Saturday August 17th, 2019 5:40PM

Gun-seizure laws grow in popularity since Parkland shooting

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

In the year since the deadly mass shooting at a Florida high school, more and more states have passed laws making it easier to take guns away from people who may be suicidal or bent on violence against others, and courts are issuing an unprecedented number of seizure orders across the country.

Supporters say these "red flag" laws are among the most promising tools to reduce the nearly 40,000 suicides and homicides by firearm each year in the U.S. Gun advocates, though, say such measures undermine their constitutional rights and can result in people being stripped of their weapons on false or vindictive accusations.

Nine states have passed laws over the past year allowing police or household members to seek court orders requiring people deemed threatening to temporarily surrender their guns, bringing the total to 14. Several more are likely to follow in the months ahead.

More than 1,700 orders allowing guns to be seized for weeks, months or up to a year were issued in 2018 by the courts after they determined the individuals were a threat to themselves or others, according to data from several states obtained by The Associated Press. The actual number is probably much higher since the data was incomplete and didn't include California.

The laws gained momentum after it was learned that the young man accused in the Florida attack, Nikolas Cruz, was widely known to be mentally troubled yet had access to weapons, including the assault-style rifle used to kill 17 students and staff members last Valentine's Day at Parkland's Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School.

"Parkland would never have happened if Florida had a red flag law," Linda Beigel Schulman said during a recent news conference with New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo, who is expected to sign his state's new law any day. Her son, Scott Beigel, was a teacher and coach killed during the Parkland attack.

Florida passed a red flag law as part of a gun-control package in the wake of the shooting. Aside from New York, Delaware, Illinois, Maryland, Massachusetts, New Jersey, Rhode Island and Vermont also have adopted variations since then. California, Connecticut, Indiana, Oregon and Washington already had similar laws.

Several states are debating them this year, including New Mexico, where two students were killed in a school shooting in December 2017.

Mike Heal, police chief in the town of Aztec, responded to the shooting at the local high school and testified in support of the red flag proposal, saying, "I know I cannot keep everyone safe, but give me the tools to try."

The laws are being invoked frequently in many of the states that have them.

Authorities in Maryland granted more than 300 petitions to temporarily disarm individuals in the three months after the state's law went into effect Oct. 1. Montgomery County Sheriff Darren Popkin said the cases included four "significant" threats of school shootings, and that a majority of the people who were subjects of the orders were suffering from mental health crises.

"These orders are not only being issued appropriately, they are saving lives," Popkin told lawmakers last month.

In Vermont, a prosecutor obtained an order to strip gun rights from a teenager released from jail after being accused of plotting a school shooting.

Florida courts granted more than 1,000 orders in the first nine months of its new law. Broward County, which includes Parkland, has been at the forefront, accounting for roughly 15 percent of cases statewide.

Among the first people subjected to the law was Cruz's younger brother, who authorities said was showing signs of violence after allegedly trespassing at the high school after the shooting. In another case, Florida authorities took dozens of firearms from a bailiff accused of threatening other courthouse employees.

Connecticut has the nation's longest-standing red flag law, which went into effect in 1999 after a mass shooting at the state lottery office. Authorities there say new awareness of the law contributed to a spike in 2018 in warrants issued to take away weapons — 268, the highest total on record, according to court data.

The rise reflects the more aggressive posture police have adopted since the 2012 mass shooting at Sandy Hook Elementary School in Newtown and other attacks.

One study found that the Connecticut law reduced gun suicides by more than 10 percent in recent years and that a similar law in Indiana led to a 7.5 percent drop.

"It really gives us a unique opportunity as prosecutors to come in before the violence has occurred. Often we are tackling it on the other side," said Kimberly Wyatt, a prosecutor in King County, Washington, who has been seeking one or two such orders per week in and around Seattle.

She said authorities use the best available research and their judgment, looking at whether a person has talked about suicide, threatened others, stalked someone or shown signs of a mental health crisis.

Gun-rights advocates argue that the laws can be used unfairly based on unproven accusations.

"In today's society, the police are going to err on the side of caution. The threshold for issuing these types of warrants has been lowered," lamented Scott Wilson Sr., president of the Connecticut Citizens Defense League.

Debates in state legislatures often turn on how much due process gun owners should receive and who can petition for the orders. In some states, only police can file the petitions. Other states allow members of the person's household, relatives, school officials, employers and health care providers to do so.

Most states allow for temporary orders that are issued for days or weeks. Judges then hold hearings to decide whether to extend them for up to one year.

During the debate in New Mexico, Army veteran Rico Giron testified that people could see their guns seized over grudges between family members or neighbors.

"It's incredibly dangerous because it opens the door for vindictiveness and revenge," Giron said.

The bill's sponsor, Democratic Rep. Daymon Ely, said he wants parents to have another option if they have a child suffering from mental illness.

"The state has an obligation to say, 'Yes, there is something we can do for you,'" Ely said.


Associated Press writer Morgan Lee in Santa Fe, New Mexico, contributed to this report.


Follow Ryan J. Foley at

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Politics, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines
© Copyright 2019
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Calls mount for Virginia lieutenant governor's resignation
The head of Virginia's House of Delegates has joined the chorus of calls for the resignation of Lt. Gov. Justin Fairfax
2:12PM ( 16 minutes ago )
Gun-seizure laws grow in popularity since Parkland shooting
Last year's mass shooting at a high school in Parkland, Florida, prompted a number of states to pass "red flag" laws that allow law enforcement or family members to seek an order seizing guns from people who appear violent and pose a possible danger
1:27PM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: Virginia's governor to focus on racial equity
Virginia's embattled governor says he wants to spend the remaining three years of his term pursuing racial "equity."
1:13PM ( 1 hour ago )
U.S. News
Losing climate change race a 'disaster for Africa,' UN says
Losing climate change race can be 'disaster for Africa' and beyond, UN chief says
2:11PM ( 18 minutes ago )
Vonn to go 'full throttle' in last race of her career
Anyone expecting Lindsey Vonn to take it easy in her last race should think again
1:58PM ( 31 minutes ago )
Liverpool climbs back atop EPL standings; United into 4th
Liverpool produced a rampant display in a 3-0 win at Anfield that not only put the team back atop the Premier League standings but also showed that the fears over another late-season collapse may be unwarranted
1:57PM ( 31 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Warren makes presidential bid official with call for change
Democratic Sen. Elizabeth Warren makes bid for the presidency official, grounding her 2020 campaign in a populist call to fight economic inequality and build "an America that works for everyone."
1:35PM ( 53 minutes ago )
7 get life in prison for Tunisia's 2015 terror attacks
A lawyer says Tunisian authorities have given seven suspects life in prison and handed out other sentences in the trial over two separate 2015 attacks in Tunisia that killed 60 people, mainly tourists
1:10PM ( 1 hour ago )
French yellow vest anti-govt protests turn violent in Paris
A French yellow vest protester's hand was ripped apart during violent clashes in Paris as demonstrators tried to storm the French National Assembly in a 13th consecutive week of unrest
12:38PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
Janelle Monae applauds jump in Grammy nominations for women
Janelle Monae hosted a pre-Grammy brunch Friday to celebrate her Grammy nominations, including a bid for album of the year for her groundbreaking album, "Dirty Computer."
5:14AM ( 9 hours ago )
Likely deal would give Trump fraction of desired wall money
Congressional bargainers work toward border security compromise amid indications Trump will accept fraction of money he wants for border barriers
1:31AM ( 12 hours ago )
Manfred: No DH or draft changes likely for 2019
Manfred knocks down prospect of DH in NL, calling issue too complicated to put in place this season
11:53PM ( 14 hours ago )
AP Online National News
Going green: States would get free hand under pot bill
A US senator from Oregon has proposed legislation that would give states a free hand to allow legal marijuana markets without the threat of federal criminal intervention
9:50PM ( 16 hours ago )
NY gov raps Amazon critics amid report company's rethinking
Gov. Andrew Cuomo is warning about what he calls "political pandering" to critics of Amazon's proposed secondary headquarters amid a report that the company is reconsidering its planned New York City headquarters.
9:09PM ( 17 hours ago )
Virginia governor's No. 2 is hit with new sex allegations
Virginia's state government seems to be coming unglued
8:02PM ( 18 hours ago )
Top U.S. News short headlines
Trump says summit with North Korea's Kim will be in Hanoi
President Donald Trump is filling in the details on his planned Vietnam summit with North Korea's Kim Jong Un: He says the summit will take place in Hanoi
8:31PM ( 17 hours ago )
Virginia gov says he won't quit; new allegation hits deputy
Virginia Gov. Ralph Northam has told top staff that he is not going to resign over a racist photo as another sexual assault accusation was leveled at his lieutenant governor, who would succeed him if he stepped down
7:52PM ( 18 hours ago )
Cindy McCain apology shows challenge for mixed-race families
Cindy McCain is apologizing after inaccurately claiming that she stopped human trafficking at the Phoenix airport when she reported a toddler with a woman of a different ethnicity and "something didn't click."
6:59PM ( 19 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
Calls mount for Virginia lieutenant governor's resignation
The head of Virginia's House of Delegates has joined the chorus of calls for the resignation of Lt. Gov. Justin Fairfax
2:12PM ( 16 minutes ago )
The Latest: Virginia's governor to focus on racial equity
Virginia's embattled governor says he wants to spend the remaining three years of his term pursuing racial "equity."
1:13PM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: Va. Dems call on Lt. Gov. Fairfax to resign
The Democratic Party of Virginia is calling for Lt. Gov. Justin Fairfax to resign
12:25PM ( 2 hours ago )
Black Virginia voters feel betrayed, left in no-win scenario
Black voters in Virginia feel a deep sense of betrayal over two top leaders admitting their wore blackface
12:00PM ( 2 hours ago )
Depression 101: Dallas schoolkids learn about mental health
Dozens of Dallas-area schools are among a growing number around the world that are teaching children how to spot the signs of depression in themselves and others
9:54AM ( 4 hours ago )