Saturday August 8th, 2020 4:43PM

Incapacitated woman's rape spurs push to catch up on cameras

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

PHOENIX (AP) — Arizona is trying to catch up to 10 states with laws allowing electronic monitoring and other technology aimed at deterring abuse of vulnerable people at long-term care facilities following the rape of an incapacitated Phoenix woman who later gave birth.

Cameras are most commonly used, but they pose privacy issues, and advocates and experts disagree about their effectiveness. Some say video surveillance can help in criminal cases but may not stop attacks, while others have seen improvements and urge any effort to safeguard those who are aging, sick, disabled or otherwise unable to protect themselves.

The Arizona House is considering a measure that would let certain facilities install video surveillance in common areas. The provider would have to detail how to avoid privacy violations.

"We're looking into how to make it so parents have more reliable ways to ensure their loved ones are safe," Republican Rep. Nancy Barto, the measure's sponsor. "I'm learning a lot of group homes already do this. Some of those policies are actually working."

Arizona would join Illinois, Kansas, Louisiana, Maryland, New Mexico, Oklahoma, Texas, Utah, Virginia and Washington with laws or regulations allowing surveillance equipment inside nursing homes, assisted living centers and other group residential settings.

Most of those laws place the option and cost of electronic monitoring on residents and their guardians. A majority of the laws say residents or their surrogates can put a camera or monitoring device in their room but would need to notify the facility, among other conditions.

Carole Herman, founder of the advocacy group Foundation Aiding the Elderly, isn't sure cameras would have helped her aunt who died of bedsores in a nursing home but that they might be useful in other cases.

Cameras in hallways can show who is at a patient's bedside and how often they're getting care, she said. She questions why any facility would oppose them.

"The industry doesn't want it obviously," Herman said. "But if they care about these people, what's the resistance to these cameras?"

Nicole Jorwic, director of rights policy at The Arc, a national advocacy group serving people with intellectual and developmental disabilities, cautioned that cameras are not a "magic pill."

"Even if the law's written perfectly well, it's not going to capture every form of abuse and neglect," Jorwic said.

While cameras could help in catching an abuser, it's not clear they're effective at preventing violence, said Brian Lee, a former Florida long-term care public advocate who heads the advocacy group Families for Better Care.

"As far as prevention, I don't know," Lee said, "but I've seen it used for prosecution."

But one expert says a properly designed closed-circuit TV system with multiple monitoring points can be a good deterrent. A common mistake is to have one monitoring area that nobody is watching, which makes cameras reactive instead of proactive tools, said Steve Wilder, president of Sorensen, Wilder & Associates, an Illinois-based health care safety and security consulting group that works primarily with hospitals and senior living communities.

"A lot of facilities think cameras give the message of 'We're not a safe facility.' Nothing could be further from the truth," Wilder said.

Details were not known about the security system at the Phoenix facility, where a licensed nurse is accused of sexually assaulting a 29-year-old woman who had a baby boy Dec. 29.

Hacienda HealthCare said Thursday that it was closing the intermediate care facility that serves young people with intellectual or developmental disabilities and would work with the state to move patients elsewhere.

After the birth, the Arizona Department of Health Services implemented new safety measures at Hacienda, including more monitoring of patient care areas but not video cameras.

The department declined to comment on the surveillance legislation Thursday.

In Texas, a 2013 law allowing facilities to install and operate video surveillance equipment in common areas has made an impact, health officials said. Devices can only be placed in the state's 13 intermediate care facilities, which serve nearly 3,000 patients with intellectual disabilities.

Cameras have both confirmed and cleared staff in allegations of abuse, neglect or exploitation.

"There was an initial rise as (the Department of Family Protective Services) was able to confirm cases more readily, but since then, the rates have fallen," Carrie Williams, a Texas Health and Human Services Commission spokeswoman, said in an email.

New Jersey has taken a different approach. Its "Safe Care Cam" program aims to catch abuse or neglect by allowing residents to borrow a hidden camera.

A loaner camera led to the January arrest of a caretaker at an assisted living facility. The attorney general's office said footage showed her slapping a 90-year-old bedridden woman on the hand and roughly pushing her head back onto a pillow several times. The victim couldn't communicate verbally because of a stroke.

In Arizona, the lawmaker behind the camera legislation said it has "a good chance" of passing. As chairwoman of the House Health & Human Services Committee, Barto can likely get the measure a hearing.

Gov. Doug Ducey, a Republican, is usually skeptical of regulations and has touted his record of rolling them back, but the Republican has ordered agencies to improve protections for people with disabilities.

Arizona also is considering legislation that would require facilities like Hacienda to get a state license and conduct background checks of employees that care for clients. So far, neither bill is scheduled for a vote.


Associated Press national writer Matt Sedensky in New York City contributed to this report.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Health, AP Business, AP Business - Industries, AP Business - Health Care, AP Technology News
© Copyright 2020
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Dignitaries praise former Congressman John Dingell
Dignitaries praise former Congressman John Dingell, who died Thursday at the age of 92
1:30AM ( 12 minutes ago )
US officials to investigate San Francisco gas explosion
The National Transportation Safety Board will investigate a natural gas explosion on a San Francisco street that sent flames into the sky for hours and damaged five buildings
1:27AM ( 15 minutes ago )
How Virginia Gov. survives scandal by staying out of sight
Virginia Gov. Ralph Northam has disappeared after saying he wanted to start an honest conversation about race.
1:23AM ( 19 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Oil workers flee Venezuela's crisis for a better life
Thousands of Venezuelan oil workers are fleeing poverty wages and dangerous working conditions, taking lucrative jobs in far-flung parts of the world
12:08AM ( 1 hour ago )
Former Rep. Dingell, US's longest-serving lawmaker, dies
Former Michigan Rep. John Dingell, the longest-serving member of Congress in American history, has died
11:45PM ( 1 hour ago )
Historic candidacy of princess upends tradition in Thailand
A Thai political party has selected a princess as its nominee to serve as the next prime minister, upending tradition that the royal palace plays no public role in politics
11:40PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP National News
Frank Robinson, baseball's fearsome trailblazer, dies at 83
Hall of Famer Frank Robinson, the 1st black manager in Major League Baseball and the only player to win the MVP award in both leagues, dies at 83
11:12PM ( 2 hours ago )
Whitaker confirmed to appear before panel as scheduled
The Justice Department says Acting Attorney General Matthew Whitaker will testify before the House Judiciary Committee
9:34PM ( 4 hours ago )
Virginia Democrats struggle with interlocking crises
The Virginia Legislative Black Caucus has reiterated its call for Gov. Ralph Northam to resign, but stopped short of calling for Lt. Gov. Justin Fairfax or Attorney General Mark Herring to step down
9:14PM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Online National News
Man charged with firing on school bus, wounding driver
Prosecutors say a 31-year-old security guard fired five shots into the windshield of a school bus that had scraped his car on a snowy highway near downtown Minneapolis, wounding the driver but not striking a child who was on board
8:32PM ( 5 hours ago )
Bankruptcy judge gives Sears another chance, OKs $5.2B plan
A bankruptcy judge has blessed the $5.2 billion plan by Sears chairman and biggest shareholder Eddie Lampert to keep the iconic business going
8:01PM ( 5 hours ago )
Desert attraction temporarily closes after 4 dolphin deaths
Dolphinaris Arizona says it will close temporarily as a panel of experts investigates potential factors in the death of four dolphins
7:19PM ( 6 hours ago )
Top U.S. News short headlines
From Gucci to Prada, fashion fails evoke racist imagery
Gucci has apologized for a wool sweater after complaints that it resembled blackface makeup and said the item had been pulled from its online and physical stores
7:54PM ( 5 hours ago )
Bezos says Enquirer threatened to publish revealing pics
Amazon CEO and Washington Post owner Jeff Bezos says the National Enquirer is threatening to publish revealing photographs of him unless his private investigators back off the tabloid
7:40PM ( 6 hours ago )
Prosecutor: Manafort meeting with Russian at heart of probe
A newly unsealed court transcript says an August 2016 meeting between President Donald Trump's former campaign chairman and an associate with ties to Russian intelligence goes to the "heart" of the Russia investigation.
7:23PM ( 6 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
The Latest: Whitaker now confirmed to attend panel hearing
The chairman of the House Judiciary Committee says Acting Attorney General Matthew Whitaker will appear before the panel Friday
8:08PM ( 5 hours ago )
US officials visiting Mideast to seek backing for peace plan
White House senior adviser Jared Kushner and other administration officials are headed to the Middle East later this month to brief diplomats on the economic section of a U.S. proposal for peace between Israel and the Palestinians
7:33PM ( 6 hours ago )
Whitaker committee testimony uncertain amid subpoena threat
Acting Attorney General Matthew Whitaker says he won't appear before Congress unless a House committee drops its threat of a subpoena for his testimony
7:08PM ( 6 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Brazil lawmaker showing deep cleavage stirs controversy
Brazilian lawmaker Ana Paula da Silva is causing a furor after wearing a red outfit showing deep cleavage for a swearing-in ceremony at the Santa Catarina state assembly
4:45PM ( 8 hours ago )
Judge denies Hawaii's move to get Airbnb host records
A judge denied Hawaii's move to compel Airbnb to hand over a decade of vacation rental receipts as the state examines whether hosts have been paying the equivalent of hotel and sales taxes
4:02PM ( 9 hours ago )
Key GOP negotiator: Trump 'very reasonable' on border talks
GOP negotiators are optimistic after meeting with President Donald Trump on the broad outlines of a potential bipartisan agreement on border security
3:34PM ( 10 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Stanford probes faculty ties to China gene-edited baby work
Stanford University has started a review of interactions that some professors had with the Chinese scientist who claims to have helped make gene-edited babies
3:01PM ( 10 hours ago )
Wave of concussion lawsuits to test NCAA's liability
NCAA facing more than 300 lawsuits from former college football players who claim mistreated concussions left them with medical problems
2:20PM ( 11 hours ago )
Johnson & Johnson will list drug prices in TV commercials
Johnson & Johnson plans to air first TV ads disclosing list prices of its prescription drugs
1:38PM ( 12 hours ago )
AP Health
Asian stocks fall after Trump says no plans for Xi meeting
Asian stocks fall after Trump says no plans to meet Xi before tariffs truce ends
10:23PM ( 3 hours ago )
Renault probes gift from Versailles chateau to ex-CEO Ghosn
Carmaker Renault has alerted French authorities to a 50,000-euro gift from the chateau of Versailles to its former chairman and CEO Carlos Ghosn
9:42PM ( 4 hours ago )
Dutch, Russia in talks about responsibility in MH17 downing
The Dutch foreign minister says his country is in diplomatic discussions with Russia about whether Moscow bears legal responsibility in the 2014 downing of a Malaysia Airlines jet over Ukraine
8:47PM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Business
The Latest: UN chief believes aid must not be politicized
The U.N. says Secretary-General Antonio Guterres believes "humanitarian aid should never be used as a political pawn"
4:23PM ( 9 hours ago )
The Latest: US envoy wants Maduro to leave Venezuela
U.S. special envoy for Venezuela Elliot Abrams wants to see Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro leave the country as he cedes power to a transitional government
3:21PM ( 10 hours ago )
The Latest: Site of Venezuela embassy in Washington down
The home page of the Venezuelan embassy in Washington appeared to be down amid increasing tensions between the United States and the South American nation
3:16PM ( 10 hours ago )
AP Business - Industries
Arizona may require license for care facilities after rape
Arizona may boost state oversight of long-term care facilities like the one in Phoenix where an incapacitated woman was raped and later gave birth
6:39PM ( 1 day ago )
Among 2020 Democrats, a debate over 'Medicare-for-all'
Democratic hopefuls trying to define 'Medicare for all' and what it means for health care
5:42PM ( 3 days ago )
Idaho judge urged to force disclosure of execution drugs
A judge will decide whether the public interest in knowing where Idaho has obtained its lethal injection drugs for executions is outweighed by what prison officials say is the risk that future drug suppliers will dry up
5:14PM ( 3 days ago )
AP Business - Health Care
Dignitaries praise former Congressman John Dingell
Dignitaries praise former Congressman John Dingell, who died Thursday at the age of 92
1:30AM ( 12 minutes ago )
US officials to investigate San Francisco gas explosion
The National Transportation Safety Board will investigate a natural gas explosion on a San Francisco street that sent flames into the sky for hours and damaged five buildings
1:27AM ( 15 minutes ago )
How Virginia Gov. survives scandal by staying out of sight
Virginia Gov. Ralph Northam has disappeared after saying he wanted to start an honest conversation about race.
1:23AM ( 19 minutes ago )
In or out of the House, John Dingell was at home on Twitter
John Dingell was long known for his dry takes and quick wit alongside his mastery of legislative deal-making. But the longest-serving Congress member's musings on Twitter caught people by surprise and kept him au courant.
1:15AM ( 28 minutes ago )
Virginia Dems brace for 2020 political fallout from scandal
The political crisis in Virginia threatens to turn a state that has trended Democratic back into a battleground, and that could complicate the party's effort to defeat President Donald Trump next year
1:08AM ( 35 minutes ago )