cloudy.png
Monday January 27th, 2020 11:10AM

You may have to give more personal data to get personal loan

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

Would you feel comfortable disclosing your bank account information on a personal loan application? What about your work history? Your college major?

That’s what it could take to borrow money from some loan companies that consider alternative data — which can be anything that isn’t in your credit report — when deciding whether to approve your loan application.

Companies that use the data say it helps them better evaluate applicants by giving them insight beyond a credit report, which usually shows things like your name, address, Social Security number, and current and past credit accounts.

But some consumer advocates say that while certain types of alternative data can be promising for consumers, others have the potential to reinforce existing racial and economic disparities and limit access to money for low- and middle-income people.

DOES IT HELP OR HURT?

With the consumer’s approval, using bank account information like credits and debits — which can show responsible financial behavior — on a loan application can be positive for those historically underserved by the credit system, says Chi Chi Wu, an attorney with the National Consumer Law Center, a consumer advocacy group.

But incorporating educational and occupational data in a loan application “replicates existing inequality and it reinforces it,” she says.

Wu referenced racial disparities in occupational and educational attainment in testimony she gave to the U.S. House Financial Services Committee about the use of alternative data in credit scoring and underwriting.

A 2018 Bureau of Labor Statistics report shows that 41% of employed white people and 54% of Asian people work in professional or management fields, while 31% of employed blacks and 22% of Latinos work in those fields.

But Dave Girouard, CEO and co-founder of online lending platform Upstart, which asks for financial information, education and work history on loan applications, says the company works closely with regulators to avoid unfair bias in its application decisions.

When tested against a model that uses traditional credit and application information, the combination of alternative data and machine learning that Upstart uses to assess borrowers approved applicants with 620 to 660 credit scores — bad-to-fair scores on the FICO scale — about twice as often, according to a post on the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau’s website summarizing the test.

Girouard says that while many of the variables Upstart considers in an application decision have a clear connection to an applicant’s financials, others are considered because the algorithms the company uses have deemed them relevant to someone’s ability to repay.

“Our model wouldn’t care about a variable unless it had demonstrated that it’s predictive,” he says.

DON’T DISCOUNT YOUR CREDIT SCORE

Lenders and consumer advocates agree the credit scoring system is imperfect. The Federal Trade Commission reported in 2013 that 1 in 5 Americans had a mistake in at least one of their three credit reports. You can check for errors on your credit reports for free.

Wu says a credit score can also represent an economic advantage or disadvantage that’s outside of a person’s control.

“In terms of lending without replicating existing disparities, it’s hard because even the credit score itself has racial disparities,” she says.

But many lenders have a minimum credit score requirement for an unsecured loan, because it’s still considered a strong indicator of your financial responsibility.

Online lender Earnest requires borrowers have at least a 680 credit score to get a personal loan. But Chief Product Officer David Green says the company also asks applicants to link bank account information to give a more current view of how that person spends and saves.

“(Your credit score) is still a big deal because … it’s a very robust dataset and it’s an important part of your financial story,” Green says. “I looked at thousands and thousands of credit reports in my first couple years at Earnest, and a lot of times you can tell (the credit score) just is telling the wrong story.”

LENDERS NEED CONSENT

An increase in the intrusive nature of the data lenders consider in application decisions should be met with more transparency to the consumer about what’s being used, says Brent Adams, senior vice president of policy and communication for the Chicago-based financial research and advocacy nonprofit Woodstock Institute.

“There’s another piece of this which (is) — it’s inevitable,” Adams says. “There’s no real point in digging one’s heels in and opposing the use of alternative data because it’s inevitable.”

This article was provided to The Associated Press by the personal finance website NerdWallet. Annie Millerbernd is a writer at NerdWallet. Email: amillerbernd@nerdwallet.com. Twitter: @annieanyway.

RELATED LINKS

NerdWallet: What credit score do you need to get a personal loan?

http://bit.ly/credit-score-personal-loan

Annual Credit Report.com: Check your credit report for free

https://www.annualcreditreport.com/index.action

  • Associated Categories: Homepage, Local/State News, Associated Press (AP), AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Business, AP Business - Consumer News, AP Business - Personal Finance
© Copyright 2020 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
At each end of Pacific, skepticism over China farm purchases
President Donald Trump likes to joke that America's farmers have a nice problem on their hands: They're going to need bigger tractors to keep up with surging Chinese demand for their soybeans and other agricultural goods under a preliminary deal between the world's two largest economies
9:58AM ( 8 minutes ago )
Pennsylvania dioceses offer $84M to 564 clergy abuse victims
An Associated Press review finds that Pennsylvania’s Roman Catholic dioceses have paid nearly $84 million to 564 victims of sexual abuse
9:42AM ( 24 minutes ago )
You may have to give more personal data to get personal loan
When applying for a personal loan, some lenders may ask you for information that isn’t on your credit report
9:31AM ( 35 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
State officials are at the core of 2020 election security
Past and present national security leaders are urging state elections officials to consider themselves linchpins in efforts to defend U.S. elections from an attack by Russia, China or other foreign threats
8:20AM ( 1 hour ago )
Rwanda avoids US-style opioids crisis by making own morphine
Rwanda doesn't have access to costly opioids from big pharmaceutical companies, so the African country has come up with a solution
11:18PM ( 10 hours ago )
Remains of US soldier killed in Afghanistan returned to US
The remains of a 33-year-old American soldier killed in combat in Afghanistan have been returned to the United States, arriving at Dover Air Force Base in Delaware
3:47PM ( 18 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Rwandan answer to its pain crisis: Cheap, available morphine
While people in rich countries are dying from overuse of prescription painkillers, millions in poor countries are suffering from a lack of them
2:19AM ( 1 day ago )
Wildfires cause turmoil in CA property insurance market
Thousands of California homeowners have lost their insurance policies as insurers pull out of areas that are at risk of fire damage or stop insuring homes altogether
3:11PM ( 1 day ago )
Trump lashes out as impeachment trial stuck in limbo
President Donald Trump is lashing out as his Senate impeachment trial remains at an impasse, with Republican and Democratic leaders at odds over its format and whether witnesses should be called
11:31AM ( 1 day ago )
AP Online Congress News
World shares mostly higher; China plans stimulus measures
World shares are mostly higher though many markets are closed for Christmas holidays
3:33AM ( 6 hours ago )
China's November soybean imports rise after US trade deal
China's imports of soybeans surged in November following the announcement of an interim trade deal with the United States
2:10AM ( 7 hours ago )
Asian shares mostly higher in quiet post-Christmas trading
Shares are mostly higher in Asia with many world markets closed for Christmas holidays
1:07AM ( 9 hours ago )
AP Business
Health system pays $575 million to settle anti-trust lawsuit
One of Northern California's largest health systems is paying $575 million to settle claims that it used anti-competitive practices to bump up costs for patients
5:58PM ( 5 days ago )
France fines Google $166 million for abusing ad dominance
France’s competition authority has fined Google $166 million for “abusing its dominant position” in the online ad market
8:37AM ( 6 days ago )
Senate passes anti-robocalls bill; Trump expected to sign
The Senate has passed a bill to crack down on robocalls, a persistent and costly problem for Americans
4:22PM ( 6 days ago )
AP Business - Consumer News
Millennial Money: Money rules of thumb can be handy
Personal finance rules of thumb can be useful for evaluating how you’re doing with your money and for setting financial goals
10:05AM ( 2 days ago )
Operation Holiday Express brings gifts to US troops in Syria
Hundreds of American troops based in Syria have received Christmas gifts thanks to Operation Holiday Express
9:40AM ( 2 days ago )
Liz Weston: How to create a retirement 'paycheck'
Your expenses don't end when your paychecks do, but creating a reliable income stream in retirement can be tricky
1:19PM ( 2 days ago )
AP Business - Personal Finance
At each end of Pacific, skepticism over China farm purchases
President Donald Trump likes to joke that America's farmers have a nice problem on their hands: They're going to need bigger tractors to keep up with surging Chinese demand for their soybeans and other agricultural goods under a preliminary deal between the world's two largest economies
9:58AM ( 8 minutes ago )
Pennsylvania dioceses offer $84M to 564 clergy abuse victims
An Associated Press review finds that Pennsylvania’s Roman Catholic dioceses have paid nearly $84 million to 564 victims of sexual abuse
9:42AM ( 24 minutes ago )
Red wolves court battle reignites as governor urges action
Wildlife advocates have returned to court to prod the federal government to jump-start its recovery efforts for the critically endangered red wolf
9:29AM ( 37 minutes ago )
Russian authorities raid opposition leader Navalny's offices
Security officers in Moscow have raided the offices of Alexei Navalny, the most prominent foe of President Vladimir Putin and the governing United Russia party
9:17AM ( 49 minutes ago )
Iraq president won't name Iran-backed bloc's nominee as PM
Iraq's president has refused to designate the Iran-backed bloc's nominee for prime minister and says he's prepared to submit his resignation to Parliament
9:10AM ( 56 minutes ago )