mcloudy.png
Saturday December 14th, 2019 1:54PM

Judge rejects Trump moral-objection rule for health care

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

NEW YORK (AP) — A federal judge on Wednesday struck down a new rule, not yet in effect, that allowed health care providers to refuse participation in abortions and other services on moral or religious grounds.

U.S. District Judge Paul A. Engelmayer in New York said he was tossing out the rule in its entirety.

The decision came after 19 states, the District of Columbia, three local governments, health organizations and others sued the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.

The rule let clinicians object to providing abortions and other services that conflict with their moral and religious beliefs.

Engelmayer said his ruling came in three consolidated lawsuits.

Health and Human Services and the Justice Department are reviewing the ruling but "will not comment on the pending litigation at this time," said Caitlin Oakley, a Health and Human Services spokeswoman.

Plaintiffs had argued that the rule was unconstitutional because it would be discriminatory and stall access to health care for populations nationwide.

"The court heard clear and compelling arguments about the harm communities face when our health care system is distorted to the point in which a patient's health care needs are not paramount," said Clare Coleman, president of the National Family Planning & Reproductive Health Association, one of the plaintiffs.

New York Attorney General Letitia James said the state sued in part because the rule "was an unlawful attempt to allow health care providers to openly discriminate and refuse to provide necessary health care to patients based on providers' 'religious beliefs or moral objections.'"

The rule emerged after President Donald Trump in May 2017 signed an executive order instructing the attorney general to issue guidance interpreting religious liberty protections in federal law.

In May, the Department of Health and Human Services published a rule applying more than 30 "Conscience Provisions" that must be complied with for an entity to receive federal funding.

Lawsuits challenging the rule argued that the department exceeded its authority in establishing the rule, violated the Constitution and acted in an arbitrary and capricious manner in creating it.

Engelmayer, who was appointed by Democratic President Barack Obama, wrote that existing laws already define the duties of employers with respect to religious objections.

The 2019 rule, which had been set to take effect late this month, would effectively supersede existing law in the health care field, he said.

The judge rejected arguments that the rule was "mere housekeeping." Rather, he said, it relocates "the who, what, when, where, and how — of conscience protection under federal law."

The Department of Health and Human Services lacked authority to create major portions of its rule, including to terminate an entity's federal health funding if it violates one of the provisions.

At the time the rule was issued, Engelmayer noted, the president said it conferred "new protections."

The rule, for the first time, put limits on an employer's ability to inquire about conscience objections, the judge said.

"These limits have clear potential to inhibit the employer's ability to organize workplace arrangements to avoid inefficiencies and dislocations," he said.

___

Associated Press writers Ricardo Alonso-Zaldivar in Washington and Jennifer Peltz in New York contributed to this report.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Health, AP Business, AP Health - Women's health, AP Business - Industries, AP Business - Health Care
© Copyright 2019 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Judge rejects Trump moral-objection rule for health care
A federal court judge in New York has struck down a rule letting health care clinicians object to providing abortions and other services on moral or religious grounds
1:21PM ( 2 minutes ago )
Family: France's Catherine Deneuve hospitalized with stroke
Her family says French cinematic icon Catherine Deneuve has had a mild stroke while filming her latest movie
1:14PM ( 9 minutes ago )
Trump attacks whistleblower anonymity, but won't utter name
President Donald Trump paints the anonymity of the whistleblower whose complaint triggered the House Democrats' impeachment inquiry as something sinister
1:11PM ( 13 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Democrats promise swift action after win in Virginia
Gov. Ralph Northam laid out his vision Wednesday for a changing Virginia a day after Democrats seized control of the General Assembly for the first time in more than two decades
12:50PM ( 33 minutes ago )
Judge rejects moral-objection rule for abortion providers
A federal court judge in New York has struck down a rule letting health care clinicians object to providing abortions and other services on moral or religious grounds
12:42PM ( 41 minutes ago )
Kansas City votes to remove King's name from historic street
Kansas City voters have overwhelmingly approved removing the name of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. from a historic boulevard
12:42PM ( 42 minutes ago )
AP National News
A princess, dates and milk welcome Ivanka Trump to Morocco
White House adviser Ivanka Trump arrives in Morocco to promote women's economic empowerment, is welcomed by Princess Lalla Meryem
10:11AM ( 3 hours ago )
Dems flip Virginia; Kentucky governor race too close to call
Democrats take full control of Virginia legislature for 1st time in more than 2 decades while race for governor in deeply Republican Kentucky too close to call despite last-minute boost from Trump
8:43AM ( 4 hours ago )
Liberal Tucson, Arizona rejects plan to be sanctuary city
Voters in Tucson have rejected an initiative making it Arizona's only sanctuary city
3:46AM ( 9 hours ago )
Top U.S. News short headlines
Biden accuses Warren of having elitist view of policy
Democratic presidential candidate Joe Biden is ramping up his feud with rival Elizabeth Warren in a new post that attacks her as having an "angry unyielding viewpoint" on health care
8:12PM ( 17 hours ago )
US health officials link childhood trauma to adult illness
US officials say physical and psychological harms in children are linked to millions of illnesses in adults
8:12PM ( 17 hours ago )
Biden accuses Warren of having elitist view of health care
Democratic presidential candidate Joe Biden is ramping up his feud with rival Elizabeth Warren in a new post that attacks her as having an "angry unyielding viewpoint" on health care
7:35PM ( 17 hours ago )
AP Health
Japan's Softbank posts big losses after WeWork debacle
Japanese technology company SoftBank Group Corp. reports $6.4 billion 2Q loss as investments in WeWork, others drag on earnings
12:50PM ( 33 minutes ago )
US productivity falls for first time in nearly 4 years
US productivity falls in 3rd quarter for first time in nearly 4 years
12:49PM ( 35 minutes ago )
Former UAW executive charged in widening corruption probe
A retired vice president is the latest to be charged in a corruption scandal at the United Auto Workers union
12:04PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
WeWork's ex-CEO faces pregnancy discrimination complaint
A former top aide to ousted WeWork co-founder Adam Neumann is accusing him and other WeWork executives of discriminating against her when she became pregnant
6:55PM ( 5 days ago )
Doctor at Missouri abortion clinic defends patient care
The top doctor at Missouri's sole abortion clinic has defended its handling of four patients who faced complications _ women whose care has been cited by the state as it seeks to revoke the clinic's license
8:39PM ( 6 days ago )
Missouri agency tracked Planned Parenthood patients' periods
Missouri's health department director says he tracked menstrual periods of Planned Parenthood patients to identify what the agency says were "failed abortions" at a St. Louis clinic
7:12PM ( 1 week ago )
AP Health - Women's health
Brazil oil tender brings $17 billion to sluggish economy
The Brazilian government has secured about $17 billion dollars in an oil field auction, disappointing officials who had hoped to attract more investment
10:44AM ( 2 hours ago )
US child survivors of Mexico ambush saved by courage, mother
Children who survived Mexico ambush went through horrifying ordeal, but showed stoic bravery
9:03AM ( 4 hours ago )
CVS gets a booster shot from Aetna, revenue soars
CVS Health, a company transformed by acquisition of the health insurer Aetna, reports soaring revenue and profit in third quarter
8:01AM ( 5 hours ago )
AP Business - Industries
Trump picks cancer specialist from Texas hospital to run FDA
President Donald Trump is nominating a cancer specialist to lead the Food and Drug Administration
5:17PM ( 4 days ago )
Trump taps cancer specialist from Texas hospital to run FDA
President Donald Trump is nominating a cancer specialist to lead the Food and Drug Administration
2:42PM ( 4 days ago )
US stocks cap wobbly day of trading with modest losses
Technology companies led stocks lower on Wall Street Tuesday as a wobbly day of trading ended with modest losses for the market
5:53PM ( 1 week ago )
AP Business - Health Care
Family: France's Catherine Deneuve hospitalized with stroke
Her family says French cinematic icon Catherine Deneuve has had a mild stroke while filming her latest movie
1:14PM ( 9 minutes ago )
Trump attacks whistleblower anonymity, but won't utter name
President Donald Trump paints the anonymity of the whistleblower whose complaint triggered the House Democrats' impeachment inquiry as something sinister
1:11PM ( 13 minutes ago )
Congress approves bill expanding animal cruelty law
Congress has passed a bill making certain types of animal cruelty a federal felony
1:07PM ( 16 minutes ago )
US business sees dwindling prospects in Cuba
The Havana International Trade Fair is where Cuba puts the best face on its struggling economy, but one dark spot this year was the American section
1:05PM ( 18 minutes ago )
Sheriff: Murder suspects who fled California jail arrested
Authorities say two murder suspects who escaped from a California jail have been arrested by federal officials
1:05PM ( 18 minutes ago )