Tuesday June 2nd, 2020 2:06PM

Arizona health facility rape spurs video surveillance push

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

PHOENIX (AP) — Arizona is trying to catch up to 10 states with laws allowing electronic monitoring and other technology aimed at deterring abuse of vulnerable people at long-term care facilities, following the rape of an incapacitated Phoenix woman who later gave birth.

Cameras are most commonly used, but they pose privacy issues, and advocates and experts disagree about their effectiveness.

Some say video surveillance can help in criminal cases but may not stop attacks, while others have seen improvements and urge any effort to safeguard those who are aging, sick, disabled or otherwise unable to protect themselves.

The Arizona Legislature is considering a measure that would let certain facilities install video surveillance in common areas. The providers would have to detail how to avoid privacy violations.

The state would join Illinois, Kansas, Louisiana, Maryland, New Mexico, Oklahoma, Texas, Utah, Virginia and Washington with laws or regulations allowing surveillance equipment inside nursing homes, assisted living centers and other group residential settings.

"We're looking into how to make it so parents have more reliable ways to ensure their loved ones are safe," said Republican Rep. Nancy Barto, the measure's sponsor. "I'm learning a lot of group homes already do this. Some of those policies are actually working."

Most of those laws place the option and cost of electronic monitoring on residents and their guardians. A majority of the laws say residents or their surrogates can put a camera or monitoring device in their rooms but must notify the facility, among other conditions.

Carole Herman, founder of the advocacy group Foundation Aiding the Elderly, is not sure cameras would have helped her aunt, who died of bedsores in a nursing home but said that they might be useful in other cases.

Cameras in hallways can show who is at a patient's bedside and how often the patient is getting care, she said. She questions why any facility would oppose them.

"The industry doesn't want it obviously," Herman said. "But if they care about these people, what's the resistance to these cameras?"

Nicole Jorwic, director of rights policy at The Arc, a national advocacy group serving people with intellectual and developmental disabilities, cautioned that cameras are not a "magic pill."

"Even if the law's written perfectly well, it's not going to capture every form of abuse and neglect," Jorwic said.

While cameras could help catch abusers, it's not clear they're effective at preventing violence, said Brian Lee, a former Florida long-term care public advocate who heads the advocacy group Families for Better Care.

"As far as prevention, I don't know," Lee said, "but I've seen it used for prosecution."

But one expert says a properly designed closed-circuit TV system with multiple monitoring points can be a good deterrent. A common mistake is to have one monitoring area that nobody is watching, which makes cameras reactive instead of proactive tools, said Steve Wilder, president of Sorensen, Wilder & Associates, an Illinois-based health care safety and security consulting group that works primarily with hospitals and senior living communities.

"A lot of facilities think cameras give the message of 'We're not a safe facility.' Nothing could be further from the truth," Wilder said.

Details were not known about the security system at the Phoenix facility, where a licensed nurse is charged with sexually assaulting a 29-year-old woman who had a baby boy Dec. 29.

Hacienda HealthCare said Thursday that it was closing the intermediate care facility that serves young people with intellectual or developmental disabilities and would work with the state to move patients elsewhere.

After the birth, the state Department of Health Services implemented new safety measures at Hacienda, including more monitoring of patient care areas but not video cameras.

The department declined to comment on the surveillance legislation Thursday.

In Texas, a 2013 law allowing facilities to install and operate video surveillance equipment in common areas has made an impact, health officials said. Devices can only be placed in the state's 13 intermediate care facilities, which serve nearly 3,000 patients with intellectual disabilities.

Cameras have both confirmed and cleared staff in allegations of abuse, neglect or exploitation.

"There was an initial rise as (the Department of Family Protective Services) was able to confirm cases more readily, but since then, the rates have fallen," Carrie Williams, a Texas Health and Human Services Commission spokeswoman, said in an email.

New Jersey has taken a different approach. Its "Safe Care Cam" program aims to catch abuse or neglect by allowing residents to borrow a hidden camera.

A loaner camera led to the January arrest of a caretaker at an assisted living facility. The attorney general's office said footage showed her slapping a 90-year-old bedridden woman on the hand and roughly pushing her head back onto a pillow several times. The victim couldn't communicate verbally because of a stroke.

In Arizona, the lawmaker behind the camera legislation said it has "a good chance" of passing. As chairwoman of the House Health & Human Services Committee, Barto can likely get the measure a hearing.

Gov. Doug Ducey, a Republican, is usually skeptical of regulations and has touted his record of rolling them back, but the Republican has ordered agencies to improve protections for people with disabilities.

Arizona also is considering legislation that would require facilities like Hacienda to get a state license and conduct background checks of employees that care for clients. So far, neither bill is scheduled for a vote.


Associated Press national writer Matt Sedensky in New York City contributed to this report.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Health, AP Business, AP Technology News
© Copyright 2020 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Arizona health facility rape spurs video surveillance push
Arizona is trying to catch up to 10 states that laws allowing electronic monitoring and other technology aimed at deterring abuse of vulnerable people at long-term care facilities
5:52PM ( 25 minutes ago )
Border Patrol rescues 5 in Texas near where caravan waits
The U.S. Border Patrol says its agents rescued five Honduran migrants _ including a 1-year-old and a 3-year-old _ trying to illegally cross the river separating Mexico from Texas
5:31PM ( 46 minutes ago )
AP sources: Prosecutors probing Enquirer after Bezos report
The National Enquirer's alleged attempts to blackmail Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos could get the tabloid's parent company and top editors in deep legal trouble
5:20PM ( 57 minutes ago )
U.S. News
For Chloe Kim, another title, and a taste of things to come
Queen of air: For Chloe Kim, another title and a taste of things to come
6:04PM ( 13 minutes ago )
Wild finish for Mickelson, wet one for Spieth at Pebble
Wet and wild at Pebble Beach as Mickelson, Spieth among leaders in the rain
6:02PM ( 15 minutes ago )
Amid sanctions calls, Saudis deny prince had role in slaying
A top Saudi official is insisting the crown prince had no role in the October slaying of a Washington Post columnist, saying the trial of the suspects and the ongoing investigation would show it was a "rogue operation" with no official backing
5:54PM ( 23 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
AP Explains: Venezuela's humanitarian aid standoff
Opposition lawmaker Juan Guaido declared himself Venezuela's interim president last month, vowing to oust President Nicolas from power and end the once-wealthy nation's deepening political and humanitarian crisis
5:12PM ( 1 hour ago )
Larger groups seen crossing border as overall arrests drop
Central American migrants are increasingly entering the United States illegally in large groups in rugged, remote stretches of the Mexican border, while overall border arrests drop for a second straight month in January
4:37PM ( 1 hour ago )
Volunteers ready US aid set for Venezuela as Maduro digs in
Standing before a warehouse filled with sacks of rice, canned tuna and biscuits, Venezuela's opposition vowed Friday to deliver U.S. humanitarian aid to their troubled nation, even if it means staging a mass mobilization of people to carry it in
4:16PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP National News
Trump's counselor claims woman assaulted her at restaurant
President Donald Trump's White House counselor Kellyanne Conway says she was grabbed and shaken by a woman at a Mexican restaurant in Maryland late last year
2:02PM ( 4 hours ago )
Family healing after 1 son slain, other wounded at Parkland
Mitch Dworet and his wife Annika are members of a tiny circle within the small club no parent joins voluntarily
1:30PM ( 4 hours ago )
Sex abuse case not only time Kansas judge has been lenient
A Kansas judge who blamed two teenage girls for a sexual encounter with a 67-year-old man has spent a decade on the bench overseeing mostly sealed juvenile and child-in-need-of-care cases behind closed doors
11:47AM ( 6 hours ago )
Top U.S. News short headlines
GOP candidate withdraws challenge for Kentucky House seat
Republican candidate DJ Johnson has withdrawn his challenge of a close Kentucky state House race
5:17PM ( 59 minutes ago )
Budding deal would give Trump fraction of desired wall money
Congressional bargainers work toward a border security compromise giving Trump fraction of wall money he wants
5:12PM ( 1 hour ago )
'Veep' star Julia Louis-Dreyfus no fan of Trump
'Veep' star Julia Louis-Dreyfus doesn't know who she will support for president, but is sure she'll be opposing President Donald Trump
4:41PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Virginia Dems brace for 2020 political fallout from scandal
The political crisis in Virginia threatens to turn a state that has trended Democratic back into a battleground, and that could complicate the party's effort to defeat President Donald Trump next year
2:18PM ( 3 hours ago )
Whitaker: I have 'not interfered' with Mueller investigation
Acting Attorney General Matthew Whitaker insists he has 'not interfered in any way' in the special counsel's Russia investigation
1:29PM ( 4 hours ago )
Indicted political operative popped up in unlikely places
Paul Erickson seemed to pop up in unlikely places from presidential campaigns to lobbying for an African dictator over more than two decades
1:09PM ( 5 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Late burst of buying on Wall Street leaves indexes mixed
U.S. stock indexes stemmed an early slide Friday, finishing mostly higher and nudging the benchmark S&P 500 index to its second weekly gain in a row
4:56PM ( 1 hour ago )
FDA questions Juul, Altria commitment to combat teen vaping
FDA questions commitment to stop teen vaping from e-cigarette maker Juul, partner Altria
4:09PM ( 2 hours ago )
Manfred: No DH or draft changes likely for 2019
Manfred knocks down prospect of DH in NL, calling issue too complicated to put in place this season
3:52PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Business
Instagram changes rules on self-harm postings after suicide
Instagram has agreed to ban graphic images of self-harm after objections were raised in Britain following the suicide of a teen whose father said the photo-sharing platform had contributed to her decision to take her own life
1:05PM ( 5 hours ago )
Bezos says Enquirer threatened to publish revealing pics
Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos says he was the target of "extortion and blackmail" by the publisher of the National Enquirer
10:44PM ( 19 hours ago )
Judge denies Hawaii's move to get Airbnb host records
A judge denied Hawaii's move to compel Airbnb to hand over a decade of vacation rental receipts as the state examines whether hosts have been paying the equivalent of hotel and sales taxes
6:10PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Technology News
Border Patrol rescues 5 in Texas near where caravan waits
The U.S. Border Patrol says its agents rescued five Honduran migrants _ including a 1-year-old and a 3-year-old _ trying to illegally cross the river separating Mexico from Texas
5:31PM ( 46 minutes ago )
AP sources: Prosecutors probing Enquirer after Bezos report
The National Enquirer's alleged attempts to blackmail Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos could get the tabloid's parent company and top editors in deep legal trouble
5:20PM ( 57 minutes ago )
Virginia gov says he won't quit; new allegation hits deputy
Virginia Gov. Ralph Northam has told top staff that he is not going to resign over a racist photo as another sexual assault accusation was leveled at his lieutenant governor, who would succeed him if he stepped down
5:20PM ( 57 minutes ago )
Woman says she aided man suspected of killing of his fiance
A woman has pleaded guilty to a charge that she tampered with evidence connected to the disappearance of a Colorado woman and has agreed to testify against the man charged the woman's killing
4:50PM ( 1 hour ago )
Funeral, memorial planned for longtime Rep. John Dingell
A funeral and a public memorial will be held next week to honor former Rep. John Dingell, the longest-serving member of Congress in U.S. history
4:42PM ( 1 hour ago )