Thursday November 26th, 2020 1:26AM

Selective shutdown? Trump tries to blunt impact, takes heat

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — The government shutdown is wreaking havoc on many Americans: Hundreds of thousands of federal employees don't know when they'll see their next paycheck, and low-income people who rely on the federal safety net worry about whether they'll make ends meet should the stalemate in Washington carry on another month.

But if you're a sportsman looking to hunt game, a gas company planning to drill offshore or a taxpayer awaiting your refund , you're in luck: This shutdown won't affect your plans.

All administrations get some leeway to choose which services to freeze and which to maintain when a budget standoff in Washington forces some agencies to shutter. But in the selective reopening of offices, experts say they see a willingness to cut corners, scrap prior plans and wade into legally dubious territory to mitigate the pain. Some noted the choices seem targeted at shielding the Republican-leaning voters whom Trump and his party need to stick with them.

The cumulative effect is a government shutdown — now officially the longest in U.S. history — that some Americans may find financially destabilizing and others may hardly notice.

Russell T. Vought, deputy director of the Office of Management and Budget, said the overarching message from Trump has been "to make this shutdown as painless as possible, consistent with the law."

"We have built on past efforts within this administration not to have the shutdown be used to be weaponized against the American people," he said.

Others say such a strategy suggests a lack of urgency and a willingness to let the political impasse in Washington drag on indefinitely.

"The strategy seems to be to keep the shutdown in place, not worry about the effect on employees and furloughed people and contractors, but where the public might be annoyed, give a little," said Alice Rivlin, who led OMB during the 21-day shutdown in 1996, the previous recordholder for the longest in history.

That's a clear difference between then and now, Rivlin said.

"We weren't trying to make it better. We were trying to emphasize the pain so it would be over," she said. "We wanted it to end. I'm not convinced the Trump administration does."

The Trump administration earlier this week announced that the IRS will issue tax refunds during the shutdown, circumventing a 2011 decision barring the agency from distributing refunds until the Treasury Department is funded. The National Treasury Employees Union filed a lawsuit, arguing its workers are being unconstitutionally forced to return to work without pay.

Some agencies are finding creative ways to fund services they want to restore.

The administration has emphasized continued use of public lands in general, and particularly for hunters and oil and gas developers, angering environmental groups. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, using funds leftover from 2018, this week announced it will direct dozens of wildlife refuges to return staffers to work, ensuring planned activities on those lands, including organized hunts, continue.

Barbara Wainman, a spokeswoman for the agency, said most refuges have remained accessible to hunters throughout the shutdown, and the decision to staff them was made based on three criteria: resource management, high visitation and previously scheduled programming, which includes organized hunts and school field trips. Wainman said 17 of the 38 refuges have scheduled hunts that would have been canceled without the restaffing effort.

The IRS is using user fees to restore the income verification program, used by mortgage lenders to confirm the income of a borrower and considered a critical tool for the banking industry. After national parks were left open but unstaffed, causing damage to delicate ecosystems, the National Park Service announced it would take "an extraordinary step" and use visitation fees to staff some of the major parks. And despite the shutdown, the Bureau of Land Management is continuing work related to drilling efforts in Alaska.

Trump has refused to sign spending bills for nine of the 15 Cabinet-level departments until Congress approves his request for $5.7 billion in funding to build a wall along the U.S.-Mexico border. Democrats have refused. The president initially said he would be "proud" to own the partial shutdown, but he quickly shifted blame onto Democratic leaders and has flirted with taking some extraordinary measures to find money for the wall. Although most Republicans have stood by the president, others have expressed discomfort with the strategy.

The focus on services that reach rural voters, influential industries and voters' pocketbooks is intended to protect Republicans from blowback, said Barry Anderson, who served as assistant director of the Office of Management and Budget from 1988 to 1998.

During the 1996 shutdown, Anderson said, he and others met each day to review which offices and services should be deemed essential. He said tax refunds never made the cut.

"A government agency may employ services in advance of appropriations only when there's a reasonable connection between the functions being performed and the safety of human life or protection of property," he said. "How does issuing tax refunds fall under either of those categories? It's not a human life or property issue. I don't know the proper word: surprised, aghast, flabbergasted.

"This," he said, "is to keep Republican senators' phones silent."

OMB has held regular conference calls with agencies and is fielding a high volume of requests for services they'd like to resume. In addition, OMB officials are intentionally working to legally reopen as much of the government as possible, according to a senior administration official, adding that agencies are permitted to update their lapse plans as the shutdown progresses. The official was not authorized to discuss the internal discussions publicly and spoke on condition of anonymity.

Across the government, agencies are scrambling. The Food and Drug Administration has scaled back on food inspections. The Department of Agriculture recently announced that the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, which provides food aid to nearly 40 million low-income Americans, will continue to operate through February because of a loophole in the short-term spending bill, which expired Dec. 22. But should the shutdown stretch into March, the department's reserves for the program, $3 billion, won't cover a month of benefits for all who need them. Other feeding programs, such as school lunch, food distribution and WIC, which provides nutrition aid to pregnant women, mothers and babies, are also in jeopardy should the shutdown last until March.

Hundreds of federal contracts for low-income Americans receiving housing assistance are expiring. The Department of Housing and Urban Development is unable to renew them and has instead directed private owners to dip into their reserves to cover shortfalls.

As time goes on, more and more programs will become vital, said Linda Bilmes, a public policy professor at the Harvard Kennedy School, and the meaning of what's essential will shift.

"Even apart from the fact that there may be particular instances of things that are being manipulated for political purposes," she said, "there are also realities that government agencies are facing as they reassess what is absolutely essential to do now that we're here, with no immediate end in sight."


For AP's complete coverage of the U.S. government shutdown:

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Business, AP Business - Corporate News, AP Business - Industries, AP Business - Utilities
© Copyright 2020
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
The Latest: Spain says Spanish woman killed in Paris blast
The Spanish foreign minister says a Spanish woman is among those killed in a Paris bakery explosion and fire believed caused by a gas leak, and another Spanish person was injured
10:20AM ( 10 minutes ago )
Selective shutdown? Trump tries to blunt impact, takes heat
Selective reopening of government offices to ease the pain for some citizens shows willingness to cut corners and wade into dubious territory, experts say
10:16AM ( 15 minutes ago )
Congo runner-up Fayulu asks court to order election recount
Congo presidential runner-up Fayulu asks court to order recount, calling results 'fabricated'
10:13AM ( 17 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
US starts withdrawing supplies, but not troops, from Syria
The U.S. military says it has started pulling equipment, but not troops, out of Syria as a first step in meeting President Donald Trump's demand for a complete military withdrawal
9:27AM ( 1 hour ago )
French yellow vest protests stretch into 9th straight week
Thousands of people wearing yellow vests started marching in the streets of Paris as others were gathering in the central French city of Bourges amid high security measures as authorities feared possible violence between police and protesters
9:08AM ( 1 hour ago )
Ex-kidnapping victims: Jayme Closs needs space, time to heal
Former kidnapping victims say 13-year-old Jayme Closs must be allowed to discuss her ordeal on her own terms as she tries to recover from her traumatic experiences
8:55AM ( 1 hour ago )
AP National News
After Wisconsin girl's safe return, question is: Why?
Investigators in Wisconsin say they're trying to figure out what prompted a man suspected in the abduction of 13-year-old Jayme Closs to carry out the crime
6:38AM ( 3 hours ago )
The Latest: 36 injured, 12 critically in Paris bakery blast
A Paris fire department spokesman says that 36 people, including 12 in critical condition, have been injured in the blast at a bakery that was apparently caused by a gas leak
6:20AM ( 4 hours ago )
Shutdown becomes longest federal closure in US history
Government shutdown enters 22nd day, becoming the longest federal closure in US history
6:17AM ( 4 hours ago )
AP Online National News
Harden has triple-double to lead Rockets over Cavs 141-113
James Harden had 43 points, 10 rebounds and 12 assists in three quarters to lead the Houston Rockets to a 141-113 rout of the Cleveland Cavaliers
11:35PM ( 10 hours ago )
AP source: LeMahieu, Yankees agree to $24M, 2-year deal
AP source: Gold Glove-winning free agent second baseman D.J. LeMahieu and the Yankees have agreed to a $24 million, two-year contract, a person familiar with the negotiations tells The Associated Press
11:15PM ( 11 hours ago )
SpaceX to lay off 10 percent of workforce to become leaner
SpaceX is laying off 10 percent of its roughly 6,000 workers, saying it needs to get leaner so it can succeed in enormous projects such as creating an interplanetary spacecraft
10:29PM ( 12 hours ago )
AP Business
Nissan executive Munoz resigns after Ghosn's arrest
Nissan Chief Performance Officer Jose Munoz, who took a leave of absence a week ago, has resigned, the first high-profile departure at the Japanese automaker publicly acknowledged as related to the arrest of former Chairman Carlos Ghosn
8:53PM ( 13 hours ago )
SpaceX launches 10 more Iridium Communications satellites
A SpaceX rocket has delivered 10 satellites to low-Earth orbit, completing a two-year campaign by Iridium Communications to replace its original fleet with a new generation of mobile communication technology and added global aircraft tracking capability
5:56PM ( 16 hours ago )
The Latest: Suspect worked with teen's parents for a day
The company that employed the slain parents of a Wisconsin teen who was kidnapped says the man accused in the attack worked at the plant for one day nearly three years ago
2:48PM ( 19 hours ago )
AP Business - Corporate News
Fed officials feared adverse market reaction in 2013
Transcripts: Federal Reserve officials feared adverse market reaction to bond tapering in 2013
5:16PM ( 17 hours ago )
911 audio shows shock, panic after comatose woman gave birth
Dramatic 911 audio shows panicking staff members at a long-term care facility scrambled to save a baby born to an Arizona woman in a vegetative state amid their shock to learn she was pregnant
5:15PM ( 17 hours ago )
US stocks drift in a quiet close to another winning week
U.S. stock indexes nestled a hair lower on Friday after the falling price of oil weighed on energy companies. The S&P 500 nevertheless closed out its third straight winning week following a brutal stretch in December.
4:47PM ( 17 hours ago )
AP Business - Industries
Asian stocks rise on Fed restraint, US-China trade hopes
Asian markets are mostly higher as investors cheer more restrained Federal Reserve and US-China trade talks
1:38AM ( 1 day ago )
Asian stocks rise on Fed restraint, U.S-China trade hopes
Asian markets are mostly higher as investors cheer a more reactive Federal Reserve and U.S.-China trade talks
11:23PM ( 1 day ago )
Isolation greets Maduro's new term as Venezuela's president
President Nicolas Maduro has been sworn in for a second, six-year term amid widespread international repudiation that his increasingly authoritarian rule has stripped Venezuela of its last vestiges of democracy
6:59PM ( 1 day ago )
AP Business - Utilities
The Latest: Spain says Spanish woman killed in Paris blast
The Spanish foreign minister says a Spanish woman is among those killed in a Paris bakery explosion and fire believed caused by a gas leak, and another Spanish person was injured
10:20AM ( 10 minutes ago )
Congo runner-up Fayulu asks court to order election recount
Congo presidential runner-up Fayulu asks court to order recount, calling results 'fabricated'
10:13AM ( 17 minutes ago )
Trump AG pick poised to reclaim old job in a changed capital
As attorney general a quarter century ago, William Barr promoted more police and prisons to address violence ravaging American cities
9:59AM ( 31 minutes ago )
Small plane crashes in field in eastern Germany, 2 dead
German police say a small plane has crashed east of Berlin, killing two people
9:54AM ( 36 minutes ago )
Hundreds inspired by yellow vest movement rally in London
Hundreds of protesters inspired by the so-called yellow vest movement are rallying in London, drawing attention to austerity programs that have hit the poor hard
9:52AM ( 38 minutes ago )