Wednesday August 12th, 2020 6:22AM

AP FACT CHECK: Trump's misstatements at NATO summit

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — President Donald Trump on Tuesday wholly misrepresented the U.S. record on international trade disputes, incorrectly accused House Democrats of denying him lawyers in impeachment proceedings and dismissed as a mysterious “rumor” his own statement from months ago about Britain's health system.

Here's a look at some of his statements from London, where's he is attending a NATO meeting:


TRUMP: “We won, in the World Trade Organization, we won seven and a half billion dollars. We never used to win before me, because, before me, the United States was a sucker for all of these different organizations.” — remarks with NATO Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg.

THE FACTS: He is wildly wrong to state that the U.S. never won victories in disputes taken to the trade organization before him.

The U.S. has always had a high success rate when it pursues cases against other countries at the WTO. In 2017, trade analyst Daniel Ikenson of the libertarian Cato Institute found that the U.S. won 91% of the cases it took to the Geneva-based trade monitor.

As Ikenson noted, countries bringing complaints to the organization tend to win because they don't bother going to the WTO in the first place if they don't have a strong case.

As for his claim that the U.S. “won” $7.5 billion from the WTO, that's not quite right.

Trump was referring to a WTO decision in October siding with the U.S. on imposing tariffs on $7.5 billion worth of European imports annually. The value of the tariffs on those imports is much less than $7.5 billion.

The WTO announcement culminated a 15-year fight over EU subsidies for Airbus — a fight that began long before Trump was in office.



TRUMP: “For the hearings, we don’t get a lawyer.” — remarks with Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau.

THE FACTS: Trump is wrong about being deprived of an attorney in the House Judiciary Committee hearings. The committee has invited Trump and his lawyers to appear if he wishes, but so far the White House has refused.

In a letter Sunday to Judiciary Committee Chairman Jerrold Nadler, D-N.Y., White House counsel Pat Cipollone declined the invitation for the president’s counsel to appear Wednesday while Trump is at the NATO summit, insisting that the inquiry violates “basic due process rights.”

Trump has until Friday to decide whether he would take advantage of due process protections afforded to him under House rules adopted in October for hearings next week, including the right to request witness testimony and to cross-examine the witnesses called by the House. Cipollone has demanded more information from Democrats on how they intended to conduct further hearings before Trump would decide whether to participate in those hearings.

If the House impeaches Trump, the Senate trial will look like a normal trial in some respects, with senators as the jury. Arguments would be heard from each side’s legal team for and against Trump’s removal from office.

The Intelligence Committee hearings, in contrast, were like the investigative phase of criminal cases, conducted without the participation of the person under investigation.


TRUMP, on whether acting chief of staff Mick Mulvaney and Secretary of State Mike Pompeo should testify: “We don’t get any witnesses. ...This is a fix. ...I want them to testify, but I want them to testify in the Senate where they’ll get a fair trial.” — remarks with Trudeau.

THE FACTS: He’s incorrect that the Intelligence Committee hearings only brought forward witnesses hand-picked by the Democratic majority on the panel. Several were invited at the request of Republicans on the committee.

While Trump and his GOP allies have limited ability to bring forward witnesses in the Judiciary Committee, the president also says he wouldn’t want to send any witnesses until the Senate impeachment trial anyway.



TRUMP: “We have a tremendous amount of captured fighters, ISIS fighters over in Syria. And, they're all under lock and key, but many are from France, many are from Germany. Many are from U.K. They are mostly from Europe.” — remarks with French President Emmanuel Macron.

MACRON: There are “very large number of fighters ... ISIS fighters coming from Syria, from Iraq and the region.” Those from Europe are "a tiny minority of the overall problem."

THE FACTS: Trump is incorrect to say the Islamic State fighters who were captured and held by the Kurds in Syria are mostly from Europe.

Of the more than 12,000 IS fighters in custody in Kurdish areas, only 2,500 are from outside the region of the conflict, some from Europe, some from other parts of the world. Most of the captured fighters — about 10,000 — are natives of Syria or Iraq.

European nations have indeed been reluctant to take detainees who came from Europe, frustrating Trump. But such detainees are far fewer than the majority he frequently claims.


TRUMP, on protecting oilfields in Syria: “We have the oil, and we can do with the oil what we want." — remarks with Stoltenberg.

THE FACTS: That’s not true. The oil in Syria belongs to Syria and the U.S. can’t do anything it wants with it.

As secretary of state, Rex Tillerson reviewed whether the U.S. could make money off the oil-rich areas and concluded there was no practical way to do so, said Brett McGurk, Trump's former special envoy to the global coalition to defeat the Islamic State. “Maybe there are new lawyers now, but it was just illegal for an American company to go and seize and exploit these assets,” McGurk told a panel on Syria held in October by the Foundation for Defense of Democracies.

Stephen Vladeck, a national security law professor at the University of Texas at Austin, said there is no solid legal argument the Trump administration could make if it sought to claim Syria's oil.

While Trump has said he will withdraw the bulk of roughly 1,000 American troops from Syria, he’s made clear he will leave some military forces in the country to help secure the oil from any Islamic State resurgence.

The Pentagon has said it is committed to sending additional military forces to eastern Syria to "reinforce" control of the oil fields and prevent them from “falling back to into the hands of ISIS or other destabilizing actors.”



TRUMP, speaking about claims that Britain's state-funded health care system would be part of future U.K.-U.S. trade talks: “I don't even know where that rumor started. We have absolutely nothing to do with it and we wouldn't want to. If you handed it to us on a silver platter, we want nothing to do with it.” — remarks with Jens Stoltenberg.

THE FACTS: He's referring to his own past statements as a “rumor.”

Asked about the National Health Service during a visit to Britain in June, he said “when you're dealing in trade, everything’s on the table. So, NHS or anything else."

The service, which provides free health care to all Britons, could in fact be a bargaining chip in U.S.-U.K. trade talks. U.S. health-services firms can already bid for contracts if they have European subsidiaries. A future government could increase the amount of private-sector involvement or let U.S. companies bid directly.

As well, the U.S. could demand during trade talks that Britain pay American pharma firms more for drugs. Medicines became a big issue in negotiations on a revamped North American free trade deal, as the U.S. pushed successfully for tighter restrictions on the development in Canada and Mexico of generic versions of U.S.-patented drugs.

Leaked documents from preliminary talks between U.S. and U.K. negotiators over two years from July 2017 — released by the Labour Party last week — said “patent issues” around “NHS access to generic drugs will be a key consideration” in talks.

It’s an overstatement to say the national health service as a whole would be up for sale, as Labour has alleged will happen if Prime Minister Boris Johnson’s Conservatives win the Dec. 12 election and try to strike a post-Brexit trade deal with the U.S. Britain would not be “selling off” the health service, as Labour asserts, because taxpayers would still be footing the bill.

But it's also improbable to think U.S. negotiators would “want nothing to do" with Britain's health care market, despite Trump’s words.


EDITOR'S NOTE — A look at the veracity of claims by political figures.


Lawless reported from London. Associated Press Economics Writer Paul Wiseman contributed to this report.


Find AP Fact Checks at

Follow @APFactCheck on Twitter:

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Business, AP Business - Corporate News, AP Business - Economy, AP Business - Industries, AP Business - Utilities
© Copyright 2020
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Claire Foy on hand to unveil Pirelli’s 2020 calendar
Pirelli’s 2020 calendar pays romantic tribute to Shakespeare’s tragic figure Juliet in the city of her famously failed romance
5:52PM ( 6 minutes ago )
Children of Casey Kasem settle lawsuit with widow over death
Family members of longtime “American Top 40" host Casey Kasem have settled dueling lawsuits that alleged he was badly mistreated before his death in 2014
5:49PM ( 9 minutes ago )
AP FACT CHECK: Trump's misstatements at NATO summit
An AP Fact Check finds some misstatements by President Donald Trump at the NATO summit in London
5:41PM ( 18 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Gun background checks are on pace to break record in 2019
Background checks on gun purchases in the U.S. are climbing toward a record high this year
5:03PM ( 56 minutes ago )
Records: Giuliani, Nunes and White House in frequent contact
A new report by the House Intelligence Committee reveals contact between President Donald Trump's personal attorney, Rudy Giuliani, and California Rep
4:53PM ( 1 hour ago )
DeVos calls for making financial aid unit a separate agency
Education Secretary Betsy DeVos is calling on Congress to consider splitting her department’s financial aid operation into a separate federal agency with the flexibility to operate like a private bank
4:23PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Prosecutor says he will seek 1 year for corrupt congressman
A federal prosecutor said Tuesday he plans to ask for at least a year in prison for California Rep. Duncan Hunter, who pleaded guilty to misusing $150,000 in campaign funds
2:58PM ( 3 hours ago )
House report outlines evidence for Trump impeachment
The House has released a sweeping impeachment report outlining evidence of what it calls President Donald Trump’s wrongdoing toward Ukraine
2:48PM ( 3 hours ago )
The Latest: California’s Hunter doesn’t say when he’ll quit
California Rep. Duncan Hunter showed no emotion in the courtroom when he pleaded guilty to misusing campaign money
2:01PM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Mississippi felons push court to restore voting rights
A key advocate for restoring voting rights to felons in Mississippi says he’s fighting to restore his rights as a “human being.”
5:11PM ( 48 minutes ago )
Asylum seekers jam US border crossings to evade Trump policy
Asylum seekers desperate to enter the U.S. have started to spring down vehicle lanes or rent cars at border crossings to try to avoid the Trump policy that prohibits them from filing claims at the border
5:04PM ( 55 minutes ago )
Lawyer: Elon Musk’s 'pedo guy' tweet forced diver to sue
Troublesome tweets that followed cave rescue have Tesla CEO Elon Musk facing defamation trial by British diver he’s accused of branding a pedophile
4:41PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
Elon Musk faces defamation trial for 'pedo guy' tweet
Troublesome tweets that followed underwater cave rescue have Tesla CEO Elon Musk facing defamation trial by British diver he’s accused of branding a pedophile
2:20PM ( 3 hours ago )
Cleveland-Cliffs buying AK Steel in $1.1B stock deal
Cleveland-Cliffs, North America’s biggest producer of iron ore pellets, is buying AK Steel in a stock deal valued at about $1.1 billion
12:12PM ( 5 hours ago )
Tesla CEO Musk facing defamation trial for 'pedo guy' tweet
Troublesome tweets that followed underwater cave rescue have Tesla CEO Elon Musk facing defamation trial by British diver he allegedly dubbed a pedophile
1:02AM ( 16 hours ago )
AP Business - Corporate News
Trump says China deal could wait until after 2020 election
President Donald Trump appears to be downplaying the chances for a US-China trade deal
12:39PM ( 5 hours ago )
France to retaliate if US doubles Champagne, cheese prices
France is bristling at a U.S. threat to slap steep tariffs on French cheeses, Champagne and other products
11:55AM ( 6 hours ago )
The Latest: Trump not worried about US stock market dive
President Donald Trump says he's not worried that the U.S. stock market took a dive over his remarks that a trade deal with China might not materialize until after the 2020 election
11:28AM ( 6 hours ago )
AP Business - Economy
Iran says it killed ‘rioters’ in deadliest unrest in decades
Iran acknowledges it shot and killed ‘rioters’ in deadliest unrest to strike country since 1979 Islamic Revolution
11:52AM ( 6 hours ago )
Iran state TV says ‘rioters’ shot and killed amid protests
Iranian state TV acknowledges security forces shot and killed ‘rioters’ amid recent gas price protests
6:42AM ( 11 hours ago )
Amnesty says at least 208 killed in Iran protests, crackdown
Amnesty International says at least 208 people were killed in Iran during protests over gasoline price increases and a security crackdown that followed
9:17PM ( 20 hours ago )
AP Business - Industries
The Latest: Poland to focus on clean energy
The head of Poland’s new Climate Ministry has said his goal is to redouble efforts to cut carbon gas emissions and faster develop clean energy sources
12:13PM ( 1 day ago )
The Latest: UN chief disappointed by climate action so far
The head of the United Nations says he’s “disappointed” with efforts to cut greenhouse gas emissions and the world’s most polluting countries should accept that they, too, need to become carbon neutral by 2050
9:19AM ( 1 day ago )
China, Russia launch massive joint gas pipeline
China and Russia have launched a gas pipeline that is more than 6,000 kilometers (3,750 miles) long, an outcome of their long-planned energy partnership
7:00AM ( 1 day ago )
AP Business - Utilities
In first, Turner Prize for art goes to all 4 finalists
The prestigious Turner Prize for art has been awarded to all four finalists after they wrote to the jury and asked to be treated as a collective.
5:54PM ( 5 minutes ago )
Yankees to meet with Gerrit Cole, Stephen Strasburg next
Top free agent pitcher Gerrit Cole was set to meet with New York Yankees officials in California
5:40PM ( 20 minutes ago )
Devils fire coach Hynes after dismal start to season
The New Jersey Devils have fired coach John Hynes two months into the season
5:36PM ( 24 minutes ago )
US stocks fall for 3rd straight day over more trade worries
Stocks closed broadly lower and bond prices rose sharply on Wall Street after President Donald Trump cast doubt over the potential for a trade deal with China this year
5:31PM ( 29 minutes ago )
Mississippi felons push court to restore voting rights
A key advocate for restoring voting rights to felons in Mississippi says he’s fighting to restore his rights as a “human being.”
5:11PM ( 49 minutes ago )