Monday September 21st, 2020 1:53PM

Health system pays $575 million to settle anti-trust lawsuit

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

SACRAMENTO, Calif. (AP) — One of Northern California's largest health systems will pay $575 million to settle claims that it used anti-competitive practices to bump up costs for patients, the state's attorney general said Friday, though that falls short of damages sought in a related private lawsuit that could have exceeded $1 billion.

California Attorney General Xavier Becerra had sought an injunction to stop the alleged anti-trust practices by Sutter Health, but no monetary damages. The settlement imposes a new court-approved monitor on the health system for 10 years to ensure it is not using anti-competitive practices with insurance companies to increase patients' costs.

Becerra called it “one of the largest actions against anti-competitive conduct in the health care marketplace across the country, with unprecedented levels of injunctive relief to restore competition in the market.” It is larger than recent similar settlements with other providers in North Carolina and Washington state, his office said.

The settlement immediately set off a debate between hospitals and consumer advocates over whether it will limit or increase health care costs.

About 1,400 self-funded employers separately obtained the $575 million in damages from Sutter and will have claims paid through an independent administrator, minus attorneys fees. It's not clear if consumers will get a share of the settlement, Becerra said, but he said patients should benefit from increased competition.

Under previous market conditions a typical inpatient procedure might cost $90,000 more in Northern California than in the southern part of the state, he said citing a university study. The state had said Sutter was largely to blame.

The Sacramento-based nonprofit did not admit wrongdoing and denied the allegations, arguing that there is plenty of competition and that insurance companies were the ones boosting costs.

“There were no claims that Sutter’s contracting practices with insurance companies affected patient care or quality,” Sutter Health Senior Vice President and General Counsel Flo Di Benedetto said in a statement hailing the agreement.

Sutter and Becerra announced in October that they had settled the class-action lawsuit just in time to avoid a trial. But they did not provide details until Friday, after it was submitted to a San Francisco Superior Court judge for approval. The suit was first filed by employers and unions in 2014, but Becerra filed a similar lawsuit last year after a six-year investigation.

Among other things, the settlement limits what Sutter can charge for out-of-network procedures and increases pricing transparency.

It bars Sutter from blocking insurance companies from using incentives to direct patients to cheaper health care providers, a practice that critics said made it harder for patients to use Sutter's lower-priced competitors. And it prohibits what Becerra called Sutter's "all or nothing" approach with insurance companies, which required insurers to include all the company's hospitals in their provider networks even if it didn't make financial sense.

American Hospital Association general counsel Melinda Hatton said commercial health insurance companies will benefit most because it will let them “cherry-pick” hospitals and eliminate incentives for them to work with hospitals to provide lower cost care. She predicted it will increase health care costs, warning that patients in rural or vulnerable communities could be harmed most by the settlement.

Anthony Wright, executive director of the health care consumer advocacy coalition Health Access California, countered that Sutter's pricing is one reason that patients in Northern California typically pay $3,000 more in health insurance premiums than in Southern California.

“We want hospitals to compete on lower costs and higher quality, and not on whether they can get bundled in with bigger and bigger hospital systems,” he said. ”This settlement takes a first step to changing the incentives to the market and competition we want. That benefits consumers.”

Wright was hopeful the settlement would set a national precedent and reignite stalled proposals in Congress and California to limit “surprise medical bills” for out of network procedures.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Health, AP Business, AP Business - Consumer News, AP Business - Corporate News, AP Business - Industries, AP Business - Financial Services, AP Business - Health Care, AP Business - Personal Finance
© Copyright 2020
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Trump blasts Christian magazine that called for his removal
President Donald Trump is blasting a prominent Christian magazine that published an editorial arguing that he should be removed from office
5:14PM ( 15 minutes ago )
All-star games could shake up team recruiting rankings
College football’s early signing period closed with several top-100 prospects still officially uncommitted
5:11PM ( 18 minutes ago )
MS-13 arrests deal blow to gang leadership on Long Island
Law enforcement officials say they have dealt a crippling blow to the violent MS-13 street gang on Long Island
5:01PM ( 28 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
What if you knew a cookie would take 20 minutes to run off?
Researchers are studying whether people might make better food choices if labels said how much exercise would be needed to burn off their calories
11:29AM ( 6 hours ago )
French telecom company Orange convicted over suicides
French telecom powerhouse Orange has been found guilty of a string of employee suicides and ordered to pay 3.5 million euros ($3.8 million) in fines and damages
7:59AM ( 9 hours ago )
EU funds help Kosovo fight unhealthy air pollution
The European Union is investing more than 80 million euros ($89 million) to improve air quality in Kosovo
7:12AM ( 10 hours ago )
AP Health
United pulls 737 Max until June, adding to Boeing woes
United Airlines says it will be pulling the Boeing 737 Max out of its flight schedule until June
4:21PM ( 1 hour ago )
S&P 500 index closes out 10th winning week in the past 11
Major US indexes are closing broadly higher on Wall Street, giving the S&P 500 index its 10th winning week in the last 11
4:05PM ( 1 hour ago )
Boeing capsule launches to wrong orbit, skips space station
Boeing's new Starliner capsule is in the wrong orbit after launching for the first time and will have to skip its visit to the International Space Station
3:59PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
France fines Google $166 million for abusing ad dominance
France’s competition authority has fined Google $166 million for “abusing its dominant position” in the online ad market
8:37AM ( 8 hours ago )
Senate passes anti-robocalls bill; Trump expected to sign
The Senate has passed a bill to crack down on robocalls, a persistent and costly problem for Americans
4:22PM ( 1 day ago )
EU court boost for activist in Facebook data transfer fight
An advisor to the European Union’s top court says EU regulators must make more effort to stop tech companies from transferring data to countries with weaker protections
2:34PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Business - Consumer News
Stocks open broadly higher on Wall Street, extending gains
Stocks are rising across the board in early trading on Wall Street, building on the market's record-setting run
9:44AM ( 7 hours ago )
Switzerland shuts down 47-year-old nuclear power plant
Switzerland is shutting down one of its oldest nuclear power plants after 47 years of operation
8:36AM ( 8 hours ago )
Asian shares mixed as markets yawn at Trump's impeachment
Stocks are mixed in early trading in Asia after Wall Street posted more record highs, extending the market's gains for the week
8:25PM ( 21 hours ago )
AP Business - Corporate News
AP Exclusive: Early PG&E blackouts forewarned later problems
Even before widespread blackouts hit California this fall, the utility that triggered them showed signs it wasn’t fully prepared
12:39PM ( 4 hours ago )
Is Russia eyeing Belarus takeover? Integration talks deepen
The presidents of Belarus and Russia have met to discuss deeper economic ties between the two close allies amid mounting concerns in Minsk that Moscow ultimately wants to subdue its neighbor
12:00PM ( 5 hours ago )
US consumer spending up 0.4% in November, best since July
Americans increased their spending in November at the fastest pace in four months while income growth rebounded to the strongest gain since August. The Commerce Department said Friday that consumer spending rose 0.4% last month, led by a big jump in spending on durable goods such as autos
10:52AM ( 6 hours ago )
AP Business - Industries
After ebullient 2019, Wall Street warns of slower road ahead
Wall Street is telling investors to expect less from their investments next year following a fabulous 2019
11:05AM ( 1 day ago )
Bank of England audio feed 'misused' by hedge funds
British financial authorities have begun investigating how some hedge funds allagedy got access to market-sensitive news conferences at the Bank of England a crucial few seconds earlier than anyone else
8:46AM ( 1 day ago )
Global stocks dip after Trump impeachment vote
Global stocks have largely edged down after the U.S. House of Representatives voted to impeach President Donald Trump
8:23AM ( 1 day ago )
AP Business - Financial Services
North America trade pact deals rare setback to Big Pharma
A revamped North American trade deal nearing passage in Congress gives both the White House and Democrats a chance to claim victory
4:43PM ( 1 day ago )
How North America trade deal dealt a setback to Big Pharma
A revamped North American trade deal is nearing passage in Congress, giving both the White House and House Democrats cause to claim victory
11:07AM ( 1 day ago )
British man accused of hacking US health care companies
A 38-year-old British man who is allegedly a member of a hacking group called The Dark Overlord has pleaded not guilty in U.S. federal court in Missouri to charges that he threatened to release data stolen from health care and accounting companies
2:27PM ( 2 days ago )
AP Business - Health Care
Warren’s origin story, her mother and THE dress, comes home
Massachusetts Sen. Elizabeth Warren tells campaign audiences a story of an Oklahoma upbringing so plagued by financial hardship that her mother had to pull on her best dress and join the workforce at 50 to save her family's house
8:02AM ( 9 hours ago )
AP FACT CHECK: Examining claims from 2020 Democratic debate
Democratic presidential contenders have tangled in their last debate of the year and an AP Fact Check examined their statements
11:00PM ( 18 hours ago )
Bloomberg health plan aims to lower costs, cover more people
Michael Bloomberg has unveiled a health care plan that would expand coverage and cut people's costs by building on the current system, not replacing it
2:10PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Business - Personal Finance
Trump blasts Christian magazine that called for his removal
President Donald Trump is blasting a prominent Christian magazine that published an editorial arguing that he should be removed from office
5:14PM ( 16 minutes ago )
MS-13 arrests deal blow to gang leadership on Long Island
Law enforcement officials say they have dealt a crippling blow to the violent MS-13 street gang on Long Island
5:01PM ( 28 minutes ago )
Police: Body found likely Texas mom who vanished with baby
Authorities say a Texas mother appears to be dead but her 1-month-old daughter is alive a week after they disappeared
4:59PM ( 31 minutes ago )
Biden: No regrets for talking openly about stuttering
Joe Biden has been fighting a stutter since his childhood, and he says he has no regrets about talking openly about it
4:53PM ( 36 minutes ago )
Female candidates asked for forgiveness. Men, not so much
During the final question of Thursday's Democratic presidential debate, the seven candidates were asked to either give a gift or ask for forgiveness
4:50PM ( 40 minutes ago )