clearn.png
Sunday December 15th, 2019 5:53AM

Supreme Court takes up cases about LGBT people's rights

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Supreme Court on Tuesday heard highly anticipated cases on whether federal civil rights law should apply to LGBT people, with Chief Justice John Roberts questioning how doing so would affect employers.

In the first of two cases, the justices heard arguments on whether a federal law banning job discrimination on the basis of sex should also protect sexual orientation. Lower courts have split on the issue. A related case on transgender employees is also being heard Tuesday.

Roberts, a possible swing vote in the cases, wondered about the implications of what he described as an expansion of the job-discrimination law.

"If we're going to be expanding the definition of what 'sex' covers, what do we do about that issue?" Roberts asked.

Justice Samuel Alito, a conservative, suggested that the high court would be usurping the role of Congress by reading protection for sexual orientation into the 1964 Civil Rights Act, when lawmakers at the time likely envisioned they were doing no such thing.

"You're trying to change the meaning of 'sex,'" he said.

Justice Elena Kagan, a liberal, suggested sexual orientation is a clear subset of sex discrimination, saying that a man who loves other men cannot be treated differently by an employer than a woman who loves men.

The cases Tuesday are the court's first on LGBT rights since Justice Anthony Kennedy's retirement and replacement by Justice Brett Kavanaugh. Kennedy was a voice for gay rights and the author of the landmark ruling in 2015 that made same-sex marriage legal throughout the United States. Kavanaugh generally is regarded as more conservative.

A decision is expected by early summer 2020, amid the presidential election campaign.

A ruling for employees who were fired because of their sexual orientation or gender identity would have a big impact for the estimated 8.1 million LGBT workers across the country because most states don't protect them from workplace discrimination. An estimated 11.3 million LGBT people live in the U.S., according to the Williams Institute at the UCLA law school.

The Trump administration has changed course from the Obama administration and now supports the employers in arguing that the civil rights law's Title 7 does not prohibit discrimination because of sexual orientation or transgender status.

People have been waiting in line outside the court since the weekend to try to snag the few seats the court makes available to the public for arguments.

The justices will first hear appeals in lawsuits filed by Gerald Lynn Bostock, who claims he lost his job working for Clayton County, Georgia, after he began playing in a gay recreational softball league. He lost his case in federal district court and at the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Atlanta.

Skydiving instructor Donald Zarda was fired shortly after telling a woman he was preparing to take on a dive that he was gay. Zarda, who worked for Altitude Express on New York's Long Island, said he would sometimes reveal his sexual orientation to allay concerns women might have about being strapped together during a dive.

Zarda initially lost his lawsuit, but the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled for him. Zarda has since died.

The other case involves fired transgender funeral home director Aimee Stephens. She lost her job when she told Thomas Rost, owner of the Detroit-area R.G. and G.R. Harris Funeral Homes, that she had struggled with gender identity issues almost her whole life. She was planning to exchange the dark suit and tie she had worn to work for nearly six years as an embalmer and funeral director for a conservative dress or skirt that was required for women who worked for Rost.

Rost told Stephens her plan wouldn't work and let her go. The federal Equal Employment Opportunity Commission sued on her behalf and, after losing in a district court, won a ruling in the 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Cincinnati.

During the Obama years, the EEOC had changed its longstanding interpretation of civil rights law to include discrimination against LGBT people. The law prohibits discrimination because of sex, but has no specific protection for sexual orientation or gender identity.

The Trump administration and the employers say Congress could easily settle the matter by amending Title 7 to include LGBT people. Legislation to that effect is pending in Congress, but is not likely to pass the Republican-controlled Senate.

But the workers contend, and the lower courts that have ruled for them have reasoned, that the law as it stands plainly covers sexual orientation and gender identity because discrimination against them is based on generalizations about sex that have nothing to do with their ability to do their jobs.

They also argue that they were fired for not conforming to sex stereotypes, a form of sex discrimination that the Supreme Court recognized 30 years ago.

___

Associated Press writer Matthew Barakat contributed to this report.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Business, AP Online - Georgia News, AP Online Headlines - Georgia News
© Copyright 2019 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Turkey says it won't bow to US threat over its Syria plans
Turkey says it won't bow to US threats over Syria plans in apparent response to Trump's warning to Ankara
6:19AM ( 11 minutes ago )
3 win Nobel Prize in Physics for discoveries in cosmology
Three scientists have won the 2019 Nobel Prize in Physics for their work in understanding how the universe has evolved, and the Earth's place in it
6:15AM ( 14 minutes ago )
Trump envoy set to testify hasn't always been a Trump backer
Trump envoy caught up in Ukraine controversy, Gordon Sondland, hasn't always been a Trump backer
6:14AM ( 16 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Chinese state TV suspends 2 NBA preseason game broadcasts
Chinese state broadcaster CCTV has suspended broadcasts of two NBA preseason games set to be played in China
5:44AM ( 46 minutes ago )
Trump defends decision to abandon Kurdish allies in Syria
President Donald Trump's decision to pull U.S. troops off Syria's northern border is leading to criticism - and confusion
5:44AM ( 46 minutes ago )
The Latest: Silver says NBA will not regulate speech
NBA Commissioner Adam Silver says the league "will not put itself in a position of regulating what players, employees and team owners say or will not say on these issues."
5:19AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
EU's Chief Prosecutor Kovesi vows not to bend under pressure
For Romania's Laura Codruta Kovesi, opposition to her successful candidacy to become the European Union's first chief prosecutor came from a familiar source _ her own country's government
2:17AM ( 4 hours ago )
FBI: Inmate is the deadliest serial killer in US history
The Federal Bureau of Investigation says the man who claims to have killed more than 90 women across the country is the deadliest serial killer in U.S. history
1:05AM ( 5 hours ago )
Scherzer, Zimmerman lead Nats past LA 6-1 to force Game 5
Max Scherzer's season-saving, seven-inning pitching performance and Ryan Zimmerman's three-run homer lifted the wild-card Washington Nationals to a 6-1 victory over the league-best Los Angeles Dodgers to force a deciding Game 5 in their NL Division Series
12:42AM ( 5 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
Biden plan: Free community college, expanded loan programs
Democratic presidential candidate Joe Biden proposes higher education policies that would make community and technical college free while making existing federal college loan programs more generous
5:30AM ( 1 hour ago )
EU chief on the back foot as MEP's challenge governing team
The next European Union's top official has yet to take office, and she's already facing challenges from defiant European lawmakers flexing their muscles in the politically-charged process validating her governing team
4:07AM ( 2 hours ago )
Hong Kong leader says economy taking a hit from protests
Hong Kong's embattled leader Carrie Lam says the city's economy is being battered by months of increasingly violent protests
3:05AM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
US Rep. Maloney falters at public event, cites bronchitis
U.S. Rep. Carolyn Maloney of New York City is explaining a medical problem she experienced during a public event by saying she is recovering from bronchitis
5:29PM ( 13 hours ago )
McConnell largely avoids impeachment talk while back home
While impeachment drama swirls in Washington, Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell was back home in Kentucky talking about fighting opioid misuse and confirming conservative judges
5:22PM ( 13 hours ago )
US Rep. Maloney says she's recovering from bronchitis
U.S. Rep. Carolyn Maloney of New York City says she's recovering from bronchitis after she became ill and went to the hospital
5:16PM ( 13 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Protests squeezing Hong Kong economy, tourism, leader says
Hong Kong's embattled leader Carrie Lam says the city's economy is being battered by months of increasingly violent protests
5:28AM ( 1 hour ago )
UK to publish no-deal plans as gloom surrounds Brexit talks
The British government says it still hopes to strike a Brexit deal with the European Union, despite mounting gloom on both sides of the Channel about the chances of success
5:15AM ( 1 hour ago )
European markets down, Asia gains ahead of US-China talks
European markets down, Asia gains ahead of US-China talks
4:54AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
Turkey says it won't bow to US threat over its Syria plans
Turkey says it won't bow to US threats over Syria plans in apparent response to Trump's warning to Ankara
6:19AM ( 11 minutes ago )
3 win Nobel Prize in Physics for discoveries in cosmology
Three scientists have won the 2019 Nobel Prize in Physics for their work in understanding how the universe has evolved, and the Earth's place in it
6:15AM ( 15 minutes ago )
Trump envoy set to testify hasn't always been a Trump backer
Trump envoy caught up in Ukraine controversy, Gordon Sondland, hasn't always been a Trump backer
6:14AM ( 17 minutes ago )
White House to fight impeachment by stalling and attacking
White House undertakes high-stakes strategy to counter the impeachment threat by stalling, attacking and blowing smoke
6:06AM ( 24 minutes ago )
The Latest: Chinese say people have expressed their opinion
Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesman Geng Shuang says ordinary people have already expressed their position after a tweet unraveled the country's relationship with the NBA
6:04AM ( 26 minutes ago )