago )
Alabama woman who joined Islamic State seeks return to US
An Alabama woman who left home to join the Islamic State after becoming radicalized online wants to return to the United States
6:16PM ( 1 hour ago )
Aurora gunman's family: 'We deeply apologize' for shootings
A relative of the man who fatally shot five people at a suburban Chicago manufacturing warehouse says her family is offering condolences to the victims' families, saying 'we deeply apologize'
6:13PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
Georgia voting problems highlighted in congressional hearing
Congressional Democrats are highlighting voting problems in Georgia as justification for restoring federal oversight of elections in certain places with a history of discrimination
5:13PM ( 2 hours ago )
A look at rival Branson vs Maduro concerts for Venezuela
A look at the rival concerts planned by billionaire Richard Branson and Nicolas Maduro's government on both sides of Venezuela's border with Colombia
5:12PM ( 2 hours ago )
Lagerfeld's legacy: Youthful designs, elaborate showmanship
Lagerfeld's legacy: Youthful designs, showmanship, eccentricities and an acid tongue
5:04PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Online National News
Governor signs measure to hike Illinois minimum wage to $15
Illinois Gov. J.B. Pritzker has signed a measure gradually hiking the state's minimum wage to $15 an hour by 2025, the highest in the Midwest
4:53PM ( 2 hours ago )
Police: Colorado man wanted another woman to kill fiancee
Investigators say a Colorado man charged with murder and solicitation to commit murder in the death of his missing fiancee tried to convince a woman he was having an affair with to kill Kelsey Berreth
4:15PM ( 3 hours ago )
Key players in disputed congressional race in North Carolina
The investigation into ballot fraud allegations in the nation's last undecided congressional race involves a mix of characters, including a nationally known election lawyer and a local political operative suspected of illegal practices
3:53PM ( 3 hours ago )
Top U.S. News short headlines
Former Dodgers great Don Newcombe dies at 92
Don Newcombe, the hard-throwing Brooklyn Dodgers pitcher who was one of the first black players in the major leagues and who went on to win the Rookie of the Year, Most Valuable Player and Cy Young awards, has died
5:48PM ( 1 hour ago )
Lady Gaga, fiance Christian Carino no longer together
Lady Gaga and her fiance, talent agent Christian Carino, have split up
4:50PM ( 2 hours ago )
Meghan Markle spotted in New York for rumored baby shower
Meghan Markle has been spotted at several upmarket venues in New York City, cradling her baby bump as she visited friends for what is rumored to be a baby shower
4:39PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Entertainment
Venezuela's Maduro to throw concert rivaling Richard Branson
Venezuela's Maduro to throw concert rivaling fund-raiser planned by Virgin Group's Richard Branson
11:04PM ( 20 hours ago )
AP Interview: Branson hopes concert saves Venezuelan lives
Billionaire Richard Branson says that he hopes that the concert he's throwing to rally humanitarian aid for Venezuela will help draw global attention and saves lives by raising funds for "much-needed medical help."
4:51PM ( 1 day ago )
Vandal topples wax statue of Sean 'Diddy' Combs
Police say someone attacked a statue of Sean "Diddy" Combs at Madame Tussauds wax museum in New York, shoving the rap impresario's likeness so forcefully it lost its head
12:00PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Online Recordings News
The Latest: Fendi: Lagerfeld changed 'essence of fur'
Luxury Italian fashion house Fendi says that is "immensely affected" by the death of its long-time creative director Karl Lagerfeld.
11:51AM ( 7 hours ago )
The Latest: Keira Knightley calls Lagerfeld 'legend'
Actress Keira Knightley, one of Chanel's "faces" representing the brand, says she was "incredibly sad to hear the news about Karl (Lagerfeld.)"
10:58AM ( 8 hours ago )
High court won't take up dispute involving Bill Cosby
The Supreme Court is declining to revive a defamation lawsuit against Bill Cosby that was filed by a woman who says he raped her and later spread lies about her when she came forward
10:44AM ( 8 hours ago )
APOnline Celebrity News
Police dismiss tip Smollett, 2 brothers together in elevator
Chicago police have investigated but dismissed a tip that on the night "Empire" actor Jussie Smollett reported being attacked by two masked men he was in an elevator of his apartment building with two brothers questioned in the probe
7:17PM ( 11 minutes ago )
Lawmakers seek probe of ICE force-feeding of immigrants
Nearly 50 Democratic lawmakers are calling for a watchdog investigation of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement after reporting revealed that the agency was force-feeding immigrant detainees on a hunger strike
7:05PM ( 24 minutes ago )
Trump wants California to pay back billions for bullet train
The Trump administration plans to cancel $929 million in U.S. money for California's beleaguered high-speed rail project and wants the state to return an additional $2.5 billion it's already spent
6:58PM ( 31 minutes ago )
Key witness says Colorado man fatally beat fiancee with bat
Colorado investigators say a man beat his missing fiancee to death with a baseball bat after trying to persuade a woman he was having an affair with to commit the killing
6:53PM ( 36 minutes ago )
Judge OKs suit aimed at halting Obama library in Chicago
A judge has given the green light to a lawsuit that aims to stop Barack Obama's $500 million presidential center from being built in a Chicago park beside Lake Michigan
6:53PM ( 36 minutes ago )