Sunday April 5th, 2020 6:10PM

Judge weighs whether Georgia must switch to paper ballots

By The Associated Press

ATLANTA (AP) — A federal judge who's considering whether Georgia should have to switch from electronic voting machines to paper ballots for the November election called the situation "a catch-22."

Voting integrity groups and individuals sued state and county election officials, arguing that the touchscreen voting machines Georgia has used since 2002 are vulnerable to hacking and provide no way to confirm that votes have been recorded correctly because they don't produce a paper trail.

They've asked U.S. District Judge Amy Totenberg to order Secretary of State Brian Kemp, the Republican candidate for governor, to implement the use of paper ballots for the Nov. 6 midterm elections.

But lawyers for the state argue that making the switch would be difficult, costly and would create chaos. Early voting is set to begin Oct. 15, and training for poll workers has already begun in many counties, they said.

Totenberg heard arguments Wednesday from both sides and said she hopes to have a decision by Friday, or Monday at the latest.

Five states, along with more than 300 counties in eight other states, exclusively use touchscreen voting machines that provide no paper record, according to Verified Voting, a nonprofit group focused on ensuring the accuracy of elections.

"Georgia has been frozen in time for the last 16 years and, as a result, has been left behind by virtually every other state," said David Cross, a lawyer for a group of individuals challenging the voting machines.

The constitutional right to vote includes not only the right to cast a vote but also the right to have that vote counted accurately, he said. "The right to vote in the state of Georgia is illusory," he added.

Georgia has repeatedly ignored warnings from cybersecurity experts and federal officials that voting machines without an auditable paper trail are not secure, lawyers for those seeking paper ballots said.

Georgia already uses paper ballots counted by optical scanners for absentee voting and for provisional ballots on election day, so the technology and protocols are already in place and simply need to be scaled up, they argued.

But Georgia doesn't have enough optical scanners and likely can't get enough in time, said lawyer John Salter, who represents Kemp and other state officials. He also argued that a safe and secure election cannot be guaranteed by using paper ballots.

"These are not the holy grail of voting integrity," Salter said.

Kemp has insisted a change can't be made before the November election in which he faces Democrat Stacey Abrams, the former state House minority leader who's trying to become the country's first black, female governor. Kemp has called on companies for proposals to implement new machines that produce verifiable paper records in time for the next presidential election in 2020.

Alex Halderman, a University of Michigan computer science and engineering professor, testified that a decade ago the main threats to election systems were dishonest insiders or candidates. But, he said, "everything changed in 2016," when threats of interference by a foreign power became much more serious than had previously been considered.

Election results could be altered without an attacker having physical access to a voting machine and without machines being connected to the internet, Halderman said. An attack could access the central administration system, allowing malware to be spread to many machines.

Paper ballots or a machine-issued paper record that a voter can check are the most secure methods, he said.

"I don't think there's anything Georgia can do to reasonably secure the paperless touchscreen machines that are in use today," Halderman said.

State elections director Chris Harvey testified that after the lawsuit was filed, the secretary of state's office re-examined the touchscreen voting system and found that the machines recorded each vote as cast. He also listed ways that paper ballots can be manipulated, including ballots that are lost, stolen or intentionally spoiled.

In large counties where there can be hundreds of different possible ballots, having to have all of them on hand at early voting sites would be unwieldy and would likely lead to a reduction in the number of early voting locations, Harvey said. Voters may also be confused by the new format and may take longer to vote, leading to long lines that could discourage voters, he said.

The issues raised in the lawsuit are big and affect voting results and the credibility of the system, Totenberg said, adding that a lot of nationally respected organizations have raised concern about electronic voting machines with no paper record. But the judge also expressed concern about the logistics of switching to paper ballots so quickly and the possibility of long lines or confusion.

"This is a catch-22," she said, later adding, "I'm concerned that we're here at the 11th hour."

  • Associated Categories: Associated Press (AP), AP Online Headlines - Washington, AP Online Congress News, AP Business, AP Online - Georgia News, AP Online Headlines - Georgia News
© Copyright 2020 AccessWDUN.com
All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed without permission.
Judge weighs whether Georgia must switch to paper ballots
A federal judge who's considering whether Georgia should have to switch from electronic voting machines to paper ballots for the November election says she hopes to have a decision by the end of the week
8:53PM ( 28 minutes ago )
Amtrak modifies schedules ahead of Hurricane Florence
Amtrak is modifying schedules and canceling trains south of Washington in response to Hurricane Florence.
3:30PM ( 5 hours ago )
Local church organizes immigration forum
In the first of a planned series of forums, Sola City Church in Gainesville will launch "For The City" this Saturday with a focus on immigration.
3:09PM ( 6 hours ago )
Local/State News
Tropical storm fades but still douses Hawaii with rain
A gradually weakening tropical storm hit Hawaii on Wednesday, soaking a part of Maui and sending gusts of wind that toppled trees and cancelled flights at a number of airports in the state
9:11PM ( 10 minutes ago )
Rinse, repeat: Rhode Island governor fight will mirror 2014
Rhode Island's Democratic governor won her party's nomination for a second term in Wednesday's primary, overcoming a spirited but poorly funded challenge, while the mayor of the state's second-largest city earned the GOP nomination
9:09PM ( 12 minutes ago )
Trump comments sting in Puerto Rico amid slow storm recovery
President Donald Trump's assertion that the federal government's response to Hurricane Maria was "an incredible, unsung success" is falling flat in Puerto Rico, where islanders are still struggling to recover a year later
9:07PM ( 14 minutes ago )
Associated Press (AP)
Florida gov hopeful in Everglades airboat, talks environment
Florida GOP governor's candidate Ron DeSantis takes airboat tour of Everglades with alligator wrestler guide, seeking to broaden voter appeal; vows to combat state's top environmental woes
8:29PM ( 53 minutes ago )
McCaskill releases tax return but not including rich husband
Missouri's U.S. Senate candidates Democrat Claire McCaskill and Republican Josh Hawley have released their 2017 tax returns
7:42PM ( 1 hour ago )
Senate OKs Trump choice for IRS head over Democrats' protest
The Senate has approved President Donald Trump's choice to become the new head of the IRS over the protests of many Democrats
7:37PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Online Headlines - Washington
Tennessee Senate hopeful 'embarrassed' by Kavanaugh hearings
Democratic Senate candidate Phil Bredesen says he's "embarrassed by the circus" in the confirmation hearings for President Donald Trump's Supreme Court nominee, and he's pointing at both Republicans and Democrats
6:14PM ( 3 hours ago )
Bush boosting Republicans in places where Trump isn't strong
Former President George W. Bush is quietly helping Republican candidates in places where President Donald Trump isn't strong
5:33PM ( 3 hours ago )
Cardinal meeting with Pope accused of ignoring abuse
As U.S. Catholic leaders head to the Vatican to meet Pope Francis about a growing church abuse crisis, the cardinal leading the delegation has been accused by two victims of not doing enough to stop an abusive priest
5:27PM ( 3 hours ago )
AP Online Congress News
Strongest typhoon this year closes in on north Philippines
The most powerful typhoon of the season is closing in on the northern Philippines, where officials ordered precautionary evacuations and closures of schools and offices and urged farmers to quickly harvest their crops to reduce damage
8:37PM ( 45 minutes ago )
Da Silva's candidate vows to be his own man in Brazil
In his first full day as the presidential candidate for Brazil's Workers' Party, Fernando Haddad pledged to be his own man if elected and not bow to financial markets or the interests of other countries, including the United States
8:21PM ( 1 hour ago )
Video shows Weinstein's hands-on encounter with rape accuser
A video of Harvey Weinstein shows him propositioning, touching a woman who later accused him of rape
8:17PM ( 1 hour ago )
AP Business
AP Online - Georgia News
AP Online Headlines - Georgia News
Florence evacuees won't find many empty hotel rooms in Hall County
Evacuees are already setting up camp in Northeast Georgia as they get off the Carolina coast ahead of Hurricane Florence, but they aren't finding many places to stay in Gainesville.
2:38PM ( 6 hours ago )
'Don't play games with it': Florence takes aim at Southeast
People who thought they were safe from the onslaught of Hurricane Florence are boarding up, and Georgia's governor has declared a state of emergency
2:28PM ( 6 hours ago )
Investigators charge Helen woman with shooting her neighbor
The White County Sheriff’s Office has released information about an argument that led to a woman being shot last Friday.
1:34PM ( 7 hours ago )
Deal issues state of emergency for all Georgia counties
Governor Nathan Deal has issued a state of emergency for all 159 counties in Georgia.
12:52PM ( 8 hours ago )
"Lots of uncertainty" about Florence's impact on North Georgia
It's too early to tell what may happen in North Georgia weather-wise, according to AccessWDUN meteorologist John Wetherbee.
10:12AM ( 11 hours ago )