sunny.png
Thursday October 17th, 2019 11:46AM

FDA plans meeting to discuss safety data on breast implants

By The Associated Press

U.S. health regulators say they'll convene a public meeting of medical advisers next year to discuss new science on breast implant safety, including an independent analysis that suggests certain rare health problems might be more common with silicone gel implants.

The Food and Drug Administration said it would hold the meeting even as its officials and several independent experts disputed the new work. Leaders of the study concede that it has big limitations and cannot prove that implants cause any of these problems.

Yet it involves nearly 100,000 women and is the largest long-term safety analysis of silicone implants since 2006, when they were allowed back on the U.S. market after a 14-year gap due to safety concerns.

"We completely stand behind this study and we do feel it's our best data to date," said lead researcher Dr. Mark Clemens, a plastic surgeon at the University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center. Women need as much information as possible to make an informed decision about whether and what kind of implant to get, he said.

The journal Annals of Surgery plans to publish the report on Monday. Study leaders have no current ties to implant makers although Clemens consulted for one in the past.

A POPULAR CHOICE

Each year in the U.S., about 400,000 women get an implant and most choose silicone over saline; surgeons say it can give a more natural look. Three-fourths are for women who want bigger breasts; the rest are for reconstruction after cancer surgery.

"Breast implants are not lifetime devices" and up to 20 percent of women getting them for enlargement need to have them removed within 8 to 10 years, the FDA's website warns.

Complications can include infections, wrinkling, scarring, pain, swelling and implant rupture. Implant users also may have a very small but increased risk of a rare lymphoma, a type of cancer, the FDA has said.

But the agency decided there was not enough evidence to tie silicone implants to other problems such as immune system and connective tissue disorders, so it approved devices from two makers — Allergan and Mentor Corp. — in 2006. FDA required the companies to do more studies on how women fared, and the Texas researchers used these reports in an FDA database for their analysis.

WHAT THEY FOUND

Compared to women without implants, those with silicone implants seemed to have greater rates of an immune system disorder called Sjogren syndrome, a connective tissue disorder called scleroderma, and the skin cancer melanoma, although cases of these were rare, the researchers reported. But rates for other problems such as fibromyalgia were lower among implant users. Reproductive problems such as birth defects and stillbirths were mixed and inconsistent.

Furthermore, a higher rate of rheumatoid arthritis was tied to one brand but a lower rate for another. The difference gets to what critics called a fundamental flaw in the data used for the analysis: One implant maker required proof of diagnosis by a doctor rather than just a patient reporting a problem to include it in the database; the other did not.

Another study weakness is that more than half of women dropped out of touch within two years of their operations.

Because of these and other shortcomings, "we respectfully disagree" with the researchers' conclusions and urge that they be viewed with caution, Dr. Binita Ashar of the FDA's Center for Devices and Radiological Health said in a statement .

WHAT OTHERS SAY

"This study is messy" and has the potential to create more anxiety than insight, said Dr. Andrea Pusic, plastic surgery chief at Brigham and Women's Hospital in Boston and president-elect of the Plastic Surgery Foundation, which supports research and advocacy by the American Society of Plastic Surgeons.

The group gets industry grants for some of its work, and Pusic gets royalties from a questionnaire used in many studies including this one.

Dr. Charles Thorne, plastic surgery chairman at Lenox Hill Hospital in New York and president elect of the American Society of Aesthetic Plastic Surgery, said the inconsistency in some of the results "is a little hard to explain" since the devices are similar chemically.

But the study is a worthy effort, he said.

"We have to constantly reevaluate the data and make sure things are safe," Thorne said. "The best evidence we have now indicates there's no increased likelihood of these systemic diseases."

___

Marilynn Marchione can be followed at @MMarchioneAP .

___

The Associated Press Health & Science Department receives support from the Howard Hughes Medical Institute's Department of Science Education. The AP is solely responsible for all content.

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP National News, AP Health, AP Business
© Copyright 2019 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
'Uninvited brute': Hurricane Florence drenches the Carolinas
Hurricane Florence's top winds make it just a Category 1 storm _ but its biggest threat comes from heavy rainfall
2:15PM ( 12 minutes ago )
Mexico vies for best foreign film Oscar with Cuaron's 'Roma'
The ninth time may be the charm for Mexico at the Oscars as Alfonso Cuaron's Roma is the country's selection for a best foreign language film nomination
2:11PM ( 16 minutes ago )
Manafort pleads guilty, will cooperate with special counsel
Former Trump campaign chairman Paul Manafort pleaded guilty Friday to two federal crimes after cutting a deal with prosecutors and agreeing to cooperate with the special counsel's Russia probe
2:05PM ( 22 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Zimbabwe's government criticized over cholera outbreak
Zimbabwe's government criticized over cholera outbreak that has killed 25, spread from capital
11:46AM ( 2 hours ago )
No progress as US, Cuba meet on mysterious 'health attacks'
Cuba said Thursday the United States is continuing to withhold important information that could help in the investigation into mysterious incidents that have injured some two dozen Havana-based American diplomats
11:23PM ( 15 hours ago )
Boss revenge, self-colonoscopy studies win 2018 Ig Nobels
Researchers who found that that using a virtual voodoo doll to exact revenge on an abusive boss can help you feel better, and who figured out that nutrition isn't a good reason to engage in cannibalism were among this year's winners of the Ig Nobel
9:45PM ( 16 hours ago )
AP Health
US stock indexes turn lower on renewed trade concerns
US stocks are giving up an early gain and turning slightly lower after Bloomberg News reported that President Donald Trump wants to go ahead with new tariffs on imports from China.
1:32PM ( 56 minutes ago )
Officials work to pinpoint cause of 'Armageddon'-like blasts
Investigators are working to pinpoint the cause of a series of dramatic natural gas explosions that killed a teenager, injured at least 25 others and left dozens of homes in smoldering ruins
1:26PM ( 1 hour ago )
$1.5M settlement for Muslim workers fired in prayer dispute
A U.S. meatpacker has agreed to pay $1.5 million to 138 Somali-American Muslim workers who were fired from their jobs at a Colorado plant after they were refused prayer breaks
1:06PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
'Uninvited brute': Hurricane Florence drenches the Carolinas
Hurricane Florence's top winds make it just a Category 1 storm _ but its biggest threat comes from heavy rainfall
2:15PM ( 12 minutes ago )
Mexico vies for best foreign film Oscar with Cuaron's 'Roma'
The ninth time may be the charm for Mexico at the Oscars as Alfonso Cuaron's Roma is the country's selection for a best foreign language film nomination
2:11PM ( 16 minutes ago )
Manafort pleads guilty, will cooperate with special counsel
Former Trump campaign chairman Paul Manafort pleaded guilty Friday to two federal crimes after cutting a deal with prosecutors and agreeing to cooperate with the special counsel's Russia probe
2:05PM ( 22 minutes ago )
SpaceX changes plans to send tourists around the moon
SpaceX says it has signed the first private moon traveler
2:04PM ( 23 minutes ago )
US stock indexes turn lower on renewed trade concerns
US stocks are giving up an early gain and turning slightly lower after Bloomberg News reported that President Donald Trump wants to go ahead with new tariffs on imports from China.
1:32PM ( 56 minutes ago )