Monday May 25th, 2020 2:14PM

Warren’s ‘Medicare for All’ plan reignites health care clash

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — Elizabeth Warren’s proposal to gradually move the country to a government-funded health care system has further inflamed the debate over “Medicare for All,” likely ensuring the issue will play a significant role in this week’s Democratic presidential debate.

The Massachusetts senator announced Friday that her administration would immediately build on existing laws, including the Affordable Care Act, to expand access to health care while taking up to three years to fully implement Medicare for All. That attempt to thread the political needle has roiled her more moderate rivals, who say she’s waffling, while worrying some on the left, who see Warren’s commitment to a single-payer system wavering.

The divide could complicate plans by Democrats to turn health care into a winning issue in 2020. The party successfully took back control of the House last year by championing programs that ensure that people with preexisting medical conditions keep their insurance coverage while arguing that Republicans want to weaken such provisions. But the Medicare for All debate is more delicate as advocates including Warren grapple with concerns that a new government-run system won’t provide the same quality of coverage as private insurance — and would be prohibitively expensive.

“The Medicare for All proposal has turned out to be a real deal-breaker in who gets the Democratic nomination,” said Robert Blendon, a Harvard University School of Public Health professor whose teaching responsibilities include courses on political strategy in health policy and public opinion polling. “This is not just another issue.”

Warren’s transition plan indicates she’d use her first 100 days as president to expand existing public health insurance options. That is closer to what has been supported by former Vice President Joe Biden and Mayor Pete Buttigieg of South Bend, Indiana. Both Democratic presidential candidates have criticized Medicare for All for wiping out private insurance — something they say many Americans aren’t ready for.

Warren insists she’s simply working to expand health insurance in the short term to people who don’t have it while remaining committed to the full plan in the long run.

“My commitment to Medicare for All is all the way,” Warren said while campaigning in Iowa over the weekend.

Still, the transition signified a step toward pragmatism and an acknowledgement that the government has ways to expand health insurance coverage before embracing a universal system — something that would be difficult for any president to get through Congress. Consider that current entitlements, such as Social Security and Medicare, were phased in over years, not all at once.

“If she’s looked at it and decides the sensible thing to do in order to not cause too much disruption in employment situations and within the medical system is to gear up over three years, she's probably right,” said Cindy Wolf, a customer service and shipping manager who attended the California state Democratic Convention on Saturday in Long Beach.

Still, the move may prove politically problematic for a candidate who has long decried others settling for consultant-driven campaigns seeking incremental changes at the expense of big ideas.

Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders is the original architect of Medicare for All and has made fighting for it the centerpiece of his 2020 White House bid. He tweeted following the release of Warren’s transition plan: “In my first week as president, we will introduce Medicare for All legislation.”

Campaigning in Nevada on Monday, California Sen. Kamala Harris said, “I believe that government should not be in a position of taking away people's choice.”

“Especially on one of the most intimate and personal decisions people can make,” Harris said, “which is about how to address their health care needs.”

The criticism from others was far sharper. Top Biden adviser Kate Bedingfield dismissed Warren’s plan as “trying to muddy the waters” by offering “a full program of flips and twists.” Buttigieg spokeswoman Lis Smith said it was a “transparently political attempt to paper over a very serious policy problem.”

It’s easy to see the issue spilling into Wednesday’s debate because Warren rode a steady summer climb in the polls to become one of the primary field’s front-runners — but no longer seems to be rising. Polls recently show her support stabilizing, though not dipping, as focus on her Medicare for All ideas intensifies.

The last two debates featured Warren failing to answer direct questions on whether she would be forced to raise middle class taxes to pay for the universal health care system she envisions. That set up a plan released two-plus weeks ago in which Warren vowed to generate $20-plus trillion in new government revenue without increasing taxes on the middle class — but that’s been decried by critics who accuse Warren of underestimating how much Medicare for All would really cost.

And, though Warren never promised to begin working toward Medicare for All on Day 1 of her administration, the release of the transition plan, which spelled out that the process will take years, has unsettled some.

Una Lee Jost, a lawyer who was holding “Bernie” signs in Chinese and English at the California Democratic Convention, called any lengthy transition to Medicare for All “a serious concern.”

“We should have implemented this decades ago,” she said.


Associated Press writers Kathleen Ronayne and Michael R. Blood in Long Beach, Calif., and Michelle Price in North Las Vegas, Nev., contributed to this report.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Health, AP Elections, General Election News, General Presidential Election News, AP Business, AP Elections - Campaigns, AP Business - Industries, AP Business - Health Care
© Copyright 2020
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Long-running coal plant on Navajo Nation stops production
A massive coal-fired power plant that served customers in the U.S. West for nearly 50 years has shut down
4:20PM ( 18 minutes ago )
Trump backing off banning vaping flavors popular with teens
President Donald Trump is backing away from a ban on most flavored e-cigarettes popular with teens
4:17PM ( 21 minutes ago )
Warren’s ‘Medicare for All’ plan reignites health care clash
Elizabeth Warren wants to move the country to a government-funded health care system in stages over three years rather than immediately push for a full “Medicare for All”
4:13PM ( 25 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
US softening position on Israeli settlements in West Bank
Secretary of State Mike Pompeo says the U.S. is softening its position on Israeli settlements in the West Bank, the latest in a series of Trump administration moves that weaken Palestinian claims to statehood
3:46PM ( 52 minutes ago )
Georgian police move to disperse large protest in Tbilisi
Police in riot gear in the country of Georgia are trying to push thousands of demonstrators away from the parliament building in the capital on the second day of sizeable protests over the failure of promised election reforms
3:45PM ( 53 minutes ago )
Crucial impeachment hearings break into open for all to see
Impeachment hearings enter a crucial second week as Democrats prepare to hear from eight witnesses
3:44PM ( 54 minutes ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Buttigieg touts military service, wary of overstating role
Pete Buttigieg is leaning hard on his 7-month deployment as an intelligence officer in Afghanistan as a powerful credential, but the Democratic presidential candidate is walking a narrow path between giving his service its due and overstating it
1:47PM ( 2 hours ago )
UK leader Johnson faces questions about ties to US woman
British Prime Minister Boris Johnson is facing new questions about his relationship with an American businesswoman who allegedly received favors and public funds while Johnson was the mayor of London
12:21PM ( 4 hours ago )
Bloomberg wins key SC endorsement ahead of possible 2020 bid
If he opts to enter the Democratic presidential primary, New York billionaire Michael Bloomberg will get one of South Carolina’s most-coveted endorsements
11:14AM ( 5 hours ago )
AP Elections
2020 Watch: Big tests loom for late entries and top tier
2020 Watch: Big tests loom for late entries into presidential race and shuffling top tier
5:13AM ( 11 hours ago )
Drug cost legislation gets a push from White House
Battling impeachment, White House presses for drug cost legislation with new urgency
3:22AM ( 13 hours ago )
Leaked Russian interference report raises UK vote questions
A senior Labour party official says leaks from a report on Russian interference in Britain raise serious questions about the security of next month’s general election
2:45PM ( 1 day ago )
General Election News
Gotabaya Rajapaksa sworn in as Sri Lanka’s new president
Former defense secretary Gotabaya Rajapaksa has been sworn in as Sri Lanka’s president and appealed to minority Tamils and Muslims who voted against him to give their support
5:53AM ( 10 hours ago )
Bloomberg apologizes for ‘stop-and-frisk’ police practice
Former New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg is reversing his longstanding support of the controversial “stop-and-frisk” police strategy ahead of a potential Democratic presidential run
12:50AM ( 15 hours ago )
Bloomberg apologizes for ‘stop and frisk’ police practice
Former New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg is reversing his longstanding support of the controversial “stop and frisk” police strategy ahead of a potential Democratic presidential run
10:20PM ( 18 hours ago )
General Presidential Election News
New, old drugs may offer fresh ways to fight heart disease
Doctors are reporting that novel drugs may offer fresh ways to reduce heart risks beyond the usual medicines to lower cholesterol and blood pressure
3:26PM ( 1 hour ago )
California sues e-cigarette maker Juul over ads, youth sales
California is suing e-cigarette maker Juul, alleging its past marketing appealed to teens
3:18PM ( 1 hour ago )
US again extends limited reprieve on tech sales to Huawei
The Trump administration has extended for 90 more days a limited reprieve on U.S. technology sales to the Chinese technology giant Huawei
2:46PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
Lionel Messi in Israel despite rockets and boycott threats
Soccer superstar Lionel Messi has finally arrived in sports-crazed Israel after a Palestinian protest campaign derailed his previous visit and the latest round of cross-border fighting in Gaza threatened to scare him off once again
3:07PM ( 1 day ago )
Biden holding Democratic campaign town hall at Vegas school
Former Vice President Joe Biden brought an alarmist warning to a diverse crowd of Democrats in early-caucus Nevada during a town hall, saying the country is at risk as long as Donald Trump is president.
12:03AM ( 1 day ago )
Biden, Warren absence at California gathering irks top Dems
The decisions by Joe Biden and Elizabeth Warren to skip a weekend gathering of California Democrats have frustrated and puzzled some party leaders
8:39AM ( 2 days ago )
AP Elections - Campaigns
Iran downplays, demonizes protests amid internet shutdown
Iranian officials are alternatively downplaying and demonizing continuing protests across the country over a 50% increase in gasoline prices
2:11PM ( 2 hours ago )
Anti-government protests cripple major Iraqi port, oil field
Iraqi officials: Anti-government protests block road to main port in country’s south, Iraq’s central bank in Baghdad
1:55PM ( 2 hours ago )
Yogurt sales sour as US breakfast culture changes
Yogurt aisle grows but sales sour as US breakfast culture changes
10:49AM ( 5 hours ago )
AP Business - Industries
White House seeks disclosure of actual health care prices
New rules from the Trump administration would require insurers and hospitals to disclose upfront the actual prices for common tests and procedures
4:12PM ( 3 days ago )
US panel backs wider use of fish oil to prevent heart attack
US health experts recommend wider use of prescription-strength fish oil to help prevent heart problems
6:17PM ( 3 days ago )
Google's health care ambitions now involve patient data
Google is working with large health care system Ascension, the latest foray into the health industry by the tech giant
5:21PM ( 5 days ago )
AP Business - Health Care
Long-running coal plant on Navajo Nation stops production
A massive coal-fired power plant that served customers in the U.S. West for nearly 50 years has shut down
4:20PM ( 19 minutes ago )
Trump backing off banning vaping flavors popular with teens
President Donald Trump is backing away from a ban on most flavored e-cigarettes popular with teens
4:17PM ( 22 minutes ago )
Buttigieg visits Morehouse in effort to build black support
Pete Buttigieg will speak at historically black Morehouse College in Atlanta on Monday as he tries to expand his appeal among black voters.
4:13PM ( 26 minutes ago )
Browns take first steps without suspended star Myles Garrett
Browns return to practice in aftermath of star Myles Garrett’s indefinite suspension for helmet-swinging incident against Steelers
4:03PM ( 35 minutes ago )
US asks federal judge to toss out Nevada plutonium lawsuit
The federal government wants a judge to reject Nevada’s request for a court order to remove weapons-grade plutonium from a site north of Las Vegas
4:00PM ( 38 minutes ago )