Friday July 10th, 2020 1:24AM

Among 2020 Democrats, a debate over 'Medicare-for-all'

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — "Medicare-for-all" is quickly becoming a rallying cry for many Democratic White House hopefuls, but there are growing questions about how to pull off such a dramatic switch to a government-run health care system.

The debate over scrapping private insurers has heated up in recent days since Democratic Sen. Kamala Harris of California, a supporter of "Medicare-for-all," told CNN's Jake Tapper, "Who of us has not had that situation, where you've got to wait for approval, and the doctor says, well, I don't know if your insurance company is going to cover this? Let's eliminate all of that. Let's move on."

But since her nationally televised remarks, several of Harris' rivals have pointedly spoken about their plans to work toward universal health care in more pragmatic, incremental ways. Those Democrats portray the single-payer health care proposal they've backed as only one strategy to achieve universal coverage, while emphasizing the importance of other, less sweeping paths.

Among the skeptics, former New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg has said "Medicare-for-all" would "bankrupt for us for a very long time."

Uniting Democrats is a desire to guarantee coverage for all, including an estimated 29 million people who remain uninsured. Some are backing a plan that would let people buy into Medicare, with tax credits from the Obama-era Affordable Care Act.

At the forefront of the debate is Vermont independent Sen. Bernie Sanders' 'Medicare-for-all" bill, which holds out the promise of health care as a right, the potential for national savings from reduced administrative costs and government price-setting, and no more copays, deductibles or surprise medical bills. His plan envisions a four-year transition, phasing in the change by age groups. Simultaneously, some big tax increases would be taking effect.

But there would be enormous challenges to put in place a single-payer health insurance with the government fully in control of the $3.5 trillion U.S. health care system, experts say. And polls show a looming political problem because many people don't yet realize it would mean giving up their private coverage. Another issue: Sanders' office says his plan would cover abortion, a major change from current federal laws and policies.

In addition to Harris, Democratic Senators Cory Booker of New Jersey, Kirsten Gillibrand of New York, and Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts have signed onto the Sanders bill.

Gillibrand, who crafted language in Sanders' bill that allows people to buy nonprofit insurance coverage during the transition, emphasized the importance of that bridge.

"If more people buy into Medicare over whatever your transition period is, you will disrupt the insurance market . because you've created more competition for lower prices and quality care," Gillibrand told The Associated Press.

"What I like about where the Democrats are today is, we have four or five versions of 'Medicare-for-all'," she added. "I think we all want to get to single payer. And I think the best way to do it is what I wrote in Sen. Sanders' bill."

Booker, who declared his own candidacy on Friday, told a satellite radio show that day that he is "a big believer in 'Medicare-for all'- but I believe that if we give people a quality public option, we're going to be able to get more people into the system."

And Warren, for her part, told Bloomberg TV last week that "multiple bills on the floor in the United States Senate" would accomplish her core priority of ensuring that "every American has health care at a price they can afford."

Sens. Amy Klobuchar of Minnesota and Sherrod Brown of Ohio also describe universal health care as an ultimate goal, but neither has signed onto Sanders' legislation. Brown has called for the expansion of Medicare to those over 50 as a more workable first step, while Klobuchar said in a recent interview that "on health care, there's a lot more that unites us in the Democratic Party."

"One, we do not want to repeal" Obamacare, she added. "Two, we want to expand Medicaid . three, we want to improve on that as well as get to universal coverage."

Others are less sanguine about a single-payer approach. "We can't pay for it, it eliminates choices, most versions...would make private health care coverage for almost all health care needs illegal, and it will diminish quality and access," said former Maryland Rep. John Delaney.

Among non-candidates, Kathleen Sebelius, former Health and Human Services secretary under President Barack Obama, said Democrats should debate a full range of options.

"I think this is a great opportunity to put plans on the table and hopefully not have an early litmus test that says we only want to talk about one idea," said Sebelius. "I want to talk about 15 ideas."

A long-time supporter of single-payer said Democrats should tread carefully. Now retired from political office, former Democratic congressman Jim McDermott of Washington said, "A single-payer system would be best if we had a magic wand, but in the real world it is going to be extraordinarily difficult to make this change."

The last industrialized nation to transition to a single-payer system was Taiwan in 1995. Princeton health policy analyst Tsung-Mei Cheng, who studied the Taiwan experience, said she believes the Democratic candidates are doing poorly explaining pros and cons.

"I don't think that the full information that would really help voters is out there," she said. "You need to offer more specifics, and first of all about financing."


Associated Press writers Elana Schor and Juana Summers contributed to this report.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Elections, AP Business, AP Elections - Campaigns, AP Business - Industries, AP Business - Financial Services, AP Business - Health Care, AP Business - Personal Finance
© Copyright 2020
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Among 2020 Democrats, a debate over 'Medicare-for-all'
Democratic hopefuls trying to define 'Medicare for all' and what it means for health care
5:42PM ( 13 minutes ago )
Statue of limitations? Facebook draws line over museum nudes
A Geneva art museum says Facebook prohibited it from promoting an upcoming exhibit with images of two statues, a half-naked Venus and a nude, kneeling man
5:41PM ( 13 minutes ago )
At Oscar nominees luncheon, a pitch for brevity
Winners at this year's Oscars will need to be quick, both in their walks to the stage and their acceptance speeches
5:41PM ( 14 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Some Dems demur on 'Medicare-for-all' as pitfalls emerge
Democratic hopefuls trying to define 'Medicare for all' and what it means for health care
4:40PM ( 1 hour ago )
Virginia scandal could push newcomer into governor's office
Lingering doubts over Gov. Ralph Northam's political future after the publication of a racist yearbook photo could propel an African-American political newcomer into the governor's mansion
4:25PM ( 1 hour ago )
Trump to call for unity, face skepticism in State of Union
The White House says President Donald Trump will call for optimism and unity in his State of the Union address, using the moment to attempt a reset after two years of bitter partisanship and deeply personal attacks
4:16PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
El Salvador's president-elect to face governing challenges
El Salvador's new president-elect won in resounding fashion, but breaking the three-decade hold on power of the country's two dominant parties means that Nayib Bukele will take office with few friends in congress
2:58PM ( 2 hours ago )
The Latest: EU leader pushes Italy for unity on Venezuela
European Parliament President Antonio Tajani is pressing Italy's populist government to side with other EU countries on Venezuela
1:04PM ( 4 hours ago )
Ocasio-Cortez to bring Kavanaugh critic to Trump's SOTU
Democrat Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez's guest at Trump's State of the Union address is a woman who tearfully protested Kavanaugh's nomination
12:17PM ( 5 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
EU nations endorse Venezuela opposition leader over Maduro
A key group of European Union countries has endorsed Venezuelan opposition leader Juan Guaido as the country's interim president, piling the pressure on embattled President Nicolas Maduro to resign and let the country hold a new presidential election
4:47PM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: Guaido calls for aid conference on Venezuela
The interim government challenging Venezuelan socialist Nicolas Maduro says it will hold an international conference to seek emergency humanitarian assistance at the headquarters of the Organization of American States in Washington
3:57PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Interview: Ukraine ex-PM accuses president of corruption
AP Interview: Former Ukrainian Prime Minister Yulia Tymoshenko, who is running for president in next month's election, has accused the incumbent of corruption
3:02PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Elections
Idaho judge urged to force disclosure of execution drugs
A judge will decide whether the public interest in knowing where Idaho has obtained its lethal injection drugs for executions is outweighed by what prison officials say is the risk that future drug suppliers will dry up
5:14PM ( 40 minutes ago )
Winter storm dumps rare snow on Seattle as Midwest warms up
Winter weather is pounding a swath of the U.S. West, closing schools, snarling traffic and turning coastal cities like Seattle that rarely get much snow unusually white
5:14PM ( 41 minutes ago )
Technology companies lead stocks higher after an early slide
Stocks recovered from an early wobble Monday, lifting the benchmark S&P 500 to its fourth straight gain
4:47PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
Booker announces 2 key hires to lead South Carolina campaign
Booker hires 2 veteran political operatives to head up his campaign in South Carolina
7:00AM ( 10 hours ago )
The Latest: Trump: Photo would've doomed Northam's campaign
President Donald Trump says Virginia Gov. Ralph Northam's Republican opponent would have easily won the 2017 governor's race if the racist photo in Northam's yearbook had been discovered during the campaign
8:35PM ( 1 day ago )
Racist yearbook photo becomes a test for 2020 Democrats
Democratic presidential hopefuls decry racist photo on Virginia governor's yearbook page as they react to first major racial controversy of 2020 campaign
4:52PM ( 2 days ago )
AP Elections - Campaigns
'Bond King' Bill Gross to retire from Janus
Janus Henderson Investors says famed 'Bond King' William H. Gross is retiring from the firm to manage his personal assets and charitable foundation
2:39PM ( 3 hours ago )
Gas driller backs off demand to have man thrown in jail
A gas driller has backed off its demand to have a Pennsylvania homeowner thrown in jail after he agreed to talk to the company's lawyers next month
1:45PM ( 4 hours ago )
Poland says no sick cows slaughtered; EU begins inspection
Polish government officials denied that sick cows were slaughtered for meat in Poland as European Union investigators began a weeklong inspection Monday
12:08PM ( 5 hours ago )
AP Business - Industries
Goldman execs may have pay cut over Malaysian fund scandal
Goldman Sachs Group's board says it is taking steps to slash its top executives' 2018 compensation, depending upon the outcome of investigations into the investment bank's role in the ransacking of a multibillion-dollar Malaysian state investment fund
8:26PM ( 2 days ago )
Trump health chief asks Congress to pass drug discount plan
Administration plan would channel behind-the-scenes drug discounts directly to patients
8:10PM ( 2 days ago )
US stock indexes shedding early gains from jobs report
Major U.S. stock indexes are edging mostly lower in late-afternoon trading as enthusiasm over a surge in hiring in January was tempered by a weak revenue forecast by Amazon
3:55PM ( 3 days ago )
AP Business - Financial Services
Merck 4Q net powered by cancer treatment sales, lower taxes
Merck posts better-than-expected 4Q profit on higher sales and lower tax bill
9:58AM ( 3 days ago )
Merck 4Q powered by cancer treatment sales
Merck posts better than expected profit for the fourth quarter with revenue up 4.6 percent.
7:04AM ( 3 days ago )
US stocks end mixed as Wall Street assesses earnings
Stocks posted an uneven finish on Wall Street Tuesday, handing the S&P 500 index its second decline in a row
5:32PM ( 6 days ago )
AP Business - Health Care
US average mortgage rates edge up; 30-year at 4.46 percent
U.S. long-term mortgage rates edged up this week after declining over recent weeks. The average rate on the benchmark 30-year, fixed-rate mortgage rose to 4.46 percent from 4.45 percent last week.
12:00PM ( 4 days ago )
Buying a home by age 35 is worth it now - and later
Becoming a first-time homeowner by age 35 may mean more wealth at retirement
11:25AM ( 4 days ago )
Apple opens new chapter amid weakening iPhone demand
Apple CEO Tim Cook confronts toughest challenge yet as company grapples with slowing iPhone demand
10:26PM ( 5 days ago )
AP Business - Personal Finance
Statue of limitations? Facebook draws line over museum nudes
A Geneva art museum says Facebook prohibited it from promoting an upcoming exhibit with images of two statues, a half-naked Venus and a nude, kneeling man
5:41PM ( 14 minutes ago )
AP Explains: Racist history of blackface began in the 1830s
AP Explains: Blackface began in the 1830s, became immensely popular with post-Civil War whites
5:37PM ( 17 minutes ago )
Trump to name acting Interior secretary to lead department
President Donald Trump says he's nominating a Washington veteran with lobbying ties to U.S. energy companies to lead the Interior Department
5:32PM ( 22 minutes ago )
Australia urges Thailand free refugee soccer player
Australia has urged Thailand to exercise its legal discretion to free a refugee soccer player after the Australian resident told a Bangkok court that he refuses to be voluntarily extradited to Bahrain
5:24PM ( 30 minutes ago )
Video aids recapture of MMA fighter suspected in killings
Police say surveillance video helped police locate an MMA fighter accused in two killings who escaped a prison van in Texas
5:20PM ( 34 minutes ago )