sunny.png
Monday September 23rd, 2019 2:02PM

Smaller class sizes not proven but teachers strike for them

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

LOS ANGELES (AP) — Most educators and parents see class size as an indicator of a quality education and have made it a priority in teacher strikes across the United States in the past year, but its effectiveness is still up for debate.

There's no universal standard for the best class size, though some states and school districts have instituted policies, particularly in lower grades. While many believe smaller is better, studies are mixed on exactly how much it can improve academic outcomes, considering the cost.

The ratio of students to teachers is at the heart of a teacher strike in the nation's second-largest school district, where tens of thousands of Los Angeles educators walked out Monday. Teachers have complained about having kids sitting on window sills or the floor of overcrowded classrooms that can push past 45 students.

Farther north, some teachers in Oakland called in sick Friday as part of an unofficial rally over their contract negotiations, which also hinge partly on a demand for smaller class sizes.

At the high school level, Los Angeles has routinely had more students per teacher than the national average, said John Rogers, a professor of education at University of California, Los Angeles.

He said there's no easy way to assess the impact of class size on educational outcomes over the last couple of decades in the Los Angeles Unified School District — in part because classes have been overcrowded despite a state mandate calling for an average class size of 30 students through eighth grade.

Rogers said the question of whether districts should be able to increase class size unilaterally is important because it makes teachers feel they lack control over learning conditions.

"When your class size can be increased dramatically, you lose the ability to ensure that you can do right by the students you are serving," Rogers said.

United Teachers Los Angeles is demanding the elimination of a longstanding contract clause giving the district authority over class sizes. If the district won't agree to remove the provision, union leaders say they can't trust that school officials won't ignore any deal it cuts on class sizes in the future.

The district has insisted on replacing it with new language that also grants it power to raise class sizes under certain conditions, including a financial emergency. It said its latest contract offer included $100 million to add nearly 1,000 additional teachers, nurses, counselors and librarians in 2019-20 and reduce some class sizes. Schools with the greatest needs would see larger reductions — about four students per class.

But union president Alex Caputo-Pearl said the district's offers were limited to one year and then class sizes could spike again and new staff could be cut. He has called class size a "fundamental issue" that's directly "about educator working conditions."

Superintendent Austin Beutner has said he would like to reduce class sizes even more but the district simply doesn't have the money. He has suggested the union might consider trading other contract demands for greater reductions in class size.

Brent Smiley, a 23-year district veteran who teaches at Sherman Oaks Center For Enriched Studies, said he's had as many as 42 students in one class and that his smallest has 39.

"Struggling to keep them focused can be an impossible task," he said this week.

A 2016 report by the National Education Policy Center suggested class sizes be set as low as 15 students in lower grades and found that all things being equal, the student ratio affected their academic achievement.

William Mathis, who authored the study as an education policy expert at the University of Colorado, pointed to a 1979 study that tracked young students in smaller classes in Tennessee and saw lasting effects. The children had better grades and test scores, fewer disciplinary issues and an increased likelihood of going to college.

The gains were twice as large for poor and minority students and so convincing that in 1998 President Bill Clinton pushed a $12 billion class size reduction program through Congress, though academic disparities remain.

Mathis contends that smaller class sizes in younger grades work because teacher quality improves and getting more attention helps children develop skills, such as establishing peer groups and positive attitudes, that are needed to progress to more intense learning.

"The bigger the class, the more likely you are to treat kids as a big group, and you don't read papers as good, you don't read them as closely, you don't have as much attention to give to each child," Mathis said of teacher quality.

But Matthew Chingos, vice president of the Urban Institute's Center on Education Data and Policy, is skeptical of a one-size-fits-all approach. He's studied state-regulated class sizes and says that it may not be the "biggest bang for the buck" for every classroom.

Requiring a school to have more teachers is expensive and potentially problematic, he argues, because it limits local control at the campus level, which in turn can dilute teacher quality.

California tried to boost its reading and math scores between 1996 and 2013 with a program that gave extra money to schools if they reduced kindergarten through third-grade classes down to 20 students.

That experiment, Chingos said, didn't prove its worth because there was no prior data for comparison.

Without more high-quality research, Chingos said parents and teachers both push for smaller class sizes based largely on their intuition that it's better for children. Teachers also benefit, including adding to the union ranks, he said.

"Class sizes are a political winner. No one thinks it's bad. If money grew on trees, then sure," Chingos said.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top U.S. News short headlines
© Copyright 2019 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Kenzo explores designer's roots at Paris Fashion Week
Psychedelic Peruvian paintings covered panel upon panel of Kenzo's fall menswear show at Paris Fashion Week
11:49AM ( 8 minutes ago )
Smaller class sizes not proven but teachers strike for them
Most educators and parents see class size as an indicator of a quality education and have made it a priority in teacher strikes across the United States, but its effectiveness is still up for debate
11:49AM ( 8 minutes ago )
The Latest: TSA says many of its workers calling out of work
The impacts of the record-breaking partial government shutdown are continuing to escalate
11:41AM ( 16 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
May plans next move in Brexit fight as chances rise of delay
As Prime Minister Theresa May prepares her next move in Britain's deadlocked Brexit battle, a senior opposition politician says unlikely the U.K. will leave the European Union as scheduled on March 29
11:21AM ( 36 minutes ago )
Unclaimed veterans buried with dignity, thanks to strangers
A national effort by a funeral home company, medical examiners, state veterans' affairs departments and local veterans' groups honors members of the military whose bodies were not claimed by any relatives
11:16AM ( 41 minutes ago )
IRA dissidents suspected in Northern Ireland car bomb blast
Northern Ireland politicians are condemning a car bombing outside a courthouse in the city of Londonderry
11:15AM ( 42 minutes ago )
AP National News
Kenzo explores designer's roots at Paris Fashion Week
Psychedelic Peruvian paintings covered panel upon panel of Kenzo's fall menswear show at Paris Fashion Week
11:49AM ( 8 minutes ago )
The Latest: TSA says many of its workers calling out of work
The impacts of the record-breaking partial government shutdown are continuing to escalate
11:41AM ( 16 minutes ago )
Polish PM calls for respect in public life after mayor slain
Poland's conservative Prime Minister Mateusz Morawiecki has called on politicians and public figures to make the public debate more respectful after the slaying of Gdansk city mayor which raised calls for national reconciliation
11:37AM ( 20 minutes ago )
M. Night Shyamalan's 'Glass' is No. 1 with $40.6M debut
M. Night Shyamalan's "Glass" didn't live up to expectations but it still easily dominated the Martin Luther King Jr. weekend at the box office, debuting with an estimated $40.6 million in ticket sales
11:35AM ( 22 minutes ago )
Paying for funerals impossible for many poor families
Some relatives of people whose cremated remains were found among hundreds in a Detroit funeral home say they would have loved to bury them in marked graves but couldn't afford traditional funeral services
11:30AM ( 27 minutes ago )