Monday August 3rd, 2020 11:12PM

Germany to Facebook: Stop forcing users to share their data

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

BERLIN (AP) — Facebook is pushing back against a German ruling that could make it harder for the company to combine data from all the services it runs in order to target ads even more precisely.

Thursday's ruling, though aimed at current practices, hints at potential troubles ahead if Facebook follows through with plans to integrate the messaging functions of WhatsApp, Instagram and Messenger as early as next year.

German antitrust authorities ruled Thursday that Facebook was exploiting its dominance in social media to force users to share data from other Facebook-owned services like WhatsApp and Instagram, as well as third-party websites through the "Like" and "Share" buttons.

The Federal Cartel Office, or Bundeskartellamt, isn't contesting Facebook's use of customer data to target ads on the main Facebook service. Rather, the ruling said Facebook should have to get permission separately before using customer data from other apps and websites to do so.

Facebook said it would appeal.

The company currently collects data on users' activities on Facebook and the other apps it owns, along with third-party websites. So, what someone views, likes or shares on Instagram — or the broader web — could be used to show that person an ad on Facebook.

Facebook also has been moving to further integrate WhatsApp and Instagram into its main service after initially promising to keep both as stand-alone companies when it bought them.

Although Facebook hasn't given many details on its plans to integrate messaging, CEO Mark Zuckerberg said recently that the idea is to help users message one another more easily, without having to worry about who's on which service. The company also said it would encrypt all the messaging services, something it does by default only with WhatsApp.

But critics have raised another possible reason — the threat of antitrust crackdowns. Essentially, if Facebook combines its messaging services so that they are different in name and design only, it will be much more difficult, if not impossible, to then separate out and spin off Instagram and WhatsApp as separate companies.

Combining the three services also lets Facebook build more complete data profiles on all of its users. Already, businesses can already target Facebook and Instagram users together with the same ad campaign, and ads are likely coming to WhatsApp eventually.

Then there's competition from other messaging services, such as Apple's or Google's. Users are more likely to stay within Facebook's properties if they can easily message their friends across different services, rather than having to switch between Messenger, WhatsApp and Instagram.

Privacy attorney Scott Vernick said he expects the integration plans to draw regulatory scrutiny, particularly in Europe. That's because of Facebook's promises that it would keep the companies separate when it bought Instagram in 2012 and WhatsApp in 2014. WhatsApp's founders quit the company over disagreements about user privacy.

"There is a high chance for antitrust concerns, as well as those over how user data is collected and used," Vernick said.

There are also worries that Facebook could build deeper profiles, such as by linking phone numbers to real-life identities, he added. Facebook doesn't require users to add their phone number, but WhatsApp is generally used with phone numbers. Between the two, Facebook gets more data.

In ruling that Facebook was a "dominant company," the Cartel Office said it was subject to "special obligations under competition law" and "must take into account that Facebook users practically cannot switch to other social networks."

"The only choice the user has is either to accept the comprehensive combination of data or to refrain from using the social network," it said in its judgment. "In such a difficult situation the user's choice cannot be referred to as voluntary consent."

The office said many users were not aware that Facebook is able to "collect an almost unlimited amount of any type of user data from third-party sources."

Facebook said German authorities underestimated the competition Facebook has in Germany from YouTube, Snapchat, Twitter and others. The company said it had been cooperating with the Cartel Office since 2016 and would "defend these important arguments in court."

Regardless of whether the German ruling — which would only apply in Germany — sticks, Vernick said the European data protection commission is already looking closely at Facebook's integration plans and the data it collects across all its services and beyond.


Ortutay reported from New York.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, AP World News, AP Business, AP Business - Corporate News, AP Technology News
© Copyright 2020
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Bankruptcy judge gives Sears another chance
A bankruptcy judge has blessed the $5.2 billion plan by Sears chairman and biggest shareholder Eddie Lampert to keep the iconic business going
5:31PM ( 3 minutes ago )
Germany to Facebook: Stop forcing users to share their data
German antitrust authorities have issued a ruling prohibiting Facebook from combining user data from different sources, a decision the company will appeal.
5:19PM ( 15 minutes ago )
Frank Robinson, baseball's fearsome trailblazer, dies at 83
Hall of Famer Frank Robinson, the 1st black manager in Major League Baseball and the only player to win the MVP award in both leagues, dies at 83
5:15PM ( 18 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Brazil lawmaker showing deep cleavage stirs controversy
Brazilian lawmaker Ana Paula da Silva is causing a furor after wearing a red outfit showing deep cleavage for a swearing-in ceremony at the Santa Catarina state assembly
4:45PM ( 48 minutes ago )
US emergency aid for Venezuela arrives at Colombian border
Trucks carrying U.S. humanitarian aid headed to crisis-wracked Venezuela have arrived at the Colombia border
4:37PM ( 57 minutes ago )
The Latest: UN chief believes aid must not be politicized
The U.N. says Secretary-General Antonio Guterres believes "humanitarian aid should never be used as a political pawn"
4:23PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP World News
US stock indexes drop as economic, earnings worries rise
Renewed pessimism about the strength of the global economy and corporate profits this year led to sharp losses on Wall Street Thursday
4:49PM ( 44 minutes ago )
Pence promises missions to the moon and Mars during ceremony
Vice President Mike Pence leads the honoring of the nation's fallen astronauts during a NASA day of remembrance at Arlington National Cemetery
4:42PM ( 52 minutes ago )
Judge to release some info on FBI raid of Trump lawyer Cohen
A judge who sentenced President Donald Trump's former personal lawyer to prison says some search warrant materials can be publicly released but an ongoing probe prevents the release of others
4:29PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
First Nassar accuser to question USA Gymnastics official
The first woman to publicly accuse sports doctor Larry Nassar of sexual abuse is expected to question USA Gymnastics' chief financial officer in bankruptcy court
2:24PM ( 3 hours ago )
South Africa leader in national speech looks toward election
South Africa leader in national speech looks toward election, says recovery has begun
2:00PM ( 3 hours ago )
Fiat Chrysler shares tank on forecast for drop in earnings
Shares in Italian American automaker Fiat Chrysler have tanked after the company issued conservative earnings forecasts for 2019.
11:44AM ( 5 hours ago )
AP Business - Corporate News
Frank Robinson, baseball's fearsome trailblazer, dies at 83
Hall of Famer Frank Robinson, the 1st black manager in Major League Baseball and the only player to win the MVP award in both leagues, dies at 83
5:15PM ( 18 minutes ago )
Democrats seek Green New Deal to address climate change
Democrats call for Green New Deal to address climate change and transform economy
5:13PM ( 21 minutes ago )
More women come forward after Arias sexual assault complaint
Two more women have accused Nobel laureate and Costa Rican ex-President Oscar Arias of sexual misconduct after a criminal complaint alleging sexual assault against another woman was filed against him this week
5:09PM ( 25 minutes ago )
Trump-GOP meeting boosts optimism about reaching border deal
Negotiators are optimistic after meeting between President Donald Trump and a top GOP lawmaker on the broad outlines of a potential bipartisan agreement on border security
5:05PM ( 28 minutes ago )
Ivanka Trump project seeks to help women in developing world
Ivanka Trump has launched a White House effort aimed at helping 50 million women in the developing world get ahead economically over the next six years
4:56PM ( 38 minutes ago )