Tuesday July 14th, 2020 10:05AM

Trump-Ukraine whistleblower is part of long tradition

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

NEW YORK (AP) — Erin Brockovich, who has some experience in revealing disturbing secrets, knows what she would say to the government whistleblower at the heart of allegations that President Donald Trump pressured Ukraine's president to investigate his political rival Joe Biden.

"I would say, 'You are obviously a person of integrity and you take it seriously when you hear about wrongdoing,'" Brockovich, the environmental and consumer activist, said in a recent telephone interview. "The name 'whistleblower' gets a bad connotation, and I've never understood that."

As Democrats move to begin impeachment hearings and Trump tweets accusations of treason, the headlines turn on a government official's written complaint about the president "using the power of his office to solicit interference from a foreign country in the 2020 U.S. election."

Labeled #FakeWhistleBlower by Trump, the official remains unknown to the public but has already been linked to such whistleblowers of the past as Brockovich, Daniel Ellsberg and Edward Snowden.

Presidents, military leaders and corporate executives have raged against them, but whistleblowers have been around as long as the country itself.

The world's first whistleblower protection legislation is widely considered to have been passed in the U.S., in 1778, and whistleblowers have since helped advance or break scandals ranging from Enron to lies about the Vietnam War. Whistleblowers have inspired movies ("Erin Brockovich," ''Silkwood," ''Serpico") and countless books, most recently Snowden's best-selling memoir, "Permanent Record."

"Whistleblowing is as American as apple pie," says author Allison Stanger, whose "Whistleblowers: Honesty in America from Washington to Trump" came out last week.

Whistleblowers have a long, diverse and complicated history, right down to the definition and spelling of the word. It dates back at least to the 19th century, when a police officer trying to warn citizens about a riot was referred to as a "whistle blower."

In the 20th century, "whistle blowers" became "whistle-blowers" and were at times associated with sports referees or with "snitches" or "rats" who violated a code of silence.

The expression was rebranded in the 1970s by consumer advocate Ralph Nader and moved closer to its current understanding of someone who calls out corporate or government wrongdoing. "Whistleblower" is now one word, generally unhyphenated, and defined by activists as someone who exposes wrongdoing, often from the inside at personal risk.

"It isn't surprising to me that the Trump-Ukraine whistleblower is from the intelligence community," says Danielle Brian, executive director of the watchdog Project on Government Oversight. "Whistleblowers don't plan to become whistleblowers. People think of whistleblowers as some kind of anarchist, but they tend to be more conservative than we realize and to see the world in terms of right and wrong."

Whistleblowing may begin with a moment of conscience, but there is no single path to action, no single kind of crime exposed or agreed-upon canon of whistleblowers. The Trump-Ukraine official worked within established government channels, but others have openly broken laws.

Ellsberg has said he expected to spend the rest of his life in prison after leaking the Pentagon Papers, a Defense Department study of the government's involvement in Vietnam that he helped prepare (Charges against him of violating the Espionage Act were thrown out after it was learned that the Nixon administration had burglarized his psychiatrist's office.)

Snowden, a former intelligence contractor who now lives in Russia, leaked files on massive government surveillance and would almost surely face prosecution if he returned to the U.S.

Whistleblowers have revealed financial fraud at Enron, excessive costs of military weapons systems, and the tampering with tobacco at Brown & Williamson, a scandal from the 1990s that inspired the movie "The Insider."

Louis Clark, who heads the nonprofit Government Accountability Project, cites Robert MacLean, the federal air marshal who in 2003, just two years after the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks, disclosed government plans to cut costs by removing air marshals from all overnight long-distance flights.

"Very soon after he went public, they reversed that decision," Clark says.

Experts on whistleblowing agree on the importance of whistleblowers, but not on who deserves to be called one.

Snowden was criticized not just by government leaders but by the liberal historian Sean Wilentz, who has noted that Snowden didn't just unearth information on domestic surveillance, but on foreign programs such as the tracking of the Taliban.

"Regardless of whether any of these documents in any way compromised U.S. interests abroad, they were plainly not the revelations of 'whistle-blowers' seeking to secure Americans' constitutional rights," Wilentz wrote in The New Republic in 2014. "They are the revelations of leakers, out to damage their bugaboo national security behemoth."

Clark says that Mark Felt, the once-anonymous "Deep Throat" of Watergate, was a whistleblower who made a critical contribution to the scandal that led to Nixon's resignation. Former Nixon White House counselor John W. Dean, whose own whistleblower status has been debated since his devastating testimony during the 1973 Watergate hearings, says Felt was more a disgruntled bureaucrat than advocate for justice.

"He had an agenda," Dean says of Felt, an associate director of the FBI at the time of Watergate. "He wanted to be director of the FBI and thought if he could remove (acting director) L. Patrick Gray, Nixon would pick a (J. Edgar) Hooverite like himself."

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, AP Entertainment, AP Online Movies News, AP Business, AP Business - Consumer News
© Copyright 2020
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
UAW strike could cost GM about $1 billion - and counting
The 16-day strike by auto workers has cost General Motors about $1 billion according to at least one estimate while a parts shortage forced the company to close pickup truck and transmission plants in Mexico
3:38PM ( 8 minutes ago )
Trump-Ukraine whistleblower is part of long tradition
The anonymous government official whose complaint has touched off the impeachment inquiry against President Donald Trump is part of a long tradition of whistleblowers in the U.S.
3:32PM ( 14 minutes ago )
Pipeline rules adopted years after deadly explosion, spills
US transportation officials have finalized long-delayed measures meant to prevent pipeline spills and deadly gas explosions but don't address recommended steps to lessen accidents once they occur
3:31PM ( 15 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Former President Jimmy Carter celebrates 95th birthday
Former President Jimmy Carter is celebrating his 95th birthday, the first U.S. president in history to reach that milestone
3:01PM ( 45 minutes ago )
Thousands march as Catalonia marks secession vote date
Thousands of supporters of the secession of Catalonia from the rest of Spain marched in Barcelona on Tuesday to mark two years since a banned independence referendum that shook Spanish politics
2:58PM ( 47 minutes ago )
Drug stores go to court on US opioid litigation judge
A group of drug retailers and distributors is asking an Ohio federal appeals court to remove the judge overseeing national opioid litigation after the judge himself denied their requests.
2:35PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
Governor denies clemency for Missouri death-row inmate
Missouri Gov. Mike Parson has denied a clemency request hours before the scheduled execution of a convicted killer with a rare medical condition
12:17PM ( 3 hours ago )
Deliberations resume in Dallas ex-cop's murder trial
A jury has resumed deliberations in the murder trial of a former Dallas police officer who fatally shot her neighbor in his apartment
10:16AM ( 5 hours ago )
Las Vegas massacre anniversary sparks debate on gun control
Gun control advocates say they're frustrated that more hasn't been done since 58 people died at a concert on the Las Vegas Strip, and that mass shootings keep happening nationwide
9:27AM ( 6 hours ago )
Top U.S. News short headlines
Mets' Alonso donates customized cleats to 9/11 museum
Mets star Pete Alonso visits 9/11 museum to donate custom first-responder cleats and baseball bat he used in game on 18th anniversary of attacks
1:28PM ( 2 hours ago )
Viard's debut at Chanel ready-to-wear is crashed by comedian
In her first solo ready-to-wear show since Karl Lagerfeld's death, Chanel designer Virginie Viard had a lot to prove but a runway crasher stole the spotlight
12:24PM ( 3 hours ago )
NFL At 100-AP Was There-Music City Miracle
NFL At 100-AP Was There-Music City Miracle
12:22PM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Entertainment
'Clueless' actress Stacey Dash charged with domestic battery
An actress known for appearing in the 1990s comedy "Clueless" is facing a domestic battery charge in Florida
6:00PM ( 21 hours ago )
'Abominable' No.1 with $20.9M; Zellweger's 'Judy' sings out
The DreamWorks animated adventure "Abominable" has topped the box office with an estimated $20.9 million, while the Renee Zellweger-led Judy Garland tale "Judy" got off to a sonorous start
2:27PM ( 2 days ago )
Martin Scorsese's epic 'The Irishman' premieres in New York
Martin Scorsese's crime epic "The Irishman" premieres at the New York Film Festival
9:05PM ( 3 days ago )
AP Online Movies News
A slump in US manufacturing knocks stock market lower
A surprise contraction in US manufacturing last month knocked the stock market lower, erasing an early rally.
2:53PM ( 52 minutes ago )
Global trade to see weakest growth since Great Recession
Global trade is forecast to weaken this year to the slowest pace since the depths of the Great Recession in 2009 due the U.S.-China trade war.
2:32PM ( 1 hour ago )
Electrical short caused Liberia fire that killed 27 children
Liberia's National Fire Service says "electrical shock" caused a fire that killed 27 children at a Quranic boarding school east of Monrovia two weeks ago
2:11PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
The Latest: EU Parliament chief: UK Brexit ideas fall short
The European Parliament's chief Brexit official says the latest proposals from British Prime Minister Boris Johnson seeking a breakthrough in the stalled Brexit negotiations still fall well short of expectations
9:04AM ( 5 days ago )
House votes to end forced arbitration in business disputes
The House has approved a bill to end forced arbitration clauses that prevent workers and consumers from filing lawsuits in disputes with companies over employment practices, billing or civil rights
1:38PM ( 1 week ago )
Senate tech critic to Facebook CEO: Sell WhatsApp, Instagram
The Senate's most vocal critic of the tech industry asks Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg to sell WhatsApp and Instagram.
8:23PM ( 1 week ago )
AP Business - Consumer News
UAW strike could cost GM about $1 billion - and counting
The 16-day strike by auto workers has cost General Motors about $1 billion according to at least one estimate while a parts shortage forced the company to close pickup truck and transmission plants in Mexico
3:38PM ( 8 minutes ago )
Pipeline rules adopted years after deadly explosion, spills
US transportation officials have finalized long-delayed measures meant to prevent pipeline spills and deadly gas explosions but don't address recommended steps to lessen accidents once they occur
3:31PM ( 15 minutes ago )
Condor chick makes 1st flight attempt from Utah cliff
Park officials say the first endangered California condor chick has fledged at Zion National Park in southern Utah
3:25PM ( 21 minutes ago )
Ex-Dallas officer who killed neighbor found guilty of murder
A white former Dallas police officer could be facing decades in prison after being convicted of murder in the fatal shooting of her black, unarmed neighbor who she said she believed was an intruder in her home
3:24PM ( 22 minutes ago )
The Latest: Giuliani retains a lawyer in face of subpoena
Rudy Giuliani, the president's lawyer, has retained a lawyer
3:21PM ( 25 minutes ago )