sunny.png
Saturday August 17th, 2019 7:11PM

Critics ask what took PG&E so long on wildfire safety effort

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

SAN FRANCISCO (AP) — Pacific Gas & Electric Corp. is promising to spend more than $2 billion this year to improve wildfire prevention after its equipment was blamed for causing more than 1,500 Northern California wildfires since 2014.

Lawyers, industry watchdogs and a federal judge alike wonder: What took so long? They question the utility's sincerity in the face of decades-long record linked to wildfires.

The advocacy group The Utility Reform Network and a lawyer representing hundreds of wildfire victims suing PG&E expressed skepticism Thursday after PG&E submitted its proposed safety plan to regulators. Attorney Frank Pitre says PG&E has historically accepted high risks in its electrical operations.

PG&E says it isn't waiting for regulatory approval and has already begun implementing enhanced safety measures meant to reduce the number of wildfires.

"PG&E fully intends to meet or exceed each of the goals set forth in the plan," company spokesman Jeff Smith said. "We currently have programs up and running throughout our service area designed to perform against the targets listed in the plan."

TURN executive director Mark Toney said PG&E's failure to trim enough trees dates to at least 1994, when a Nevada County jury convicted the utility of 739 misdemeanor counts of criminal negligence for not pruning branches that fell on a wire and caused a wildfire.

Toney said "we've got to wonder what they've been doing to address the problem since then."

"Again and again PG&E has tried to convince us it is devoted to safety, and again and again that's been proven false," Toney said. "So pardon us if we're skeptical."

On Wednesday, PG&E promised to step up its tree cutting and trimming this year. It also said it wasn't waiting for regulatory and judicial approval and has already instituted more inspections of its equipment.

"Preventing wildfires outright is likely impossible," the company said. "However, PG&E is approaching the issue with urgency to do everything we can to prevent our facilities from creating public safety risks."

On Wednesday, PG&E proposed removing 375,000 trees this year after cutting down 160,000 last year that threatened to fall into power lines.

Frank Pitre, a lawyer suing PG&E on behalf of wildfire victims, also expressed skepticism. He argued in a federal court filing that PG&E has been historically accepted "high risks in its electrical operations" while its two biggest California — Southern California Edison and San Diego Gas & Electric— have more broadly embraced reform.

"PG&E accepts a high risk of wildfires in its electrical operations and causes significantly more wildfires than other comparable utilities," Pitre wrote in a court filing to U.S. District Judge William Alsup, who is overseeing PG&E criminal case arising from the 2010 deadly natural gas pipeline explosion in a San Francisco suburb.

Alsup on Jan. 30 found the utility in violation of its probation for its handling of a wildfire last year. Alsup eviscerated PG&E's lawyers who argued the utility was working on its safety program.

"That's just platitudes," Alsup responded, citing the numerous wildfires tied to PG&E.

"Why is it PG&E says, 'Safety is our No. 1 thing' — I heard it all the time, 'safety, safety, safety,' but it's not really true," Alsup said.

California Public Utilities Commission records show PG&E's equipment caused 1,552 fires between 2014 and 2017, compared to the similarly sized Southern California Edison's equipment being blamed for 344 fires over the same period.

PG&E serves 16 million people throughout Northern California while Edison provides power to 15 million Los Angeles-area residents.

"While PG&E may not be able to mitigate all risk, it should be able to at least keep pace with its counter-part," Pitre wrote.

PG&E's proposal was submitted to the California Public Utilities Commission, which has scheduled several public hearings.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, AP Business, AP Business - Industries, AP Business - Utilities
© Copyright 2019 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Desert dolphin attraction hit by 4 deaths
Dolphinaris Arizona says it will close temporarily as a panel of experts investigates potential factors in the death of four dolphins
6:22PM ( 2 minutes ago )
Denver teachers are ready to strike over pay raises alone
Denver teachers are prepared to walk of the job for the first time in 25 years over an incentive-based pay system that they call unpredictable and unfair to experienced educators
6:21PM ( 3 minutes ago )
Critics ask what took PG&E so long on wildfire safety effort
Critics question Pacific Gas & Electric Corp.'s sincerity with new wildfire-prevention plan after a years-long record that includes hundreds of fires
6:04PM ( 20 minutes ago )
U.S. News
Data center smoke causes outage for Wells Fargo customers
Smoke at one of Wells Fargo's data centers left some of the bank's customers without access to online or mobile banking as well as other services Thursday
6:07PM ( 17 minutes ago )
From Gucci to Prada, fashion fails evoke racist imagery
Gucci has apologized for a wool sweater after complaints that it resembled blackface makeup and said the item had been pulled from its online and physical stores
6:06PM ( 18 minutes ago )
Illinois Senate backs $15 hourly minimum wage within 6 years
The Illinois Senate has agreed to hike the statewide minimum wage to $15 an hour within six years, quickly advancing a top campaign promise of the newly elected Democratic governor
6:06PM ( 18 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Germany to Facebook: Stop forcing users to share their data
German antitrust authorities have issued a ruling prohibiting Facebook from combining user data from different sources, a decision the company will appeal.
5:19PM ( 1 hour ago )
Democrats seek Green New Deal to address climate change
Democrats call for Green New Deal to address climate change and transform economy
5:13PM ( 1 hour ago )
More women come forward after Arias sexual assault complaint
Two more women have accused Nobel laureate and Costa Rican ex-President Oscar Arias of sexual misconduct after a criminal complaint alleging sexual assault against another woman was filed against him this week
5:09PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
Former NY Times editor acknowledges sourcing errors in book
Former New York Times editor acknowledges sourcing errors in new book
3:18PM ( 3 hours ago )
US officials to investigate San Francisco gas explosion
The National Transportation Safety Board will investigate a natural gas explosion on a San Francisco street that sent flames into the sky for hours and damaged five buildings
3:11PM ( 3 hours ago )
Cindy McCain walks back claim of stopping human trafficker
Cindy McCain is walking back from a claim that she intervened to stop human trafficking at the Phoenix airport last month
1:56PM ( 4 hours ago )
Top U.S. News short headlines
Ivanka Trump project seeks to help women in developing world
Ivanka Trump has launched a White House effort aimed at helping 50 million women in the developing world get ahead economically over the next six years
4:56PM ( 1 hour ago )
US stock indexes drop as economic, earnings worries rise
Renewed pessimism about the strength of the global economy and corporate profits this year led to sharp losses on Wall Street Thursday
4:49PM ( 1 hour ago )
Pence promises missions to the moon and Mars during ceremony
Vice President Mike Pence leads the honoring of the nation's fallen astronauts during a NASA day of remembrance at Arlington National Cemetery
4:42PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
The Latest: US envoy wants Maduro to leave Venezuela
U.S. special envoy for Venezuela Elliot Abrams wants to see Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro leave the country as he cedes power to a transitional government
3:21PM ( 3 hours ago )
The Latest: Site of Venezuela embassy in Washington down
The home page of the Venezuelan embassy in Washington appeared to be down amid increasing tensions between the United States and the South American nation
3:16PM ( 3 hours ago )
The Latest: US aid to Venezuela arrives at Colombia border
Trucks carrying U.S. humanitarian aid headed to crisis-wracked Venezuela have arrived at the Colombia border
2:49PM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Business - Industries
Flames from San Francisco gas explosion damage 5 buildings
Explosion on a gas line in San Francisco prompted evacuations, damaged 5 nearby buildings
1:13AM ( 17 hours ago )
Pacific Gas & Electric vows to improve wildfire prevention
Up to five million California customers could temporarily lose power this year in the name of wildfire prevention if regulators approve Pacific Gas & Electric's $2.3 billion safety proposal submitted Wednesday
9:51PM ( 20 hours ago )
San Francisco gas explosion shoots fire that burns buildings
An explosion on a gas line in San Francisco prompted evacuations of nearby buildings
9:17PM ( 21 hours ago )
AP Business - Utilities
Data center smoke causes outage for Wells Fargo customers
Smoke at one of Wells Fargo's data centers left some of the bank's customers without access to online or mobile banking as well as other services Thursday
6:07PM ( 17 minutes ago )
From Gucci to Prada, fashion fails evoke racist imagery
Gucci has apologized for a wool sweater after complaints that it resembled blackface makeup and said the item had been pulled from its online and physical stores
6:06PM ( 18 minutes ago )
Illinois Senate backs $15 hourly minimum wage within 6 years
The Illinois Senate has agreed to hike the statewide minimum wage to $15 an hour within six years, quickly advancing a top campaign promise of the newly elected Democratic governor
6:06PM ( 18 minutes ago )
Bloody handprint among evidence in Chinese scholar's case
Prosecutors are building a case based partly on a bloody handprint and the responses of a cadaver-sniffing dog that a former University of Illinois student killed a Chinese scholar in his apartment
6:01PM ( 23 minutes ago )
Virginia Democrats struggle with interlocking crises
Democratic politicians are now waiting on the Virginia Legislative Black Caucus to respond to the latest developments threatening to bring down the state's top three elected officials
5:51PM ( 33 minutes ago )