Friday February 28th, 2020 2:21PM

NCAA rejects Missouri appeal, postseason ban looms

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

KANSAS CITY, Mo. (AP) — The NCAA rejected an appeal by the University of Missouri to limit or overturn sanctions for infractions tied to the case of a former tutor Tuesday, angering school officials and leaving in place postseason bans in three high-profile sports along with other restrictions.

The school had filed a 64-page brief to the NCAA’s appeals committee in March, arguing that the penalties handed down Jan. 31 were contrary to precedent, not supported or appropriate given the nature of the allegations and could have a chilling effect on future NCAA enforcement.

The five-member NCAA infractions appeals committee rejected those assertions, and said in its decision Tuesday that it was “hesitant to overturn a penalty within the appropriate penalty guidelines unless there is a clear indication of arbitrary decision-making.”

“Last night when we received the decision, obviously very disappointed and then shock set in. Now I’m just angry,” athletic director Jim Sterk said at the Sprint Center, where the Missouri men’s basketball team was playing in the consolation game of the Hall of Fame Classic. “I’m angry because of our student-athletes and coaches who were wrongly affected by this decision.”

The Tigers’ basketball programs were not involved in the case.

“The NCAA has proven once again,” Sterk said, “that they cannot affectively serve its members and student-athletes they’re supposed to protect. The decision today is just wrong.”

The case in question dates to 2016, when tutor Yolanda Kumar acknowledged she had violated NCAA rules by doing course work and ensuring athletes in football, baseball and softball passed certain courses. The school immediately launched an investigation and self-imposed many penalties, hoping its proactive approach would curry favor when the NCAA rendered its punishment.

The Tigers were instead hit with postseason bans and scholarship and recruiting restrictions in each sport while the entire athletic department was placed on probation.

“Today’s decision was disappointing and appalling, to have this type of conclusion to the process,” Missouri chancellor Alexander Cartwright said. “This decision has made that difficult for us to determine what should be done when there is a compliance case.”

School officials even disseminated a spreadsheet comparing sanctions handed down to Mississippi State in August following a similar case. The Bulldogs’ football program was hit with far less severe scholarship and recruiting restrictions and no postseason ban.

“No one can look at the Missouri case and the Mississippi state cases, which have almost identical violations, and see that common sense was used,” Sterk said. “There was no logic in today’s decision.”

The Tigers would have qualified for a bowl game by beating Arkansas on Friday, and the school estimated that its share of lost conference bowl revenue would be about $10 million.

“I hate the news for our program and for our seniors who have represented the university in a very positive way,” football coach Barry Odom said. “This decision negatively impacts their short experience in life as college student-athletes who had nothing to do with this situation. It’s a tough lesson to be dealt, but they will learn from this and motivationally use it later in life.”

Missouri said about 180 student-athletes across the three sports were ultimately punished by the postseason ban, even though they had nothing to do with the case. Many were still in high school when Kumar did course work for 12 players in the football, baseball and softball programs.

“I am absolutely heartbroken and disappointed by the committee's decision,” softball coach Larissa Anderson said. “The NCAA claims to value the student-athlete experience, but this decision continues to cause unnecessary harm to a group of innocent student-athletes.”

The penalties could have long-term ramifications for Missouri, too.

The school has struggled for both success and relevance in its highest-profile sports since it left the Big 12 for the Southeastern Conference, and now the Tigers now must deal with recruiting and scholarship reductions that put them at an additional competitive disadvantage.

“I think there’s a lot of talk and a lot disgruntled people. Where we go from here, I don’t know,” Sterk said. “There needs to be reform in the NCAA system to gain back some credibility. The credibility every day, every week, keeps eroding on this case.”

U.S. Sen. Roy Blunt, a longtime Tigers fan who blasted the initial penalties, issued a statement Tuesday in which he said “the NCAA made the absolute wrong decision here.”

“The facts in this case clearly do not support these unfair, unwarranted sanctions,” Blunt said. “The University of Missouri did the right thing by self-reporting the actions of the tutor and a small number of players. The NCAA is punishing current players for actions that occurred years ago.”

SEC Commissioner Greg Sankey, who was kept apprised of the case during the initial investigation and when Missouri filed its appeal, said there must be a balance between accountability and reprimand.

“It is regrettable that so many innocent current Missouri student-athletes across three sports will miss postseason opportunities due to actions for which they were not responsible,” he said. “While it is important to hold accountable those individuals who engage in unethical behavior and conduct that fails to meet our expectations for integrity in college athletics, it is also important to fully consider the nuances and unique set of circumstances present in each case.”


Associated Press writer Avery Osen contributed to this report.


More AP college football: and

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Sports, AP Online Football, AP Online Basketball, College Sports, AP Sports - College Football, AP Sports - Men's College Basketball
© Copyright 2020
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Labour’s Corbyn struggles to contain anti-Semitism charge
Labour Party leader Jeremy Corbyn Tuesday tried to defuse harsh criticism about anti-Semitism leveled in a newspaper column by Britain’s chief rabbi
3:51PM ( 18 minutes ago )
Snow causes travel mayhem across US just before Thanksgiving
A storm that has dumped heavy snow in Colorado and Wyoming has forced airlines to cancel hundreds of flights in Denver and has made driving impossible in some areas during the busy Thanksgiving week travel period
3:50PM ( 20 minutes ago )
NCAA rejects Missouri appeal, postseason ban looms
NCAA rejects appeal by the University of Missouri to limit or overturn sanctions for infractions tied to the case of a former tutor
3:43PM ( 26 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
NCAA rejects Missouri appeal, postseason ban remains
NCAA rejects Missouri appeal, postseason ban remains
2:47PM ( 1 hour ago )
Doping report obtained by AP shows depths of Russia cover-up
WADA doping report obtained by AP shows depths of Russian cover-up
2:32PM ( 1 hour ago )
Whan wants companies to ‘walk the talk’ in sponsorship
Golf notes: Whan says companies that believe in equality for women should show it with their sports sponsorship dollars
1:44PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Sports
Vita Vea disappears and so does Dwayne Haskins
Week 12 in the NFL produced many memorable moments, none more intriguing than 347-pound defensive tackle Vita Vega catching his first touchdown pass
4:17AM ( 11 hours ago )
Bob Davie to step aside as coach at New Mexico
Bob Davie has agreed to step aside as New Mexico’s coach at the end of the season, ending an uneven eight-season tenure with the Lobos
12:58AM ( 15 hours ago )
Lamar Jackson throws 5 TD passes, Ravens rout Rams 45-6
Lamar Jackson threw five touchdown passes and the Baltimore Ravens routed the Los Angeles Rams 45-6 for their seventh consecutive victory
12:35AM ( 15 hours ago )
AP Online Football
Antetokounmpo scores 50, Bucks beat Jazz 122-118
Giannis Antetokounmpo scored a season-high 50 points and grabbed 14 rebounds for his 17th consecutive double-double to help the Milwaukee Bucks rally in the second half for their eighth consecutive victory, 122-118 over the Utah Jazz
11:56PM ( 16 hours ago )
Celtics hold off Kings 103-102 despite Hield's 41 points
Jaylen Brown scored 24 points, Jayson Tatum had 20 and the Boston Celtics held off the Sacramento Kings 103-102 despite a career-high 41 points from Buddy Hield
11:25PM ( 16 hours ago )
Jones hits 3 in final second of OT, Arkansas beats Jackets
Mason Jones banked in a 3-pointer from the right wing with one-tenth of a second left in overtime, helping Arkansas stay unbeaten with a 62-61 victory over Georgia Tech
10:48PM ( 17 hours ago )
AP Online Basketball
Duke solidifies No. 1 in AP Top 25; Maryland rises to No. 5
Duke solidifies grip on No. 1 while top four teams remain same after quiet week on schedule in AP Top 25 men’s college basketball poll; Maryland leapfrogs North Carolina to No. 5
1:53PM ( 1 day ago )
Duke solidifies No. 1 in AP Top 25 poll after tourney win
Duke solidified its grip on No. 1 while the top four teams remained the same after a relatively quiet week on the schedule in the AP Top 25 men’s college basketball poll
12:48PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Top 25: No. 2 Ohio State gains on LSU; Oregon drops to 14
Utah up to No. 6, Oklahoma at No. 7 in AP Top 25 after Oregon loss; LSU, Ohio State and Clemson stay top 3; Michigan, Minnesota into top 10
10:58PM ( 1 day ago )
College Sports
No. 13 Baylor in Big 12 title game with 24-10 win over Texas
No. 13 Baylor going to Big 12 title game for rematch with Oklahoma after 24-10 win over Texas
11:31PM ( 2 days ago )
Harvard-Yale game delayed by student protest; 20-30 arrested
136th edition of The Game between Harvard and Yale delayed at halftime when protesters took over the field; about 20-30 arrested, organizer says
8:57PM ( 2 days ago )
Patterson leads No. 12 Michigan past Indiana 39-14
Shea Patterson threw five touchdown passes and Nico Collins scored a career-high three times to lead No. 12 Michigan to a 39-14 blowout at Indiana
8:47PM ( 2 days ago )
AP Sports - College Football
Achiuwa scores 25, No. 16 Memphis holds off Ole Miss 87-86
Precious Achiuwa scored 25 points and grabbed 11 rebounds as 16th-ranked Memphis held off Mississippi 87-86 for its third consecutive victory without heralded freshman center James Wiseman.
5:06PM ( 2 days ago )
Krzyzewski gets milestone, Duke tops tough Georgetown in NYC
Mike Krzyzewski set the record for wins coaching a No. 1 team as top-ranked Duke got 20 points and 10 rebounds from Vernon Carey Jr. to beat Georgetown 81-73 at Madison Square Garden
10:44PM ( 3 days ago )
Ewing wins big again at MSG, Hoyas knock off No. 22 Texas
Mac McClung scored 19 points to help give coach Patrick Ewing another signature moment at Madison Square Garden, leading Georgetown to an 82-66 victory over No. 22 Texas
9:18PM ( 4 days ago )
AP Sports - Men's College Basketball
Labour’s Corbyn struggles to contain anti-Semitism charge
Labour Party leader Jeremy Corbyn Tuesday tried to defuse harsh criticism about anti-Semitism leveled in a newspaper column by Britain’s chief rabbi
3:51PM ( 20 minutes ago )
Trump campaign, GOP groups criticize Google’s new ad policy
President Donald Trump’s reelection campaign and the Republican National Committee are harshly criticizing tech giant Google for making it harder for political advertisers to target specific types of people
3:38PM ( 33 minutes ago )
House Judiciary Committee sets Dec. 4 impeachment hearing
The House Judiciary Committee is set to take over the impeachment probe of President Donald Trump next week, scheduling a Dec. 4 hearing.
3:33PM ( 38 minutes ago )
US stock indexes eye new highs amid optimism over trade
Technology companies and retailers are leading stocks modestly higher on Wall Street, adding to the market’s solid start to the week
3:15PM ( 56 minutes ago )
Ravens, Patriots, 49ers remain top 3 teams in AP Pro32 poll
Ravens, Patriots, 49ers remain top 3 teams in AP Pro32 poll; Seahawks, Saints round out top 5
3:14PM ( 57 minutes ago )