pcloudy.png
Sunday June 7th, 2020 4:50AM

Illinois man who took on ballistics evidence faces retrial

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

An Illinois man who spent more than two decades in prison for a murder conviction obtained with shoddy ballistics evidence is getting a chance to prove his innocence with a new trial.

The retrial of Patrick Pursley in the April 1993 killing of 22-year-old Andy Ascher is set to begin Thursday in Rockford, where Ascher was fatally shot during a robbery while sitting in a car with his girlfriend.

Pursley, 53, was convicted in Ascher's death in 1994 based mostly on ballistics analysis that was once thought to infallible but is now considered antiquated.

Five years after he went to prison, though, a much more accurate approach emerged called the Integrated Ballistic Identification System, or IBIS, which uses much higher-resolution and multi-dimensional images for ballistics analysis. For years, while representing himself in prison, Pursley pushed for the evidence in his case to be retested using IBIS, and in 2007, his efforts persuaded Illinois lawmakers to pass the nation's only law requiring such retesting when inmates appealing their convictions request it.

When the evidence in Pursley's case was retested with IBIS, it showed that the scratches and dents on bullets and shell casings from the crime scene didn't match the gun that prosecutors presented at trial as the murder weapon. In March 2017, Judge Joseph McGraw ordered Pursley retried on a first-degree murder charge and allowed him to go free on bail.

A month after McGraw ordered the retrial, the victim's mother, Lois Ascher, informed prosecutors that a detective told her after Pursley's first trial that police never found the murder weapon and that another gun was entered as evidence. But prosecutors didn't inform Pursley's new defense attorneys about Lois Ascher's assertion until right before his retrial was supposed to begin, in November 2018.

The retrial was delayed while Pursley's attorneys argued for his case to be dismissed, accusing prosecutors of misconduct for not revealing potentially exculpatory evidence. However, McGraw declined to dismiss the case, calling Lois Ascher's assertion "uncorroborated hearsay" and saying he didn't think prosecutors acted in bad faith even though they "willfully failed" to immediately tell the defense about the detective's supposed statement.

The gun and shell casings were the only physical evidence prosecutors used to convict Pursley. Pursley's girlfriend at the time of the killing implicated him in the crime but later recanted, saying her testimony had been coerced. Prosecutors also relied on testimony from a man who received a Crime Stoppers reward for telling police that Pursley had confessed to the crime.

Lawyers from Northwestern University's Center on Wrongful Convictions and the Chicago-based firm Jenner and Block will represent Pursley free of charge at the retrial. McGraw — not a jury — will decide the verdict, at Pursley's request.

Katie Zimmerman, a spokeswoman for the Winnebago County State's Attorney's Office, said her office couldn't discuss the case because it is pending.

Since his release on bail, Pursley has been busy speaking out about wrongful convictions and gang violence. He also started a nonprofit dedicated to encouraging young people to go to college and avoid a life of crime and he built a recording studio in his basement to develop a talent agency for urban youth interested in music.

"I believe justice will be done," Pursley told The Associated Press by phone on Tuesday. "Of course, it's not in my hands and it's a chance — you never know what will happen."

___

Moreno reported from Milwaukee.

  • Associated Categories: U.S. News, Associated Press (AP), AP National News, Top U.S. News short headlines
© Copyright 2020 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Amazon founder Jeff Bezos divorcing wife after 25 years
Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos is divorcing his wife MacKenzie, ending a 25-year marriage, raising questions about fate of his $137 billion fortune
2:12PM ( 13 minutes ago )
Elderly, conservatives shared more Facebook fakery in 2016
Study: People over 65 and conservatives shared the most false information on Facebook in 2016
2:11PM ( 14 minutes ago )
In shaming 90-year-old rider, anti-doping earns a black eye
A 90-year-old champion cyclist who made headlines worldwide by failing a doping test has made his first public comments on the case to The Associated Press
2:10PM ( 16 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Male workers face DNA testing after comatose woman had baby
Phoenix police have served a search warrant to get DNA from all male employees at a long-term care facility where a patient in a vegetative state for years gave birth
1:57PM ( 28 minutes ago )
Trump hastens to Capitol to hold GOP in line on shutdown
White House tries to hold jittery GOP in line over wall, government shutdown
1:49PM ( 37 minutes ago )
Trump's move to send Haitians home goes on trial in New York
A trial in New York over the Trump administration's move to cut off permission for thousands of Haitians to live in the U.S. has brought to light emails in which officials talked about downplaying crisis conditions in the Caribbean nation
1:43PM ( 42 minutes ago )
AP National News
Denver unveils new system for clearing marijuana convictions
Officials say a simplified program will make it easier for thousands of people to seek the elimination of low-level marijuana convictions that occurred in Denver before recreational use became legal in Colorado
12:41PM ( 1 hour ago )
He posted frantic video with police and ended up dead. How?
Authorities are trying to determine how a New Jersey man who recorded a frantic video at a police station wound up unresponsive while being transported by police to the hospital and later died
12:18PM ( 2 hours ago )
Teacher strike looms for second-largest US school district
Teachers in Los Angeles are ready to strike Thursday over a contract dispute that follows teacher walkouts in other states that emboldened organized labor
11:35AM ( 2 hours ago )
Top U.S. News short headlines
Amazon founder Jeff Bezos divorcing wife after 25 years
Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos is divorcing his wife MacKenzie, ending a 25-year marriage, raising questions about fate of his $137 billion fortune
2:12PM ( 13 minutes ago )
Elderly, conservatives shared more Facebook fakery in 2016
Study: People over 65 and conservatives shared the most false information on Facebook in 2016
2:11PM ( 14 minutes ago )
In shaming 90-year-old rider, anti-doping earns a black eye
A 90-year-old champion cyclist who made headlines worldwide by failing a doping test has made his first public comments on the case to The Associated Press
2:10PM ( 16 minutes ago )
Abu Dhabi fund, developer seek to sell Chrysler Building
The owners of New York City's Chrysler Building are putting the iconic Art Deco skyscraper on the market
2:06PM ( 19 minutes ago )
'Seattle Squeeze': City gears up for major highway closure
Seattle is bracing for traffic issues related to the closure of a major thoroughfare for commuters along the city's waterfront
2:01PM ( 24 minutes ago )