Monday July 13th, 2020 6:31AM

From Gucci to Prada, fashion fails evoke racist imagery

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

MILAN (AP) — Luxury fashion is all about breaking codes, creating a new, irresistible message that captivates consumers. But some of the globe's top brands have raised eyebrows with designs that have racist connotations.

The latest instance of that was Italian fashion designer Gucci, which produced a black wool balaclava sweater with an oversized collar that pulls over the chin and nose. It includes a slit where the mouth is, ringed with what look like giant red lips. Its similarity to blackface prompted an instant backlash from the public and forced the company to apologize publicly late Wednesday.

And it's not just the fashion labels. Adidas on Thursday apologized and announced it was removing a running shoe from its collection celebrating Black History Month. It did so after critics slammed the company on social media for including the all-white shoe in a collection Adidas said was inspired by the Harlem Renaissance.

Gucci also withdrew its offending garment from sale on websites and stores, and said the incident would be "a powerful learning moment for the Gucci team and beyond."

But the question persists: How can fashion houses that thrive on detail miss such critical social cues?

Prada similarly withdrew a monkey bag charm that recalled blackface in December, saying it "abhors racist imagery." And Dolce & Gabbana issued a video apology after one of the designers made insulting remarks about the Chinese in a private chat discussing the questionable depiction of a Chinese model in a campaign.

"Luxury brands used to be able to get away with provocative and eccentric ads that push the boundaries of our society and culture in the name of being creative and cutting edge," said Qing Wang, a professor of marketing at Warwick Business School.

"However, a long list of recent incidents have caused public outrage, suggesting that era is now gone or that luxury brands have lost touch with public sentiment. What used to be considered "creativity" has now turned into "bad taste" or even "racist," he said.

He cited other fashion fails that evoked stereotypes, including Dolce & Gabbana's "slave sandal" in its spring/summer 2016 collection and a recent Burberry campaign for the Chinese New Year that was compared to Asian horror films.

While many of these incidents have caused immediate social media backlashes, the longer-term impact will take time to measure, and will depend on the brands' reaction and future sensitivity.

Dolce & Gabbana was forced to cancel its Shanghai runway show after the insulting remarks were publicized, top Asian influencers backed out of campaigns and Chinese websites dropped their line — a warning sign from a region responsible for 30 percent of all global luxury sales.

The blackface images have particular resonance in the United States at a time when the governor of Virginia and his attorney general have been caught up in a scandal over blackface incidents from their college days in the 1980s. The offensive depictions are reminiscent of traveling minstrels from the 19th Century, who would paint their faces black to portray African characters in a ridiculous and mocking fashion, spreading racial stereotypes along the way.

Italian sociologist Michele Sorice at Rome's Luiss university says that the evocation of blackface by Italian fashion houses signals "a mixture of good faith, and ignorance." He noted that Italian society still wasn't fully aware of the racial charge in some words and images.

"I imagine that they don't truly think they are racist," Sorice said. "I think they didn't have the instruments to understand that these images are archetypes that were used to contrast the concept of blackness and make them ridiculous. I think that many simply don't know. It is a cultural issue."

Paolo Cillo, a marketing professor at Milan's Bocconi University, said the designer's intent may have been taken out of context and amplified, and she credited Gucci with acting swiftly to quell the controversy.

"I wouldn't stigmatize fashion," Cillo said, comparing fashion designer process to artistic pursuits like filmmaking, painting or music. "There are artists in the world of culture that did more outrageous things and no one ever said a thing. There is a perception that fashion is ephemeral, or commercial. But from my point of view, it is not. It reflects the times, like all other artistic forms."

While the fashion world has been at the forefront of addressing sexual norms — Gucci has been redefining genderless dress codes under Alessandro Michele — it has lagged behind other industries in taking on social issues such as racial tolerance, climate change or women's empowerment, according to Larry Chiagouris, a marketing professor at Pace University.

"It is not clear why this is," Chiagouris said, "but the evidence clearly points to the fashion industry's need ... to catch up with the rest of the world."


Nicole Winfield contributed from Rome.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP World News, AP Business
© Copyright 2020
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
From Gucci to Prada, fashion fails evoke racist imagery
Gucci has apologized for a wool sweater after complaints that it resembled blackface makeup and said the item had been pulled from its online and physical stores
6:06PM ( 7 minutes ago )
Illinois Senate backs $15 hourly minimum wage within 6 years
The Illinois Senate has agreed to hike the statewide minimum wage to $15 an hour within six years, quickly advancing a top campaign promise of the newly elected Democratic governor
6:06PM ( 7 minutes ago )
Critics ask what took PG&E so long on wildfire safety effort
Critics question Pacific Gas & Electric Corp.'s sincerity with new wildfire-prevention plan after a years-long record that includes hundreds of fires
6:04PM ( 9 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Bankruptcy judge gives Sears another chance
A bankruptcy judge has blessed the $5.2 billion plan by Sears chairman and biggest shareholder Eddie Lampert to keep the iconic business going
5:31PM ( 42 minutes ago )
France recalls ambassador to Italy after yellow vest meeting
France has recalled its ambassador to Italy amid mounting tensions after Italy's deputy prime minister met with French yellow vest protesters and a string of critical Italian comments toward French President Emmanuel Macron's government
5:30PM ( 43 minutes ago )
Germany to Facebook: Stop forcing users to share their data
German antitrust authorities have issued a ruling prohibiting Facebook from combining user data from different sources, a decision the company will appeal.
5:19PM ( 54 minutes ago )
AP National News
Hall of Famer, pioneering manager Frank Robinson dies at 83
Hall of Famer Frank Robinson, the 1st black manager in Major League Baseball and the only player to win the MVP award in both leagues, dies at 83
3:50PM ( 2 hours ago )
Dems turn focus to tax returns - and Trump's loom largest
The new Democratic-controlled House is looking at proposals to compel presidents and presidential candidates to make public years of their tax returns
3:24PM ( 2 hours ago )
The Latest: Trump's more measured on border security talks
Trump waiting to 'see what happens' with congressional talks toward a bipartisan agreement on border security
3:18PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Online National News
Northam surviving short term, long-term plans a mystery
Virginia Gov. Ralph Northam has disappeared after saying he wanted to start an honest conversation about race.
3:40PM ( 2 hours ago )
Key GOP negotiator: Trump 'very reasonable' on border talks
GOP negotiators are optimistic after meeting with President Donald Trump on the broad outlines of a potential bipartisan agreement on border security
3:34PM ( 2 hours ago )
'The View' host Joy Behar under fire for use of blackface
Joy Behar and ABC were silent Thursday after an old photo resurfaced of "The View" co-host using makeup to darken her skin for a Halloween costume, the latest flashpoint in a series of blackface scandals making national headlines
2:27PM ( 3 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
Ivanka Trump project seeks to help women in developing world
Ivanka Trump has launched a White House effort aimed at helping 50 million women in the developing world get ahead economically over the next six years
4:56PM ( 1 hour ago )
Brazil lawmaker showing deep cleavage stirs controversy
Brazilian lawmaker Ana Paula da Silva is causing a furor after wearing a red outfit showing deep cleavage for a swearing-in ceremony at the Santa Catarina state assembly
4:45PM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: UN chief believes aid must not be politicized
The U.N. says Secretary-General Antonio Guterres believes "humanitarian aid should never be used as a political pawn"
4:23PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP World News
US stock indexes drop as economic, earnings worries rise
Renewed pessimism about the strength of the global economy and corporate profits this year led to sharp losses on Wall Street Thursday
4:49PM ( 1 hour ago )
Pence promises missions to the moon and Mars during ceremony
Vice President Mike Pence leads the honoring of the nation's fallen astronauts during a NASA day of remembrance at Arlington National Cemetery
4:42PM ( 1 hour ago )
Judge denies Hawaii's move to get Airbnb host records
A judge denied Hawaii's move to compel Airbnb to hand over a decade of vacation rental receipts as the state examines whether hosts have been paying the equivalent of hotel and sales taxes
4:02PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Business
Illinois Senate backs $15 hourly minimum wage within 6 years
The Illinois Senate has agreed to hike the statewide minimum wage to $15 an hour within six years, quickly advancing a top campaign promise of the newly elected Democratic governor
6:06PM ( 7 minutes ago )
Critics ask what took PG&E so long on wildfire safety effort
Critics question Pacific Gas & Electric Corp.'s sincerity with new wildfire-prevention plan after a years-long record that includes hundreds of fires
6:04PM ( 9 minutes ago )
Democrats seek Green New Deal to address climate change
Democrats call for Green New Deal to address climate change and transform economy
6:02PM ( 10 minutes ago )
Bloody handprint among evidence in Chinese scholar's case
Prosecutors are building a case based partly on a bloody handprint and the responses of a cadaver-sniffing dog that a former University of Illinois student killed a Chinese scholar in his apartment
6:01PM ( 12 minutes ago )
Virginia Democrats struggle with interlocking crises
Democratic politicians are now waiting on the Virginia Legislative Black Caucus to respond to the latest developments threatening to bring down the state's top three elected officials
5:51PM ( 22 minutes ago )