fogn.png
Friday September 25th, 2020 11:18PM

Developers, not farmers, get biggest win from wetlands rule

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — President Donald Trump often points to farmers as among the biggest winners from the administration's proposed rollback of federal protections for wetlands and waterways across the country.

But under longstanding federal law and rules, farmers and farmland already are exempt from most of the regulatory hurdles on behalf of wetlands that the Trump administration is targeting. Because of that, environmental groups long have argued that builders, oil and gas drillers and other industry owners would be the big winners if the government adopts the pending rollback, making it easier to fill in bogs, creeks and streams for plowing, drilling, mining or building.

Government numbers released last month support that argument.

Real estate developers and those in other business sectors take out substantially more permits than farmers for projects impinging on wetlands, creeks, and streams, and who stand to reap the biggest regulatory and financial relief from the Trump administration's rollback of wetlands protections.

But Trump and his administration put farmers front and center as beneficiaries of the proposed rollback because of the strong regard Americans historically hold for farming, opponents say. Trump traveled to New Orleans on Monday to speak to a national farm convention.

"The administration understands good optics in surrounding themselves with farmers," in proposing the rollback, said Geoff Gisler, a senior attorney at the Southern Environmental Law Center. "Surrounding themselves with folks that would represent the industries that actually benefit would not be as good an optic."

Backers "have been really happy to have farmers be the face of it," said Kenneth Kopocis, the Environmental Protection Agency's deputy assistant administrator for water under the Obama administration. But the building industry, oil and gas and others with lower profiles in the campaign "are going to be some of the big beneficiaries."

The more than 300-page financial analysis the administration released last month when it formally proposed the rollback appears to starkly quantify that disparity. Of 248,688 federal permits issued from 2011 to 2015 for work that would deposit dirt or other fill into protected wetlands, streams and shorelines, the federal government on average required home builders and other developers to do some kind of mitigation — pay to restore a wetland elsewhere, generally — an average of 990 times a year, nationwide, according to the government's analysis.

In all, other industries and agriculture obtained an average of 3,163 such wetlands permits with some kind of extra payment or other mitigation strings attached each year.

Farmers represented just eight of those on average in a year, according to the administration's figures.

The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, which administers the wetlands protections with the Environmental Protection Agency, and the National Association of Home Builders confirmed Friday that developers and other industries, not farmers, have felt the biggest impact from the federal wetlands protections and would get most of the financial breaks under the rollback.

"The residential construction industry does pull more wetlands permits than farmers do," Liz Thompson, spokeswoman for the National Association of Home Builders, said in an email.

The Trump administration's pending rollback of wetlands protections "could be a benefit to builders who will see some relief in terms of cost and time. That said, builders will still be regulated and will still be the industry that pulls the largest number of 404 permits which are very costly," Thompson wrote, referring to the section of the Clean Water Act dealing with the regulatory enforcement and permits.

The administration's proposal greatly narrows what kind of wetlands and streams fall under federal protection. If it is formally adopts it after a public comment period, it would change how the federal government enforces the landmark 1972 Clean Water Act and scale back a 2015 Obama administration rule on what waterways are protected. Environmental groups say millions of miles of streams and wetlands would lose protection.

Trump signed an order in February 2017 directing the rollback. With farmers as well as homebuilders by his side, Trump called the waterways protections then in force a "massive power grab" targeting "nearly every puddle or every ditch on a farmer's land."

The farm bloc has been one of the most loyal to Trump, despite farmers' complaints that the administration has favored oil and gas producers over corn ethanol farmers, and their worries over a trade war with China.

Acting EPA head Andrew Wheeler surrounded himself with farm bureau representatives and farm-state Congress members in signing the rollback proposal last month.

In Tennessee, Wheeler, Agriculture Secretary Sonny Perdue and farm industry leaders from Washington stood in front of tractors and U.S. flags last month to urge farmers to campaign for the rollback.

"The EPA has done its job, now all of us in this room have to help to get this over the finish line," Zippy Duvall, head of the American Farm Bureau Federation, told the Tennessee farm crowd then.

Farmers who support the rollback call the federal protections of wetlands and creeks a burden, and insist farmers know best how to protect their property.

Environmental groups, public-health organizations and others say it's impossible to keep the country's downstream lakes, rivers and water supplies clean unless upstream waters are also regulated federally. The targeted regulations also protect wildlife and their habitats.

The Clean Water Act permits deal with work that would dump dirt or fill into a wetland or waterway. Breaks for farmers long have been written into the law, so that a farmer doesn't need permits for ordinary ongoing farming that, for instance, sends some soil running off into a wetland.

The American Farm Bureau Federation — one of the most active promoters of the scaling back of the Clean Water Act's reach — says the 2015 Obama version of the rule could force farmers to pursue costly wetlands permits and mitigation for routine plowing and other farm work.

"It's just really a nightmare for farmers to have to navigate," said Don Parrish, the senior director of regulatory relations at the agriculture trade group. "It can cost them the use of the land, generally they have to stop using their land" if they run afoul of it.

"If you could see me, I'd be laughing" at that claim, Kopocis, the lead Obama water official behind the 2015 rule, said by phone Sunday. "Every single exemption or exclusion that agriculture had" was preserved in the Obama administration's 2015 work on the wetlands rule, he said.

In an email, Cindy Barger, an Army Corps of Engineers official involved in the proposed regulatory change, confirmed that the rules targeted by the Trump administration had kept the regulatory relief for farmers.

Compared to other industries, as wetlands protections currently stand, "the agricultural industry has less economic exposure because of the permit exemptions," Barger said. The gain for farmers would be the Trump administration's attempt to streamline definition of protected wetlands, meaning farmers wouldn't have to consult experts to know if an area is protected, she said.

___

John Flesher contributed from Traverse City, Michigan.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Business, AP Business - Industries, AP Business - Agriculture, AP Business - Utilities
© Copyright 2020 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Filipino Muslims vote on autonomy after long peace effort
Muslims in the southern Philippines voted on a new autonomous region that seeks to end nearly half a century of unrest
8:11PM ( 19 minutes ago )
More sexual abuse claims rock South Korean skating
An athletes' group has raised further allegations of sexual abuse in South Korean speed skating following explosive claims by two-time Olympic champion Shim Suk-hee that she had been raped by her former coach
7:55PM ( 36 minutes ago )
Utah women's hoops ranked for first time in more than decade
Utah earned its first appearance in The Associated Press women's basketball poll in a decade, entering at No. 21 on Monday
7:54PM ( 37 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
TSA screener sick-outs hit 10 percent over holiday weekend
Absence rate among unpaid government airport screeners hits 10 percent
7:09PM ( 1 hour ago )
MLK holiday offers stage for Democratic hopefuls
MLK holiday gives platform for Democratic 2020 hopefuls as they spread out across the country
6:27PM ( 2 hours ago )
Houston home to rival Martin Luther King Day parades
Houston will have dueling Martin Luther King Jr. Day parades despite the mayor's attempt to unify behind one event
5:35PM ( 2 hours ago )
AP National News
For the poor, the safety net in a shutdown doesn't feel safe
As the longest government shutdown in U.S. history stretches into a fifth week, America's safety net no longer feels so safe
4:01PM ( 4 hours ago )
Frigid air, high winds cause dangerous travel conditions
Frigid air and high winds are causing dangerous travel conditions throughout the eastern U.S. after a powerful winter storm pummeled the region over the weekend
3:00PM ( 5 hours ago )
Israel increasingly goes public with its strikes in Syria
Israel claims responsibility for airstrikes on Iranian military targets in Syria, drifting further away from its longstanding policy of strategic ambiguity
2:12PM ( 6 hours ago )
AP Online National News
The shutdown today: No signs of progress
The shutdown today: No signs of progress
7:05PM ( 1 hour ago )
Macron ex-security aide: Diplomatic passports given back
French President Emmanuel Macron's former security aide, at the heart of a damaging political scandal, has told a Senate commission that he turned in his two diplomatic passports after being fired last summer but they were returned to him two months later
1:19PM ( 7 hours ago )
Trump marks MLK day with memorial visit
President Donald Trump has paid a visit to the Martin Luther King Jr. memorial in Washington
12:57PM ( 7 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Saints owner vows to pursue changes in NFL policies
Saints owner Gayle Benson says she pledges to aggressively pursue changes in NFL policies that will promote more "fairness and integrity."
5:27PM ( 3 hours ago )
Saints owner vows to purse changes in NFL policies
Saints owner Gayle Benson says she pledges to aggressively pursue changes in NFL policies that will promote more "fairness and integrity."
5:16PM ( 3 hours ago )
Inside a big top, Dior puts on circus-themed couture
Dior went to the circus for inspiration in creating a playful couture show in Paris, where models inside a big top walked through an arch of acrobats
4:05PM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Business
France holds trial over horse meat found in frozen lasagna
Four people on in trial in Paris accused of passing off cheap horse meat as pricier beef
9:54AM ( 10 hours ago )
France's Macron to promote foreign investment at Versailles
French President Emmanuel Macron hosting 150 international business leaders at Palace of Versailles in hopes of producing support for his agenda amid weekly citizen protests of his government's economic policies
9:21AM ( 11 hours ago )
Death toll reaches 85 in Mexico fuel pipeline fire horror
People in the Mexican town where a gasoline explosion killed at least 85 people say the section of pipeline that gushed fuel has been a habitual gathering site for thieves, repeatedly damaged and patched like a trusty pair of jeans
9:12PM ( 23 hours ago )
AP Business - Industries
Scientists ID another possible threat to orcas: pink salmon
Four biologists have identified a surprising potential culprit in the decline of the Pacific Northwest's resident killer whales: pink salmon.
5:29AM ( 2 days ago )
Less beef, more beans. Experts say world needs a new diet
A report says limiting meat is optimal for people and the planet, but not everyone agrees
10:46PM ( 4 days ago )
Big winners in Trump rollback of wetlands rules? Developers
Builders and other developers stand to get the biggest financial and regulatory relief under a rollback of protections for wetlands
8:01PM ( 1 week ago )
AP Business - Agriculture
The Latest: Mexican local recalls geyser of gas
A local of Mexico's Hidalgo state says civilians ignored soldiers' warnings to stay clear of a geyser of gasoline that later exploded, killing at least 66 people
2:30PM ( 2 days ago )
Fireball at illegal Mexico pipeline tap kills 66; 85 missing
Forensic experts are attempting to separate and count charred heaps of corpses in central Mexico after a massive fireball erupted at an illegal pipeline tap, killing at least 66
10:32AM ( 2 days ago )
Horrifying fireball at ruptured Mexico oil pipeline kills 21
A huge fire exploded at a pipeline leaking fuel in central Mexico on Friday, killing at least 21 people and badly burning 71 others as locals were collecting the spilling gasoline in buckets and garbage cans
8:00AM ( 2 days ago )
AP Business - Utilities
Filipino Muslims vote on autonomy after long peace effort
Muslims in the southern Philippines voted on a new autonomous region that seeks to end nearly half a century of unrest
8:11PM ( 19 minutes ago )
More sexual abuse claims rock South Korean skating
An athletes' group has raised further allegations of sexual abuse in South Korean speed skating following explosive claims by two-time Olympic champion Shim Suk-hee that she had been raped by her former coach
7:55PM ( 36 minutes ago )
Utah women's hoops ranked for first time in more than decade
Utah earned its first appearance in The Associated Press women's basketball poll in a decade, entering at No. 21 on Monday
7:54PM ( 37 minutes ago )
Zimbabwe's president returns amid economic crisis, crackdown
Zimbabwe's President Emmerson Mnangagwa arrived in Harare late Monday after cutting short his fund-raising trip in order to address the country's economic crisis and crackdown
7:45PM ( 46 minutes ago )
Hurdles cleared, Patriots head to 3rd straight Super Bowl
Patriots ride underdog label all the way to their third straight Super Bowl appearance
7:21PM ( 1 hour ago )