Tuesday May 26th, 2020 4:51PM

Deadly Brazil dam collapse was disaster waiting to happen

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

SAO PAULO (AP) — Lax regulations, chronic short staffing and a law that muffled the voices of environmentalists on mining licenses made the devastating collapse of a dam in southeastern Brazil all but destined to happen, experts and legislators say.

The failure of the dam holding back iron ore mining waste on Jan. 25 unleashed an avalanche of mud that buried buildings and contaminated water downstream. At least 115 people have died, and another 248 people remain missing.

But one of the cruelest parts of the tragedy in Brumadinho is that it has happened before: In 2015, a mining dam burst about 80 miles (130 kilometers) away in Mariana, in what is considered Brazil's worst environmental disaster.

What's more, it could happen again, as many Brazilian states and the federal government move to ease regulation in the name of economic development.

In the three years since the Mariana rupture killed 19 people, the regulation of the industry has gotten less, not more, rigorous in Minas Gerais state.

"It felt like it was just a matter of time before something bigger would happen," said Josiele Rosa Silva Tomas, the president of the Brumadinho residents' association.

Problems that existed when the dams in Mariana burst, like dramatic short-staffing, have persisted, while a new law has reduced the say of environmental groups in the project licensing process.

And the danger remains widespread: A 2017 report from the National Water Agency classified more than 700 dams nationwide as at high risk of collapse, with high potential for causing damage.

In fact, some fear the risk may only increase. Environmental groups accused the previous Congress and president of rolling back significant protections, and many expect further weakening under President Jair Bolsonaro, who has said environmental regulation hamstrings several industries, including mining.

But the politics that contributed to the collapses in Minas Gerais are much more local. For centuries, the mineral-rich state has revolved around the mining industry — its name, given by Portuguese colonizers, translates to "General Mines."

More than 300 mines employ thousands in the state, often in poor, rural areas.

Civil society groups often struggle to achieve basic guarantees. For instance, Tomas' group has long fought to prevent mining projects from contaminating drinking water.

"Minas Gerais has a centuries-long history of being lenient with the mining sector. It's cultural," Joao Vitor Xavier, a state deputy, told The Associated Press. "The industry creates a discourse where they dangle jobs and economic growth in front of people, but they put profit over safety."

The CEO of Vale SA, which owned and operated the Brumadinho mining complex, acknowledges their regulatory measures fell short.

"Apparently to work under the (current) rules has not worked," Flavio Schvartsman said during a press conference several hours after the dam breach.

Vale officials have said they don't yet know why the dam collapsed.

Arrest warrants have been issued for five people responsible for safety assessments of the dam, including three Vale employees. Vale was also involved in the Mariana rupture: The dams there were administered by the Brazilian giant and Australia's BHP Billiton.

The Mariana collapse unleashed nearly 80 million cubic yards (60 million cubic meters) of mining waste into rivers and eventually the Atlantic Ocean. While its environmental impact is considered the worst in Brazilian history, Brumadinho has already far surpassed its death toll.

In the wake of the Mariana tragedy, Minas Gerais was already struggling to implement what regulation it had: A 2016 audit found the state had only 20 percent of the staff needed at the agency charged with regulating mines. Environmentalists say mining regulation has gotten even weaker since.

In 2015, the state approved a new process for licensing mining projects. It shifted responsibility from a board that included several environmental organizations to the state environmental secretary, who created a new board with a majority of participants favorable to mining industry interests.

Then-Gov. Fernando Pimentel argued the bill would reduce bureaucracy. But days before the law was approved, the Minas Association of Environmental Defense called it "one of the biggest setbacks in environmental regulation in the country."

"The conditions are set so the licenses never get turned down," Maria Teresa Corujo, a rare pro-environmental voice on the new board, told the AP.

In December, Corujo, of the National Forum of Civil Society in Watershed Communities, was the only member of the new board to vote against approving the expansion of the mining complex in Brumadinho. Notes from that meeting show the complex's pollutant rating had been downgraded — a move that is now the purview of the environmental secretary — allowing the company to skip regulatory steps.

In July 2018, Xavier, the state lawmaker who has pushed for a ban on iron ore waste dams, made a grave prediction.

"I'm not saying we might have other dam ruptures in Minas Gerais. I am saying that, from everything I've seen and studied, I have no doubt we will have more ruptures of dams," he told the state assembly.

Today, he still has no doubt that there will be more tragedies unless more rigorous regulations are implemented.

"These dams are not 100 percent safe," he said. "How many of them can rupture? Any one of them."

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP World News, AP Business
© Copyright 2020
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Deadly Brazil dam collapse was disaster waiting to happen
Experts say a combination of lax oversight, short-staffing and the strength of pro-mining lobby made the collapse of a dam holding mine waste in southeastern Brazil all but destined to happen
12:02AM ( 4 minutes ago )
APNewsBreak: Detainee on hunger strike details force-feeding
Immigrants who have joined a hunger strike over conditions inside US detention facilities are being force-fed through plastic nasal tubes at a Texas location.
11:51PM ( 15 minutes ago )
NBA adds Wade, Nowitzki to All-Star player pool
Dwyane Wade, Dirk Nowitzki added to All-Star rosters by NBA commissioner
11:38PM ( 29 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Virginia governor apologizes for racist photo; not resigning
Virginia Gov. Ralph Northam has apologized for a racist photo in which he appeared more than 30 years ago, but he says he doesn't plan to resign
10:59PM ( 1 hour ago )
Trump suspends arms treaty, citing Chinese, Russian threats
The Trump administration is pulling the plug on a decades-old nuclear arms treaty with Russia
10:56PM ( 1 hour ago )
New Jersey Democratic Sen. Cory Booker launches 2020 bid
U.S. Sen. Cory Booker is running for president in 2020
10:47PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
Seal takeovers, downed trees: Parks clean up post-shutdown
Some national park visitors cut new trails, pried open gates and even mowed down an iconic twisted-limbed Joshua tree in California during the government shutdown
8:19PM ( 3 hours ago )
Human toll of cold: more than 2 dozen dead, hundreds hurt
Polar blast exacts human toll: more than 2 dozen dead, hundreds suffer frostbite and other injuries
8:16PM ( 3 hours ago )
Trump health chief asks Congress to pass drug discount plan
Administration plan would channel behind-the-scenes drug discounts directly to patients
8:10PM ( 3 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
The Latest: Booker wants to keep private health insurance
Democratic presidential candidate Cory Booker says he wants universal health insurance coverage in the U.S. But the New Jersey senator says he doesn't want to eliminate private insurance
10:42PM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: Trump pulls the plug on arms treaty with Russia
President Donald Trump is pulling the plug on a nuclear arms treaty with Russia
10:31PM ( 1 hour ago )
Gillibrand promises bipartisanship, but not in her Cabinet
Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand won't promise to appoint a bipartisan Cabinet if she's elected president
9:37PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Trump suspends arms treaty to focus on China, Russia threats
The Trump administration is pulling the plug on a decades-old nuclear arms treaty with Russia, lifting what it sees as unreasonable constraints on competing with a resurgent Russia and a more assertive China
3:54PM ( 8 hours ago )
Trump's 'America first' mantra will be prominent in address
For all of President Donald Trump's talk about "America first," the next two years of his presidency could shine a sharp spotlight on America abroad
3:27PM ( 8 hours ago )
The Latest: Booker's uplifting language defines his message
U.S. Sen. Cory Booker is appealing to Americans to come together from their partisan corners as he launches his 2020 presidential candidacy
2:19PM ( 9 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Honda's profit drops on incentives, currencies, flat sales
Japanese automaker Honda Motor Co. has reported a 71 percent decline in fiscal third quarter profit as growing incentives, an unfavorable exchange rate and flat vehicle sales offset gains from cost cuts
10:18PM ( 1 hour ago )
Seinfeld sued over sale of Porsche alleged to be fake
Jerry Seinfeld has been sued by a company that claims it bought the comedian's 1958 Porsche for $1.5 million only to discover it was fake
9:17PM ( 2 hours ago )
The Latest: Bolton: US to send humanitarian aid to Venezuela
U.S. National Security Adviser John Bolton has tweeted that the United States plans to send humanitarian aid to Venezuela despite the President Nicolas Maduro's refusal to accept aid
9:05PM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Business
APNewsBreak: Detainee on hunger strike details force-feeding
Immigrants who have joined a hunger strike over conditions inside US detention facilities are being force-fed through plastic nasal tubes at a Texas location.
11:51PM ( 15 minutes ago )
NBA adds Wade, Nowitzki to All-Star player pool
Dwyane Wade, Dirk Nowitzki added to All-Star rosters by NBA commissioner
11:38PM ( 29 minutes ago )
Big storm sets sights on California, evacuations ordered
A powerful storm bearing down on California is expected to produce heavy rainfall, damaging winds, localized stream flooding and heavy snow in the Sierra Nevada
11:29PM ( 37 minutes ago )
Charley Pride is in the spotlight with upcoming TV specials
Charley Pride finds himself in the spotlight with two upcoming PBS projects
11:12PM ( 54 minutes ago )
Irving gets cheers and a win at MSG as Celtics beat Knicks
Kyrie Irving had 23 points, 10 rebounds and six assists before a Madison Square Garden crowd eager to start the free agent wooing five months early, and the Boston Celtics beat New York 113-99 in the Knicks' first game since trading Kristaps Porzingis
11:08PM ( 58 minutes ago )