Monday June 1st, 2020 12:01PM

Less beef, more beans. Experts say world needs a new diet

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

NEW YORK (AP) — A hamburger a week, but no more — that's about as much red meat people should eat to do what's best for their health and the planet, according to a report seeking to overhaul the world's diet.

Eggs should be limited to fewer than about four a week, the report says. Dairy foods should be about a serving a day, or less.

The report from a panel of nutrition, agriculture and environmental experts recommends a plant-based diet, based on previously published studies that have linked red meat to increased risk of health problems. It also comes amid recent studies of how eating habits affect the environment. Producing red meat takes up land and feed to raise cattle, which also emit the greenhouse gas methane.

John Ioannidis, chair of disease prevention at Stanford University, said he welcomed the growing attention to how diets affect the environment, but that the report's recommendations do not reflect the level of scientific uncertainties around nutrition and health.

"The evidence is not as strong as it seems to be," Ioannidis said.

The report was organized by EAT, a Stockholm-based nonprofit seeking to improve the food system, and published Wednesday by the medical journal Lancet. The panel of experts who wrote it says a "Great Food Transformation" is urgently needed by 2050, and that the optimal diet they outline is flexible enough to accommodate food cultures around the world.

Overall, the diet encourages whole grains, beans, fruits and most vegetables, and says to limit added sugars, refined grains such as white rice and starches like potatoes and cassava. It says red meat consumption on average needs to be slashed by half globally, though the necessary changes vary by region and reductions would need to be more dramatic in richer countries like the United States.

Convincing people to limit meat, cheese and eggs won't be easy, however, particularly in places where those foods are a notable part of culture.

In Sao Paulo, Brazil, systems analyst Cleberson Bernardes said as he was leaving a barbecue restaurant that limiting himself to just one serving of red meat a week would be "ridiculous." In Berlin, Germany, craftsman Erik Langguth said there are better ways to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, and dismissed the suggestion that the world needs to cut back on meat.

"If it hasn't got meat, it's not a proper meal," said Langguth, who is from a region known for its bratwurst sausages.

Before even factoring in the environmental implications, the report sought to sketch out what the healthiest diet for people would look like, said Walter Willett, one of its authors and a nutrition researcher at Harvard University. While eggs are no longer thought to increase risk of heart disease, Willett said the report recommends limiting them because studies indicate a breakfast of whole grains, nuts and fruit would be healthier.

He said everybody doesn't need to become a vegan, and that many are already limiting how much meat they eat.

"Think of it like lobster — something that I really like, but have a few times a year," Willett said.

Advice to limit red meat is not new, and is tied to its saturated fat content, which is also found in cheese, milk, nuts and packaged foods with coconut and palm kernel oils. The report notes most evidence on diet and health is from Europe and the United States. In Asian countries, a large analysis found eating poultry and red meat (mostly pork) was associated with improved lifespans. That might be in part because people might eat smaller amounts of meat in those countries, the report says.

Ioannidis of Stanford noted nutrition research is often based on observational links between diet and health, and that some past associations have not been validated. Dietary cholesterol, for example, is no longer believed to be strongly linked to blood cholesterol.

The meat and dairy industries also dispute the report's recommendations, saying their products deliver important nutrients and can be part of healthy diets.

Andrew Mente, a nutrition epidemiology researcher at McMaster University, urged caution before making widespread dietary recommendations, which he said could have unintended consequences.

Still, the EAT-Lancet report's authors say the overall body of evidence strongly supports reducing red meat for optimal health and shifting toward plant-based diets. They note the recommendations are compatible with the U.S. dietary guidelines, which say to limit saturated fat to 10 percent of calories.

While people in some poorer counties may benefit from getting more of the nutrients in meat and dairy products, the report says they shouldn't follow the path of richer countries in how much of those foods they eat in coming years.

Though estimates vary, a report by the United Nations said livestock is responsible for about 15 percent of the world's gas emissions that warm the climate.

Robbie Andrew, a senior researcher at CICERO Center for International Climate Research in Norway, said farming practices that make animals grow faster and bigger may help limit emissions. But he said cows and other ruminant animals nevertheless produce a lot of methane, a powerful greenhouse gas.

"It's very difficult to get down these natural emissions that are part of their biology," Andrew said.

The environmental benefits of giving up red meat depend on what people eat in its place. Chicken and pork produce far fewer emissions than beef, Andrew said, adding that plants in general have among the smallest carbon footprints.

Brent Loken, an author of the EAT-Lancet report, said the report lays out the parameters of an optimal diet, but acknowledged the challenge in figuring out how to work with policy makers, food companies and others in tailoring and implementing it in different regions.


AP reporters Frank Jordans in Berlin and Stan Lehman in Sao Paulo, Brazil, contributed to this article.


The Associated Press Health and Science Department receives support from the Howard Hughes Medical Institute's Department of Science Education. The AP is solely responsible for all content.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP Health, AP Business, AP Business - Industries, AP Business - Agriculture, AP Business - Utilities
© Copyright 2020
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Less beef, more beans. Experts say world needs a new diet
A report says limiting meat is optimal for people and the planet, but not everyone agrees
10:12PM ( 26 minutes ago )
Pliskova, Svitolina advance to Australian Open's third round
Karolina Pliskova extended her winning start to the season by reaching the third round of the Australian Open with a rain-interrupted 4-6, 6-1, 6-0 victory over Madison Brengle
10:01PM ( 37 minutes ago )
Michigan State President Engler says he'll resign next week
Former Gov. John Engler is resigning as Michigan State's interim president amid public backlash over his comments about women and girls sexually assaulted by now-imprisoned campus sports doctor Larry Nassar
9:33PM ( 1 hour ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Bob Costas exiting longtime home at NBC Sports
NBC Sports says Bob Costas is leaving his longtime broadcast home, where he emceed NBC's Olympics coverage 11 times
9:05PM ( 1 hour ago )
Trump administration to roll out new missile defense plan
The Trump administration is rolling out a new strategy for a more aggressive space-based missile defense system
9:02PM ( 1 hour ago )
John Bogle, founder of Vanguard, dies at 89
John Bogle, investing pioneer and founder of Vanguard Group, who brought index funds to millions of investors, dies at age 89, the company says
9:00PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
Government shutdown may upend State of the Union speech
A ritual is imperiled as Pelosi asks Trump to delay State of the Union speech if shutdown persists
7:50PM ( 2 hours ago )
Syria attack kills 4 Americans, raising questions on pullout
A suicide bombing claimed by the Islamic State group has killed at least 16 people, including two U.S. service members and two American civilians, in northern Syria
7:35PM ( 3 hours ago )
American anchor for Iranian TV is arrested on visit to US
Prominent American-born news anchor for Iranian state television arrested during US visit
7:22PM ( 3 hours ago )
Top General short headlines
US lawmaker opposes drilling permit work during shutdown
The chairman of the U.S. House Natural Resources Committee says the Interior Department should not be working on oil and gas development permits and leases in Alaska and elsewhere during the partial government shutdown
7:32PM ( 3 hours ago )
John Bogle dies at 89; fought for lower fees for investors
John Bogle, who simplified investing and fought for lower fees for investors, dies at age 89
7:16PM ( 3 hours ago )
Watchdog: GSA ignored emoluments in OKing Trump hotel lease
The inspector general for the General Services Administration says the agency improperly ignored the U.S. Constitution's provision outlawing foreign gifts when it OKed President Donald Trump's management of his Washington hotel after his 2016 election
6:59PM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Business
EPA nominee: Climate change huge issue, not greatest crisis
President Donald Trump's nominee to head the Environmental Protection Agency calls climate change "a huge issue" but not the "greatest crisis."
3:13PM ( 7 hours ago )
Fed survey finds businesses worried by political uncertainty
Fed survey cites rising concerns about stock market volatility and political uncertainty
2:39PM ( 7 hours ago )
Democrats hit Wheeler's rollbacks at EPA during hearing
Acting EPA chief Andrew Wheeler describes himself as a champion of deregulation and the environment at his confirmation hearing
1:11PM ( 9 hours ago )
AP Business - Industries
Big winners in Trump rollback of wetlands rules? Developers
Builders and other developers stand to get the biggest financial and regulatory relief under a rollback of protections for wetlands
8:01PM ( 2 days ago )
FDA resuming some food inspections halted by shutdown
FDA to resume inspections of riskier foods during government shutdown
7:21PM ( 2 days ago )
Trump seeks to sell shutdown, trade policies to farmers
President Donald Trump is urging a gathering of farmers to stick with him even as many of them grapple with the impact of his trade battles with China and Washington's shuttered bureaucracy.
6:27PM ( 2 days ago )
AP Business - Agriculture
PG&E bankruptcy could mean price hikes, unpaid fire lawsuits
Pacific Gas & Electric Co. pending bankruptcy is raising concern that prices will rise and victims of wildfires who are suing the nation's largest utility won't get all the money they may be owed
8:50PM ( 1 day ago )
US indexes hit one-month highs as tech stocks rally
Stocks are trading at their highest levels in a month, led by Netflix and other technology and internet companies as well as health care companies
3:01PM ( 1 day ago )
Zimbabwe military quells fuel price hike protests; 8 killed
Military deploys, fires tear gas on 2nd day of Zimbabwe fuel hike protests; 8 killed says rights group
12:59PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Business - Utilities
Pliskova, Svitolina advance to Australian Open's third round
Karolina Pliskova extended her winning start to the season by reaching the third round of the Australian Open with a rain-interrupted 4-6, 6-1, 6-0 victory over Madison Brengle
10:01PM ( 37 minutes ago )
Michigan State President Engler says he'll resign next week
Former Gov. John Engler is resigning as Michigan State's interim president amid public backlash over his comments about women and girls sexually assaulted by now-imprisoned campus sports doctor Larry Nassar
9:33PM ( 1 hour ago )
The Latest: Pliskova beats Brengle at Australian Open
Karolina Pliskova has set up a third-round match against Elina Svitolina with a 4-6, 6-1, 6-0 win over Madison Brengle at Melbourne Park
9:24PM ( 1 hour ago )
SpaceX to build Mars ships in Texas, not Los Angeles
SpaceX says it will build test versions of its Mars spaceship in south Texas instead of the Port of Los Angeles, dealing another blow to the local economy only days after the company announced massive layoffs
9:19PM ( 1 hour ago )
California storm triggers crashes, fears in wildfire areas
Rain and snow falling across California have forced the closure of a major freeway, snarled commutes and triggered deadly wrecks on slick roads
9:10PM ( 1 hour ago )