clearn.png
Tuesday April 23rd, 2019 2:29AM

Trump's speech: Less analytical, more sure than predecessors

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — Leaders are speaking far more simply and with more confidence than they did four score and seven years ago. Donald Trump's speech has accelerated that trend.

A new study says Trump talks less analytically, and more confidently, than all past U.S. presidents.

Psychologists at the University of Texas and Princeton University used a computer language program to study nearly 3 million texts going back to 1789, using speeches by leaders in the United States, Canada, United Kingdom and Australia, along with general stories in books and newspapers, movie subtitles and cable news transcripts.

Trump's speeches, debates and documents scored the highest among presidents on a scale that tries to measure confidence in language, more than twice that of low man William Henry Harrison. He ranks last in speaking analytically, scoring less than half of leader John Quincy Adams and substantially below recent presidents such as George W. Bush and Barack Obama.

Kayla Jordan, a psychology researcher at the University of Texas and lead author of the study, said the nature of leaders' communication began to change around the time of Woodrow Wilson, when radio and then other mass media began to emerge and when the voting population expanded to women, minorities and young people.

There's nothing wrong with being simple, she said: "You want everyone to understand what you're saying."

The study is in Monday's Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

Jordan said the team looked at how leaders spoke, not at what they said. The study looked at all sorts of utterances — but not tweets — including presidential debates in part to try to minimize the effects of professional speechwriters and get more "off the cuff" speech, Jordan said. They examined articles and prepositions — such as "the" and "of" as signs of more analytical thinking, because often those words signal a phrase that explains things. Personal pronouns and adjectives — "I'' and "beautiful" — are rated less analytical.

Words like "we" and "you," are rated more confident, while tentative and negative words, like "not," ''would" or "should," are rated as less confident, Jordan said. A computerized system developed by one of the study's authors called Linguistic Inquiry Word Count spits out a score for analytics and complexity.

"We understand that Trump is very different in a lot of other metrics. We're focused on these two and in these two he's not outside of the norm," Jordan said. "This isn't capturing his intelligence or other traits."

Trump so far has averaged a 44 on a 1 to 100 scale for analytical thinking. The average presidential score was 90. Every president but Trump and Barack Obama scored over 70. John Quincy Adams topped the chart just a shade under 99. Trump hit an all-time low of 16 for analytic speech in a December 2015 debate.

Before Wilson, a former president of Princeton, the average presidential analytical score was 97.7. Since then it's has been 79.5. Obama's 69 was almost 13 points below George W. Bush.

When it comes to speaking with confidence, or what the researchers also call clout, Trump tops all the presidents with an 89 rating, far above the average of 64. Only four presidents averaged more than 80 on clout and they are all relatively recent: Trump's 89, Lyndon Johnson and Obama's 81 and George W. Bush's 80.

"The more simple a message is, the easier it is to be clear and certain about it. Complex messages don't lend themselves to high levels of certainty," said Pennsylvania State University communications professor Mary Stuckey, who wsasn't part of the study. "So as messages simplify certainty will go up."

Stuckey, who is editor of the Quarterly Journal of Speech, said the study was consistent with other, similar research, but that style of speech is only one component of political language. "It does a good job of measuring what it does," she said.

Jennifer Mercieca, a professor of political rhetoric at Texas A&M University who wasn't part of the study was skeptical of the way that system scored. She doesn't think the study's system takes into account seemingly contradictory and even ironic statements Trump makes.

___

Follow Seth Borenstein on Twitter: @borenbears .

___

The Associated Press Health & Science Department receives support from the Howard Hughes Medical Institute's Department of Science Education. The AP is solely responsible for all content.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Elections, AP Elections - Campaigns
© Copyright 2019 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Dozens rescued after being trapped on Lake Erie ice floe
Authorities say nearly four dozen fishermen trapped on an ice floe in Lake Erie have been rescued by the U.S. Coast Guard and local safety personnel
3:33PM ( 12 minutes ago )
Wanted: More pastures for West's overpopulated wild horses
US government seeks more pastures for thousands of wild horses that have overpopulated Western ranges
3:25PM ( 20 minutes ago )
Pot-litics: 2020 Democrats line up behind legalization
Many Democratic presidential contenders want the federal government to legalize marijuana, and many have no problem saying they smoked pot ... and inhaled
3:19PM ( 26 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
For Jussie Smollett, 1 story equals 16 felony counts
A grand jury's 16-count indictment announced Friday against Jussie Smollett might be the result of prosecutors looking to charge the "Empire" actor for individual lies they contend he told about the night he says he was attacked by two masked men
2:46PM ( 59 minutes ago )
R. Kelly: 'We're going to straighten all this stuff out'
R&B singer R. Kelly released from a Chicago jail after someone made a $161,000 child support payment for him
2:34PM ( 1 hour ago )
R. Kelly released from jail after payment made
R&B singer R. Kelly released from a Chicago jail after someone made a $161,000 child support payment for him
1:27PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP National News
Biden eyes fundraising challenge amid new sense of urgency
Questions about political fundraising are among the nagging issues as former Vice President Joe Biden considers whether to run for the White House in 2020
10:13AM ( 5 hours ago )
First lady: Growing ease in official role, but not politics
As President Donald Trump shows his eagerness for the coming 2020 re-election battle, less clear is the first lady's fervor for participating in the effort
9:59AM ( 5 hours ago )
UK official criticized after baby dies in Syrian camp
British Home Secretary Sajid Javid is facing criticism after the death of a U.K. teenager's baby in a Syrian camp
9:37AM ( 6 hours ago )
AP Online National News
'He said, he said' - Who can you trust in Cohen-Trump saga?
Trump-Cohen saga: It's a "he said, he said" where the "he" -- no matter who he is -- has a credibility problem.
2:15AM ( 13 hours ago )
Smollett indicted on 16 counts stemming from reported attack
A Chicago grand jury has filed a 16 counts indictment of "Empire" actor Jussie Smollett related to his report of an attack earlier this year.
12:08AM ( 15 hours ago )
NCAA can claim victory after losing federal antitrust case
The NCAA was able to claim victory Friday night after a judge ruled against the governing body for college sports in a federal antitrust lawsuit
12:05AM ( 15 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
US envoy in Kosovo to push for lifting of tax on Serbia
A senior U.S. official has met with Kosovo top leaders trying to convince Pristina to revoke or suspend a tariff on Serb goods so that dialogue with Serbia can resume
2:32PM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: Sanders promises reform to Iowa supporters
Sen. Bernie Sanders has told a packed house in Des Moines that as president his power to reform industries and institutions would be limited, but he'd still fulfill his campaign promises with their support
2:04PM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: Klobuchar differs from Warren on tech companies
Sen. Amy Klobuchar of Minnesota isn't calling for a breakup of the biggest U.S. technology companies like one of her Democratic presidential rivals, Sen. Elizabeth Warren
1:41PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Bill Shine resigns from White House communications post
Former Fox News executive Bill Shine has resigned as White House communications director and has joined President Donald Trump's re-election campaign as a senior adviser
8:22PM ( 19 hours ago )
Chelsea Manning jailed for refusing to testify on WikiLeaks
Former Army intelligence analyst Chelsea manning has been ordered to jail for refusing to testify to a Virginia grand jury investigating WikiLeaks
5:50PM ( 21 hours ago )
House OKs election, ethics overhaul; Senate to slam door
The Democratic-controlled House has approved legislation aimed at reducing the role of big money in politics, ensuring fair elections and strengthening ethics standards
4:59PM ( 22 hours ago )
AP Elections
Bill Shine resigns White House communications post
Former Fox News executive Bill Shine has resigned as White House communications director and has joined President Donald Trump's re-election campaign as a senior adviser
12:07PM ( 1 day ago )
House broadly condemns hate after anti-Semitism dispute
House votes to condemn anti-Semitism, anti-Muslim bias
12:50AM ( 1 day ago )
Hickenlooper kicks off campaign with fiery ode to pragmatism
Former Colorado Gov. John Hickenlooper has delivered a fiery defense of his pragmatic approach to politics in the first rally of his presidential campaign
10:35PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Elections - Campaigns
Dozens rescued after being trapped on Lake Erie ice floe
Authorities say nearly four dozen fishermen trapped on an ice floe in Lake Erie have been rescued by the U.S. Coast Guard and local safety personnel
3:33PM ( 12 minutes ago )
Wanted: More pastures for West's overpopulated wild horses
US government seeks more pastures for thousands of wild horses that have overpopulated Western ranges
3:25PM ( 20 minutes ago )
Pot-litics: 2020 Democrats line up behind legalization
Many Democratic presidential contenders want the federal government to legalize marijuana, and many have no problem saying they smoked pot ... and inhaled
3:19PM ( 26 minutes ago )
Italian envoy confirms deaths of 2 climbers in Pakistan
Italy's ambassador to Pakistan has confirmed the deaths of two European mountain climbers missing on Nanga Parbat, the world's ninth-tallest mountain
3:17PM ( 28 minutes ago )
'Blood everywhere': Package bomb 911 calls are released
A year after a series of deadly package bombings in Austin, police have released several 911 calls that show the chaos and panic that occurred after those explosions took place
3:11PM ( 34 minutes ago )