Wednesday June 3rd, 2020 8:31AM

PG&E must deal with problem that bankruptcy won't end: fires

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

LOS ANGELES (AP) — Big corporations forced into bankruptcy by liability lawsuits often take the offending product off the market and try to move on. That's what happened with the Dalkon Shield birth control device, asbestos and silicone breast implants.

But when the nation's biggest utility, Pacific Gas & Electric, comes out of bankruptcy, it will face the same danger that put it in financial peril in the first place: wildfires.

As the case makes its way through the courts, the industry and the public will be watching closely to see what steps PG&E takes to control its legal exposure to future blazes in an era in which climate change is likely to make such disasters more common.

Will PG&E invest more in preventive maintenance to keep power lines from starting fires, adopting more aggressive tree-trimming and brush-clearing practices? Will it fortify its equipment better? Will it shut off the power in certain areas when the fire risk is high?

"Where other companies have been able to say, 'We're going to deal with hazards we caused in the past through bankruptcy,' PG&E somehow has to find a solution to the fact that California is going to have drought conditions for a very long time," said Jared Ellias, a law professor at the University of California Hastings School of Law in San Francisco. "How do you solve the liability crisis that they face?"

PG&E is the nation's first utility forced into bankruptcy by potentially massive legal bills from wildfires. It filed for Chapter 11 reorganization this week to deal with potentially tens of billions of dollars in claims over several of California's devastating blazes in 2017 and 2018.

The company faced 750 lawsuits from fire victims and expected hundreds more, Stephen Karotkin, an attorney for PG&E, said at a court hearing Thursday.

One was the nation's deadliest, most destructive wildfire in a century: the blaze in November that leveled the Northern California town of Paradise, killed at least 86 people and destroyed nearly 15,000 homes. The cause is still under investigation, though PG&E had reported problems with equipment near where the fire started.

PG&E was found responsible for 17 other fires that tore through Northern California since 2017.

The bankruptcy could lead to smaller payouts for fire victims, whose claims will most likely be heard by a judge, a step that could reduce the risk of excessive jury verdicts.

Attorneys for wildfire victims urged a bankruptcy judge at Thursday's hearing to prioritize their claims and move fast. Some victims are facing the prospect of homelessness if they don't receive a settlement soon, attorney Frank Pitre said.

PG&E wants to establish a trust fund for all the lawsuits that would expedite payments to victims, Karotkin said. The bankruptcy was not a "strategic ploy to avoid PG&E's responsibility for the devastating damage and loss of life" from wildfires, he said.

The judge approved $1.5 billion in financing that the utility said it needed to keep operating.

The bankruptcy also could lead to higher bills for customers of PG&E, which supplies natural gas and electricity to 16 million people in Northern and central California.

The case could be an early glimpse of the financial pressures utilities could face as a result of climate change.

In the past, utilities have sought protection in bankruptcy court because of such things as nuclear reactors that didn't pay off or costly fluctuations in the electricity market.

"This time around, you have a whole different problem," said David Wiggs, who was chairman and CEO at the Texas-based El Paso Electric Co. in 1992 when it became the second utility since the Depression to declare bankruptcy. "Claims of fire damage are not normal. That is a lot of liability that is not your normal utility expense."

Under California law, a public utility is liable if its equipment caused a fire, even if the company wasn't shown to be negligent. Some of the lawsuits, however, have accused PG&E of inadequate maintenance and other failings.

PG&E will have to develop a business plan that shows it is not likely to end up in bankruptcy court again. How it does that is not clear at this point, but it may have to address how to minimize liability from future fires in a warming world.

Some possible solutions have been proposed in a separate criminal case where the company is on probation over a 2010 gas line explosion in the San Francisco Bay Area that killed eight people and destroyed 38 homes.

The federal judge overseeing that case criticized the company's wildfire safety record and proposed earlier this year that it remove or trim all trees that could fall onto its power lines in high winds and shut off the electricity when fire is a risk, regardless of the inconvenience to customers or loss of profit.

PG&E has said that is unrealistic, it could cost $150 billion and that lives could be endangered if it cuts power.

As PG&E spends the next two to three years reorganizing, other utilities are likely to be watching.

"They're on notice," said Robert Rasmussen, a law professor at the University of Southern California. "I think a lot of these fires are caused by extreme conditions that are brought on by climate change. I'm sure they're struggling with what to do."


Associated Press writer Sudhin Thanawala and video journalist Haven Daley in San Francisco contributed to this report.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, AP Business, AP Business - Corporate News, AP Business - Economy, AP Business - Industries, AP Business - Utilities, AP Business - Small Business
© Copyright 2020
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Bill Cosby victim settles defamation suit with ex-prosecutor
The victim in Bill Cosby's criminal sex-assault trial has settled a defamation lawsuit filed against a former prosecutor who said she added details to her story over time
8:21PM ( 6 minutes ago )
PG&E must deal with problem that bankruptcy won't end: fires
Bankruptcy won't let the nation's biggest utility escape the danger that caused it financial peril in the first place
8:16PM ( 11 minutes ago )
Varner hears the roars on No. 16, shares Phoenix Open lead
Harold Varner III dabs his way to the top of the Phoenix Open leaderboard to tie Rickie Fowler and Justin Thomas with a 7-under 64
8:08PM ( 19 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Survivors question brevity of FBI report on Vegas massacre
The brevity of an FBI report on the Las Vegas massacre has prompted disbelief and outrage from survivors and relatives of victims
7:45PM ( 42 minutes ago )
Federal court again blocks San Francisco warning on soda ads
A federal appeals court has blocked a San Francisco law requiring health warnings on advertisements for soda and other sugary drinks in a victory for beverage and retail groups that sued to block the ordinance
7:42PM ( 45 minutes ago )
US doctor who survived Ebola honored for service in Liberia
A Massachusetts doctor who was among a handful of Americans treated and cured of Ebola in 2014 is being recognized for his work in Liberia through the deadly epidemic
7:41PM ( 45 minutes ago )
AP National News
How will bankrupt utility deal with wildfires from now on?
When California's Pacific Gas & Electric comes out of bankruptcy, it will face the same danger that put the company in financial peril in the first place: wildfires
6:05PM ( 2 hours ago )
'Empire' actor's family calls Chicago attack a hate crime
Jussie Smollett's family says the attack on the black and gay "Empire" actor in downtown Chicago this week was a "hate crime" and that he has been honest with the police
6:00PM ( 2 hours ago )
Are school districts going 'soft'? Cold spell stirs debate
The extreme weather that shuttered schools across a swath of the northern United States this week also spurred debates over whether when such calls are appropriate
5:52PM ( 2 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
The Latest: Rams hold practice outside at Falcons' facility
The Latest: The Los Angeles Rams opted to practice outside on the grass fields at the Falcons' training facility in Flowery Branch, Georgia.
7:24PM ( 1 hour ago )
Trump plan would channel prescription discounts to patients
Trump administration plan would channel behind-the-scenes drug discounts directly to patients
7:12PM ( 1 hour ago )
Union, league preparing "war chests" for 2021 labor talks
Two years before the labor agreement with the NFL runs out the players' union is gathering a war chest it hopes it doesn't need. Union leaders, however, expect a work stoppage in 2021, while not exactly inevitable, will be difficult to avoid
6:48PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
S&P 500 index delivers biggest monthly gain since 2015
Wall Street got its mojo back in January after finishing 2018 with its worst December since 1931. Stocks finished higher Thursday, closing out the month with the best monthly gain for the S&P 500 index since 2015
5:01PM ( 3 hours ago )
Poland exported 5,500 pounds of meat from sick cows to EU
Poland's top veterinary official says about 2,500 kilograms (5,500 pounds) of meat from illegally slaughtered sick cows was exported to 10 other European countries
4:04PM ( 4 hours ago )
S&P 500 index heads for its biggest monthly gain since 2015
Major stock indexes are mostly higher in late-afternoon trading, placing the benchmark S&P 500 toward its best monthly gain since 2015
3:41PM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Business - Corporate News
A robust US job market likely defied shutdown during January
A robust US job market is thought to have defied partial government shutdown during January
5:43PM ( 2 hours ago )
The Latest: Pence praises DEA help in convict Maduro allies
U.S. Vice President Mike Pence has congratulated the Drug Enforcement Administration for helping bring drug trafficking convictions against several members of Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro's family and inner circle
5:38PM ( 2 hours ago )
The Latest: US rejects mediation offers on Venezuela crisis
The United States strongly rejects offers from Mexico, Uruguay and the Vatican to mediate a dialogue between embattled Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro and the head of the country's opposition-controlled congress, Juan Guaido
5:18PM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Business - Economy
Natural gas prices slump despite US winter weather blast
While the polar vortex is driving up demand for natural gas, it isn't doing the same for the price
3:34PM ( 4 hours ago )
Dramatic temperature swings heading to Midwest
Historic deep freeze expected to ease, but disruptions and record-breaking lows still hit the Midwest
2:36PM ( 5 hours ago )
APNewsBreak: US oil lease near sacred park pushes forward
Politicians and tribal leaders are decrying U.S. officials for moving forward with the sale of oil and gas leases near a park in New Mexico that Native Americans consider sacred
2:12PM ( 6 hours ago )
AP Business - Industries
Judge: PG&E put profits over wildfire safety
A U.S. judge berated Pacific Gas & Electric Corp., accusing the nation's largest utility of enriching shareholders instead of clearing trees that can fall on its power lines and start fires
8:35PM ( 23 hours ago )
Polar blast envelops Midwest, strains aging infrastructure
Blast of polar air envelops much of Midwest, straining infrastructure with some of the lowest temperatures in a generation
8:13PM ( 1 day ago )
Lawsuits by fire victims swept up in PG&E bankruptcy
Some 1,000 lawsuits have been filed demanding Pacific Gas & Electric Co. pay for damages caused by wildfires
6:46PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Business - Utilities
Outdoor retailers expand political fight with climate push
Patagonia, Columbia Sportswear, REI and other major outdoor retailers are building on a political fight over public lands by making climate change a priority
1:11PM ( 7 hours ago )
Insurance claims from deadly California wildfires top $11.4B
Insurance claims from California's deadly November 2018 wildfires have topped $11.4 billion
6:20PM ( 3 days ago )
California sues wealthy coastal city over low-income housing
Gov. Gavin Newsom has used a new law for the first time to try to force a wealthy Southern California coastal city to end its years of opposition to meeting low-income housing goals
8:52PM ( 5 days ago )
AP Business - Small Business
Varner hears the roars on No. 16, shares Phoenix Open lead
Harold Varner III dabs his way to the top of the Phoenix Open leaderboard to tie Rickie Fowler and Justin Thomas with a 7-under 64
8:08PM ( 19 minutes ago )
January was officially Australia's hottest month on record
Australia has sweltered through its hottest month on record in January and the summer of extremes continues with wildfires razing the drought-parched south while expanses of the tropical north are flooded
8:03PM ( 24 minutes ago )
Long johns to short sleeves: Rapid thaw follows polar blast
Long johns to short sleeves: Rapid thaw to follow polar blast; temperatures could climb by 80 degrees
7:54PM ( 33 minutes ago )
Thousands fired after garment industry protest in Bangladesh
More than 5,000 workers fired, hundreds charged with crimes after street protests demanding higher wages in Bangladesh's garment industry
7:46PM ( 41 minutes ago )
Survivors question brevity of FBI report on Vegas massacre
The brevity of an FBI report on the Las Vegas massacre has prompted disbelief and outrage from survivors and relatives of victims
7:45PM ( 42 minutes ago )