Saturday July 4th, 2020 8:44PM

Court: Suits challenging Georgia voting machines can proceed

By The Associated Press

ATLANTA (AP) — A ruling by a federal appeals court in Atlanta clears the way for two lawsuits challenging Georgia's use of paperless electronic voting machines to move forward.

The lawsuits, filed by Georgia voters and an election integrity group, seek to bar Georgia from using the machines in future elections. In an opinion Thursday, a three-judge panel of the 11th U.S. Court of Appeals did not rule on the merits of the case but rejected arguments that state officials have immunity from the suits.

The lawsuits argue that the touchscreen voting machines Georgia has used since 2002 are vulnerable to hacking and provide no way to confirm that votes have been recorded correctly because there's no paper trail. They sought in motions filed in August to force the state to use paper ballots in the November midterm election.

U.S. District Judge Amy Totenberg in September denied those requests, saying she worried it would be too chaotic or problematic to make the switch so close to the election. But she found that the Georgia voters and election integrity advocates who filed the suits had demonstrated "the threat of real harms to their constitutional interests."

Totenberg also declined to dismiss claims against the Georgia secretary of state and state election board members, and the state appealed that rejection to the 11th Circuit.

In oral arguments last week, the three-judge panel was clearly skeptical of arguments by a lawyer for the state officials that claimed state officials were immune from the suits, so Thursday's ruling rejecting those arguments wasn't terribly surprising.

The ruling says requests to keep the state from using the current voting machines don't violate state sovereignty.

"(S)uits are permitted when the plaintiff alleges that state election officials are conducting elections in a manner that does not comport with the Constitution," the opinion says.

Furthermore, the opinion says, the lawsuits "do not seek a court order directing the precise way in which Georgia should conduct voting." Rather, they are just asking the court to order the state to stop using "a system that they decry as unconstitutionally unsecure."

Legislative immunity does not apply because the lawsuits don't challenge acts of the legislature but instead challenge the way state laws are implemented, the opinion says.

Lawyer John Salter, who represents the state officials, did not respond to an email seeking comment Friday.

Marilyn Marks, executive director of the Coalition for Good Governance, which filed one of the lawsuits, said she looks forward to getting answers to "questions about systemic irregularities" in past elections.

"Such information will greatly benefit voters, election officials and lawmakers as plans are made for a new voting system, and Congress considers changes to federal laws on voting systems," Marks said in an emailed statement.

"We appreciate that the court of appeals acted quickly in rejecting defendants' arguments on appeal, which enables us to finally move forward with our case on the merits for the benefit of all Georgia voters," Michael Qian, who represents a group of voters, said in an emailed statement.

Totenberg recognized that her September order would likely be appealed but said at the time that if the case returned to her, she would handle it on an expedited basis.

"The 2020 elections are around the corner," she wrote. "If a new balloting system is to be launched in Georgia in an effective manner, it should address democracy's critical need for transparent, fair, accurate, and verifiable election processes that guarantee each citizen's fundamental right to cast an accountable vote."

Georgia state lawmakers are expected to come up with criteria for a new election system during the current legislative session. Then the secretary of state's office would handle the procurement of a new system in line with the changes that lawmakers outline in state law.

Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger has said that, ideally, the state would have new machines in place for some municipal elections in November 2019, before having them fully implemented across the state for the 2020 election cycle.

  • Associated Categories: Local/State News, Georgia News, Associated Press (AP), AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Business, AP Online - Georgia News, AP Online Headlines - Georgia News
© Copyright 2020 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Community mourns the loss of local business leader, philanthropist Jack Hough after Thursday night shooting
Business associates, colleagues and friends are reacting with shock and disbelief following Thursday night's shooting death of Jack Hough, a business and philanthropic leader in the Gainesville community.
1:00PM ( 5 minutes ago )
Court: Suits challenging Georgia voting machines can proceed
A decision by a federal appeals court in Atlanta clears the way for two lawsuits challenging Georgia's use of paperless electronic voting machines to move forward
12:46PM ( 18 minutes ago )
Flowery Branch gets good report from budget audit
The Flowery Branch City Council heard good news Thursday at their annual budget audit.
12:00PM ( 1 hour ago )
Local/State News
Fraud investigation launched in northeast Georgia election voided twice by judge
State officials are investigating whether a state lawmaker's election in northeast Georgia that was thrown out twice by a judge was tainted by fraud.
6:20PM ( 18 hours ago )
Kemp names new GBI head, replacement for Gainesville man at Office of Highway Safety
A Cobb County man has been named director of the Georgia Bureau of Investigation and a west Georgian will replace a Gainesville man as head of the Governor's Office of Highway Safety.
6:00AM ( 5 days ago )
Georgia groundhog sees shadow, predicting more winter
Georgia's celebrity groundhog is predicting winter will stick around
1:47PM ( 5 days ago )
Georgia News
The Latest: Prosecutors probing tabloid's Bezos story
Federal prosecutors in New York are probing whether the National Enquirer's parent company violated a cooperation agreement in its handling of the story regarding Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos
1:02PM ( 2 minutes ago )
The Latest: Trump at Walter Reed for annual medical checkup
President Donald Trump has arrived at Walter Reed National Military Medical Center for his annual medical checkup
12:48PM ( 16 minutes ago )
Virginia Democrats try to thread the needle on crisis
Confronted with a triple threat to the party's top ranks, Virginia Democrats are trying to thread the needle
12:47PM ( 17 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
The Latest: Thai king vetoes sister's election candidacy
Thailand's king has issued an order stating that no member of the royal family should be involved in politics, quashing a bid by his older sister to run for prime minister in next month's elections
12:18PM ( 46 minutes ago )
Whitaker: I have 'not interfered' with Mueller investigation
Acting Attorney General Matthew Whitaker insists he has 'not interfered in any way' in the special counsel's Russia investigation
12:02PM ( 1 hour ago )
Irish PM says he's listening, but not negotiating on Brexit
The British and Irish leaders are looking to mend fences after a week of Brexit tensions with a dinner in Dublin, but have dampened expectations of a breakthrough on the thorny issue of the Irish border
11:32AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
John Dingell, longest serving member of Congress, dies at 92
Former Rep. John Dingell, who served nearly six decades in the U.S. House, was hard to typecast
10:07AM ( 2 hours ago )
The Latest: Congressman calls hearing a 'dog and pony show'
The top Republican on the House Judiciary Committee says a hearing with acting Attorney General Matthew Whitaker is a "dog and pony show."
10:01AM ( 3 hours ago )
Whitaker: There's been no change in Russia probe management
Acting Attorney General Matthew Whitaker will tell lawmakers there's been no change since his arrival in the job in the "overall management" of the special counsel's Russia investigation
9:40AM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
France keeps up pressure on Italy in historic EU dispute
France keeps up pressure on Italy amid their biggest diplomatic spat since World War II
12:13PM ( 51 minutes ago )
Director Spike Lee boycotts Gucci, Prada over blackface
Director Spike Lee says he will no longer wear Gucci or Prada until the brands hire some black designers, following a pair of blackface fashion fails
11:52AM ( 1 hour ago )
Finnish basic income trial: creates happiness, but not jobs
Finnish officials say a nationwide experiment with basic income has not increased employment among those participating during the first year of the trial, but their general well-being seemed to have increased
11:21AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
Atlanta officer charged in wreck that led driver to lose arm
An Atlanta police officer has been indicted on charges including reckless driving in a wreck that caused another driver to lose an arm
8:57AM ( 4 weeks ago )
AP Online - Georgia News
AP Online Headlines - Georgia News
Community mourns the loss of local business leader, philanthropist Jack Hough after Thursday night shooting
Business associates, colleagues and friends are reacting with shock and disbelief following Thursday night's shooting death of Jack Hough, a business and philanthropic leader in the Gainesville community.
By AccessWDUN Staff
1:00PM ( 6 minutes ago )
Flowery Branch gets good report from budget audit
The Flowery Branch City Council heard good news Thursday at their annual budget audit.
12:00PM ( 1 hour ago )
Talmo man charged in rape of toddler
A Talmo man faces charges of rape and aggravated child molestation in alleged attacks on a toddler.
11:00AM ( 2 hours ago )
Forensic evidence from Gainesville CVS shooting sent to GBI, expedited
Gainesville Police Department investigators have obtained some forensic evidence after spending the night investigating a shooting incident that happened Thursday evening at a city drugstore.
10:16AM ( 2 hours ago )
Animal health company creating 225 jobs in Hall, Gwinnett, Clarke counties
Boehringer Ingelheim Animal Health USA Inc. plans to create 225 jobs and invest more than $120 million in Gwinnett, Clarke, and Hall counties.
By AccessWDUN Staff
8:30AM ( 4 hours ago )