Saturday December 14th, 2019 11:40PM

AP Exclusive: US Nobelist was told of gene-edited babies

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

Long before the claim of the world's first gene-edited babies became public, Chinese researcher He Jiankui shared the news with a U.S. Nobel laureate who objected to the experiment yet remained an adviser to He's biotech company.

The revelation that another prominent scientist knew of the work, which was widely condemned when it was revealed, comes as scientists debate whether and how to alert troubling research, and the need for clearer guidelines.

Emails obtained by The Associated Press under a public records request show that Nobel Prize winner Craig Mello of the University of Massachusetts learned about the pregnancy last April from He in a message titled "Success!"

"I'm glad for you, but I'd rather not be kept in the loop on this," Mello replied. "You are risking the health of the child you are editing ... I just don't see why you are doing this. I wish your patient the best of luck for a healthy pregnancy."

Mello stayed on as a scientific adviser for He's Direct Genomics company for eight more months, until December, just after news of the births became public and drew international scorn. The Chinese scientist's gene-editing work was not a company experiment. He tried to alter the genes of twin girls to help them resist possible future infection with HIV, the AIDS virus.

Several U.S. researchers knew or strongly suspected He was considering trying embryo gene editing, and his disclosure to Mello in April is notable because it specified the pregnancy had been achieved, and came on the day He himself said he learned of it.

Editing embryos intended for a pregnancy is not allowed in the U.S. and many other places because of the risk of harming other genes and concerns that these DNA changes can be passed to future generations. But there's no certain way to stop a rogue scientist from experimenting, no matter what rules are in place, because the gene-editing technology is cheap and easy to use.

It's not clear how someone would have raised concerns about He's project, said University of Wisconsin bioethicist Alta Charo, who was one of the leaders of the Hong Kong gene-editing conference where He gave details of the experiment. He's work has not been published in a scientific journal.

University of Minnesota bioethicist Leigh Turner said the lack of action by scientists who learned of He's intentions indicates a broader culture of silence. "There seems to have been multiple lost opportunities," Turner said.

Last week, China's state media reported that He could face consequences after investigators determined he acted alone and fabricated an ethics review by others. The Xinhua report said the twins and people involved in a second, ongoing pregnancy with a gene-edited embryo will remain under medical observation with regular visits supervised by government health departments. Efforts to reach He were unsuccessful.

Mello declined requests for an interview. In statements provided through his university, Mello said he had no idea He was "personally interested" in human gene editing or had the means to pull it off, and that their discussions were "hypothetical and broad." Mello repeated his disapproval of He's project and said he resigned from Direct Genomics' scientific advisory board because he felt that a company led by He could no longer be effective.

Mello said he started on the board in October 2017, and said he didn't accept compensation for the role. A representative for his university said faculty members are allowed to serve on scientific advisory boards. Mello is paid by the Howard Hughes Medical Institute, which also supports AP's Health & Science Department. Mello's work with Direct Genomics was not as an HHMI representative, according to the university and an email from an HHMI lawyer to He.

According to a statement Mello's university provided, He approached Mello during a break at a company meeting in November 2017 to talk about the possibility of using the powerful gene-editing tool CRISPR to prevent HIV infection from parent to child. The statement said Mello said he had no idea of He's intention to try this himself.

After the meeting, emails show that Mello connected He to a colleague for advice on "pediatric HIV transmission risks for a therapy he is contemplating."

Infectious disease expert Dr. Katherine Luzuriaga replied that she looked forward to talking. She did not respond to requests for an interview. The university released a statement saying that Luzuriaga and He had a brief phone call, and that she was not aware the advice she was providing could be for He's work on gene-edited embryos.

In April, He emailed Mello: "Good News ... the pregnancy is confirmed!" He asked Mello to keep the news confidential.

Mello, who won a Nobel in 2006 for genetics research, expressed concern about health risks.

"I think you are taking a big risk and I do not want anyone to think that I approve of what you are doing," he wrote. "I'm sorry I cannot be more supportive of this effort, I know you mean well."

The emails show Mello attended another Direct Genomics meeting in China in November, about a week before the Hong Kong conference where He made his claim public.

Mello's statement said he resigned from the company's scientific advisory board on Dec. 6.


Follow Candice Choi at @candicechoi and Marilynn Marchione at @MMarchioneAP


The Associated Press Health and Science Department receives support from the Howard Hughes Medical Institute's Department of Science Education. The AP is solely responsible for all content.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, Top U.S. News short headlines, Top General short headlines, AP Health, AP World News, AP Business, AP Health - Women's health
© Copyright 2019 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
The Latest: White House threatens executive action over wall
The White House is again threatening executive action if lawmakers can't reach a deal on border security over the next three weeks
4:36PM ( 10 minutes ago )
AP Exclusive: US Nobelist was told of gene-edited babies
US Nobel laureate knew about Chinese researcher's claim of world's first gene-edited babies, furthering debate about scientists' duty to alert troubling research
4:33PM ( 12 minutes ago )
The Latest: Falcons owner hopes roof is open for Super Bowl
The Latest: Atlanta Falcons owner Arthur Blank hopes retractable roof at Mercedes-Benz Stadium is open for Super Bowl Sunday
4:33PM ( 13 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Strongest tornado in 8 decades hits Cuba; 3 dead, 172 hurt
Neighborhood brigades and teams of government workers are hacking at fallen trees and hauling chunks of concrete out of collapsed homes as the Cuban capital attempted to recover from what officials call the strongest tornado to hit Cuba in nearly 80 years
3:59PM ( 47 minutes ago )
Science Says: Get used to polar vortex outbreaks
A sudden warming way above the North Pole weeks ago set the stage for the dreaded polar vortex to escape to the U.S.
3:57PM ( 49 minutes ago )
US hits Venezuela state-owned oil company with sanctions
The Trump administration has imposed sanctions on the state-owned oil company of Venezuela
3:54PM ( 52 minutes ago )
AP National News
Henson and Badu say comments on R. Kelly misrepresented
Taraji P. Henson and Erykah Badu say their recent comments regarding R. Kelly were taken out of context
2:40PM ( 2 hours ago )
US envoy: 'Agreement in principle' on Afghan peace talks
The top U.S. envoy on Afghanistan says negotiators for the U.S. and Taliban insurgents have reached "agreements in principle" on key issues for a peace deal that would end 17 years of war
2:20PM ( 2 hours ago )
5 years after 'snow jam,' storm takes aim at Super Bowl city
Five years after cars, trucks and school buses became marooned on Atlanta freeways in what came to be known as "snow jam," another winter storm is threatening the city _ just as fans begin pouring into town for Super Bowl 53
2:08PM ( 2 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
Companies navigate dementia conversations with older workers
As American workforce ages, companies are increasingly navigating delicate conversations between management and employees suffering from cognitive declines
3:02AM ( 13 hours ago )
Measles outbreak grows in northwest US, 30 cases reported
Health officials say the number of confirmed cases of measles in western Washington state has grown to 30 from 25. Nine additional cases are suspected
7:32PM ( 2 days ago )
Arizona governor urges new leaders at facility after rape
Arizona's governor is looking into whether the state can remove the board of directors of a long-term care facility where a nurse is accused of raping an incapacitated woman who later gave birth
7:01PM ( 2 days ago )
AP Health
Stocks slide as slow growth in China weighs on earnings
Major indexes are falling as weak growth in China cuts into corporate financial results
3:45PM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: Rubio says US to sanction Venezuela's oil co
Sen. Marco Rubio says the U.S. will hit Venezuela's state-owned oil company with sanctions aimed at increasing pressure on President Nicolas Maduro to step down from office
3:36PM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: Priest says parishioners believed buried in mud
A Catholic priest for a church now being used as a command center for officials trying to rescue people after a mining dam burst says many of the church's parishioners are believed to be buried in mud
3:26PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
Battles expected in many states over abortion-related bills
Legislators and activists will push this year to pass high-priority bills on abortion in statehouses across the United States
7:11PM ( 1 week ago )
911 audio shows shock, panic after comatose woman gave birth
Dramatic 911 audio shows panicking staff members at a long-term care facility scrambled to save a baby born to an Arizona woman in a vegetative state amid their shock to learn she was pregnant
5:15PM ( 2 weeks ago )
Expert: Comatose woman may not have shown signs of pregnancy
Court documents say a doctor examined an Arizona woman in a vegetative state nearly nine months before she gave birth but didn't find that was pregnant
8:38AM ( 2 weeks ago )
AP Health - Women's health
The Latest: White House threatens executive action over wall
The White House is again threatening executive action if lawmakers can't reach a deal on border security over the next three weeks
4:36PM ( 10 minutes ago )
The Latest: Falcons owner hopes roof is open for Super Bowl
The Latest: Atlanta Falcons owner Arthur Blank hopes retractable roof at Mercedes-Benz Stadium is open for Super Bowl Sunday
4:33PM ( 13 minutes ago )
Rescuers search in deep mud after Brazil dam breach, 60 dead
Brazilian firefighters are carefully searching through mud as they continue searching for survivors or victims following the collapse of a dam owned by a big iron ore mining company
4:32PM ( 14 minutes ago )
Ahead of Oscars, 'Black Panther' to return to theaters again
Fresh off of its win at the Screen Actors Guild Awards, 'Black Panther' is heading back into theaters
4:21PM ( 25 minutes ago )
The Latest: White House rejects report showing slowed growth
The director of the National Economic Council is rejecting a Congressional Budget Office assessment showing slowed growth following a five-week government shutdown
4:14PM ( 32 minutes ago )