sunny.png
Tuesday March 19th, 2019 1:08PM

No stethoscope for pain: Scientists seek real way to measure

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — Is the pain stabbing or burning? On a scale from 1 to 10, is it a 6 or an 8?

Over and over, 17-year-old Sarah Taylor struggled to make doctors understand her sometimes debilitating levels of pain, first from joint-damaging childhood arthritis and then from fibromyalgia.

"It's really hard when people can't see how much pain you're in, because they have to take your word on it and sometimes, they don't quite believe you," she said.

Now scientists are peeking into Sarah's eyes to track how her pupils react when she's hurting and when she's not — part of a quest to develop the first objective way to measure pain.

"If we can't measure pain, we can't fix it," said Dr. Julia Finkel, a pediatric anesthesiologist at Children's National Medical Center in Washington, who invented the experimental eye-tracking device.

At just about every doctor's visit you'll get your temperature, heart rate and blood pressure measured. But there's no stethoscope for pain. Patients must convey how bad it is using that 10-point scale or emoji-style charts that show faces turning from smiles to frowns.

That's problematic for lots of reasons. Doctors and nurses have to guess at babies' pain by their cries and squirms, for example. The aching that one person rates a 7 might be a 4 to someone who's more used to serious pain or genetically more tolerant. Patient-to-patient variability makes it hard to test if potential new painkillers really work.

Nor do self-ratings determine what kind of pain someone has — one reason for trial-and-error treatment. Are opioids necessary? Or is the pain, like Sarah's, better suited to nerve-targeting medicines?

"It's very frustrating to be in pain and you have to wait like six weeks, two months, to see if the drug's working," said Sarah, who uses a combination of medications, acupuncture and lots of exercise to counter her pain.

The National Institutes of Health is pushing for development of what its director, Dr. Francis Collins, has called a "pain-o-meter." Spurred by the opioid crisis , the goal isn't just to signal how much pain someone's in. It's also to determine what kind it is and what drug might be the most effective.

"We're not creating a lie detector for pain," stressed David Thomas of NIH's National Institute on Drug Abuse, who oversees the research. "We do not want to lose the patient voice."

Around the country, NIH-funded scientists have begun studies of brain scans, pupil reactions and other possible markers of pain in hopes of finally "seeing" the ouch so they can better treat it. It's early-stage research, and it's not clear how soon any of the attempts might pan out.

"There won't be a single signature of pain," Thomas predicted. "My vision is that someday we'll pull these different metrics together for something of a fingerprint of pain."

NIH estimates 25 million people in the U.S. experience daily pain. Most days Sarah Taylor is one of them. Now living in Potomac, Maryland, she was a toddler in her native Australia when the swollen, aching joints of juvenile arthritis appeared. She's had migraines and spinal inflammation. Then two years ago, the body-wide pain of fibromyalgia struck; a flare-up last winter hospitalized her for two weeks.

One recent morning, Sarah climbed onto an acupuncture table at Children's National, rated that day's pain a not-too-bad 3, and opened her eyes wide for the experimental pain test.

"There'll be a flash of light for 10 seconds. All you have to do is try not to blink," researcher Kevin Jackson told Sarah as he lined up the pupil-tracking device, mounted on a smartphone.

The eyes offer a window to pain centers in the brain, said Finkel, who directs pain research at Children's Sheikh Zayed Institute for Pediatric Surgical Innovation.

How? Some pain-sensing nerves transmit "ouch" signals to the brain along pathways that also alter muscles of the pupils as they react to different stimuli. Finkel's device tracks pupillary reactions to light or to non-painful stimulation of certain nerve fibers, aiming to link different patterns to different intensities and types of pain.

Consider the shooting hip and leg pain of sciatica: "Everyone knows someone who's been started on oxycodone for their sciatic nerve pain. And they'll tell you that they feel it — it still hurts — and they just don't care," Finkel said.

What's going on? An opioid like oxycodone brings some relief by dulling the perception of pain but not its transmission — while a different kind of drug might block the pain by targeting the culprit nerve fiber, she said.

Certain medications also can be detected by other changes in a resting pupil, she said. Last month the Food and Drug Administration announced it would help AlgometRx, a biotech company Finkel founded, speed development of the device as a rapid drug screen.

Looking deeper than the eyes, scientists at Harvard and Massachusetts General Hospital found MRI scans revealed patterns of inflammation in the brain that identified either fibromyalgia or chronic back pain.

Other researchers have found changes in brain activity — where different areas "light up" on scans — that signal certain types of pain. Still others are using electrodes on the scalp to measure pain through brain waves.

Ultimately, NIH wants to uncover biological markers that explain why some people recover from acute pain while others develop hard-to-treat chronic pain.

"Your brain changes with pain," Thomas explained. "A zero-to-10 scale or a happy-face scale doesn't capture anywhere near the totality of the pain experience."

___

The Associated Press Health & Science Department receives support from the Howard Hughes Medical Institute's Department of Science Education. The AP is solely responsible for all content.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Health, AP Business, AP Business - Corporate News
© Copyright 2019 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
The Latest: Trump arrives at Texas border town
President Donald Trump arrived at a Texas border town to make the case for his long-promised border wall after negotiations with Democrats blew up over his funding demands
1:49PM ( 14 minutes ago )
No stethoscope for pain: Scientists seek real way to measure
Forget simply rating pain from 1 to 10: Scientists are seeking ways to finally take a real measure of the ache, so they can better treat it
1:49PM ( 14 minutes ago )
Powell repeats pledge to remain 'patient' with rate hikes
Fed Chairman Powell repeats pledge to remain 'patient' in determining when to hike rates
1:42PM ( 21 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Physicians criticize state lawsuits over pelvic mesh
Doctors who specialize in female pelvic medicine say lawsuits by four states over products used to treat pelvic floor disorders and incontinence might scare patients away from the best treatment options _ or maybe even push the products off the market
9:35AM ( 4 hours ago )
Coke-funded group swayed China's obesity efforts, papers say
A new research paper says a food industry-funded group undermined China's efforts to keep obesity rates in check
9:31AM ( 4 hours ago )
Scientists seek ways to finally take a real measure of pain
There's no stethoscope for pain: Scientists are seeking ways to finally take a real measure of the ache so patients no longer have to hope they're describing it right
1:12AM ( 12 hours ago )
AP Health
4 on trial over theft of huge gold coin from Berlin museum
Four young men went on trial Thursday in Germany over the brazen theft of a 100-kilogram (221-pound) Canadian gold coin that disappeared from a Berlin museum two years ago
1:09PM ( 55 minutes ago )
Trump threatens emergency declaration ahead of border visit
Trump threatens to declare national emergency to circumvent Congress if he can't reach a deal with Democrats to fund his promised border wall as he headed to the U.S.-Mexico border
12:54PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Explains: In Yemen war, rebels increasingly deploy drones
AP Explains: In Yemen, where US once owned the sky with its drones, Shiite rebels increasingly deploy them in civil war
12:22PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
American Airlines shares tumble on more cautious 4Q outlook
American Airlines shares tumble after the world's biggest carrier reduces its estimate of recent revenue and profit
11:51AM ( 2 hours ago )
Auto industry troubles buffet Ford, Jaguar Land Rover
Ford Motor Co. says it is cutting jobs in its European business in a wide-ranging restructuring as it focuses on its most profitable models and shifts to the production of more electric cars
11:28AM ( 2 hours ago )
US apparel firm cuts off Chinese factory in internment camp
U.S. apparel firm severs ties with Chinese factory in internment camp
11:03AM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Business - Corporate News
The Latest: Trump arrives at Texas border town
President Donald Trump arrived at a Texas border town to make the case for his long-promised border wall after negotiations with Democrats blew up over his funding demands
1:49PM ( 14 minutes ago )
Powell repeats pledge to remain 'patient' with rate hikes
Fed Chairman Powell repeats pledge to remain 'patient' in determining when to hike rates
1:42PM ( 21 minutes ago )
The Latest: Trump cancels Davos trip, cites gov't shutdown
President Donald Trump says he is canceling his trip to Davos, Switzerland because of the partial government shutdown, now in its 20th day
1:31PM ( 33 minutes ago )
Macedonian PM struggles to secure majority for name change
Macedonia's prime minister is struggling to raise the parliamentary majority needed to finalize constitutional changes that will rename the country North Macedonia and allow its NATO accession under a deal with neighboring Greece
1:27PM ( 36 minutes ago )
Venezuela's Maduro celebrates 2nd term as crisis deepens
President Nicolas Maduro has been sworn in for a second, six-year term amid widespread international repudiation that his increasingly authoritarian rule has stripped Venezuela of its last vestiges of democracy
1:25PM ( 39 minutes ago )