Wednesday November 25th, 2020 3:54AM

Democrats worry over AG nominee's view of presidential power

By The Associated Press
Related Articles
  Contact Editor

WASHINGTON (AP) — William Barr once advised that a president didn't need Congress' permission to attack Iraq, that his administration could arrest a foreign dictator and that the FBI could capture suspects abroad without that country's consent.

It's an expansive view of presidential power and an unsettling one for Democrats as the Senate holds a confirmation hearing next week for Barr, a onetime attorney general and President Donald Trump's pick to again serve as America's top law enforcement official.

Democrats already fear that Barr, if confirmed, would be overly deferential to Trump in a position where legal decisions aren't supposed to be guided by political considerations. Trump has made clear he demands loyalty from an attorney general, repeatedly haranguing and ultimately forcing out his first one, Jeff Sessions, for not protecting the president from the Russia investigation.

Barr's philosophy on presidential power adds to those concerns. As attorney general and in the years since, Barr has expressed his belief that presidents have broad authority, limiting the power of Congress and courts to hold them in check.

Those views were evident in an unsolicited memo Barr sent the Justice Department last year arguing Trump couldn't have obstructed justice by firing ex-FBI Director James Comey. Barr contended presidents cannot be investigated for actions they're lawfully permitted to take, arguments similar to those of Trump's lawyers. That document raised Democratic alarms that Barr could influence special counsel Robert Mueller's investigation in ways that protect Trump. Mueller is investigating Russia's meddling in the 2016 election and contacts with the Trump campaign.

"This view that anything the president does pursuant to his constitutional authority can never be a crime, I think, is very troubling, very alarming and very disconcerting," said Notre Dame law professor Jimmy Gurule, a former Justice Department colleague.

Deputy Attorney General Rod Rosenstein, who appointed Mueller and remains his most visible Justice Department protector, is expected to leave his position soon after Barr is confirmed, a person familiar with the plans said Wednesday.

If confirmed, Barr would be positioned to oversee the Mueller investigation as pivotal decisions await that could test the scope of presidential authorities and land in court.

Those include whether Trump can be subpoenaed if he won't answer additional questions, and whether to disclose to Congress whatever report Mueller produces. Barr hasn't publicly discussed those questions, but his memo did criticize Mueller's theory of obstruction as "fatally misconceived."

"Bill is a learned man and is a capable lawyer, and he knows how to make the arguments in the trenches for the construction of a statute in favor of the president's authority," said Pepperdine University law professor Douglas Kmiec, who preceded Barr as head of the Justice Department's legal counsel office. Barr, he said, exhibited a demeanor of, "'The president must be right, let's find a way to make it so.'"

Barr has rejected any suggestion of being a rubber stamp for presidential powers, citing instances in which he concluded that the White House lacked authorities for a line-item veto or to index the capital gains text to inflation. He noted in one 1992 speech the president's responsibility to "advance responsible positions of law," saying the government will lose ground through unreasonable stances.

"Our view has been that if we go into court with untenable positions and lose, we ultimately weaken the office of the President," he said.

A Justice Department spokeswoman declined to comment.

Barr's friends and associates say it's not his nature to be a pushover for a president and defend his viewpoints as carefully reasoned, respectful of the Justice Department and White House and consistent with conservative legal philosophy.

They note that the legal counsel office he once led is tasked with advising executive branch agencies and under various administrations has issued opinions favorable to the president, including that a sitting president cannot be indicted. The office, said Timothy Flanigan, who held the job after Barr, operates with the premise that the "president starts with a lot of powers, significant powers, based on the Constitution."

"Bill's not some type of extremist or outlier," said Chuck Cooper, a friend who also led the office. "He falls well within mainstream executive branch learning, if you will, about the powers of the presidency and its relationship to the other branches."

It was in the legal counsel job that Barr provided some of his most meaningful guidance: opinions that empowered FBI agents to seize fugitives overseas and that justified the invasion of Panama and arrest of dictator Manuel Noriega. The night President George H.W. Bush gave the invasion order, Barr was playing bagpipes at Attorney General Richard Thornburgh's Christmas party, then scurried to the White House.

As attorney general between 1991 and 1993, Barr blessed Bush's desire to pardon Reagan administration officials in the Iran-Contra scandal as within the president's authority. The Constitution, he observed in one 1992 speech, created a "strong, unitary executive with veto power" and called it "grade school" analysis to suggest the Founding Fathers were primarily concerned with presidential overreach.

"The aim of the framers was not to enfeeble the executive branch, but quite the contrary, to recreate a strong executive, with sufficient constitutional powers of its own, to check abuse and encroachment by the legislature," he said.

He was deputy attorney general when, with Thornburgh out of town, he was summoned to a White House meeting and asked if Bush had authority to attack Iraq without congressional approval.

"I said, 'Mr. President, there's no doubt that you have the authority to launch an attack,'" Barr recalled in a 2001 oral history.

But, he added, a congressional resolution was wise nonetheless. Congress ultimately authorized it.

When then-Defense Secretary Dick Cheney said Barr was giving political rather than legal advice, Barr interjected: "I said, No, I'm giving him both political and legal advice. They're really sort of together when you get to this level."

After leaving government, he supported President George W. Bush's authority to designate as enemy combatants militants captured overseas and prosecute them in military tribunals.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Online National News, Top General short headlines, AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online President, White House, advisers News, AP Online Congress News
© Copyright 2020
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Democrats: Trump using misinformation, malice in wall debate
Top congressional Democrats say Trump chooses 'fear' in his drive to build a southern border wall
7:59AM ( 8 minutes ago )
China allowing 2,000 ethnic Kazakhs to leave Xinjiang region
China is allowing more than 2,000 ethnic Kazakhs to abandon their Chinese citizenship and leave the country
7:57AM ( 10 minutes ago )
Democrats worry over AG nominee's view of presidential power
Trump nominee for attorney general, William Barr, takes an expansive view of presidential power that worries Democrats
7:55AM ( 12 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
On his Mideast trip, Pompeo makes unannounced Iraq stop
US Secretary of State Pompeo makes unannounced stop in Iraq on Mideast tour
7:11AM ( 57 minutes ago )
US, China end talks on tariff battle with no word on outcome
US, China wrap up talks on tariff battle after Trump says they are 'going very well!' but no details immediately released
6:24AM ( 1 hour ago )
Trump pleads on TV for wall money; Dems say he stokes 'fear'
President Donald Trump uses his prime-time address from the Oval Office to urge congressional Democrats to fund his proposed U.S.-Mexico border wall
5:48AM ( 2 hours ago )
AP National News
Kim Jong Un heads home via train after 2-day Beijing visit
A special train believed to be carrying Kim Jong Un has departed Beijing after a two-day visit by the North Korean leader to the Chinese capital
2:20AM ( 5 hours ago )
Seattle braces for highway closure, historic traffic squeeze
A major thoroughfare for commuters along downtown Seattle's waterfront is set to close for good Friday, ushering in what officials say will be one of the most painful traffic periods in the history of the booming Pacific Northwest city
2:18AM ( 5 hours ago )
The Latest: Kim Jong Un's train departs Beijing
Kim Jong Un's train has left Beijing after a two-day visit by the North Korean leader to the Chinese capital
2:09AM ( 5 hours ago )
AP Online National News
Showdown looms as UK lawmakers clash over May's Brexit deal
The British government is bringing its little-loved Brexit deal back to Parliament, a month after postponing a vote on the agreement to stave off near-certain defeat
7:21AM ( 46 minutes ago )
EU parliament lamenting trans-Atlantic relations under Trump
A key European Union legislative group has lambasted the approach of U.S. President Trump to trans-Atlantic relations and is warning that the divisions it creates will only embolden global rivals
7:01AM ( 1 hour ago )
Italian minister in Poland seeking allies in EU elections
Italian interior minister Salvini to meet Poland's powerful ruling party leader as well as his Polish counterpart, as the two populist and nationalist parties discuss strategies ahead of spring elections to the European Parliament
5:54AM ( 2 hours ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Trump seeks an edge in shutdown fight with TV address
President Donald Trump will try to convince America that funding for his long-promised border wall is needed on security and humanitarian grounds, though his pitch will face intense pushback from Democrats
7:54PM ( 12 hours ago )
Trump, Democrats taking border wall fight to prime-time TV
President Donald Trump plans to use his first Oval Office address to argue that a "crisis" at the U.S.-Mexico border requires the wall he's demanding before ending the partial government shutdown
4:31PM ( 15 hours ago )
Trump's AG pick has argued presidents have robust powers
William Barr once advised the U.S. government that it could attack Iraq without Congressional approval, arrest a deposed foreign dictator and capture suspects abroad without that country's permission
4:22PM ( 15 hours ago )
AP Online President, White House, advisers News
The Latest: Trump says building wall would be act of 'love'
President Donald Trump is arguing that building a southern border wall would be an act of "love."
9:48PM ( 10 hours ago )
The Latest: Schumer to Trump: 'No excuse' for hurting people
Senate Democratic leader Chuck Schumer says President Donald Trump should reopen government while talks continue over the U.S.-Mexico border wall because there's "no excuse for hurting millions of Americans."
9:43PM ( 10 hours ago )
The Latest: Pelosi accuses Trump of having 'chosen fear'
House Speaker Nancy Pelosi says the president has "chosen fear" in making the case to the American people for the border wall and Democrats "want to start with the facts."
9:27PM ( 10 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Democrats: Trump using misinformation, malice in wall debate
Top congressional Democrats say Trump chooses 'fear' in his drive to build a southern border wall
7:59AM ( 8 minutes ago )
China allowing 2,000 ethnic Kazakhs to leave Xinjiang region
China is allowing more than 2,000 ethnic Kazakhs to abandon their Chinese citizenship and leave the country
7:57AM ( 10 minutes ago )
The Latest: Italy's deputy premier slams EU migrant deal
Italian Deputy Premier Matteo Salvini has slammed a deal on rescued migrants that was brokered by the European Union, saying it will encourage human traffickers.
7:53AM ( 14 minutes ago )
Yellow vest protesters call for huge run on French banks
Yellow vest activists are urging French citizens to empty their bank accounts and spark a bank run to get the French government to listen to their demands
7:49AM ( 18 minutes ago )
Australia considering resettlement for fleeing Saudi woman
Australia's government will assess the resettlement case of a Saudi woman who fled from her family now that the United Nations has deemed her a refugee, taking her high-profile quest for asylum a step forward
7:48AM ( 20 minutes ago )