Monday June 1st, 2020 8:04AM

Warren struggles to move past Native American heritage flap

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — Sen. Elizabeth Warren is on the verge of launching a presidential campaign that should be all about her vision for the future. But first she has to explain her past.

For the second time in two weeks, the Massachusetts Democrat apologized Wednesday for claiming Native American identity on multiple occasions early in her career. The move followed a report that she listed her race as "American Indian" — in her own handwriting — on a 1986 registration card for the Texas state bar.

By providing fresh evidence that she had personally identified her race, the document resurrected the flap just as she's trying to gain momentum for her 2020 presidential bid, which she's expected to formally announce on Saturday. Warren didn't rule out the possibility of other documents in which she identified as a Native American.

In a Democratic primary already dominated by candidates expressing remorse for past actions, Warren's repentance stood out, both for the distraction the controversy has become for her candidacy and the complexity of her efforts to move beyond it. While her competitors are fine-tuning their messages and trying to demonstrate competence and polish, Warren has repeatedly opened herself up to criticism by relitigating the past.

"It's not exactly how you'd want to enter the arena" as a presidential candidate, said Paulette Jordan, a former Democratic state representative in Idaho and a member of the Coeur d'Alene Tribe who became the party's gubernatorial nominee last year. Jordan warned that Warren's treatment of her heritage raises "a whole lot of questions and doubt" about her integrity: "If you cannot uphold that, then it makes things challenging."

Questions about Warren's heritage date to at least 2012, when her Republican opponent seized on the issue during her first Senate campaign to wrongly argue she identified as a Native American to advance her career. President Donald Trump frequently deploys a racial slur to criticize Warren.

Still, Warren has sometimes compounded the problem. In October, she released a DNA analysis that purported to bolster her claims to Native American heritage. Instead, it drew quick criticism from some Native Americans, including a Cherokee Nation official, as insensitive and fumbling.

She apologized in private last week to the principal chief of the Cherokee Nation for "causing confusion on tribal sovereignty and tribal citizenship and the harm that resulted," said tribal spokeswoman Julie Hubbard. And after The Washington Post reported on the Texas state bar registration, Warren addressed the issue publicly Wednesday, telling reporters outside her Senate office that her answers in the past were "based on my understanding of my family's story."

"I am not a tribal citizen. Tribes, and only tribes, determine citizenship," Warren said, adding, "I have apologized for not being more sensitive to that distinction. It's an important distinction."

The episode threatens to undermine the progress Warren has made since she launched a presidential exploratory committee in December. She was well-received in Iowa, home to the nation's first caucuses, last month. She's also appealed to the Democratic base with arguments that wealthy politicians shouldn't self-fund their campaigns and proposed an "ultra-millionaire tax."

Warren's allies are hopeful that she can focus on the substance of her campaign, but they acknowledge she may have more work to do.

Sen. Mazie Hirono, D-Hawaii, a vocal critic of the double standards facing women who seek executive office, said in an interview that "now, everybody's being scrutinized" over their pasts.

"There's a tremendous sensitivity to that, with regard to Elizabeth," Hirono said, referring to relationships with Native American communities. "She is going to need to address it, deal with it. But she has a lot of other issues that she cares about and has fought for for decades. And I hope people will look at that, too."

Waleed Shahid, a spokesman for the liberal group Justice Democrats, praised Warren's apology as confidence-building "with people in the Democratic Party electorate who are skeptical about the way she's handled this issue." He suggested the flap "could be a moment for her to do a landmark speech" addressing blind spots that have beleaguered white candidates — making a subtle allusion to the racism scandal that is engulfing Virginia's Democratic leaders.

The GOP is seizing on the moment to sow doubt among voters about Warren. The Republican National Committee filed a formal grievance with Texas bar officials on Wednesday, requesting that Warren be disciplined for making "false claims."

But it's unclear whether the controversy will wound Warren with Democratic voters. Some of her primary rivals have also aired regret for their past decisions. New York Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand, for example, has disavowed her previously right-leaning approaches to immigration and guns. Others, including California Sen. Kamala Harris, have made more limited attempts to patch perceived trouble spots.

Reuben D'Silva, a Democrat in North Las Vegas, Nevada, and former congressional candidate, said he's not sure how much the average voter is paying attention to Warren's apology. But "among primary voters, it seems to be a cause of concern."

D'Silva, a history teacher whose family is from India, said he could give Warren the benefit of the doubt because he understands that people often don't have extensive records about their family history.

"But if there's proof she used this to land jobs or advance her career or maybe profit off it in some way, then maybe that could become a problem," he added.

Warren reiterated on Wednesday that she did not exact any career benefit from her Native American self-identification. But not every tribal citizen is assuaged.

David Cornsilk, a member of the Cherokee Nation and the United Keetoowah Band of Cherokee Indians in Oklahoma, pointed out that Warren had identified as a minority in professional settings beyond the Texas state bar.

"The conclusion I draw is that she may not have gotten benefit from it, but I believe she certainly was trying to," he said.

Fawn Douglas, a Democratic activist, professor at the University of Nevada, Las Vegas, and a member of the Las Vegas Paiute Tribe, said she thought Warren cleared up the matter with her DNA test because she made no formal claim to tribal membership. But Douglas now sees the Texas document as a detriment.

"I really don't like that further evidence was just introduced after her apology" to the Cherokee Nation, Douglas said. "It's just one of those smack-my-head kind of moments."

Douglas said Warren can recover by speaking about issues important to Native American communities, such as tribal sovereignty and missing and slain women.

Bob Mulholland, a Democratic National Committee member from California who's backing Harris, warned that the distraction would likely follow her to the early voting states of Iowa and New Hampshire. But, he said, "every story is an opportunity for you, the candidate, to have a conversation with the voters."

Not to mention, he added, Warren's issues are "nothing like the problems the Democrats are having in Virginia," where the state's top Democrats are engulfed in scandal over racism and sexual misconduct.


Associated Press reporters Michelle Price in Las Vegas; Felicia Fonseca in Flagstaff, Ariz.; Meg Kinnard in Clemson, S.C.; Michael R. Blood in Los Angeles; and Michael Biesecker in Washington contributed to this report.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Elections, General Presidential Election News, AP Elections - Campaigns
© Copyright 2020
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Political crisis engulfs Virginia's top 3 elected officials
Political crisis engulfs Virginia's top 3 elected officials, all Democrats, and threatens to take them down
8:34PM ( 2 minutes ago )
Woman accuses elected Virginia official of sexual assault
Woman goes public with details of sexual assault accusation against Virginia's lieutenant governor
8:31PM ( 4 minutes ago )
The Latest: Utility says crews had to hand dig gas shut-off
A PG&E spokeswoman says utility crews had to hand dig underground to shut off gas flowing to a fire that raged in a San Francisco neighborhood, which is why it took so long
8:28PM ( 7 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Freezing rain causes power outages, ices Midwest roads
Freezing rain creates dangerous roads, cuts power to thousands of homes and businesses in Midwest
7:19PM ( 1 hour ago )
Authorities: Photographer drugged, raped young models
State and federal authorities say a professional model photographer has been indicted on more than 50 charges in Oregon and California, including rape
7:15PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Source: Former Michigan Rep. John Dingell in hospice care
A person familiar with the situation says former Rep. John Dingell, the longest serving member of Congress in American history, is receiving hospice care
7:08PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
Gas line explosion in San Francisco sets buildings on fire
An explosion on a gas line in San Francisco has prompted evacuations of nearby buildings
5:59PM ( 2 hours ago )
Some workers still unpaid after shutdown, dread what's next
Many federal workers are still reeling financially and waiting to be made whole after the longest government shutdown in U.S. history
5:49PM ( 2 hours ago )
Crisis escalates in Virginia; top 3 Democrats under fire
The political crisis in Virginia has exploded: The state's attorney general has confessed to putting on blackface in the 1980s and a woman has gone public with detailed allegations of sexual assault against the lieutenant governor
5:28PM ( 3 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
Democrats unbowed by Trump's words push investigations
House Speaker Nancy Pelosi says President Donald Trump's insistence that lawmakers abandon their investigations was a "threat" that had no place in Congress
3:37PM ( 4 hours ago )
The Latest: Woman who accused lt. gov. of sex assault speaks
The woman whose sexual assault allegations against Virginia's lieutenant governor surfaced this week is speaking publicly about the encounter
2:28PM ( 6 hours ago )
Trump announces campaign rally next week in El Paso, Texas
President Donald Trump's re-election team says he'll hold his first campaign rally of the year next week in El Paso, Texas
1:40PM ( 6 hours ago )
AP Elections
Beto O'Rourke says he'll decide on 2020 run by month's end
Democrat Beto O'Rourke says he'll announce whether he'll run for president "before the end of the month"
9:09PM ( 23 hours ago )
Venezuela's dueling political movements each push elections
Venezuela's opposition-dominated congress says it will hold new elections as soon as possible within a year _ once they finally oust embattled President Nicolas Maduro from power
6:55PM ( 1 day ago )
The Latest: O'Rourke to decide on 2020 run this month
Democrat Beto O'Rourke says he'll announce whether he'll run for president "before the end of the month"
6:50PM ( 1 day ago )
General Presidential Election News
Virginia scandal could push newcomer into governor's office
Lingering doubts over Gov. Ralph Northam's political future after the publication of a racist yearbook photo could propel an African-American political newcomer into the governor's mansion
6:42PM ( 2 days ago )
Among 2020 Democrats, a debate over 'Medicare-for-all'
Democratic hopefuls trying to define 'Medicare for all' and what it means for health care
5:42PM ( 2 days ago )
Booker announces key staff hires in early-voting states
U.S. Sen. Cory Booker has announced key staff hires in several early voting states
10:51AM ( 2 days ago )
AP Elections - Campaigns
Political crisis engulfs Virginia's top 3 elected officials
Political crisis engulfs Virginia's top 3 elected officials, all Democrats, and threatens to take them down
8:34PM ( 2 minutes ago )
San Francisco police release sketch of "Doodler' killer
Police announced a reward and released a sketch depicting what a serial killer might look like now in a cold case involving at least five stabbing deaths of gay men in the mid-1970s in San Francisco.
8:22PM ( 13 minutes ago )
Trump plans rally, Pelosi seeks deal as wall deadline nears
President Donald Trump and House Speaker Nancy Pelosi are striking starkly different tones in their border security standoff
8:09PM ( 27 minutes ago )
Warren struggles to move past Native American controversy
Sen. Elizabeth Warren is on the verge of launching a campaign about her vision for the future, but first she has to explain her past
8:05PM ( 30 minutes ago )
The Latest: Utility says crews had to hand dig gas shut-off
A PG&E spokeswoman says utility crews had to hand dig underground to shut off gas flowing to a fire that raged in a San Francisco neighborhood, which is why it took so long
8:02PM ( 34 minutes ago )