clearn.png
Tuesday October 22nd, 2019 8:57PM

Schmidt: Computer strike zone good, but check your hearing

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

A hot topic all year has been the idea of computerizing the strike zone, the rise of the robot umpires. It's drawn even more attention here in October — we've already seen a perfect example of a missed call when Marcell Ozuna was rung up in the ninth inning of Game 3 between the Cardinals and Braves.

It was obvious, according to the box on the TV screen, that the pitch was clearly inside. It was a pivotal call that could have altered the outcome.

Should the computer zone be perfected, that would never be the case.

It would change the game for the good, it would continue the effort to eliminate human deficiency. We have replay everywhere else in the game, like it or not, replay gets the call right.

Now we are looking at balls and strikes, where the umpires are ridiculously good. My experience would say home plate umpires miss less than 10 pitch calls a game, out of an average of 225.

When I saw replay become part of professional tennis, I immediately thought it could change baseball. In fact, I mentioned it many times during my travels in the early 2000s, but was never taken seriously. People would say I was crazy to think balls and strikes could be called electronically.

The technology for an electronic field over home plate is available. Technically, all that has to be done is create a communication process between the umpire and the source.

Here's a shot at that. The electronic field sends a beep signal to the ump, whenever a pitch touches any part of the isosceles right pentagon (shape of home plate) extended upward, starting at the batter's knees to the midpoint of the torso (I'd note that the actual strike zone as called by today's umpires lacks about 6 inches on the top side). The beep is heard by the umpire through an earpiece, giving him time for a quick ball strike reaction.

Easy, huh? No beefs with hitters or pitchers, it gets the pitch right 100% of the time.

Who wouldn't want that? Hitters!

My perception, both from a hitter's and now a fan's view, is that a high percentage of time the umpires favor the batter on ball/strike calls. Not intentionally, it just evolved. The zone has shrunk over time. More pitches that are strikes on the electronic box are called balls, making the human element favor the hitter. I've always equated the current strike zone to the size of a basketball.

Another point to understand: A pitch is a strike if it touches any part of the electronic field. Front, back, top. Imagine a sharp curveball breaking late and coming over the front side of the grid, caught outside and low. But that's a strike because it brushed the front of the electronic field.

How would this affect baseball, the strike zone getting bigger, actually the rule book size?

First, the game would be faster because the larger zone would force hitters into the swing mindset. More swings, shorter periods between action, that's good. More swings, fewer pitches per at-bat, bases on balls would decrease and pitch counts would increase at a slower rate. Starters to go deeper into games, 20-game winners would come back.

There are big hurdles to get over, such as approval of the players' union and owners, technical issues, communication logistics and ways it would affect the game known only through testing.

The electronic strike zone is at least five years away in Major League Baseball. But it will be tested in lower affiliated leagues sooner than you might think.

A final thought, and this should not be taken as disrespectful to today's umpires, who, a very high percentage of time, have the pitch call correct. Seldom is there a game where the home plate umpire is consistently wrong on ball strike calls.

But imagine a hitter being called out on a pitch he thought was outside. Then the umpire tells him, "it beeped." Hitters say, "Bull! No way it beeped."

"Have you had your ears tested?"

___

Hall of Fame third baseman Mike Schmidt was a three-time NL MVP. He drew 1,507 walks and struck out 1,883 times. He led the Philadelphia Phillies to their first World Series championship in 1980.

___

More AP MLB: https://apnews.com/MLB and https://twitter.com/AP_Sports

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Sports, AP Online Baseball , AP Sports - Major League Baseball
© Copyright 2019 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Company making Costco pajamas flagged for forced labor
US Customs crackdown on clothes, rubber gloves and charcoal citing labor abuse rattles American companies that buy from foreign factories where labor abuse is alleged.
3:21AM ( 11 minutes ago )
Torres leads Yankees to 5-1 win and sweep of Twins
Torres slugs Yankees to 5-1 win for ALDS sweep, handing Twins 16th straight postseason loss
3:21AM ( 11 minutes ago )
Legos lying around? Toy maker tests way to recycle bricks
Lego, looking to keep its plastic bricks out of the trash, is testing a way for customers to ship their pieces away and get them into the hands of other kids
3:18AM ( 13 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Qatar's World Cup challenge magnified by track worlds issues
Now the world track and field championships are over in Qatar, the focus shifts to the country's staging of the World Cup in 2022
2:16AM ( 1 hour ago )
Not much goes right in Browns' 31-3 loss to 49ers
The Cleveland Browns punted on their first series. It was about the best thing that Freddie Kitchens' team did all night.
1:47AM ( 1 hour ago )
49ers stay perfect, dominate Mayfield, Browns in 31-3 win
Matt Breida ran 83 yards for a touchdown on San Francisco's first play from scrimmage, Baker Mayfield was harassed into his worst game as a pro, and the 49ers stayed unbeaten for their best start in nearly 30 years, beating the Cleveland Browns 31-3.
1:41AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Sports
Braves LHP Keuchel to start Game 4 of NLDS on short rest
Braves LHP Dallas Keuchel to start Game 4 of NL Division Series on short rest
12:02PM ( 15 hours ago )
LEADING OFF: All 4 Division Series matchups could be decided
LEADING OFF: All 4 Division Series matchups could be decided; Astros, Yankees try to sweep
2:39AM ( 1 day ago )
7 2-out runs in 6th lift LA past Nats 10-4 for 2-1 NLDS lead
Justin Turner's homer capped a startling and record-setting seven-run rally in the sixth inning as the Dodgers roughed up starter-turned-reliever Patrick Corbin, and Los Angeles beat Washington 10-4 for a 2-1 lead in their NL Division Series
2:03AM ( 1 day ago )
AP Online Baseball
Carpenter starting for St. Louis in Game 3 of NLDS
Matt Carpenter starts at 3B for Cardinals in Game 3 of NL Division Series against Braves
2:17PM ( 1 day ago )
Cole fans 15, Bregman homers as Astros top Rays 3-1
Gerrit Cole carried his splendid September into an outstanding October, Alex Bregman handed fans chanting MVP the mighty swing they craved and Houston survived a wild ninth inning to beat Tampa Bay 3-1 for a 2-0 lead in their AL Division Series
2:22AM ( 2 days ago )
LEADING OFF: Scherzer to start for Nats after relief outing
LEADING OFF: Scherzer to start for Nats after relief outing; Wainwright faces team that drafted him; AL takes travel day
10:47PM ( 2 days ago )
AP Sports - Major League Baseball
Company making Costco pajamas flagged for forced labor
US Customs crackdown on clothes, rubber gloves and charcoal citing labor abuse rattles American companies that buy from foreign factories where labor abuse is alleged.
3:21AM ( 11 minutes ago )
Torres leads Yankees to 5-1 win and sweep of Twins
Torres slugs Yankees to 5-1 win for ALDS sweep, handing Twins 16th straight postseason loss
3:21AM ( 11 minutes ago )
Legos lying around? Toy maker tests way to recycle bricks
Lego, looking to keep its plastic bricks out of the trash, is testing a way for customers to ship their pieces away and get them into the hands of other kids
3:18AM ( 13 minutes ago )
White House to battle impeachment by stalling, attacking
White House undertaking a high-stakes strategy to counter the impeachment threat by stalling, attacking and blowing smoke
3:14AM ( 18 minutes ago )
Hong Kong leader says economy taking a hit from protests
Hong Kong's embattled leader Carrie Lam says the city's economy is being battered by months of increasingly violent protests
3:05AM ( 27 minutes ago )